Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Jack the Giant Slayer is Fee-Fie-Fokay

Plus, Phantom is out to sea, 21 and Over is short on laugs, and The Last Exorcism Part II wasn't screened for critics.

by | March 1, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got fairy tale swashbuckling (Jack the Giant Slayer, starring Nicholas Hoult and Ewan McGregor), submarine suspense (Phantom, starring Ed Harris and David Duchovny), excessive partying (21 and Over, starring Miles Teller and Skylar Astin), and devilish doings (The Last Exorcism Part II, starring Ashley Bell and Spencer Treat Clark). What do the critics have to say?

Jack the Giant Slayer


With all the fairy tale adaptations Hollywood’s been cranking out lately, Jack and the Beanstalk seems particularly ripe for a big-budget adaptation. And critics say that while Jack the Giant Slayer is briskly paced and occasionally thrilling, it’s often more stylish than substantial. After unintentionally opening a portal to another world, Jack (Nicholas Hoult) fights to defend the earth from a group of giants who are attempting to reclaim their former realm. The pundits say Jack the Giant Slayer looks terrific, and it has some exciting set pieces, but it doesn’t do much to distinguish itself from other fantasy adventures of its ilk. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down star Ewan McGregor’s best-reviewed movies.)



Das Boot. The Hunt for Red October. Crimson Tide. There are plenty of good thrillers set on board submarines, but unfortunately, critics say the well-acted but poorly-scripted Phantom is unlikely to join their ranks. Ed Harris stars as the captain of a Soviet sub on a secret mission. However, several of the crew members, led by Bruni (David Duchovny), are planning to take over the ship and escalate conflict with the U.S. The pundits say Phantom is unfortunately short on tension, leaving its talented cast out to sea. (Watch our video interview with Harris and Duchovny.)

21 and Over


If the premise of 21 and Over — three dudes party and go on wild adventures unill somebody blacks out — sounds a lot like The Hangover, well, that’s because it shares screenwriters. What they don’t share, say critics, is a steady stream of laughs. Jeff (Justin Chon) is turning 21, but has an important interview the next day. His two buddies (Miles Teller and Skylar Astin) demand they hit the town; intoxication and hilarity ensue. The pundits say 21 and Over has a couple of solid gags, but they’re separated by long passages that are raunchy and politically incorrect rather than funny. (Check out this week’s 24 Frames for a gallery of memorable movie benders.)

The Last Exorcism Part II


Perhaps the studio behind The Last Exorcism Part II were afraid their film was less than bewitching, since it wasn’t screened prior to its release. Following the events of the previous film, Nell Sweetzer (Ashley Bell) is found alive with no recollection of what became of her family. Soon, she’s once again possessed by a demonic spirit. Time to play guess the Tomatometer again!

Also opening this week in limited release:

Finally, props to Donald Whitman Jr. for guessing Dark Skies‘s 30 percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

know your critic Apple Netflix TV Land 73rd Emmy Awards Turner Paramount Plus telelvision Nat Geo El Rey IMDb TV Winter TV Box Office biopic Pirates rotten Spectrum Originals Lifetime Action Sundance TV batman SXSW trailers Mary poppins documentaries biography screenings adaptation Neflix The Arrangement E3 Awards archives TCA 2017 ITV Walt Disney Pictures Esquire films cops crime drama cults golden globes Oscars VICE CMT New York Comic Con historical drama screen actors guild Toys Britbox satire science fiction crossover nbcuniversal SDCC deadpool 99% Election TIFF Nickelodeon franchise 45 crime thriller Quiz halloween tv Vudu Comic Book Apple TV Plus comedies CBS joker YouTube Tubi cancelled superhero Heroines American Society of Cinematographers vs. cancelled television Warner Bros. rt labs critics edition First Reviews Rom-Com scary TruTV Academy Awards Country Rocky ViacomCBS stand-up comedy HFPA TCA serial killer sitcom Legendary adenture cars National Geographic Musicals Superheroes Musical LGBTQ Creative Arts Emmys Opinion book adaptation disaster Peacock Black Mirror rt archives Spike slashers revenge crime Trophy Talk technology game of thrones Hallmark Kids & Family political drama DGA teaser Watching Series genre Crackle Sundance Now Reality Competition canceled TV shows mob First Look AMC Plus Mudbound dragons discovery rotten movies we love Thanksgiving Food Network 21st Century Fox Amazon pirates of the caribbean TV movies movies DC streaming service Exclusive Video Universal Pictures FX on Hulu festivals Christmas BAFTA popular Showtime women king kong fast and furious Countdown japan DirecTV 4/20 APB Valentine's Day emmy awards Sci-Fi Disney streaming service YA police drama royal family Extras The Walking Dead new zealand PaleyFest Animation romantic comedy jurassic park Baby Yoda Star Trek Comic-Con@Home 2021 72 Emmy Awards Holiday psychological thriller Instagram Live Writers Guild of America cartoon reviews scary movies A24 FX spy thriller Biopics new star wars movies Shudder hollywood universal monsters MCU Ghostbusters Sundance reboot marvel comics OWN HBO miniseries singing competition Horror Trivia dark Photos Binge Guide stoner dexter target Nominations independent Lionsgate japanese Mary Tyler Moore Shondaland robots finale foreign black travel hist Hallmark Christmas movies nature E! zero dark thirty Western aapi all-time romance werewolf Trailer PlayStation Teen PBS Infographic Rock spider-man comic book movies adventure Tomatazos Star Wars cinemax french vampires Lifetime Christmas movies Calendar black comedy comic book movie TLC VOD space Elton John rt labs The CW Endgame TV One laika Disney Channel aliens versus Freeform football RT History quibi italian VH1 History wonder woman TV See It Skip It legend debate Best and Worst medical drama stop motion HBO Max Women's History Month Cannes 79th Golden Globes Awards Paramount james bond X-Men Avengers Sony Pictures 71st Emmy Awards BBC One Discovery Channel animated festival DC Universe Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt YouTube Premium transformers Superheroe politics nfl boxoffice kong Fargo Television Academy chucky Bravo richard e. Grant facebook Disney+ Disney Plus Video Games scorecard comics Pride Month Mary Poppins Returns Logo new york cancelled TV shows cooking Anna Paquin 007 Wes Anderson book die hard USA Network The Purge anime critics obituary spanish language Image Comics worst zombies indiana jones MSNBC gangster Brie Larson basketball blaxploitation talk show boxing asian-american mockumentary slasher A&E supernatural indie GIFs strong female leads 2019 blockbuster Hulu comic Comedy Central Comics on TV WarnerMedia TNT unscripted Black History Month Television Critics Association elevated horror ESPN casting south america Family streaming movies The Academy spain San Diego Comic-Con Turner Classic Movies video on demand justice league christmas movies comic books 2015 kids live event psycho dramedy Pop TV war ghosts video cancelled TV series sopranos SundanceTV Adult Swim BBC America ABC Disney Plus Funimation what to watch Pet Sematary streaming Fox News news Chernobyl CW Seed spinoff mcc Super Bowl Tarantino child's play BET Awards Cosplay Chilling Adventures of Sabrina hispanic heritage month king arthur 2017 hispanic award winner MTV television Mystery dogs Stephen King Set visit OneApp name the review prank Apple TV+ spider-verse Martial Arts superman theme song Marvel Television a nightmare on elm street Universal FOX Prime Video classics movie razzies ABC Signature Pop twilight Arrowverse Crunchyroll doctor who BET Schedule NYCC Broadway Premiere Dates Fall TV Spring TV TBS documentary Cartoon Network action-comedy Awards Tour Hear Us Out Tokyo Olympics 90s 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards period drama The Witch Starz BBC 24 frames docudrama cats series Travel Channel Alien Ovation live action thriller dceu latino 1990s Lucasfilm olympics renewed TV shows ratings President 2020 young adult high school heist movie Marvel Holidays Reality The Walt Disney Company concert Acorn TV 20th Century Fox Music dreamworks lord of the rings Emmys scene in color green book Sneak Peek 2016 Character Guide zombie Marathons halloween Syfy jamie lee curtis Pacific Islander australia NBA comiccon Captain marvel Red Carpet Drama blockbusters sag awards harry potter docuseries critic resources natural history remakes Tumblr Pixar worst movies LGBT ID Rocketman Grammys Fantasy TCA Awards TCA Winter 2020 suspense Podcast HBO Go Year in Review Film witnail toy story Winners GLAAD hidden camera ABC Family Ellie Kemper mutant CBS All Access Mindy Kaling canceled saw spanish NBC CNN directors RT21 Amazon Prime Video toronto 93rd Oscars Fox Searchlight leaderboard Certified Fresh Classic Film tv talk YouTube Red Amazon Studios Tags: Comedy posters marvel cinematic universe free movies venice Amazon Prime dc Marvel Studios TV renewals Polls and Games international fresh Dark Horse Comics Song of Ice and Fire Masterpiece IFC Films 2018 social media Netflix Christmas movies Hollywood Foreign Press Association true crime AMC best IFC Interview game show sequel Summer children's TV binge monster movies breaking bad rom-coms based on movie Disney Paramount Network Epix criterion kaiju art house diversity golden globe awards 2021 trophy feel good mission: impossible Comedy FXX anthology USA godzilla GoT Emmy Nominations sports Columbia Pictures composers Film Festival TCM sequels DC Comics parents WGN