Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Oblivion Looks Great, But Its Story Meanders

Plus, In the House is creepy and witty.

by | April 18, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got only one wide release: the post-apocalyptic sci-fi adventure Oblivion, starring Tom Cruise and Morgan Freeman. What do the critics have to say?



Can a movie get by on good looks alone? Critics say Oblivion is visually striking but narratively thin, a thoughtful sci-fi head trip that starts strong but gets bogged down by its murky storyline. While working as a repairman on an abandoned, post-Apocalyptic Planet Earth, Jack Harper (Tom Cruise) discovers that he’s not alone — and that everything he knows has been a lie. The pundits say Cruise’s strong performance helps to enliven the proceedings, but Oblivion is largely derivative of other, better sci-fi films. (Check out this week’s 24 Frames and Total Recall features for more on post-apocalyptic movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Finally, props to Emilio Rodriguez and Kadeem Stewart for coming the closest to guessing Scary Movie 5‘s five percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

PaleyFest Grammys news pirates of the caribbean space Winter TV Women's History Month Lifetime Christmas movies game of thrones dragons 99% CNN TIFF The Academy festivals Exclusive Video serial killer Musical miniseries Infographic aliens cartoon boxing hidden camera stop motion 20th Century Fox Peacock 90s GIFs comic books screenings live event HBO HBO Max 79th Golden Globes Awards ABC anime blockbusters comedies laika Calendar Cannes name the review Comics on TV king arthur El Rey sequels toronto Black History Month MCU halloween tv strong female leads SXSW Chernobyl cancelled television Alien 2020 Netflix Christmas movies RT History National Geographic Lifetime scary movies hispanic Election heist movie Lionsgate 2015 USA Animation cops talk show foreign MSNBC cinemax christmas movies Comic Book San Diego Comic-Con BBC Dark Horse Comics Toys Stephen King E! Masterpiece supernatural Esquire free movies spider-verse comic 2021 Lucasfilm feel good docudrama BET Ellie Kemper Hollywood Foreign Press Association YouTube Red WarnerMedia italian Film south america natural history japan social media NBA The Walking Dead period drama stand-up comedy doctor who TBS die hard 2018 Binge Guide Pirates Funimation Television Academy marvel cinematic universe VOD mcc movies FX reboot cancelled Academy Awards fresh Mudbound Fargo 71st Emmy Awards 73rd Emmy Awards crime drama Anna Paquin Hallmark Christmas movies Mary Poppins Returns binge Extras Sneak Peek WGN Mary Tyler Moore renewed TV shows scorecard Western king kong suspense animated Mystery new york Instagram Live Reality Competition TCM 21st Century Fox universal monsters Cartoon Network child's play Fox Searchlight adventure CBS All Access Classic Film Britbox golden globe awards rt labs critics edition australia DC Universe dexter Tubi Winners joker First Look FX on Hulu rt labs ABC Family criterion Biopics olympics cooking a nightmare on elm street Emmy Nominations Awards Year in Review spanish language live action comic book movie IFC technology Drama Pop Summer revenge elevated horror Sundance Now razzies crime Teen adenture video on demand Acorn TV action-comedy Spectrum Originals singing competition spanish rotten movies we love Broadway saw medical drama political drama dramedy zombies nfl new star wars movies halloween Comedy Central American Society of Cinematographers worst Baby Yoda Captain marvel Marathons sitcom Rom-Com psychological thriller genre Polls and Games hist french book Warner Bros. harry potter witnail nature best Hallmark science fiction Arrowverse Video Games know your critic critics women dark 45 Apple romance NYCC canceled Pet Sematary Countdown DC Comics Amazon Prime IFC Films ESPN zombie ABC Signature Rocky spain Tags: Comedy anthology vampires Starz DC streaming service superman screen actors guild prank TV One The Arrangement asian-american streaming Food Network FXX documentaries Universal Pictures festival ID Trophy Talk comiccon docuseries new zealand Reality Family television Emmys Super Bowl Discovery Channel BET Awards Amazon Prime Video Kids & Family superhero werewolf mob Writers Guild of America First Reviews nbcuniversal international award winner PlayStation toy story New York Comic Con high school Logo Heroines art house BBC One james bond Best and Worst AMC Plus chucky BBC America crime thriller Nominations TV movies Paramount A&E History VH1 Nickelodeon OneApp mutant PBS GLAAD scary series Sundance TV Mary poppins NBC Disney Plus obituary E3 movie comic book movies indie Vudu Adult Swim trophy Image Comics scene in color all-time DGA spider-man facebook archives documentary teaser disaster TCA 2017 diversity psycho Opinion finale TCA Winter 2020 Ovation 93rd Oscars theme song Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Character Guide basketball Thanksgiving monster movies TruTV Marvel Studios comics TV Rock CMT USA Network Holidays richard e. Grant legend politics streaming movies 24 frames Turner independent mission: impossible The Walt Disney Company Pacific Islander rotten Showtime indiana jones Neflix Tarantino The CW Film Festival sopranos worst movies Wes Anderson Fall TV zero dark thirty Apple TV+ ratings Tumblr Marvel Television emmy awards satire venice vs. Columbia Pictures remakes boxoffice leaderboard Sundance YouTube Premium Walt Disney Pictures slasher sports TCA Awards Shudder Christmas hollywood aapi Hulu 72 Emmy Awards Pixar Crackle Comic-Con@Home 2021 Paramount Plus book adaptation Trailer Television Critics Association reviews video Musicals police drama cars Martial Arts dogs Brie Larson TV Land spinoff Avengers Endgame Superheroes kids Action IMDb TV 007 godzilla Bravo transformers See It Skip It Schedule classics Valentine's Day Mindy Kaling Pop TV historical drama trailers Creative Arts Emmys blaxploitation Country Trivia AMC Red Carpet President Crunchyroll franchise ITV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Rocketman Disney+ Disney Plus Photos game show canceled TV shows GoT Amazon thriller Cosplay Interview crossover 4/20 LGBT mockumentary Horror cats robots HBO Go SDCC Elton John 2019 blockbuster critic resources twilight films Netflix ghosts biography gangster TV renewals casting Pride Month Hear Us Out dreamworks Syfy Prime Video latino Star Wars A24 1990s OWN Sci-Fi cancelled TV shows Turner Classic Movies black Certified Fresh Travel Channel Superheroe adaptation Holiday biopic parents Tokyo Olympics batman Oscars ViacomCBS Fantasy jurassic park what to watch sequel football breaking bad cults HFPA SundanceTV travel Freeform Legendary jamie lee curtis marvel comics CBS wonder woman rom-coms The Witch composers target Amazon Studios Fox News VICE Premiere Dates YA rt archives TNT Epix young adult Black Mirror Disney Channel Sony Pictures The Purge Box Office BAFTA Watching Series debate spy thriller hispanic heritage month stoner Set visit DirecTV justice league black comedy Paramount Network Tomatazos APB 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards war Spring TV royal family Nat Geo kong green book Podcast dc MTV Shondaland Apple TV Plus sag awards fast and furious deadpool discovery Spike telelvision LGBTQ tv talk lord of the rings posters Music children's TV Quiz directors TCA CW Seed FOX Marvel YouTube golden globes Universal Awards Tour unscripted 2017 concert slashers cancelled TV series popular Disney streaming service Ghostbusters true crime japanese X-Men Song of Ice and Fire 2016 based on movie RT21 versus quibi romantic comedy dceu TLC Comedy kaiju Star Trek Disney