Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: High School Musical 3 Makes the Grade

Plus, Pride and Glory is flat-footed. And guess Saw V's Tomatometer!

by | October 23, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies we’ve got plucky thespians (High School Musical 3: Senior Year, starring Zac Efron and Vanessa Hudgens), fraternal cops (Pride and Glory, starring Edward Norton and Colin Farrell), and systematic slayings (Saw V, starring Tobin Bell and Costas Mandylor). What do the critics have to say?

One of the most irrepressible pop culture phenomena of recent years is finally getting the big-screen treatment. And critics say High School Musical 3: Senior Year, while fluff, is toe-tapping and exuberant. Zac Efron and Vanessa Hudgens star as a pair of teens going their separate ways; they join their peeps to stage a musical that summarizes their high school careers and confronts their fears for the future. The pundits say HSM3 isn’t going to win many converts beyond its tween target audience, but it’s aggressively upbeat, well-crafted, and features an excellent performance by Efron. At 64 percent on the Tomatometer, High School Musical 3 earns a passing grade.

“Awesome! It’s raining Sunny Delight!”

The world is so full of police procedurals that you’ve got to do something to separate yourself from the pack. Unfortunately, critics say Pride and Glory is essentially a generic cop movie enlivened somewhat by the strength of its cast. Edward Norton stars as Ray, a New York City detective who is tasked with investigating the murders of several fellow cops, a mission that leads him to suspect that some of his family members, including Jimmy (Colin Farrell), his brother and fellow officer, may be involved. The pundits say this one’s pretty by-the-numbers, featuring cliched dialogue, familiar plot twists, and an overall sense of weariness. At 34 percent on the Tomatometer, Pride isn’t glorious.

“If the scoreboard is any indication, it appears our team name overstates our gridiron abilities.”

It’s practically becoming an annual ritual: a new Saw gets released, and it isn’t screened for critics. Such is the case with Saw V. Jigsaw may be gone, but Hoffman is just as fond of crafting elaborate traps for those poor souls that displease him. Kids, stop playing with those power tools and guess that Tomatometer! (And be sure to check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we tally the body counts of some of your favorite movie psychos.)

“Ooh, time for Judge Judy.”

Also opening this week in limited release:

Saw Movies:

Tag Cloud

BBC One harry potter book adaptation NYCC ABC Winter TV hist asian-american Biopics Mudbound Comedy zero dark thirty VOD sports boxing mission: impossible Epix Tarantino San Diego Comic-Con video Baby Yoda PBS MTV Teen DC Comics comic books ABC Family Western Marvel Studios Warner Bros. know your critic Sundance Now french Animation 21st Century Fox feel good popular Marathons universal monsters sopranos biopic YA king arthur Countdown rom-coms The Purge Awards Arrowverse USA black RT History superman Alien Writers Guild of America talk show mutant Universal Walt Disney Pictures Quiz festival new zealand nature YouTube Red Avengers movie Marvel historical drama 20th Century Fox robots fast and furious RT21 Starz Fox News FX on Hulu screenings Superheroes Polls and Games travel Film Festival Comic Book dark CBS APB wonder woman Fantasy LGBTQ Image Comics stop motion aapi hispanic Summer Disney+ Disney Plus Best and Worst Paramount Plus australia crime miniseries all-time docuseries TV reboot marvel cinematic universe live action serial killer trophy FXX royal family suspense natural history The Arrangement spanish comedies Sundance Cartoon Network supernatural psycho crime drama OWN science fiction cancelled TV shows vampires laika biography directors dceu Pet Sematary Rocketman Comedy Central justice league romantic comedy 24 frames LGBT Apple TV+ President Lucasfilm DGA trailers Star Wars Holiday fresh target Showtime PlayStation animated Women's History Month spy thriller Lifetime zombies Tokyo Olympics Discovery Channel First Reviews basketball Pixar crime thriller young adult Hulu Emmy Nominations documentary Dark Horse Comics women stoner binge medical drama Amazon Studios TruTV HBO Go christmas movies Superheroe VH1 Spectrum Originals Extras TCA Winter 2020 twilight comic book movie japan 72 Emmy Awards game of thrones political drama OneApp independent game show Academy Awards franchise Family Awards Tour anthology aliens Martial Arts The Walking Dead spider-man indie remakes Hollywood Foreign Press Association Certified Fresh The Academy Song of Ice and Fire Disney streaming service WarnerMedia Box Office obituary satire name the review hidden camera adaptation Interview Prime Video Crunchyroll Cosplay war Reality Competition rotten Musical Election renewed TV shows Thanksgiving Television Academy Trailer Star Trek video on demand children's TV IFC Films Trophy Talk USA Network Emmys CBS All Access 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards AMC Plus psychological thriller worst movies action-comedy Universal Pictures Mystery boxoffice X-Men free movies cats Food Network Fox Searchlight award winner Tomatazos screen actors guild movies DC Universe Pop TIFF Tubi dragons halloween singing competition Country ABC Signature Amazon Prime Video WGN films 2015 Exclusive Video Opinion a nightmare on elm street 71st Emmy Awards docudrama Musicals Black Mirror foreign Rom-Com rt archives Elton John leaderboard tv talk period drama NBC New York Comic Con transformers sequel Tumblr Amazon Prime rt labs critics edition comic golden globe awards BET HBO ViacomCBS YouTube Premium scene in color SundanceTV BBC south america Photos television Amazon Trivia Christmas TCM genre Brie Larson Nickelodeon Adult Swim canceled TV shows Pop TV Lionsgate Esquire diversity Heroines theme song hollywood The Witch quibi DC streaming service Sci-Fi Reality doctor who Hallmark series Music Classic Film SDCC cancelled television Spring TV social media BET Awards deadpool razzies TV movies 90s sitcom The Walt Disney Company latino Mindy Kaling Horror dreamworks Ghostbusters Valentine's Day live event FOX Watching Series 007 Nominations venice Winners scary movies kids streaming movies Logo strong female leads comiccon indiana jones Mary poppins child's play PaleyFest discovery Kids & Family Stephen King Acorn TV Mary Tyler Moore politics 2016 new york jurassic park Super Bowl anime witnail Netflix Christmas movies Creative Arts Emmys Drama Binge Guide El Rey MSNBC Ovation DirecTV Freeform halloween tv dogs stand-up comedy book rt labs Syfy vs. spinoff MCU green book Fall TV criterion finale Oscars FX Pride Month thriller 45 Character Guide Vudu versus AMC Wes Anderson kong CMT scary Funimation cops Crackle ratings art house GLAAD TBS Grammys international Action TV Land YouTube streaming mockumentary Marvel Television hispanic heritage month Disney Channel Lifetime Christmas movies 73rd Emmy Awards History Legendary joker TNT Year in Review dexter high school Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TLC Holidays dc Video Games Paramount blaxploitation spanish language IMDb TV james bond E! emmy awards Apple TV Plus unscripted GIFs olympics Bravo italian technology sequels TCA 2017 black comedy news critic resources richard e. Grant Fargo king kong Premiere Dates Disney Plus TV renewals National Geographic concert Tags: Comedy heist movie nfl Columbia Pictures Mary Poppins Returns HFPA Ellie Kemper Paramount Network Spike SXSW The CW Travel Channel what to watch marvel comics Broadway facebook TCA Awards Instagram Live chucky Cannes comics American Society of Cinematographers slasher Turner Classic Movies Calendar classics A24 pirates of the caribbean lord of the rings space spain dramedy cartoon BBC America Black History Month comic book movies saw reviews Disney telelvision Apple monster movies festivals Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt toy story cars Infographic TCA 2017 ITV TV One police drama Anna Paquin Shudder japanese elevated horror best Hear Us Out zombie E3 Sony Pictures 4/20 Schedule cooking HBO Max casting football disaster Red Carpet composers Neflix new star wars movies romance Set visit Endgame cults documentaries 79th Golden Globes Awards Chernobyl Rock mob archives cinemax worst gangster superhero NBA CW Seed GoT werewolf godzilla 2018 Rocky Netflix Shondaland ESPN cancelled First Look A&E See It Skip It VICE CNN Sundance TV 1990s crossover Pacific Islander Britbox Peacock parents rotten movies we love Television Critics Association ID 93rd Oscars posters Nat Geo Masterpiece Film kaiju sag awards 2020 99% Turner jamie lee curtis blockbusters Hallmark Christmas movies breaking bad adenture 2021 legend nbcuniversal golden globes batman based on movie slashers 2019 cancelled TV series adventure Podcast Toys spider-verse Sneak Peek critics prank debate mcc blockbuster IFC Comic-Con@Home 2021 Captain marvel revenge Comics on TV ghosts BAFTA canceled scorecard teaser Pirates die hard true crime toronto