Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Playing for Keeps Misses the Mark

Plus, Hyde Park on Hudson is a little too soapy.

by | December 7, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies brings only one new release: Playing for Keeps, a romantic comedy starring Gerard Butler, Jessica Biel, and Uma Thurman. What do the critics have to say?

Playing for Keeps


Some bad movies are aggressive in their awfulness, while others are simply uninspired or clichéd. Critics say Playing for Keeps falls into the latter category, squandering an attractive cast on a script that offers plenty of jarring tonal shifts but no surprises. Gerard Butler stars as a washed-up soccer pro who decides that coaching his kid’s soccer team will help make up for all the time he’s been out of his son’s life. However, the other players’ moms immediately take a shine to the hunky new coach, and complications ensue. The pundits say Playing for Keeps is slavishly devoted to the romantic comedy playbook without exuding much personality of its own, and at times it’s surprisingly sexist. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Butler’s best-reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

cults book E3 crime comic book movies Action Mudbound Nominations Mary Poppins Returns art house black comedy ViacomCBS psycho Music Funimation 20th Century Fox politics DGA Peacock all-time 73rd Emmy Awards casting X-Men CNN Showtime Thanksgiving IFC historical drama nbcuniversal Quiz young adult Shudder interviews Focus Features Comics on TV streaming movies Film Festival Captain marvel a nightmare on elm street fast and furious Western thriller Ovation rom-coms VH1 Biopics telelvision Mindy Kaling halloween Amazon Prime Fox News NYCC australia Netflix Christmas movies Musicals ghosts sequel Pop TV godzilla Pride Month Tumblr indie Brie Larson Nickelodeon Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt VICE Spring TV Infographic Women's History Month award winner Black History Month Baby Yoda superman Geeked Week biopic Tags: Comedy obituary Oscar scene in color film series ratings crossover Fox Searchlight Travel Channel political drama unscripted disaster Christmas Comedy Central romance Song of Ice and Fire kids robots Lifetime period drama Crackle Ellie Kemper Summer BAFTA Classic Film Hallmark Christmas movies summer preview Holiday psychological thriller olympics international Awards Tour Sundance Martial Arts rt labs critics edition Sneak Peek singing competition toy story popular Fargo Turner USA Network Esquire Warner Bros. Logo The Arrangement supernatural sports FXX live event DirecTV Chernobyl posters Sony Film natural history scary Crunchyroll Holidays Neflix President YouTube Red GoT suspense new star wars movies free movies finale Star Wars Celebration Super Bowl breaking bad Chilling Adventures of Sabrina genre slashers james bond Hollywood Foreign Press Association live action El Rey BBC TV renewals CBS spider-verse streamig mockumentary Rock concert king kong movie LGBT canceled TV shows Tomatazos football Acorn TV GIFs crime drama criterion SXSW 2022 game show dc marvel comics green book See It Skip It Spike IMDb TV Star Trek cats Marvel hispanic heritage month 72 Emmy Awards ABC Family laika MCU E! Turner Classic Movies war Sci-Fi Rocky canceled A&E Tokyo Olympics RT History DC Universe Disney streaming service Disney Plus renewed TV shows Disney Best Picture festivals mcc Walt Disney Pictures discovery space TruTV TBS Hear Us Out nfl Star Wars CMT comedies Vudu Hulu festival obi wan kong TCA dceu Superheroe Valentine's Day IFC Films MGM 2015 foreign vampires Oscars rotten composers Comic Book National Geographic TV Land Syfy Writers Guild of America Opinion lord of the rings ESPN Endgame 21st Century Fox dexter Toys Food Network comic justice league dragons Certified Fresh History First Reviews Country Reality Best Actress hist Spectrum Originals feel good book adaptation HBO Cannes The Witch technology jamie lee curtis elevated horror Discovery Channel critics The CW children's TV Amazon Prime Video GLAAD summer TV preview Pacific Islander scorecard Red Carpet Britbox The Walt Disney Company screenings travel tv talk NBC docuseries Calendar name the review cartoon gangster nature Amazon Studios Teen teaser Exclusive Video Universal dogs basketball boxing Pixar cars PlayStation Marathons RT21 black japanese YA hollywood American Society of Cinematographers Masterpiece worst Paramount Plus YouTube spanish language series action-comedy emmy awards latino chucky video scene in color series social media Disney+ Disney Plus blaxploitation south america Cartoon Network critic resources rt archives television 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards women Superheroes theme song based on movie biography PaleyFest MTV Freeform Awards remakes Black Mirror leaderboard miniseries cooking TCM Prime Video ABC Signature venice New York Comic Con toronto aapi versus Television Critics Association italian transformers stoner Ghostbusters sequels SundanceTV 71st Emmy Awards HFPA reboot hispanic dramedy twilight scary movies Lionsgate Elton John know your critic jurassic park Tubi Native marvel cinematic universe Fantasy CBS All Access royal family fresh YouTube Premium Comedy kaiju saw french The Academy Lifetime Christmas movies 2017 sitcom Amazon Apple TV Plus Epix Pop DC streaming service classics APB 1990s indiana jones ITV TIFF police drama Box Office sopranos witnail strong female leads blockbusters Kids & Family Character Guide docudrama Rocketman Binge Guide Grammys true crime joker cancelled TV shows USA WGN cancelled television razzies Academy Awards DC Comics comics Cosplay Rom-Com universal monsters TCA 2017 Alien 2019 Musical cancelled Apple VOD Trophy Talk japan Wes Anderson AMC Plus The Purge TV movies monster movies Lucasfilm Paramount Network 24 frames legend BET Nat Geo stop motion anthology Sony Pictures Legendary Universal Pictures NBA Heroines richard e. Grant 79th Golden Globes Awards 2016 new york Countdown PBS rt labs golden globe awards high school Best Actor debate medical drama comic books Animation video on demand Image Comics 2021 aliens TNT science fiction scene in color hidden camera asian-american wonder woman Photos Starz facebook Paramount South by Southwest Film Festival spider-man 90s Arrowverse 94th Oscars Apple TV+ CW Seed FX Columbia Pictures christmas movies streaming comic book movie Hallmark worst movies documentaries mission: impossible Emmys rotten movies we love Podcast Adult Swim Fall TV animated Marvel Television HBO Max OWN franchise summer TV BBC America 4/20 halloween tv binge 45 target adenture Indigenous boxoffice Sundance TV San Diego Comic-Con anime Bravo cinemax Winners AMC Election revenge 2018 Family adaptation batman Instagram Live slasher A24 golden globes quibi new zealand MSNBC Horror ID Paramount Pictures Comic-Con@Home 2021 Pet Sematary Marvel Studios Creative Arts Emmys die hard parents child's play TLC Schedule directors cops Premiere Dates satire Tarantino vs. documentary trophy Netflix Best Director Broadway FOX Set visit dark WarnerMedia prank Watching Series target scene in color zombies superhero SXSW Emmy Nominations Reality Competition TV Mystery Polls and Games 007 spinoff reviews blockbuster diversity The Walking Dead screen actors guild First Look comiccon trailers HBO Go FX on Hulu Pirates LGBTQ films 99% Sundance Now Dark Horse Comics harry potter Winter TV TCA Awards talk show news archives game of thrones spy thriller adventure Shondaland zombie Best and Worst crime thriller doctor who BBC One what to watch zero dark thirty spanish stand-up comedy Avengers Disney Channel spain BET Awards 93rd Oscars romantic comedy Anna Paquin ABC Trivia deadpool sag awards movies Stephen King TV One best heist movie Year in Review Television Academy mutant werewolf Mary Tyler Moore independent Interview OneApp Video Games Drama mob 2020 pirates of the caribbean Extras king arthur Trailer serial killer Mary poppins TCA Winter 2020 dreamworks cancelled TV series SDCC broadcast