Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: On Stranger Tides is Out to Sea

Plus, Woody Allen's Midnight in Paris is a charmer.

by | May 20, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got the hotly-anticipated fourth journey of Capt. Jack Sparrow — Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides, starring Johnny Depp and Penelope Cruz. What do the critics have to say?

Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides


When Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl hit theaters in 2003, it was a delightful surprise — Johnny Depp charmed nearly everyone with his Keith Richards-meets-Buster Keaton performance as the lovable, roguish Capt. Jack Sparrow, and the whole enterprise was much smarter — and more exciting – than any movie based upon an amusement park ride had a right to be. What was once fresh, however, has now become pretty stale; critics say the third Pirates sequel, On Stranger Tides, has moments of inspiration, but mostly it just feels mechanical, overdosing on big effects without generating much excitement in the process. This time out, Sparrow is in search of the mythical Fountain of Youth. He commandeers the ship of the legendary Blackbeard (Ian McShane) and joins forces with the mysterious, possibly villainous Angelica (Penélope Cruz). The pundits say that while On Stranger Tides is well-acted and shows flashes of the vaudevillian swashbuckling that made the franchise a pop-culture staple, it mostly does exactly what you expect, but without the brisk pacing and panache of yore. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down producer Jerry Bruckheimer’s best-reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Louder Than A Bomb, a documentary about a group of high school students competing in a poetry slam competition, is at 100 percent.
  • Life 2.0, a doc about the strange lives of Second Life players, is at 100 percent.
  • Woody Allen‘s Midnight in Paris, starring Owen Wilson and Rachel McAdams in a comedy/fantasy about a writer who finds himself transported to Jazz Age Paris, is at 87 percent.
  • Cost of a Soul, a drama about an Iraq war vet who returns home to a dangerous neighborhood, is at 33 percent.

Tag Cloud

The Academy Schedule screen actors guild OneApp Universal Pictures USA south america streaming Mindy Kaling OWN Ghostbusters ABC HBO Go VOD ABC Family jamie lee curtis IFC name the review fresh fast and furious MCU Valentine's Day Superheroes dreamworks worst movies TV renewals Comic-Con@Home 2021 mob classics Spectrum Originals Brie Larson heist movie Paramount Network Pop TV Emmys rotten movies we love satire Hollywood Foreign Press Association spider-verse The CW sports documentary Bravo cults historical drama Emmy Nominations Acorn TV dceu Image Comics transformers television Polls and Games james bond New York Comic Con Logo FXX BET Awards jurassic park Disney streaming service dragons comedies slasher joker Fall TV Disney Plus teaser FOX Crackle godzilla news FX young adult TV One australia Tags: Comedy leaderboard crime chucky Tokyo Olympics know your critic comiccon YouTube Red Adult Swim dexter mcc Comic Book diversity National Geographic comic golden globe awards Grammys Teen Martial Arts blaxploitation animated Apple TV+ children's TV live action Sneak Peek RT History X-Men cops emmy awards hist Certified Fresh basketball canceled TV shows Chernobyl 79th Golden Globes Awards Pacific Islander Binge Guide BBC streaming movies toy story award winner Family 2016 sitcom TNT Women's History Month dark RT21 Stephen King pirates of the caribbean unscripted Syfy cancelled Star Trek Marvel Television golden globes LGBTQ Shudder space TCA 2017 A24 Reality parents Vudu mockumentary stand-up comedy ABC Signature trophy criterion boxing 2020 cancelled television Marathons directors Alien mission: impossible Summer saw scene in color Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt WGN documentaries VH1 critics kaiju YouTube Video Games Animation 2018 Esquire tv talk 71st Emmy Awards Drama disaster anime Horror video Peacock high school cartoon CNN Star Wars 4/20 cancelled TV shows Awards Tour Trivia universal monsters Rom-Com sequels discovery E3 french MSNBC 90s Netflix Christmas movies 2015 Holiday marvel cinematic universe El Rey Reality Competition Toys hispanic Tumblr serial killer Lifetime Christmas movies marvel comics international dogs hidden camera Ellie Kemper politics Kids & Family TCA football Rock Mudbound franchise romantic comedy war 007 Fantasy A&E DirecTV Western Film Festival History Disney+ Disney Plus Cosplay black comedy reboot Avengers SDCC zombie rt labs critics edition a nightmare on elm street Opinion PBS SundanceTV USA Network science fiction Food Network 21st Century Fox singing competition versus miniseries mutant true crime 2019 Photos TCA Awards Amazon CBS All Access concert Nat Geo IMDb TV Broadway Comedy Hallmark Christmas movies Heroines First Reviews target Television Critics Association revenge The Arrangement Fox Searchlight nfl legend Wes Anderson Thanksgiving game show finale Walt Disney Pictures docudrama Universal laika Fargo Comedy Central wonder woman Super Bowl cats Starz reviews PlayStation Set visit monster movies period drama blockbusters CW Seed cinemax Dark Horse Comics 24 frames canceled justice league indiana jones AMC Columbia Pictures San Diego Comic-Con Travel Channel HBO Masterpiece new zealand 73rd Emmy Awards telelvision Lionsgate Crunchyroll Spring TV remakes renewed TV shows Best and Worst The Walt Disney Company Mystery SXSW rotten Exclusive Video The Purge psycho crime thriller hispanic heritage month Winners Superheroe scorecard spain italian spinoff Ovation Hulu women twilight royal family Interview Infographic strong female leads President FX on Hulu DC streaming service new york rt archives Cannes stop motion Freeform Arrowverse superman Country First Look HBO Max lord of the rings comic book movies rt labs movies doctor who Writers Guild of America feel good 72 Emmy Awards romance action-comedy Film Oscars free movies BAFTA stoner theme song deadpool ESPN live event adaptation spanish Apple TV Plus medical drama LGBT Amazon Studios Baby Yoda Comics on TV Biopics Tubi breaking bad BBC America Showtime obituary psychological thriller APB DC Comics Sundance Now YA aliens TV Land binge game of thrones trailers scary movies Paramount Netflix crossover YouTube Premium Mary Poppins Returns popular Year in Review quibi crime drama independent TBS black Nickelodeon Neflix Calendar sopranos richard e. Grant Britbox Pixar 99% talk show art house what to watch Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Quiz dramedy best 45 NBC Epix TLC ghosts 1990s based on movie Sci-Fi ViacomCBS Pride Month Turner Classic Movies biography Musicals CMT Prime Video Disney latino Musical festivals TruTV Election Trophy Talk die hard Tomatazos japanese The Witch HFPA comic book movie VICE critic resources NYCC book adaptation travel Sundance Watching Series Disney Channel casting nature WarnerMedia political drama Apple Trailer E! spy thriller Hear Us Out Television Academy BET elevated horror natural history book nbcuniversal series films American Society of Cinematographers aapi Creative Arts Emmys police drama spanish language prank TV movies Warner Bros. 93rd Oscars Mary poppins gangster vampires Rocketman kids blockbuster slashers movie asian-american Pop dc king arthur venice Discovery Channel Awards thriller Cartoon Network batman The Walking Dead Fox News 2021 halloween tv foreign worst king kong docuseries Marvel Black Mirror NBA Endgame Action Lucasfilm TCA Winter 2020 olympics Classic Film Amazon Prime PaleyFest Extras Character Guide Paramount Plus Rocky Holidays Pet Sematary zero dark thirty Music Elton John superhero TCM posters spider-man cancelled TV series toronto CBS robots comic books adventure Red Carpet new star wars movies Box Office Sundance TV screenings BBC One sequel Anna Paquin TV ratings See It Skip It composers DC Universe Instagram Live Song of Ice and Fire AMC Plus ITV harry potter zombies video on demand christmas movies suspense Mary Tyler Moore Marvel Studios cars cooking Shondaland archives Countdown Amazon Prime Video ID hollywood razzies GIFs Hallmark TIFF sag awards all-time Academy Awards MTV genre Pirates Christmas werewolf supernatural Legendary Premiere Dates facebook Captain marvel Lifetime Turner IFC Films kong Black History Month 2017 social media technology Winter TV witnail boxoffice adenture Nominations GLAAD debate scary biopic DGA indie vs. japan Funimation green book 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards 20th Century Fox comics child's play anthology Podcast Sony Pictures rom-coms Spike halloween Tarantino festival GoT