Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Insidious: Chapter 2 is a So-So Frightfest

Plus, The Family favors brutal violence over satirical wit.

by | September 12, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a bedeviled family (Insidious: Chapter 2, starring Patrick Wilson and Rose Byrne) and some witnesses who need little protection (The Family, starring Robert De Niro and Michelle Pfeiffer). What do the critics have to say?

Insidious: Chapter 2


With Insidious and The Conjuring, director James Wan has moved away from his blood-soaked Saw roots toward a more atmospheric brand of horror. However, critics say Insidious: Chapter 2 is something of a step back; despite strong performances and a few effective scares, it’s decidedly short on the tension and surprises that made its predecessor so chilling. This time out, the Lamberts have moved to a new residence but continue to be haunted by a malevolent spirit. Could it be that it’s one of the family members, not the house, that’s possessed? The pundits say Insidious: Chapter 2 is better crafted and performed than your typical frightfest, but it’s too reliant on jump scares and backstory to fully captivate. (Read our interview with star Patrick Wilson here.)

The Family


With its distinguished cast and high concept premise, The Family looks like a can’t-miss proposition on paper. Unfortunately, critics say this fish-out-of-water action/comedy suffers from jarring tonal shifts and an overabundance of gratuitous violence. Robert De Niro stars as a mob snitch who’s been placed in the witness protection program. But when he and his family relocate to a village in France, they don’t keep a particularly low profile, and soon the mob is on their trail. The pundits say The Family boasts solid performances, but the actors can only do so much with a script that favors brutal violence over satirical wit. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down De Niro’s best-reviewed movies, and be sure to watch our video interviews with the cast.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Mother Of George, starring Danai Jekesai Gurira and Isaach De Bankolé in an impressionistic drama about a recently married woman who is under pressure to have a child, is at 100 percent.

  • Sample This, a documentary that recounts the strange history of the Incredible Bongo Band’s version of “Apache,” is at 100 percent.

  • The Saudi Arabian import Wadjda, a drama about a young suburban girl who tries to scrape together the money to buy a bicycle, is at 97 percent.

  • Blue Caprice, starring Isaiah Washington in a psychological thriller from the perspective of the perpetrators of the Beltway sniper attacks, is at 96 percent.

  • Harry Dean Stanton: Partly Fiction, a documentary portrait of the celebrated character actor, is at 93 percent.

  • Informant, a documentary about a far-left activist who became an FBI informer, is at 92 percent.

  • Mademoiselle C, , a behind-the-scenes look at fashion journalist Carine Roitfeld’s attempt to start a new magazine, is at 71 percent.

  • And While We Were Here, starring Kate Bosworth in a romantic drama about a lonely woman who meets a younger man while accompanying her husband on a trip to Naples, is at 58 percent.

  • GMO OMG, a doc that takes a skeptical view of genetically modified crops, is at 43 percent.

  • Jayne Mansfield’s Car, starring Billy Bob Thornton and Robert Duvall in a culture clash comedy about two different families that gather for a funeral, is at 35 percent (check out Thornton’s Five Favorite Films here).

Tag Cloud

dragons Pop best TNT Premiere Dates stand-up comedy all-time space Brie Larson 71st Emmy Awards TCA 2017 Mary poppins Epix docudrama ratings 20th Century Fox comic books sag awards Hulu BET Walt Disney Pictures Best and Worst Tarantino tv talk Best Picture FOX TIFF dc theme song Showtime Pride Month Hallmark Calendar documentary Disney streaming service Native IFC video San Diego Comic-Con sopranos rotten zombie scorecard HFPA target scene in color Instagram Live batman rom-coms Western spider-verse The Witch cooking latino Shudder Musical Broadway Freeform Rocketman canceled vampires toronto stop motion Emmy Nominations james bond french sequels DirecTV spy thriller Cartoon Network Comic-Con@Home 2021 cartoon twilight gangster 45 MTV unscripted Prime Video Black History Month BAFTA SDCC action-comedy Photos romance suspense Trailer Spike PlayStation WarnerMedia revenge CNN cinemax breaking bad chucky stoner politics Thanksgiving Quiz nature Oscars Hallmark Christmas movies Holidays New York Comic Con Red Carpet ABC spinoff scary movies Rocky golden globes Alien Pet Sematary Travel Channel parents 2019 Super Bowl slasher know your critic IFC Films ITV zero dark thirty El Rey Action Dark Horse Comics Opinion Ellie Kemper Paramount Pictures Emmys CBS hist elevated horror travel Video Games Comedy Food Network USA Network comics live event Baby Yoda 94th Oscars Sony Pictures Nickelodeon scene in color animated international television dramedy leaderboard doctor who Fall TV Academy Awards Creative Arts Emmys 99% medical drama serial killer HBO Go Marvel OWN Mindy Kaling Cosplay toy story documentaries Arrowverse American Society of Cinematographers streamig critic resources lord of the rings Marvel Television VOD GIFs Apple Captain marvel joker MGM Set visit Film Festival NBC ABC Signature classics First Look razzies The Academy biopic criterion venice TCA Winter 2020 new zealand movie 79th Golden Globes Awards casting obituary Pop TV target genre USA reviews Columbia Pictures Ovation streaming child's play sports Rom-Com Amazon cops Kids & Family sequel Interview Amazon Prime Video Tumblr Country Tokyo Olympics 2016 BBC One 4/20 transformers superhero movies Avengers Classic Film 2021 mcc GLAAD foreign Universal Spring TV adenture harry potter 2018 kids BBC America South by Southwest Film Festival Character Guide period drama black comedy streaming movies fast and furious Vudu Pixar X-Men Masterpiece finale Schedule cancelled cars Marathons Disney Channel Neflix scary mob composers godzilla screenings rt labs critics edition mutant APB Superheroes Netflix Christmas movies TCA trailers Turner President crime drama Certified Fresh wonder woman CW Seed Musicals royal family book adaptation Black Mirror halloween The Walt Disney Company Image Comics children's TV Awards Tour spanish language Fantasy Star Wars Britbox E3 docuseries Nominations See It Skip It marvel cinematic universe Chernobyl young adult live action independent worst A24 south america Indigenous Lucasfilm FXX VH1 heist movie binge thriller SXSW Binge Guide mockumentary australia Film broadcast Countdown monster movies Box Office directors Lifetime Christmas movies LGBT Christmas Pirates comic black Discovery Channel Paramount Plus National Geographic dreamworks Acorn TV Bravo SundanceTV Mary Tyler Moore 93rd Oscars mission: impossible saw witnail Logo MCU Hollywood Foreign Press Association richard e. Grant spain Sundance Now 2020 YouTube Premium Lifetime Nat Geo Superheroe laika Winners aapi free movies MSNBC high school Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt summer TV BET Awards Watching Series Wes Anderson legend blockbusters NYCC screen actors guild 72 Emmy Awards Oscar Marvel Studios rt labs Horror Family Best Actress Infographic nbcuniversal boxing ESPN franchise Sundance TV sitcom true crime Animation trophy indie romantic comedy video on demand disaster Amazon Prime remakes Tomatazos Winter TV comic book movie The CW The Purge new star wars movies superman 1990s Tubi Warner Bros. History Apple TV+ Apple TV Plus 73rd Emmy Awards werewolf festival AMC Plus facebook pirates of the caribbean scene in color film series Crackle psycho TV movies green book 90s biography Comedy Central posters Mary Poppins Returns women Comic Book films summer TV preview PaleyFest festivals Comics on TV DC Universe Fox News summer preview Disney Plus 24 frames comiccon TV One based on movie CBS All Access reboot crossover RT History deadpool Paramount Network anthology ABC Family YA OneApp cats Geeked Week game of thrones book kong Television Critics Association Extras Crunchyroll Music Trivia cancelled TV shows A&E Pacific Islander king kong TruTV rotten movies we love supernatural comedies NBA TLC Year in Review Awards prank cults justice league Trophy Talk Toys diversity FX DC streaming service blockbuster crime Syfy art house RT21 Elton John HBO Max italian miniseries CMT discovery Esquire technology olympics Peacock Reality versus political drama PBS satire jamie lee curtis teaser Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Lionsgate new york historical drama TV TCM critics YouTube Red Ghostbusters Star Trek Reality Competition war Star Wars Celebration TCA Awards 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Sci-Fi king arthur dceu Turner Classic Movies dark Sundance dexter 2015 popular FX on Hulu worst movies what to watch nfl Disney Anna Paquin Starz Fargo japanese Best Actor comic book movies Hear Us Out hollywood Universal Pictures DC Comics jurassic park basketball Disney+ Disney Plus canceled TV shows anime asian-american Heroines police drama E! Teen series zombies universal monsters Rock Song of Ice and Fire IMDb TV quibi Tags: Comedy vs. news SXSW 2022 christmas movies BBC LGBTQ Exclusive Video hispanic TV renewals kaiju Sneak Peek Funimation game show archives emmy awards The Arrangement a nightmare on elm street Best Director rt archives Shondaland feel good adaptation Paramount football debate Endgame Stephen King ID Women's History Month aliens Amazon Studios Valentine's Day AMC golden globe awards blaxploitation Biopics singing competition die hard Election spanish Polls and Games ghosts Martial Arts DGA fresh The Walking Dead Cannes crime thriller First Reviews indiana jones hidden camera science fiction Mystery cancelled television Podcast Drama interviews Summer scene in color series slashers Legendary Fox Searchlight japan halloween tv telelvision robots psychological thriller marvel comics award winner Adult Swim social media dogs concert boxoffice Netflix adventure renewed TV shows Sony GoT obi wan HBO TBS Writers Guild of America WGN cancelled TV series Grammys VICE ViacomCBS Focus Features Spectrum Originals 2017 Holiday TV Land YouTube Mudbound talk show hispanic heritage month 21st Century Fox natural history Television Academy spider-man 007 strong female leads name the review