Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Hancock Isn't Signature Smith

Plus, Kit Kittredge: An American Girl is Certified Fresh.

by | July 1, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got moody superheroes (Hancock, starring Will Smith and Charlize Theron), and cub reporters (Kit Kittredge: An American Girl, starring Abigail Breslin and Julia Ormond). What do the critics have to say?

It seems like a can’t-miss prospect: a moody, conflicted superhero, unloved by the public despite his best efforts, played by Will Smith, aka Mr. Independence Day. However, great ideas are a dime a dozen, and critics say Hancock never fully takes flight. An attempt at a subversive take on caped crusader mythos, Smith has super-strength and a drinking problem; however, he learns to show a softer side after saving the life of a public relations expert. The pundits say Smith is solid as always, but the film quickly abandons its clever premise in favor of typical action sequences. Additionally, its shifts in tone — from wry comedy to sentiment — don’t quite cohere. At 35 percent on the Tomatometer, Hancock is not one of Smith’s signature films.


With the Fourth of July on the horizon, it seems like an apt time to celebrate the can-do, go-get-’em American spirit. With that in mind, critics say you could do a lot worse than Kit Kittredge: An American Girl, an old-school, family-friendly charmer. Abigail Breslin stars as the title character, a sharp, kind, inquisitive pre-teen whose journalistic aspirations come in handy: she attempts to solve a mystery and, in the process, save her family’s house and exonerate some falsely-accused fellow citizens. The pundits say Kit is a gentle, heartfelt tale that’s both a delivery system for wholesome messages and a surprisingly moving drama. At 79 percent on the Tomatometer, the Certified Fresh Kit Kittredge has Girl power to spare.

“From now on, we trust no one but the Newsies.”

Also opening this week in limited release:

The surreal black comedy Kabluey, starring Lisa Kudrow and Scott Prendergast (who also directs), is at 100 percent.

The French thriller Tell No One, starring Kristin Scott Thomas and Francois Cluzet, is at 93 percent.

Gonzo: the Life and Work of Dr. Hunter S. Thompson, Alex Gibney‘s documentary portrait of the iconic gonzo journalist, is at 86 percent.

The Wackness, the coming-of-age story of a drug dealer in mid-1990s New York, starring Ben Kingsley, Famke Janssen, and Josh Peck, is at 70 percent.

Diminished Capacity, a bittersweet comedy about a newspaperman recovering from a concussion starring Matthew Broderick and Virginia Madsen, is at 17 percent.

“You weren’t a millionaire until you were 40? I was eight!”

Recent Will Smith Movies:
69% — I am Legend (2007)
66% — The Pursuit of Happyness (2006)
69% — Hitch (2005)
34% — Shark Tale (2004)
58% — I, Robot (2004)

Tag Cloud

Avengers spain fresh Western science fiction movie Song of Ice and Fire richard e. Grant 2019 Hollywood Foreign Press Association game of thrones ABC Family medical drama Classic Film critics Music CNN chucky Chilling Adventures of Sabrina monster movies USA Network 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards scene in color series festivals Discovery Channel razzies Binge Guide archives Box Office tv talk FOX LGBT lord of the rings toronto free movies twilight scary Martial Arts ID scene in color die hard Awards TV renewals Awards Tour TNT OneApp Stephen King Netflix Apple TV+ hollywood satire Wes Anderson Paramount Plus Drama ESPN cancelled TV shows sports mcc olympics disaster spider-verse thriller VICE Watching Series screen actors guild Podcast Comedy Central Shondaland documentaries E3 children's TV BBC One Disney Channel Mary Poppins Returns Musicals Adult Swim Trophy Talk Universal Pictures 21st Century Fox TV AMC Plus Brie Larson new york Rocky Pop ghosts directors SundanceTV dogs know your critic Sony Pictures zombie streaming broadcast Fox News VH1 4/20 Opinion 99% Biopics GIFs christmas movies Family halloween tv BAFTA Pacific Islander Walt Disney Pictures technology The Walking Dead Reality Competition legend Heroines Tags: Comedy indie AMC Marathons marvel comics Marvel Studios YouTube Red Animation best Horror Nominations festival Trailer quibi dexter witnail TV One Pride Month new zealand jamie lee curtis History Paramount Network Geeked Week Extras jurassic park Teen sequel hidden camera zero dark thirty SXSW 2022 harry potter diversity X-Men RT21 vs. Pop TV series canceled superhero golden globe awards movies concert sag awards Star Wars Year in Review Rock Tomatazos cancelled Pixar mob Warner Bros. E! elevated horror japan Cannes miniseries SDCC Hallmark Christmas movies Marvel Television Best Actor Freeform Calendar NBA Masterpiece Peacock TruTV heist movie hist young adult Thanksgiving vampires television Women's History Month discovery based on movie nature psycho Valentine's Day renewed TV shows Hulu comiccon kids MSNBC TV Land Showtime SXSW Amazon Prime Video TCA 2017 aliens Grammys Spectrum Originals comic book movies dc versus sequels National Geographic Acorn TV Sony award winner Christmas Esquire Academy Awards black comedy Fantasy spanish language Exclusive Video comedies james bond green book doctor who biopic genre 2015 Photos streaming movies game show true crime 1990s ABC YouTube space teaser Infographic Amazon Studios animated king kong Neflix facebook Video Games HBO zombies adenture A&E joker live event trailers slasher 2021 docudrama scary movies OWN Premiere Dates nbcuniversal Cosplay 72 Emmy Awards marvel cinematic universe Logo First Look Superheroe werewolf Toys screenings Red Carpet toy story dceu Crunchyroll supernatural 24 frames criterion cartoon hispanic heritage month Lionsgate Funimation PBS Tokyo Olympics composers international strong female leads 90s Columbia Pictures sitcom Britbox 2017 debate stand-up comedy blockbuster spy thriller Star Trek Tubi Fox Searchlight Fargo interviews police drama kong TLC The Witch wonder woman Action adaptation NBC deadpool BET Awards Best Picture live action Ellie Kemper all-time cancelled TV series 2018 Interview DC Universe critic resources Countdown prank Instagram Live Sundance TV IFC Mary Tyler Moore japanese The Academy asian-american Cartoon Network Paramount worst movies ITV Turner BET Epix what to watch TIFF cooking El Rey Sneak Peek GoT social media rom-coms cancelled television ViacomCBS American Society of Cinematographers Comic-Con@Home 2021 Universal Syfy crime Polls and Games target 2020 comic TCM Sundance Now indiana jones rt archives independent blockbusters Sundance cops Travel Channel Native sopranos Winners Crackle Elton John Comedy Spike Disney streaming service rt labs critics edition anthology talk show psychological thriller Comic Book Disney+ Disney Plus Pirates rotten movies we love New York Comic Con Musical football Oscar Star Wars Celebration Summer HBO Go reviews DirecTV Netflix Christmas movies Set visit Hear Us Out classics APB golden globes cats natural history obituary TCA Awards TV movies The Arrangement Disney Plus south america crime thriller women FX on Hulu The CW Schedule stoner Reality CW Seed PlayStation robots Quiz high school Creative Arts Emmys Mystery Sci-Fi Mudbound reboot 94th Oscars comics child's play President Baby Yoda 20th Century Fox Film Festival comic books documentary unscripted Vudu BBC TCA Winter 2020 DC streaming service aapi Fall TV comic book movie saw canceled TV shows pirates of the caribbean Ovation royal family See It Skip It Nickelodeon HFPA 79th Golden Globes Awards TBS cars Holidays TCA Black Mirror black worst dark Comics on TV latino king arthur romance Dark Horse Comics Alien Marvel anime 45 romantic comedy theme song Oscars stop motion summer TV preview crime drama basketball Super Bowl fast and furious spider-man Endgame rotten cults Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt australia 007 Lifetime art house Television Critics Association The Walt Disney Company Mindy Kaling IFC Films Image Comics MTV name the review Pet Sematary parents Apple TV Plus Amazon Prime venice Indigenous 93rd Oscars Emmy Nominations universal monsters ABC Signature VOD First Reviews PaleyFest foreign Captain marvel boxoffice San Diego Comic-Con news DC Comics mutant 71st Emmy Awards CBS laika video South by Southwest Film Festival The Purge streamig boxing HBO Max Writers Guild of America transformers crossover period drama Hallmark films Black History Month new star wars movies Apple batman YA dreamworks Lucasfilm book adaptation Best Director Starz Character Guide french rt labs video on demand leaderboard Kids & Family spanish dragons travel Winter TV NYCC biography Holiday historical drama CMT LGBTQ summer TV Rocketman Paramount Pictures dramedy YouTube Premium Best Actress Tarantino BBC America Chernobyl Legendary finale a nightmare on elm street halloween MGM war MCU political drama FXX CBS All Access Bravo remakes superman posters 2016 emmy awards hispanic trophy revenge DGA Shudder mockumentary Superheroes Ghostbusters Mary poppins politics Turner Classic Movies scorecard Amazon feel good binge Trivia cinemax italian obi wan Prime Video nfl Best and Worst slashers Disney USA Anna Paquin suspense adventure Country action-comedy Certified Fresh A24 Television Academy Rom-Com WarnerMedia Lifetime Christmas movies franchise Tumblr justice league IMDb TV singing competition kaiju Film popular breaking bad serial killer scene in color film series FX Election RT History Spring TV Arrowverse casting target scene in color Broadway book Focus Features mission: impossible godzilla gangster ratings summer preview blaxploitation 73rd Emmy Awards WGN GLAAD docuseries Food Network telelvision spinoff Emmys Nat Geo