Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Out of the Furnace is Tough but Uneven

Plus, Inside Llewyn Davis is Certified Fresh.

by | December 5, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got just one wide release: Out of the Furnace, a blue-collar crime thriller starring Christian Bale and Woody Harrelson. What do the critics have to say?

Out of the Furnace


Gritty, moody, and populated by a cast of A-listers, Out of the Furnace promises a higher class of pulp than your average vengeance thriller. But critics say that while the actors imbue their characters with heft, they’re stuck with an uneven script that serves up many fine moments but fails to fully cohere. Bale stars as Russell, a steel worker whose brother Rodney (Casey Affleck) has just come home from Iraq. But when Rodney disappears after falling in with a local criminal organization, Russell goes looking for him — a search that leads him to Harlan (Woody Harrelson), the gang’s brutal ringleader. The pundits say that Out of the Furnace is raw and atmospheric, but it’s inconsistently paced and occasionally melodramatic. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Bale’s best-reviewed films.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

FXX harry potter romance game of thrones jurassic park Fargo cults green book Pride Month dramedy Trophy Talk science fiction rom-coms renewed TV shows psychological thriller screen actors guild sequel Reality Competition slasher television Sundance TV SundanceTV best basketball Infographic cops Musicals Certified Fresh Black Mirror franchise FOX NYCC BET BBC America cancelled television book adaptation 93rd Oscars SXSW Endgame zombie TV renewals Animation National Geographic discovery kong Bravo genre Oscars Teen DirecTV trailers Vudu Year in Review Rocky royal family worst movies Tomatazos Television Academy GoT thriller The Academy The CW teaser joker Netflix independent TCA Winter 2020 Schedule cancelled ViacomCBS elevated horror witnail Amazon Studios Awards Tour Comic-Con@Home 2021 Apple TV+ rt labs crime popular Pirates Marvel mutant WarnerMedia Chilling Adventures of Sabrina documentaries Disney streaming service Tumblr Masterpiece venice screenings 2018 Elton John satire adenture latino Shudder streaming Writers Guild of America Podcast ITV 79th Golden Globes Awards 2021 NBC Trailer Awards Women's History Month suspense Baby Yoda Photos king kong Pop Holidays art house TV Land Lifetime Christmas movies VH1 prank all-time ghosts Superheroes 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Image Comics Star Trek lord of the rings Interview Wes Anderson feel good 71st Emmy Awards universal monsters 2019 Video Games YouTube Red TCA 2017 ABC Signature Food Network Walt Disney Pictures The Walking Dead technology Lucasfilm video natural history boxoffice period drama australia HBO razzies action-comedy Shondaland travel Red Carpet aapi TCA dark OWN comics laika parents RT21 Martial Arts sopranos YouTube Premium new york Funimation comic book movies Television Critics Association foreign Turner Election festivals Super Bowl Cannes 21st Century Fox Reality Fall TV directors police drama sequels spider-verse Turner Classic Movies BBC 2015 Film Festival nature critic resources medical drama BBC One Captain marvel CBS All Access dceu Marathons Acorn TV Academy Awards spinoff psycho New York Comic Con Ellie Kemper RT History talk show archives cancelled TV series chucky streaming movies cinemax Crunchyroll Quiz Mary Tyler Moore zero dark thirty scene in color kids halloween tv blockbuster 90s miniseries VOD APB Emmy Nominations IFC The Purge scary movies cats Binge Guide Black History Month award winner Comics on TV war target deadpool indiana jones documentary adaptation ABC TV richard e. Grant zombies Universal Tarantino FX on Hulu true crime biopic critics 20th Century Fox Calendar high school 45 anthology hist indie Neflix sag awards Classic Film Spring TV know your critic game show TruTV dexter Sundance Now vampires king arthur Sundance Pacific Islander comic gangster movie cooking italian ABC Family Rocketman Disney Plus child's play GIFs comedies series 2017 werewolf canceled TV shows Cartoon Network Winter TV 2016 mcc American Society of Cinematographers golden globes stoner BAFTA AMC Ghostbusters asian-american black french Drama Travel Channel unscripted hispanic heritage month Tags: Comedy name the review Starz Spike cars movies Pop TV twilight hidden camera festival 24 frames Avengers PBS See It Skip It Chernobyl TBS tv talk hispanic kaiju PlayStation romantic comedy Cosplay Apple TV Plus CW Seed emmy awards Logo Rom-Com new zealand A24 spanish Marvel Television worst remakes facebook Emmys DGA obituary Ovation TV movies Comedy Syfy Disney Channel VICE Pet Sematary Set visit Opinion Premiere Dates HBO Go Adult Swim Valentine's Day godzilla A&E Fox News dogs breaking bad Box Office films IFC Films CNN rotten Broadway leaderboard CMT Disney+ Disney Plus toronto stand-up comedy Rock X-Men vs. Pixar Star Wars japan Freeform stop motion Heroines Paramount USA Network toy story DC Universe Exclusive Video Musical supernatural strong female leads dreamworks Lionsgate boxing robots international Spectrum Originals Amazon Prime Video AMC Plus versus Superheroe Toys biography 4/20 telelvision TNT mob cartoon black comedy canceled quibi legend blaxploitation HFPA Apple singing competition diversity MTV concert theme song Creative Arts Emmys animated space comiccon composers fast and furious Anna Paquin Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Mary Poppins Returns aliens President Showtime 007 2020 San Diego Comic-Con mockumentary Amazon marvel comics Watching Series wonder woman sitcom Nominations YouTube casting Dark Horse Comics docudrama rt archives LGBTQ Extras Christmas women Arrowverse spy thriller sports Tubi ESPN TLC Summer Thanksgiving Esquire TV One ID marvel cinematic universe GLAAD comic books Mindy Kaling Comic Book Marvel Studios Western south america dc Disney nfl dragons mission: impossible spanish language Sneak Peek Universal Pictures rt labs critics edition video on demand Nat Geo nbcuniversal First Look Family Music docuseries Best and Worst Countdown comic book movie football crime drama reviews TIFF FX trophy a nightmare on elm street Tokyo Olympics Columbia Pictures scorecard saw Holiday MCU Song of Ice and Fire Hulu crossover fresh DC Comics doctor who based on movie what to watch HBO Max transformers Nickelodeon YA USA Comedy Central Film spider-man The Witch adventure CBS japanese cancelled TV shows justice league book Biopics 1990s new star wars movies political drama superhero E3 Sony Pictures Country Action monster movies El Rey DC streaming service binge 99% Paramount Network Instagram Live OneApp Lifetime young adult SDCC 72 Emmy Awards Alien classics Prime Video criterion rotten movies we love Hallmark Christmas movies disaster jamie lee curtis Amazon Prime Grammys Crackle posters 73rd Emmy Awards Brie Larson Trivia heist movie halloween pirates of the caribbean hollywood crime thriller Fantasy Hallmark Mystery live action anime blockbusters social media Legendary Britbox Horror PaleyFest E! Stephen King Paramount Plus Character Guide LGBT spain finale politics Epix slashers IMDb TV Mary poppins children's TV Fox Searchlight superman Hollywood Foreign Press Association Kids & Family The Walt Disney Company MSNBC ratings Mudbound reboot History Peacock The Arrangement serial killer revenge golden globe awards Winners debate olympics news historical drama batman Sci-Fi james bond WGN Polls and Games christmas movies Discovery Channel Hear Us Out TCM BET Awards scary TCA Awards free movies die hard live event First Reviews NBA Netflix Christmas movies Warner Bros.