Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: It's Not Easy Being Green Lantern

Plus, Mr. Popper's Penguins never takes flight.

by | June 17, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a hero with a power ring (Green Lantern, starring Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively) and some wacky waddlers (Mr. Popper’s Penguins, starring Jim Carrey and Carla Gugino). What do the critics have to say?

Green Lantern

26%

With the towering exceptions of Batman and Superman, DC’s stable of superheroes haven’t fared as well on the big screen as Marvel’s. And critics say the publisher’s latest adaptation, Green Lantern won’t reverse the trend – it’s a generic, special effects-heavy effort that lacks interesting characters and a compelling script. Ryan Reynolds plays Hal Jordan, a brash test pilot who’s recruited by the Green Lantern Corps to join their crusade against evil in the universe. With the help of a power ring, Jordan is granted a number of superpowers – but can he overcome his fears in time to defeat a marauding army of evil? The pundits say Green Lantern has a few decent set pieces and moments of loony humor, but mostly, it gets bogged down in a too-complicated backstory and never exhibits enough of a singular personality to be truly compelling.

Mr. Popper’s Penguins

47%

It’s summer, so spending time in an air-conditioned theater in the company of some Antarctic residents seems like a decent idea, right? Unfortunately, critics say Mr. Popper’s Penguins is mostly lukewarm stuff; it’s got a committed performance from Jim Carrey that’s undone by a lot of mediocre physical comedy. Based upon the Newbury Award-winning children’s classic, Mr Popper’s Penguins stars Carrey as a divorced businessman who inherits six penguins; soon after turning his apartment into a polar playground, he comes to learn a thing or two about responsibility and family. The pundits say Carrey gives it his all, and the birds are cute, but Mr. Popper’s Penguins is mostly a formulaic family comedy with some so-so slapstick and an overdone message.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Buck, a documentary portrait of real-life horse whisperer Buck Brannaman, is a 90 percent.

  • My Afternoons with Marguerite, starring Gérard Depardieu in a drama about a friendship between a simple man and a frail old lady, is at 85 percent.

  • R, a drama about a man serving time in Denmark’s toughest prison, is at 80 percent.

  • Page One: Inside the New York Times, a doc about a year in the life of the nation’s paper of record, is at 78 percent.

  • Jig, a doc that follows many of the participants in the Irish Dancing World Championships, is at 65 percent.

  • Angel of Evil, a biopic of one of Italy’s most notorious criminals, is at 61 percent.

  • Kidnapped, a drama about a family held captive by a trio of robbers, is at 36 percent.

  • The Art of Getting By, starring Freddie Highmore and Emma Roberts as a pair of troubled teens who find common ground, is at 20 percent.

Tag Cloud

canceled TV shows Superheroe RT21 Marvel game show FXX ITV FX on Hulu science fiction Polls and Games Turner Classic Movies king arthur Opinion Video Games Tumblr AMC dreamworks Pet Sematary Grammys Toys stop motion television mockumentary crime USA Network cars TV Land Women's History Month parents TIFF diversity 2018 GIFs Turner Universal discovery comic books asian-american South by Southwest Film Festival Biopics Holiday justice league Shudder zombie halloween Mudbound Tokyo Olympics Best Picture SDCC Music E3 jurassic park Lucasfilm Marathons Television Critics Association Hear Us Out X-Men canceled breaking bad Musical political drama Action reviews 2017 werewolf tv talk Star Trek spider-man OneApp french Fox News cinemax twilight rotten movies we love talk show nfl saw Fall TV comic book movies Countdown Photos Spring TV 72 Emmy Awards teaser Nominations slasher sopranos joker Spike Netflix worst kids MSNBC latino richard e. Grant golden globe awards SXSW 2022 cops boxoffice indiana jones TCM Prime Video Exclusive Video Nat Geo Trivia Alien VH1 ABC Bravo Classic Film scene in color series Indigenous rom-coms revenge streaming Dark Horse Comics GLAAD hollywood Lifetime renewed TV shows supernatural 1990s GoT mutant Reality witnail Film Festival trophy 20th Century Fox Instagram Live italian Tarantino Peacock sag awards documentary APB olympics YouTube San Diego Comic-Con video dogs book adaptation E! Premiere Dates BAFTA The Witch BBC facebook RT History Food Network sequel Amazon Prime Video Film Epix adventure NBC venice live event Christmas Martial Arts gangster ABC Signature posters blockbusters Red Carpet australia Masterpiece japanese Chernobyl sitcom ESPN Apple TV Plus Pop 71st Emmy Awards transformers Infographic Certified Fresh The CW Adult Swim zombies rt archives MGM scene in color young adult news Focus Features mob fresh directors superhero PaleyFest godzilla Rocketman 2021 Vudu Mystery aliens Endgame American Society of Cinematographers hist criterion TNT MCU Cannes game of thrones Best Actress President Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt series broadcast Super Bowl king kong Hollywood Foreign Press Association pirates of the caribbean Comedy Star Wars Disney+ Disney Plus rotten 21st Century Fox space know your critic ghosts 93rd Oscars spinoff LGBTQ Walt Disney Pictures biopic Oscars NBA Western zero dark thirty docudrama Oscar Ovation historical drama south america Nickelodeon SXSW HBO Go Mary poppins Apple TV+ Avengers japan See It Skip It royal family Spectrum Originals Mary Poppins Returns Elton John Sundance Now new york romance live action Reality Competition crime thriller Writers Guild of America Wes Anderson Character Guide VICE rt labs critics edition book toy story Heroines war die hard summer TV reboot 2015 Syfy social media History heist movie Sundance target Pirates Brie Larson CNN chucky name the review period drama scary movies new zealand Crackle Travel Channel Chilling Adventures of Sabrina documentaries Paramount Pictures christmas movies spider-verse The Academy Discovery Channel TruTV Image Comics 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Disney streaming service concert CBS Disney Channel stoner films festivals toronto debate children's TV Valentine's Day robots monster movies dceu A24 ABC Family screen actors guild Fargo kaiju Showtime LGBT deadpool 73rd Emmy Awards Tomatazos black IFC Trailer art house Paramount Plus PBS Musicals anthology Best and Worst 4/20 cancelled TV series Binge Guide VOD interviews Freeform NYCC best Sci-Fi Animation genre spain batman Sneak Peek james bond Comedy Central Geeked Week Pixar USA slashers vampires blaxploitation CBS All Access Pride Month Comic Book FOX Black Mirror Sundance TV trailers true crime Winter TV spy thriller international doctor who Funimation Horror 94th Oscars Baby Yoda Amazon Studios ViacomCBS legend Election Black History Month YA cults a nightmare on elm street Hallmark Extras movies First Reviews universal monsters PlayStation casting Stephen King remakes marvel cinematic universe leaderboard Winners OWN Native 2016 Lionsgate The Walking Dead DC Universe HBO Max crime drama CW Seed indie independent DGA singing competition cancelled TV shows Sony razzies Creative Arts Emmys Mindy Kaling 45 obi wan halloween tv streaming movies Tubi Rom-Com Podcast Pacific Islander cats binge A&E TV renewals ratings TCA new star wars movies telelvision golden globes basketball comedies summer TV preview Awards Tour Rock Legendary Mary Tyler Moore sequels Trophy Talk Amazon Prime target scene in color franchise summer preview Summer Disney Plus Academy Awards feel good Interview The Purge BET Awards HBO adenture action-comedy cartoon Thanksgiving MTV scorecard Rocky travel Amazon comiccon serial killer video on demand movie quibi TCA Awards stand-up comedy strong female leads El Rey kong green book Hulu YouTube Premium Tags: Comedy scary anime miniseries Hallmark Christmas movies TLC Shondaland hidden camera nbcuniversal Comics on TV laika Teen BET classics Best Actor TV One lord of the rings TV movies critic resources football New York Comic Con child's play docuseries Lifetime Christmas movies Year in Review Sony Pictures The Walt Disney Company politics TCA Winter 2020 Ghostbusters cancelled television high school DC streaming service worst movies BBC America wonder woman Disney psycho marvel comics spanish animated Comic-Con@Home 2021 finale dark critics women Paramount screenings 24 frames natural history Television Academy vs. YouTube Red aapi Calendar fast and furious popular AMC Plus 2020 Emmys Pop TV TCA 2017 Fox Searchlight dc IFC Films Quiz Netflix Christmas movies thriller cancelled romantic comedy hispanic Schedule Fantasy Country DC Comics Starz WGN Awards Anna Paquin IMDb TV comic black comedy Box Office BBC One National Geographic dexter biography harry potter Captain marvel sports Song of Ice and Fire The Arrangement prank blockbuster Marvel Television unscripted SundanceTV Broadway composers satire TBS Logo hispanic heritage month 90s Holidays adaptation psychological thriller Best Director 007 Watching Series technology 99% superman Drama festival rt labs obituary HFPA TV Universal Pictures spanish language Superheroes Arrowverse 79th Golden Globes Awards Kids & Family police drama emmy awards all-time Cosplay theme song Apple disaster free movies Columbia Pictures based on movie Emmy Nominations archives Neflix crossover dragons mission: impossible jamie lee curtis Marvel Studios Crunchyroll scene in color film series Ellie Kemper boxing streamig Warner Bros. Paramount Network nature Acorn TV Set visit foreign award winner mcc comics medical drama Family versus Star Wars Celebration CMT 2019 DirecTV Cartoon Network dramedy ID cooking comic book movie suspense FX WarnerMedia Esquire elevated horror Britbox what to watch First Look