Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Guess Halloween 2's Tomatometer!

Plus, Taking Woodstock is sweet but unfocused, and guess the Tomatometer for Final Destination.

by | August 27, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got the return of Michael Myers (Halloween 2, starring Malcolm McDowell and Scout Taylor-Compton), three dimensional fatalities (The Final Destination, starring Shantel VanSanten and Bobby Campo), and the dawning of the Age of Aquarius (Taking Woodstock, starring Demetri Martin and Emile Hirsch). What do the critics have to say?


Halloween II

Rob Zombie is back with a new chapter in the rebooted Halloween franchise. However, we don’t yet know for sure if Michael Myers’ latest adventure is a trick or a treat, since it wasn’t screened for critics. Once again, the masked madman is back in town, slashing everything in his path. It’s time to guess the Tomatometer! (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we scare up some of the best horror sequels around. Also, browse our gallery of memorable scream queens and take a look at Zombie’s Five Favorite Films.)


The Final Destination

It appears we’ll have to wait to see what fate has in store for the young protagonists of The Final Destination, as it was not screened for critics prior to release. Once again, a group of youngsters avoid a near-death experience, but fate has other plans for them. Oh, and it’s in 3-D. Guess the Tomatometer!


Taking Woodstock

Depending on who you ask, the Woodstock Music & Art Fair was either a beautiful, generation-defining cultural touchstone or an overrated, muddy bummer — or perhaps a bit of both. One thing’s for sure: the mother of all rock fests has been amply documented (most notably by Michael Wadleigh in his acclaimed documentary Woodstock), and critics say the versatile Ang Lee deserves credit for his approach in Taking Woodstock; he focuses on the attendees and eschews the musical performances. However, most say this gentle, amiable film is too mired in nostalgia. The film stars Demetri Martin as Elliot Tiber, whose family hotel provided a base of operations for the fest’s organizers; soon, Tiber finds himself in the midst of free thinking hippies and changing times. The pundits say Taking Woodstock captures the good vibes of the era, but misses the bigger picture, and relies too heavily on clichés to be anything more than likeable.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Hirokazu Kore-eda‘s Still Walking, a gentle drama about a recently married middle aged man and his interactions with his parents, is at 100 percent.

  • At the Edge of the World, a documentary about attempts by activists to stop a whaling fleet near the South Pole, is at 100 percent.

  • Motherland, a doc about a group of grieving women who volunteer at a school in South Africa, is at 100 percent.

  • We Live in Public, a doc about Internet pioneer Josh Harris, is at 89 percent.

  • Big Fan, starring Patton Oswalt as a die-hard New York Giants fanatic whose life takes a dark turn, is at 87 percent.

  • The September Issue, a behind the scenes look at Vogue’s editorial process, is at 86 percent.

  • This Beautiful City, in which the lives of a disparate cross-section of Toronto residents intersect, is at 20 percent.

  • Play the Game, starring Andy Griffith as a retirement home Casanova, is at 11 percent.

Tag Cloud

Disney Plus women CBS All Access Universal Mystery black comedy MSNBC cancelled TV series DirecTV zombie Watching Series game show Certified Fresh 79th Golden Globes Awards emmy awards dark war Red Carpet The Arrangement police drama DGA cinemax finale supernatural Warner Bros. scorecard Lifetime Christmas movies Pet Sematary Legendary Comic Book Crackle toronto Women's History Month sitcom scary movies 4/20 disaster spanish language 2021 TCM AMC animated comic book movie Calendar spider-verse blaxploitation The Walking Dead See It Skip It LGBT Song of Ice and Fire chucky TV Alien Fargo streaming Music Syfy Elton John crossover zero dark thirty venice period drama Marvel Studios Lucasfilm AMC Plus debate FX on Hulu Drama Tumblr mob strong female leads gangster Crunchyroll video Amazon Prime Video binge Spectrum Originals lord of the rings new zealand Chilling Adventures of Sabrina godzilla New York Comic Con ghosts Animation BAFTA singing competition 93rd Oscars technology Nominations 72 Emmy Awards cancelled television Tags: Comedy Funimation movie Opinion batman WGN book adaptation FXX documentary leaderboard Adult Swim Writers Guild of America hollywood VOD natural history anthology comics foreign Film Festival space Awards Trivia social media Rocketman black festivals Country new york TBS Nickelodeon The Purge The Witch Sundance TV Premiere Dates Spike fast and furious vs. BBC Avengers Ghostbusters serial killer latino The Walt Disney Company concert IFC kaiju Nat Geo WarnerMedia E! Shondaland live event YouTube stoner die hard Fox News American Society of Cinematographers casting TCA Awards 71st Emmy Awards BBC America cooking Ellie Kemper ID mcc revenge free movies cancelled blockbusters IFC Films Tarantino Infographic Universal Pictures directors spain Discovery Channel Rom-Com rt labs El Rey 45 laika TCA Winter 2020 aliens Spring TV olympics jamie lee curtis Apple TV+ genre Brie Larson justice league Pop TV unscripted documentaries Sci-Fi comic slashers VH1 japanese HBO monster movies TIFF Creative Arts Emmys ViacomCBS versus ABC Family DC streaming service Paramount Trophy Talk cars sag awards The CW 007 Reality Competition Star Wars YouTube Red Turner Classic Movies saw Image Comics teaser screenings Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt posters what to watch Pop BET Awards critics reboot Sundance Now ESPN obituary rom-coms 20th Century Fox Esquire Amazon Prime Chernobyl video on demand Sundance ratings Summer Horror TV One docudrama National Geographic best spy thriller slasher television jurassic park cancelled TV shows adaptation Showtime History dc GLAAD politics marvel comics hidden camera Netflix comedies Schedule Fox Searchlight Countdown USA independent 1990s TV movies Tokyo Olympics SundanceTV streaming movies golden globe awards feel good 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards San Diego Comic-Con HBO Max werewolf BET Mary Tyler Moore rt labs critics edition Quiz Lionsgate Exclusive Video TCA trophy DC Comics series psychological thriller target live action Stephen King ABC dogs children's TV crime drama Pacific Islander biography robots australia classics dceu Dark Horse Comics RT History Disney toy story zombies 24 frames Star Trek Mindy Kaling Amazon hist critic resources blockbuster green book cartoon Netflix Christmas movies elevated horror docuseries mutant Television Critics Association Interview Paramount Network adventure ITV Superheroes 99% miniseries LGBTQ pirates of the caribbean Turner Emmys adenture sopranos PlayStation renewed TV shows young adult mockumentary SDCC Holidays vampires Britbox Binge Guide mission: impossible 21st Century Fox scene in color CBS Tubi 73rd Emmy Awards Comedy action-comedy biopic south america sports MCU worst movies travel TLC Disney+ Disney Plus NBA prank Marvel know your critic Rock quibi Wes Anderson Film international TNT Freeform Instagram Live BBC One science fiction screen actors guild king kong OneApp Rocky italian wonder woman Hallmark Christmas movies stop motion Sony Pictures richard e. Grant twilight Marathons A24 festival comic books romantic comedy TV Land Action based on movie asian-american Polls and Games high school indie anime discovery Toys Comedy Central Photos Amazon Studios YA heist movie Heroines CW Seed Mary Poppins Returns Sneak Peek dexter dramedy Western Classic Film The Academy aapi Travel Channel Ovation Black Mirror remakes cats universal monsters japan Holiday Trailer 2015 Vudu all-time SXSW Biopics President football true crime PaleyFest Kids & Family james bond TV renewals stand-up comedy book hispanic Apple Valentine's Day E3 Pirates Election Acorn TV franchise crime thriller Apple TV Plus NYCC 90s Disney streaming service rotten movies we love diversity canceled TV shows doctor who 2016 superman thriller Comics on TV halloween dragons USA Network deadpool kids Bravo composers OWN movies razzies Masterpiece breaking bad boxing nature Hulu NBC 2019 Cartoon Network facebook Super Bowl comiccon basketball CMT game of thrones 2018 GIFs Cosplay Captain marvel APB king arthur Shudder VICE GoT Columbia Pictures news CNN Best and Worst hispanic heritage month Fall TV harry potter RT21 Fantasy name the review Podcast sequel transformers Superheroe First Reviews Mary poppins satire Walt Disney Pictures Musicals Endgame boxoffice Grammys IMDb TV Starz marvel cinematic universe parents kong spinoff psycho Hollywood Foreign Press Association HFPA medical drama nbcuniversal A&E films Baby Yoda a nightmare on elm street Hear Us Out Pride Month Peacock Lifetime dreamworks royal family archives fresh reviews Video Games First Look art house Mudbound joker indiana jones telelvision Thanksgiving Extras Marvel Television Neflix Reality legend christmas movies Academy Awards Teen Box Office ABC Signature Pixar canceled PBS FX nfl talk show Awards Tour halloween tv trailers Comic-Con@Home 2021 superhero cults child's play spanish comic book movies Tomatazos Epix Set visit Food Network Christmas romance TCA 2017 political drama Musical 2017 Arrowverse witnail scary FOX cops Broadway spider-man worst award winner sequels DC Universe Cannes french rotten Television Academy tv talk suspense Prime Video Oscars crime 2020 Year in Review Emmy Nominations Anna Paquin Family rt archives Logo MTV popular golden globes Martial Arts theme song criterion Black History Month YouTube Premium Character Guide Winners X-Men HBO Go Winter TV historical drama Hallmark Paramount Plus Disney Channel TruTV new star wars movies