Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Out of the Furnace is Tough but Uneven

Plus, Inside Llewyn Davis is Certified Fresh.

by | December 5, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got just one wide release: Out of the Furnace, a blue-collar crime thriller starring Christian Bale and Woody Harrelson. What do the critics have to say?

Out of the Furnace

53%

Gritty, moody, and populated by a cast of A-listers, Out of the Furnace promises a higher class of pulp than your average vengeance thriller. But critics say that while the actors imbue their characters with heft, they’re stuck with an uneven script that serves up many fine moments but fails to fully cohere. Bale stars as Russell, a steel worker whose brother Rodney (Casey Affleck) has just come home from Iraq. But when Rodney disappears after falling in with a local criminal organization, Russell goes looking for him — a search that leads him to Harlan (Woody Harrelson), the gang’s brutal ringleader. The pundits say that Out of the Furnace is raw and atmospheric, but it’s inconsistently paced and occasionally melodramatic. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Bale’s best-reviewed films.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Captain marvel Spring TV adventure emmy awards streamig biopic twilight gangster versus rotten women sopranos die hard Tags: Comedy SXSW BAFTA scary Adult Swim Esquire singing competition french 2017 20th Century Fox The Walking Dead President 73rd Emmy Awards laika Calendar Elton John Oscars Box Office Sundance Now IFC universal monsters The Academy football X-Men Pacific Islander TIFF Comic-Con@Home 2021 hollywood revenge Thanksgiving Epix NYCC deadpool IMDb TV Native Cartoon Network casting Year in Review Awards Hallmark Christmas movies LGBT comic book movies Spectrum Originals richard e. Grant Best and Worst Trailer 4/20 LGBTQ trophy cooking Disney telelvision Rom-Com tv talk 94th Oscars Amazon Prime FOX Pride Month Crackle Chernobyl based on movie Fox Searchlight Baby Yoda spanish language pirates of the caribbean summer TV preview award winner fresh facebook YouTube Premium Acorn TV black Hollywood Foreign Press Association Disney Channel venice sports christmas movies USA Network USA crossover TV Marvel Television japan live event TNT Freeform razzies TV renewals science fiction Infographic archives Turner Classic Movies game show action-comedy ITV interviews rom-coms basketball franchise war japanese Logo Comedy American Society of Cinematographers cats mockumentary DC Comics El Rey A24 hidden camera Broadway vampires Superheroe GoT Warner Bros. Masterpiece werewolf PlayStation Indigenous SundanceTV cancelled TV series Classic Film 2016 indiana jones dark posters political drama Apple TV Plus Discovery Channel comiccon hispanic heritage month BBC America critic resources 24 frames Opinion Legendary Reality genre Hear Us Out Exclusive Video young adult Focus Features sequel south america art house Lifetime Toys 2018 know your critic ABC Family true crime comedies lord of the rings talk show Alien Instagram Live halloween tv superman Fall TV batman Sony Oscar hist unscripted spinoff Tomatazos The Arrangement golden globe awards rotten movies we love serial killer nature summer TV Lifetime Christmas movies 2015 cancelled TV shows police drama BET docudrama San Diego Comic-Con slasher TCA Awards Lucasfilm remakes theme song renewed TV shows The Walt Disney Company TruTV Tarantino Character Guide FX on Hulu YA Red Carpet Ovation marvel comics Crunchyroll comic Sundance TV parents concert Podcast movie asian-american politics Star Wars target natural history Countdown anime Writers Guild of America mob suspense Certified Fresh CW Seed Extras Television Academy Peacock Heroines Musical Photos Nickelodeon robots Arrowverse king arthur news Endgame Shondaland Super Bowl films dragons NBC Academy Awards APB Pixar Wes Anderson toronto hispanic rt labs First Reviews Amazon Prime Video crime fast and furious 90s breaking bad popular children's TV spanish Paramount Pictures 21st Century Fox Starz Reality Competition stand-up comedy cancelled Walt Disney Pictures comic books MCU spain teaser Fargo AMC A&E new star wars movies Showtime streaming movies OWN kong australia NBA adaptation international supernatural kids GLAAD Watching Series BET Awards Syfy docuseries Animation best Amazon Studios thriller 79th Golden Globes Awards live action Bravo high school independent Schedule nbcuniversal series Superheroes Neflix Paramount Plus Drama stop motion Mudbound doctor who biography new zealand SDCC Netflix Christmas movies mutant trailers cinemax Pirates Best Picture nfl target scene in color Black Mirror CNN scary movies summer preview Turner FXX Disney+ Disney Plus marvel cinematic universe disaster DC streaming service Sony Pictures harry potter Kids & Family IFC Films Film Summer Quiz adenture Cosplay classics cartoon VICE The Purge technology foreign legend TCA Winter 2020 book adaptation criterion chucky VOD joker obituary quibi Set visit dreamworks boxoffice canceled TV shows Travel Channel Spike diversity Pop TV ViacomCBS Disney Plus Mary poppins critics canceled Horror a nightmare on elm street dceu transformers BBC One Marvel Studios romantic comedy CBS Best Actor Apple 71st Emmy Awards period drama Tubi worst movies DGA scene in color Premiere Dates SXSW 2022 Rock stoner Action Prime Video 93rd Oscars blockbusters spider-verse james bond festivals Chilling Adventures of Sabrina composers HBO Max historical drama Fox News zombies jurassic park Comic Book TV movies zero dark thirty 1990s Fantasy ID spy thriller child's play ratings Disney streaming service TLC binge halloween ghosts jamie lee curtis Paramount feel good Comedy Central Teen E3 FX Mary Poppins Returns screen actors guild Pop Columbia Pictures game of thrones Martial Arts BBC Rocky strong female leads king kong Ellie Kemper VH1 festival aapi book medical drama dogs psycho The Witch cancelled television Britbox TV One History vs. comics Anna Paquin Ghostbusters crime drama worst RT21 Universal Tumblr broadcast leaderboard sequels Music Netflix RT History streaming Television Critics Association 2021 YouTube MSNBC Nominations Family cops psychological thriller scorecard obi wan PaleyFest rt archives kaiju superhero Brie Larson Awards Tour Country Apple TV+ HFPA anthology mcc Holiday Sci-Fi TCM 007 blockbuster ABC Signature zombie First Look italian Trophy Talk justice league CBS All Access Film Festival saw Hallmark Election new york latino documentary Western Shudder CMT The CW Star Wars Celebration elevated horror 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Musicals crime thriller documentaries TBS Hulu YouTube Red scene in color series free movies DirecTV satire TCA heist movie miniseries Biopics Nat Geo Cannes indie 2020 sag awards spider-man South by Southwest Film Festival Tokyo Olympics green book screenings Star Trek OneApp Black History Month Emmy Nominations Trivia Paramount Network scene in color film series Stephen King name the review black comedy Song of Ice and Fire MGM Holidays Food Network cults space Valentine's Day 45 See It Skip It Geeked Week video on demand WGN witnail Marathons E! Universal Pictures wonder woman 72 Emmy Awards Rocketman Vudu finale ESPN GIFs toy story Avengers Amazon debate discovery AMC Plus DC Universe godzilla cars prank ABC WarnerMedia boxing MTV Funimation golden globes National Geographic 2019 Interview Women's History Month PBS what to watch Image Comics reviews Grammys romance Marvel olympics Mary Tyler Moore Best Actress dexter video Sundance dramedy Mystery HBO Dark Horse Comics rt labs critics edition movies TV Land Christmas TCA 2017 dc Winter TV directors royal family aliens Sneak Peek Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt social media animated mission: impossible Binge Guide blaxploitation slashers Comics on TV Best Director travel HBO Go sitcom Lionsgate 99% Polls and Games monster movies comic book movie Winners Mindy Kaling Creative Arts Emmys all-time Video Games Emmys Pet Sematary reboot New York Comic Con television