Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Mr. Peabody & Sherman is a Blast From the Past

Plus, 300: Rise of an Empire is a good looking but empty spectacle.

by | March 6, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a dog and his boy (Mr. Peabody & Sherman, with voice performances by Ty Burrell and Stephen Colbert) and some raging Spartans (300: Rise of an Empire, starring Sullivan Stapleton and Eva Green). What do the critics have to say?

Mr. Peabody & Sherman

81%

It’s never easy to stretch a series of shorts to feature-film length, especially when the source material is largely unfamiliar to its intended audience. Fortunately, critics say Mr. Peabody & Sherman is a mostly successful big screen adaptation, with enough cleverness and goofy action to please kids and their parents. Canine genius Mr. Peabody (voiced by Ty Burrell) and his adopted charge Sherman (Max Charles) use the WABAC machine to travel back in time and ensure that history’s greatest moments happen as they should. However, when Sherman takes the machine for a joyride to impress a classmate, it’s up to his doggie guardian to rescue him. The critics say Mr. Peabody & Sherman sometimes strains to maintain the inspired lunacy of the original cartoons, but most of the time, it’s bright, funny, exciting, and heartfelt. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some memorable time travel movies, as well as our interviews with the cast.)

300: Rise of an Empire

45%

If you’re in the mood stylized bloodshed, you’re in luck: 300: Rise of an Empire is chock full of beheadings, hacked-off limbs, and gallons of blood. But critics say beyond its admittedly impressive visuals, the film is short on the heroic bombast of its predecessor. This time out, it’s a band of plucky seafaring Greeks, lead by Themistokles (Sullivan Stapleton) against the mighty Persian navy, headed by Artemisia (Eva Green); as we eventually learn through a series of flashbacks, this fight is partially driven by personal animosity. The pundits say Green is fantastic as a bellicose she-devil, but little resonates in 300: Rise of an Empire beyond the lovingly rendered killings and decapitations. (Check out this week’s 24 Frames for a gallery of big stars in togas.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Miele, a drama about a woman who secretly helps people with terminal illnesses to die on their own terms, is at 100 percent.

  • Particle Fever, a documentary about the physicists working to find the Higgs boson particle, is at 92 percent.

  • In Fear, a thriller about a couple that gets lost en route to a would-be romantic getaway, is at 90 percent.

  • Journey To The West, Stephen Chow‘s adaptation of the classic Chinese novel about a Buddhist monk’s epic excursion from China to India, is at 90 percent.

  • Wes Anderson‘s The Grand Budapest Hotel, starring Ralph Fiennes and Saoirse Ronan in a period comedy about the adventures of a concierge and the oddball inhabitants of an ornate hotel, is Certified Fresh at 86 percent.

  • Grand Piano, starring Elijah Wood and John Cusack in a thriller about a concert pianist who must deliver a flawless performance to stave off a sniper, is at 82 percent.

  • Bethlehem, a drama about the tense relationship between an Israeli Secret Service officer and a Palestinian informant, is at 65 percent.

  • The Face of Love, starring Annette Bening and Ed Harris in a drama about a widow who meets a man who’s the spitting image of her dead husband, is at 53 percent.

  • Haunt, a horror film about a family that moves into an old house and stirs a malevolent curse, is at 20 percent.

Tag Cloud

unscripted CNN Amazon Studios Mindy Kaling Comics on TV Toys National Geographic LGBT remakes NBC Character Guide golden globes Star Wars YouTube YouTube Red GoT Black History Month SDCC Animation Box Office action-comedy true crime Peacock Captain marvel AMC Plus chucky mutant cats documentaries Star Wars Celebration boxing mission: impossible Trophy Talk New York Comic Con foreign rt labs critics edition Adult Swim comic book movie trophy President french YA crime die hard kids adaptation Television Academy Fall TV rotten Best Actor Spike genre hispanic heritage month venice Oscar Apple spain canceled anime blockbuster archives Mudbound based on movie critics Nominations OWN Election The Arrangement HBO Max Musicals Best Picture Baby Yoda Netflix Paramount Plus The Academy comic book movies ABC Family Native biography criterion renewed TV shows game show batman Crackle Britbox basketball italian satire Reality Competition thriller Thanksgiving FX Women's History Month TNT stand-up comedy cooking sopranos child's play Exclusive Video Infographic summer preview supernatural VH1 toronto Sundance TV OneApp dramedy Shondaland Kids & Family new york new zealand art house obituary psycho anthology target scene in color strong female leads golden globe awards Image Comics video Discovery Channel fresh slasher 71st Emmy Awards Rom-Com A24 Arrowverse olympics black binge aliens IFC Films Universal Pictures Heroines video on demand PBS know your critic X-Men SXSW worst movies canceled TV shows Ovation The Purge twilight indiana jones Song of Ice and Fire witnail movies suspense CMT popular IMDb TV Writers Guild of America Nickelodeon book adaptation zero dark thirty TV renewals adenture E! young adult trailers Disney Channel singing competition cults miniseries HBO GLAAD comedies Amazon Prime summer TV The Witch Biopics talk show all-time jamie lee curtis 2020 saw breaking bad Premiere Dates Winter TV The Walt Disney Company Television Critics Association broadcast Summer best revenge NYCC Rocketman james bond Pet Sematary Mary Tyler Moore sequels Comedy BBC American Society of Cinematographers royal family MCU documentary concert dogs 2021 psychological thriller Hulu Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TruTV international MTV obi wan mockumentary cartoon Best Actress king arthur Freeform Western Neflix Family festival facebook 2019 Paramount Network Tomatazos RT History Spring TV See It Skip It telelvision romance war Marvel Television Comedy Central Schedule nbcuniversal disaster Marvel Studios Esquire Video Games Action toy story WGN TCA Winter 2020 Rocky robots TV Land stop motion Sci-Fi BET Syfy sequel spy thriller DirecTV Tumblr Paramount Pictures Creative Arts Emmys FOX 1990s Watching Series independent Travel Channel Trailer south america comiccon YouTube Premium Chernobyl TCA 2017 First Reviews Best and Worst aapi dark women The CW spider-verse natural history new star wars movies 007 films spanish emmy awards Rock hist 21st Century Fox Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt mcc superhero Walt Disney Pictures E3 screenings cars Binge Guide teaser kong TV movies Film Festival Lifetime Apple TV+ Hallmark Christmas movies Warner Bros. Lucasfilm HBO Go Valentine's Day cancelled TV series technology 2017 Ghostbusters IFC marvel cinematic universe History Alien Disney+ Disney Plus green book Reality Certified Fresh monster movies docuseries ViacomCBS The Walking Dead Tarantino Trivia justice league Marathons king kong hispanic feel good scene in color film series heist movie RT21 animated Netflix Christmas movies Sony Pictures japan universal monsters Hallmark dreamworks 90s laika 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards zombie Hear Us Out Pop TV CBS Cosplay Sundance Fantasy rt labs Awards Tour Bravo Crunchyroll kaiju Sneak Peek Pirates Endgame Musical medical drama cops dceu historical drama Masterpiece Instagram Live Wes Anderson parents TV One streaming movies casting cancelled television TCA Awards SundanceTV halloween tv dragons scary movies indie Comic-Con@Home 2021 award winner Mystery Broadway police drama 93rd Oscars 2015 debate ITV dexter DC streaming service 45 BAFTA ratings Turner Classic Movies Amazon biopic sitcom space 20th Century Fox what to watch Oscars sports Tags: Comedy scene in color series BBC One series Horror wonder woman versus Opinion Winners Martial Arts marvel comics superman razzies Drama 79th Golden Globes Awards romantic comedy FXX Superheroe Best Director Tokyo Olympics scary a nightmare on elm street 2016 Holidays Quiz slashers australia Geeked Week TCM SXSW 2022 cinemax Paramount A&E serial killer franchise werewolf Legendary Anna Paquin composers reviews boxoffice 72 Emmy Awards Fox News posters high school worst cancelled TV shows Emmy Nominations Awards Pride Month Cartoon Network Amazon Prime Video Showtime First Look Dark Horse Comics mob Star Trek Vudu name the review asian-american Mary Poppins Returns MGM 94th Oscars comic blaxploitation BET Awards rotten movies we love spanish language 73rd Emmy Awards San Diego Comic-Con Photos political drama critic resources joker discovery comics Black Mirror screen actors guild reboot blockbusters TIFF Red Carpet Avengers television Marvel PlayStation movie PaleyFest Mary poppins Tubi HFPA Comic Book Funimation stoner crossover rt archives diversity science fiction Nat Geo ESPN Focus Features fast and furious 2018 Acorn TV theme song halloween Pacific Islander CBS All Access Universal FX on Hulu streamig summer TV preview ABC Fargo directors Prime Video TCA crime drama Turner scene in color Elton John Cannes nfl leaderboard Holiday Polls and Games classics festivals BBC America Logo adventure christmas movies vs. harry potter crime thriller tv talk ID TBS Disney streaming service Spectrum Originals Disney Plus DGA TLC live event Countdown USA Network dc Super Bowl gangster spinoff interviews black comedy Interview hidden camera hollywood ABC Signature VOD godzilla deadpool AMC cancelled DC Comics sag awards Extras El Rey live action elevated horror vampires Emmys target Music transformers Indigenous Sundance Now Apple TV Plus 99% LGBTQ Disney APB lord of the rings legend japanese Film ghosts social media Superheroes Brie Larson travel politics zombies Country CW Seed docudrama Ellie Kemper Shudder Food Network nature period drama South by Southwest Film Festival scorecard Stephen King GIFs doctor who Classic Film USA spider-man WarnerMedia finale game of thrones latino Columbia Pictures Teen Podcast free movies news Calendar prank Starz comic books Lifetime Christmas movies streaming TV pirates of the caribbean football 24 frames Lionsgate NBA Academy Awards DC Universe Sony quibi Christmas book children's TV 4/20 Fox Searchlight rom-coms Set visit Hollywood Foreign Press Association Grammys Pixar jurassic park MSNBC Epix Pop richard e. Grant Year in Review VICE