Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Narnia Looks Great, but Lacks Magic

Plus, The Tourist isn't worth the trip, and The Fighter is Certified Fresh.

by | December 10, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a spiritual journey (The Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, starring Georgie Henley and Skandar Keynes) and some European intrigue (The Tourist, starring Johnny Depp and Angelina Jolie). What do the critics have to say?


The Chronicles of Narnia: The Voyage of the Dawn Treader

Thus far, the Chronicles of Narnia movies have generated respectful enthusiasm from audiences and critics – in contrast to the rabid culthood surrounding the Lord of the Rings or Harry Potter movies. And critics say that’s not likely to change with the franchise’s latest outing, (The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, which they say is visually striking but lacks both excitement and a sense of wonder. Once again, the Pevensie children are back in Narnia, and this time they must journey across the sea and collect seven swords in order to save Narnia from certain destruction. The pundits sayDawn Treader isn’t bad, and some of the creature designs are remarkable, but it’s short on urgency, wide-eyed marvel, and a sense of fun.


The Tourist

Everybody loves a caper picture, the kind in which beautiful people get in and out amidst picturesque locales. Right? Not necessarily in the case of The Tourist; critics say the seemingly can’t-miss proposition of Johnny Depp and Angelina Jolie trying to escape danger amidst the splendor of Europe’s most iconic cities is a serious letdown, a slow-moving bagatelle with minimal chemistry between its superstar leads. Depp stars as a lovelorn American who meets the mysterious, beautiful Jolie on a train. It turns out she’s caught up in an international game of cat-and-mouse, and Depp is caught in the crossfire. A certain level of absurdity is inherent in this sort of thing, but the pundits say The Tourist is too slackly paced to keep audiences from suspending disbelief, and the romance between Depp and Jolie is a nonstarter. (Check this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some other noteworthy superstar duos in the same movie.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Finally, props to Harrison M. for coming the closest to guessing The Warrior’s Way‘s 38 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

festival VICE Apple Super Bowl Heroines hispanic heritage month screenings Cannes cooking cars comics asian-american Musical Hollywood Foreign Press Association San Diego Comic-Con Year in Review animated The CW werewolf strong female leads classics WarnerMedia legend facebook Summer El Rey TBS 2021 jamie lee curtis FXX obi wan lord of the rings Film Festival Syfy Disney Channel Netflix Women's History Month LGBT Best Actress cancelled TV shows natural history rt labs comic book movie streaming Legendary NYCC know your critic Reality twilight Drama Interview ViacomCBS golden globe awards remakes Disney indie latino Superheroe TV renewals Cartoon Network spider-verse Country romance wonder woman comiccon halloween Amazon Prime live action gangster finale Tokyo Olympics psychological thriller sequels mutant Martial Arts Schedule E3 Star Wars TIFF Podcast Comic Book Mary poppins Logo Best and Worst scary movies Trailer Hear Us Out HFPA broadcast Musicals spy thriller Walt Disney Pictures hollywood Brie Larson unscripted emmy awards Film Watching Series Mary Tyler Moore trophy Star Wars Celebration name the review Biopics comic cancelled television ESPN BBC One nfl Thanksgiving crime drama toy story Emmy Nominations Fox News ratings batman dramedy Hulu Binge Guide Disney Plus superhero Marvel NBC mcc zombie spinoff revenge Black History Month Acorn TV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Apple TV Plus mob kids Polls and Games trailers 21st Century Fox vampires cults The Academy summer TV preview Reality Competition Black Mirror National Geographic stop motion TV Land cancelled TV series PBS spanish language ITV art house free movies Chilling Adventures of Sabrina dark movie Tubi miniseries adaptation History TCM canceled Superheroes 2020 Winners PaleyFest game show halloween tv SundanceTV Food Network rt labs critics edition Fantasy monster movies Universal Pictures Baby Yoda SDCC Extras CNN TV movies japan 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards anthology Starz discovery venice godzilla dexter mockumentary OWN MTV Paramount Pictures Rocky Paramount YA 94th Oscars E! Comics on TV canceled TV shows superman 2015 2018 kong Tarantino HBO Go scorecard 93rd Oscars cartoon Grammys DGA richard e. Grant crime Emmys Turner Classic Movies robots olympics Image Comics zombies Winter TV Pirates adenture streamig 2016 Television Academy Trophy Talk Rom-Com independent films South by Southwest Film Festival marvel comics political drama boxoffice CBS All Access a nightmare on elm street SXSW 2022 Geeked Week nature HBO Awards Tour Mudbound AMC Best Director royal family Academy Awards anime Video Games movies golden globes doctor who SXSW The Arrangement Set visit science fiction sitcom Box Office PlayStation new york australia comic book movies Tomatazos Oscars The Walking Dead high school witnail young adult Lionsgate archives Sony WGN Valentine's Day teaser toronto book adaptation singing competition slasher Funimation LGBTQ New York Comic Con Exclusive Video Certified Fresh DC Universe First Reviews telelvision all-time crossover screen actors guild rt archives TruTV Calendar tv talk Holiday Tags: Comedy The Purge live event Spike 71st Emmy Awards genre Paramount Plus Shudder CBS BBC America Best Picture Crackle spider-man news Lifetime Christmas movies women Amazon Studios Ellie Kemper MGM cats dragons blaxploitation heist movie scene in color series children's TV travel Elton John Freeform Quiz french Indigenous streaming movies Trivia slashers Horror reboot aapi Endgame YouTube Red ABC Family AMC Plus Shondaland Star Trek leaderboard south america jurassic park USA Network spanish harry potter Red Carpet Travel Channel RT21 king arthur Universal Amazon Prime Video stand-up comedy The Walt Disney Company Holidays Pride Month award winner 24 frames Teen 20th Century Fox Anna Paquin Nominations sopranos Kids & Family Neflix Sundance Now Marathons hispanic YouTube Premium medical drama Ghostbusters serial killer technology hidden camera book feel good Nickelodeon chucky Comic-Con@Home 2021 TV One Pixar series black comedy blockbuster Stephen King President Peacock IFC Amazon fresh adventure period drama First Look casting rom-coms CW Seed boxing Paramount Network Tumblr dceu Lifetime USA Awards basketball DC streaming service what to watch 79th Golden Globes Awards composers Spring TV police drama Television Critics Association die hard Arrowverse king kong CMT dc Fox Searchlight war Vudu Cosplay Photos concert sag awards Pop TV IFC Films Pop Mindy Kaling dogs true crime christmas movies RT History summer TV criterion justice league talk show Sci-Fi HBO Max Animation based on movie Bravo action-comedy worst new zealand IMDb TV best The Witch Masterpiece Sundance TV Mystery BET summer preview Fargo debate Toys Sundance reviews sports video on demand biography American Society of Cinematographers deadpool 007 new star wars movies GoT Hallmark Christmas movies kaiju APB Dark Horse Comics Fall TV binge laika documentaries Esquire suspense joker comedies 45 space documentary ABC Signature Wes Anderson black biopic Mary Poppins Returns Broadway Action VOD mission: impossible 99% Warner Bros. ABC GLAAD VH1 Election 90s cinemax Premiere Dates Avengers DirecTV Opinion game of thrones japanese parents ID obituary universal monsters BAFTA Spectrum Originals See It Skip It YouTube james bond X-Men DC Comics TNT blockbusters interviews Writers Guild of America critics 72 Emmy Awards Pacific Islander GIFs Columbia Pictures historical drama Infographic Adult Swim versus foreign Lucasfilm FX on Hulu NBA Disney+ Disney Plus dreamworks Disney streaming service Alien ghosts saw festivals docudrama docuseries Sneak Peek television scary TCA Winter 2020 FOX Rock aliens supernatural politics OneApp 2019 worst movies pirates of the caribbean Sony Pictures Crunchyroll italian 73rd Emmy Awards psycho crime thriller green book Netflix Christmas movies transformers theme song Epix BET Awards video FX Pet Sematary Family zero dark thirty rotten movies we love 4/20 Western Turner disaster A&E nbcuniversal renewed TV shows Apple TV+ Ovation MCU comic books Christmas romantic comedy Britbox A24 quibi Character Guide popular cancelled target scene in color Rocketman Oscar Best Actor Marvel Television Hallmark international Chernobyl BBC Classic Film cops Prime Video prank franchise football Showtime Countdown directors scene in color spain fast and furious Focus Features scene in color film series razzies indiana jones TLC Captain marvel vs. TCA Awards satire Song of Ice and Fire sequel critic resources Comedy Central MSNBC thriller Comedy 2017 TCA 2017 rotten TV Native child's play Music Creative Arts Emmys Discovery Channel target social media Marvel Studios elevated horror Instagram Live Nat Geo marvel cinematic universe stoner breaking bad 1990s TCA posters diversity hist