Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Insidious: Chapter 2 is a So-So Frightfest

Plus, The Family favors brutal violence over satirical wit.

by | September 12, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a bedeviled family (Insidious: Chapter 2, starring Patrick Wilson and Rose Byrne) and some witnesses who need little protection (The Family, starring Robert De Niro and Michelle Pfeiffer). What do the critics have to say?

Insidious: Chapter 2


With Insidious and The Conjuring, director James Wan has moved away from his blood-soaked Saw roots toward a more atmospheric brand of horror. However, critics say Insidious: Chapter 2 is something of a step back; despite strong performances and a few effective scares, it’s decidedly short on the tension and surprises that made its predecessor so chilling. This time out, the Lamberts have moved to a new residence but continue to be haunted by a malevolent spirit. Could it be that it’s one of the family members, not the house, that’s possessed? The pundits say Insidious: Chapter 2 is better crafted and performed than your typical frightfest, but it’s too reliant on jump scares and backstory to fully captivate. (Read our interview with star Patrick Wilson here.)

The Family


With its distinguished cast and high concept premise, The Family looks like a can’t-miss proposition on paper. Unfortunately, critics say this fish-out-of-water action/comedy suffers from jarring tonal shifts and an overabundance of gratuitous violence. Robert De Niro stars as a mob snitch who’s been placed in the witness protection program. But when he and his family relocate to a village in France, they don’t keep a particularly low profile, and soon the mob is on their trail. The pundits say The Family boasts solid performances, but the actors can only do so much with a script that favors brutal violence over satirical wit. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down De Niro’s best-reviewed movies, and be sure to watch our video interviews with the cast.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Mother Of George, starring Danai Jekesai Gurira and Isaach De Bankolé in an impressionistic drama about a recently married woman who is under pressure to have a child, is at 100 percent.
  • Sample This, a documentary that recounts the strange history of the Incredible Bongo Band’s version of “Apache,” is at 100 percent.
  • The Saudi Arabian import Wadjda, a drama about a young suburban girl who tries to scrape together the money to buy a bicycle, is at 97 percent.
  • Blue Caprice, starring Isaiah Washington in a psychological thriller from the perspective of the perpetrators of the Beltway sniper attacks, is at 96 percent.
  • Harry Dean Stanton: Partly Fiction, a documentary portrait of the celebrated character actor, is at 93 percent.
  • Informant, a documentary about a far-left activist who became an FBI informer, is at 92 percent.
  • Mademoiselle C, , a behind-the-scenes look at fashion journalist Carine Roitfeld’s attempt to start a new magazine, is at 71 percent.
  • And While We Were Here, starring Kate Bosworth in a romantic drama about a lonely woman who meets a younger man while accompanying her husband on a trip to Naples, is at 58 percent.
  • GMO OMG, a doc that takes a skeptical view of genetically modified crops, is at 43 percent.
  • Jayne Mansfield’s Car, starring Billy Bob Thornton and Robert Duvall in a culture clash comedy about two different families that gather for a funeral, is at 35 percent (check out Thornton’s Five Favorite Films here).

Tag Cloud

criterion anthology TBS ID Chilling Adventures of Sabrina twilight Baby Yoda Lionsgate Film Festival Trailer DirecTV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 4/20 free movies MCU australia ESPN stoner docudrama 2018 sitcom scene in color Universal Pictures scary cops razzies screenings cults hollywood posters worst Syfy popular Interview technology Avengers TCA Marvel Studios PaleyFest die hard japanese video on demand james bond spider-man Country french mission: impossible cancelled TV series disaster Amazon Studios Pet Sematary Ghostbusters CW Seed San Diego Comic-Con mcc adenture war remakes based on movie IMDb TV cancelled television Legendary Paramount Network Netflix Acorn TV marvel comics Cannes young adult BAFTA Animation Turner Classic Movies unscripted police drama book slashers game show superhero Emmys Schedule YouTube Red BBC America OneApp nbcuniversal zombie Television Critics Association Lucasfilm Instagram Live travel Mary Tyler Moore The CW Calendar ghosts Grammys nfl FXX versus king arthur Discovery Channel Teen cartoon Fox Searchlight book adaptation The Walking Dead spinoff crime thriller emmy awards finale HBO Max latino live action IFC festivals VOD BBC aapi Quiz genre kids Black History Month revenge Hulu El Rey facebook romantic comedy 2021 Mindy Kaling Travel Channel MSNBC olympics Fox News Showtime psychological thriller HBO Peacock rotten movies we love justice league Family Spike romance Universal Podcast spain elevated horror Pixar gangster psycho Creative Arts Emmys National Geographic FOX Character Guide TLC zombies suspense Hallmark nature Lifetime Christmas movies Tomatazos worst movies 24 frames 2015 feel good Countdown TV Land Biopics Pop TV joker space hist discovery Paramount doctor who TCM Superheroes rom-coms football mob Columbia Pictures adaptation fast and furious dc Brie Larson Neflix 79th Golden Globes Awards 93rd Oscars science fiction TNT quibi Pop reviews foreign action-comedy pirates of the caribbean critics Musicals aliens biography dragons series Star Wars women children's TV films sequel 71st Emmy Awards Christmas Hollywood Foreign Press Association Broadway History sag awards TCA 2017 movie Apple TV Plus Endgame 20th Century Fox independent classics Disney Plus Binge Guide Polls and Games supernatural indie cancelled TV shows period drama NYCC sopranos Bravo Toys stop motion debate canceled TV shows new york medical drama 2019 blockbuster SundanceTV diversity best historical drama Rocky Amazon Prime documentary Apple TV+ BBC One 90s 21st Century Fox Hear Us Out Disney Channel Comic-Con@Home 2021 king kong TV renewals TCA Awards italian PBS saw APB Spring TV trailers Awards Tour thriller dceu E! Masterpiece Winners spanish VICE ITV transformers Exclusive Video heist movie dogs cancelled Star Trek casting Anna Paquin Summer toy story streaming movies Turner DC Universe Netflix Christmas movies Tarantino DC Comics Set visit Warner Bros. anime Esquire crime godzilla AMC Plus name the review 73rd Emmy Awards black Sundance Now Certified Fresh Food Network Image Comics Western Vudu adventure Amazon rt archives dreamworks LGBT christmas movies spider-verse President Disney+ Disney Plus hidden camera crossover halloween 72 Emmy Awards Starz Fall TV Best and Worst Super Bowl spanish language Crackle natural history green book hispanic heritage month docuseries werewolf GIFs Chernobyl scorecard Reality Competition LGBTQ critic resources rt labs critics edition Rom-Com japan CNN TV YouTube Premiere Dates ViacomCBS indiana jones Sci-Fi chucky Classic Film harry potter DGA new star wars movies Red Carpet Opinion TCA Winter 2020 Nominations Martial Arts asian-american international 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Epix The Academy Holidays Nickelodeon Fantasy miniseries Trivia what to watch teaser superman vs. richard e. Grant legend Kids & Family blockbusters prank WarnerMedia Rock know your critic Elton John festival FX on Hulu blaxploitation Spectrum Originals TruTV golden globe awards Crunchyroll Arrowverse Disney Disney streaming service MTV strong female leads news Black Mirror Song of Ice and Fire composers halloween tv dramedy PlayStation Awards politics movies The Walt Disney Company television video comic books Rocketman YA Paramount Plus Infographic Logo First Look fresh Pride Month comic book movies Winter TV zero dark thirty Nat Geo breaking bad HFPA theme song Adult Swim CBS WGN Photos GLAAD Action jurassic park trophy hispanic crime drama biopic ABC Signature cats jamie lee curtis canceled Sundance TV target Captain marvel royal family concert 45 Funimation parents high school screen actors guild Cartoon Network Sony Pictures cinemax TV One rotten tv talk Mary Poppins Returns Prime Video RT History basketball serial killer Pacific Islander Tubi slasher NBA ABC Family X-Men toronto TIFF Comic Book talk show comic Cosplay American Society of Cinematographers HBO Go Valentine's Day franchise Thanksgiving CBS All Access A&E sports E3 sequels animated Hallmark Christmas movies game of thrones Film spy thriller comiccon Heroines witnail CMT USA Network obituary boxoffice Tumblr lord of the rings DC streaming service political drama 2016 documentaries Mystery reboot BET Awards child's play stand-up comedy VH1 kaiju vampires Ellie Kemper renewed TV shows Pirates Amazon Prime Video Mary poppins ABC comic book movie venice true crime laika deadpool rt labs batman social media singing competition 007 Britbox First Reviews Academy Awards Holiday Election NBC Music satire Year in Review Alien Horror Women's History Month monster movies USA BET binge all-time Comics on TV new zealand kong award winner black comedy RT21 Apple robots boxing Drama Mudbound Walt Disney Pictures Tokyo Olympics YouTube Premium wonder woman Comedy Central south america AMC Shondaland Tags: Comedy a nightmare on elm street 1990s art house 99% cars comedies cooking Fargo See It Skip It directors Ovation universal monsters Shudder Stephen King Musical archives Lifetime live event OWN dark Video Games mutant FX Reality marvel cinematic universe TV movies Box Office leaderboard streaming ratings Sundance dexter Marathons IFC Films SDCC Freeform The Purge The Arrangement Television Academy Writers Guild of America New York Comic Con Oscars Comedy Sneak Peek Dark Horse Comics Watching Series The Witch telelvision 2017 GoT 2020 Superheroe SXSW scary movies Marvel Wes Anderson mockumentary golden globes A24 comics Trophy Talk Extras Emmy Nominations Marvel Television