Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: I Love You, Man Is A Fine Bromance

Plus, Knowing flunks, and Duplicity is brainy -- if too twisty.

by | March 19, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a bromantic comedy (I Love You, Man, starring Paul Rudd and Jason Segel), ominous numerology (Knowing, starring Nicolas Cage and Rose Byrne), and corporate mischief (Duplicity, starring Julia Roberts and Clive Owen). What do the critics have to say?


I Love You, Man

The term “bromance” has reached a near-saturation point in the movie lexicon, and not a moment too soon. Critics say I Love You, Man is a warm, very funny example of the burgeoning subgenre, featuring some of the best comedic chemistry between two leads since Jack Lemmon and Walter Matthau. Paul Rudd stars as Peter, a recently engaged guy who realizes that he has no one to be the best man at his wedding. After a series of man-dates, he finds himself (platonically, of course) bonding with Sydney (Jason Segel), a slovenly hipster with plenty of sound advice. The pundits say I Love You, Man is a perfect example of how old formulas can feel new again: with hearty laughs, nuance, and razor-sharp performances. I Love You, Man is Certified Fresh.



Alex Proyas has established himself as one of the more interesting sci-fi directors in Hollywood, but critics say his latest, Knowing, crosses the line that separates profundity and preposterousness. The movie stars Nicolas Cage as an MIT professor who discovers that a random string of numbers on a piece of paper from a recently unearthed time capsule successfully predicted numerous disasters over the last 50 years. As he unlocks the secrets of this strange document, he discovers that the numbers predict future calamities as well. The pundits say Knowing has some interesting ideas and a couple good scenes, but it’s weighted down by its absurd plot and over-seriousness. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Cage’s best reviewed films. Also, find out what Proyas’ five favorite films are, and don’t forget to play our “Name Nic’s Movie ‘Do” game.)



Tony Gilroy (Michael Clayton) is certainly a smart guy, but critics say his latest, Duplicity, may be just a little too brainy for its own good. The film stars Julia Roberts and Clive Owen as an on-again, off-again couple of spies turned corporate fixers that get involved in an elaborate con game between two multinational companies; as a result, our heroes become increasingly concerned that they can’t trust each other. The pundits say Roberts and Owen exude plenty of chemistry and star power, and Duplicity is nothing if not well-crafted. However, they also feel the film is more cerebral than visceral, and it gets bogged down in a densely complex plot and too many twists and turns.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

RT21 Walt Disney Pictures rom-coms HFPA obituary Disney Channel fresh fast and furious comic books Chernobyl japan concert sports emmy awards scary movies technology TCA 2017 binge revenge 73rd Emmy Awards Mary Tyler Moore ABC spinoff Brie Larson Disney streaming service Trailer 93rd Oscars SDCC See It Skip It nbcuniversal Funimation latino batman unscripted slasher scene in color japanese AMC Plus festival Amazon Prime Video USA Network LGBTQ YouTube Premium 24 frames zombies indie Amazon Prime Adult Swim Ovation PlayStation cars IFC Films foreign what to watch BET Awards worst movies Writers Guild of America reboot Country Cartoon Network spy thriller President SXSW historical drama vs. finale australia aapi FX canceled TV shows Holidays cops docudrama mission: impossible Pacific Islander spanish language comic anthology best Pride Month justice league Elton John Arrowverse war hist 2018 Oscars Vudu scorecard Action Cannes The Walt Disney Company Polls and Games aliens Tumblr screenings suspense natural history blockbusters TCA Nickelodeon 2019 Year in Review dreamworks comic book movie archives Epix comedies kids spain Endgame jurassic park rotten BBC America french richard e. Grant Lucasfilm transformers documentary TBS Bravo scary Television Critics Association halloween deadpool Sundance 20th Century Fox Nominations stoner canceled marvel comics Classic Film Neflix Mudbound Comedy Central theme song TCA Awards A24 sequel Exclusive Video free movies boxoffice biopic USA Disney+ Disney Plus romantic comedy book adaptation Hulu AMC Reality child's play cats festivals The Academy Sundance TV Anna Paquin vampires Song of Ice and Fire remakes HBO Go Winter TV posters Box Office Tomatazos Instagram Live directors rt labs critics edition BBC 2015 women The Arrangement composers spider-man TV One CBS Set visit genre kong Lifetime Christmas movies nfl quibi VICE Awards Tour sag awards San Diego Comic-Con ViacomCBS based on movie science fiction Peacock streaming movies Columbia Pictures Tarantino Musical HBO First Reviews X-Men OWN TCA Winter 2020 chucky period drama YouTube Red award winner cancelled television Women's History Month dc rt labs Awards 79th Golden Globes Awards Red Carpet sitcom Pirates ABC Signature Broadway Christmas rt archives NBC Food Network dceu adenture zero dark thirty Warner Bros. Tubi Marathons 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards miniseries Freeform Amazon MTV Musicals Mindy Kaling TV Land thriller james bond superhero Travel Channel 4/20 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Stephen King Sci-Fi NBA Spring TV stop motion adventure Winners italian psycho Summer boxing Trivia politics cooking 45 Election psychological thriller Family strong female leads kaiju worst elevated horror Hollywood Foreign Press Association ITV ESPN legend Black History Month Teen laika live event romance Apple heist movie Martial Arts comic book movies APB space TLC monster movies zombie CMT Comic-Con@Home 2021 2020 target LGBT Apple TV Plus Acorn TV renewed TV shows robots screen actors guild FX on Hulu Kids & Family game show TV Opinion Sony Pictures IFC DC Universe Cosplay blockbuster Sundance Now Horror VH1 Biopics Sneak Peek PBS The Witch 2016 die hard olympics a nightmare on elm street tv talk golden globe awards Paramount Plus BBC One Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt superman nature Best and Worst Lifetime franchise golden globes razzies WarnerMedia anime leaderboard A&E 72 Emmy Awards Wes Anderson Crackle Podcast all-time Baby Yoda crossover Britbox cancelled Calendar animated new star wars movies new york video indiana jones Esquire Infographic Animation christmas movies dark Binge Guide 90s TCM Shondaland Marvel Television marvel cinematic universe prank El Rey Lionsgate social media Masterpiece asian-american hispanic heritage month SundanceTV Avengers popular Television Academy cinemax dexter Fargo 21st Century Fox Western breaking bad Film Festival name the review game of thrones Emmys parents New York Comic Con Showtime Paramount Network DGA high school Super Bowl Watching Series Disney Fox News E! GoT Syfy green book Captain marvel telelvision The CW Academy Awards football Valentine's Day cancelled TV series halloween tv RT History spanish Pop TV CW Seed Mary poppins TruTV diversity VOD black Spectrum Originals Quiz MCU documentaries Emmy Nominations Ghostbusters facebook Hallmark Christmas movies Interview OneApp reviews international Toys know your critic doctor who universal monsters live action Discovery Channel DC Comics YouTube teaser dragons TNT dogs YA films hidden camera Certified Fresh Rock DC streaming service Comic Book National Geographic Character Guide ABC Family ratings south america Thanksgiving political drama Reality Competition comiccon slashers streaming Rocky BET Grammys Crunchyroll cartoon royal family hollywood biography comics Pop docuseries Superheroes serial killer adaptation Shudder disaster Prime Video Tags: Comedy classics saw Tokyo Olympics movie BAFTA cancelled TV shows venice blaxploitation GLAAD jamie lee curtis NYCC Turner Classic Movies satire Spike Universal Mary Poppins Returns Hear Us Out travel Dark Horse Comics Image Comics MSNBC GIFs HBO Max Paramount debate Heroines Rocketman medical drama Rom-Com stand-up comedy mcc Alien ID TV movies spider-verse young adult TIFF Turner Universal Pictures TV renewals lord of the rings Fantasy critic resources harry potter 2017 ghosts supernatural Black Mirror The Walking Dead Pixar Fox Searchlight cults twilight Comedy Holiday Music witnail basketball Amazon Studios sopranos Fall TV movies toy story crime drama king kong independent pirates of the caribbean children's TV new zealand crime thriller Nat Geo IMDb TV Video Games Superheroe criterion Photos action-comedy Legendary television Netflix casting critics toronto dramedy Hallmark art house gangster Schedule Mystery police drama king arthur Film Trophy Talk Starz Comics on TV werewolf singing competition versus FOX black comedy video on demand Ellie Kemper Drama true crime 99% 007 DirecTV crime Creative Arts Emmys History sequels news 1990s WGN mockumentary PaleyFest trophy CNN E3 71st Emmy Awards Countdown FXX Star Trek Disney Plus godzilla Apple TV+ Star Wars wonder woman rotten movies we love Logo joker hispanic talk show feel good Premiere Dates discovery mutant First Look Netflix Christmas movies book Extras mob CBS All Access The Purge series Pet Sematary 2021 trailers Marvel American Society of Cinematographers Marvel Studios