Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Footloose is Toe-Tapping Fun

Plus, The Thing doesn't have enough scares, and The Big Year is a slow but aimiable comedy.

by | October 14, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got Sunday shoe removal (Footloose, starring Kenny Wormald and Julianne Hough), an Antarctic abomination (The Thing, starring Mary Elizabeth Winstead and Joel Edgerton), and a bird watching competition (The Big Year, starring Jack Black and Owen Wilson). What do the critics have to say?

Footloose

68%

Did the world really need a new Footloose? Apparently yes, say critics, who find this update of the 1984 musical smash an energetic, toe-tapping good time. Kenny Wormald stars as the new kid in a town that has banned loud music and dancing. Can our hero melt the cold hard of Rev. Moore – and woo his daughter (Julianne Hough) in the process? The pundits say the plot is as silly as ever, but the exuberant cast and the high-energy production numbers make for a giddy night at the movies. (Check out Quaid’s best-reviewed movies, as well as director Craig Brewer’s Five Favorite Films.)

The Thing

34%

Remake fever has spread to even the most desolate corners of the globe; unfortunately, critics say the all-new The Thing ODs on CGI mayhem, eschewing the chilling atmospherics that made its 1951 and 1982 predecessors so memorable. Mary Elizabeth Winstead stars as a paleontologist who joins a research team that has discovered an alien craft buried in Antarctica — and soon, the base camp is bedeviled by a terrifying life form. The pundits say The Thing is slicker and more effects heavy than past versions, but it lacks a strong sense of storytelling.

The Big Year

42%

A languidly-paced comedy with a terrific cast, The Big Year isn’t always laugh-out-loud funny, critics say, but patient viewers may find it amusing in fits and starts. Jack Black, Owen Wilson, and Steve Martin star as a trio of rival birders who set out on a mission to observe the rarest feathered creatures in the wild – and deal with their personal issues in the process. The pundits say The Big Year is amiable and appealing, but its slow pace and lack of momentum makes it only occasionally funny.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

discovery DC Comics zombies TruTV australia hidden camera screenings Pop Oscar rt labs free movies 1990s worst movies Walt Disney Pictures superhero biopic broadcast sitcom Britbox Elton John rom-coms MGM blockbuster strong female leads book adaptation Vudu psychological thriller 24 frames dogs television Film Pacific Islander sag awards summer TV preview genre NBA telelvision TCA 2017 BBC One 73rd Emmy Awards crime thriller Binge Guide a nightmare on elm street rotten movies we love parents critic resources adaptation thriller Mindy Kaling Fargo Turner boxoffice Disney 94th Oscars Dark Horse Comics Country diversity target BBC Universal Ghostbusters hispanic unscripted spider-verse crime Pet Sematary south america Comedy Reality Competition italian action-comedy Countdown live event Captain marvel VOD Pirates Ovation VH1 olympics Biopics medical drama Native Nickelodeon BBC America IFC universal monsters superman venice First Reviews Food Network Netflix E! satire asian-american target scene in color YA mob Trivia DGA 99% Lifetime gangster GoT Box Office USA Apple TV+ BET game of thrones 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards See It Skip It Fall TV historical drama Mary poppins comedies reviews NYCC AMC Plus IFC Films Grammys 4/20 composers 71st Emmy Awards Paramount Network E3 The Academy vs. Disney+ Disney Plus Mary Poppins Returns Discovery Channel Creative Arts Emmys dc streamig Lucasfilm Arrowverse Heroines toronto hist Nominations Opinion Prime Video Stephen King Wes Anderson Columbia Pictures Marvel Studios Epix Martial Arts NBC The Purge casting Comedy Central 2019 boxing Paramount dceu halloween justice league IMDb TV FX Winners spider-man marvel cinematic universe criterion sports Marvel Television DirecTV stop motion cooking latino Comic-Con@Home 2021 Horror ABC Family Instagram Live king kong die hard The CW Chernobyl Sneak Peek miniseries Holidays The Walking Dead Lifetime Christmas movies BET Awards Fantasy rt archives harry potter football Awards National Geographic Calendar A&E quibi 20th Century Fox TV movies Hallmark Christmas movies TIFF toy story Teen Best Actress Fox News President Peacock Musicals docuseries king arthur space TNT robots know your critic slashers Video Games TCA Awards marvel comics political drama Baby Yoda fresh deadpool nbcuniversal dramedy Amazon Prime Thanksgiving suspense Tomatazos Marathons interviews Acorn TV RT History HFPA remakes adventure facebook Black Mirror Turner Classic Movies debate ghosts Drama Tokyo Olympics El Rey PBS Superheroe festivals cops A24 Funimation Neflix transformers FXX nature CBS All Access Freeform Watching Series leaderboard Photos Hear Us Out crossover TCA Winter 2020 razzies golden globes Best Actor Election Esquire Travel Channel 93rd Oscars Christmas elevated horror video on demand Sony monster movies Apple TV Plus Crackle Focus Features documentaries streaming movies cars Lionsgate Set visit LGBT Superheroes young adult reboot CBS psycho FOX Marvel comiccon Star Wars feel good aapi GIFs Legendary biography Tubi Emmys Emmy Nominations CMT scary halloween tv YouTube laika fast and furious 2016 MTV OneApp aliens PlayStation comic book movie godzilla Spring TV Geeked Week Rock art house Showtime child's play Paramount Pictures 2017 mcc new star wars movies international Writers Guild of America Hallmark Premiere Dates TV renewals anthology children's TV Exclusive Video werewolf teaser WGN Warner Bros. RT21 cancelled Film Festival Amazon politics anime critics American Society of Cinematographers classics all-time ABC Signature cancelled TV series lord of the rings Schedule high school ABC cancelled TV shows pirates of the caribbean versus Masterpiece Sundance San Diego Comic-Con black Starz YouTube Premium Hulu cartoon joker 79th Golden Globes Awards mutant batman Tarantino vampires SXSW 2022 cancelled television canceled TV shows jurassic park South by Southwest Film Festival TCA Spectrum Originals Pride Month Cosplay Pixar Image Comics streaming prank women theme song Television Academy Amazon Prime Video TBS Universal Pictures Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Women's History Month comics Extras movie worst Best and Worst romantic comedy rt labs critics edition SDCC PaleyFest Awards Tour Pop TV WarnerMedia Hollywood Foreign Press Association singing competition Cannes stoner Anna Paquin Quiz cinemax screen actors guild Toys posters Shondaland Sci-Fi Rocky Holiday concert 45 slasher summer preview sequel 72 Emmy Awards movies 007 comic books legend Sundance Now Trailer HBO travel Television Critics Association SundanceTV trailers scene in color film series Kids & Family doctor who jamie lee curtis dreamworks obituary 2021 green book FX on Hulu japanese mission: impossible Oscars Valentine's Day nfl crime drama Disney Channel 2015 spain emmy awards Classic Film Alien live action talk show First Look The Arrangement police drama Crunchyroll Super Bowl Chilling Adventures of Sabrina stand-up comedy docudrama ViacomCBS supernatural TV One Best Director Certified Fresh 2018 Polls and Games kaiju Summer technology independent MSNBC Netflix Christmas movies name the review disaster Avengers Sony Pictures Character Guide LGBTQ sequels blockbusters wonder woman TCM chucky breaking bad Tumblr Family New York Comic Con period drama renewed TV shows CW Seed Comic Book MCU Song of Ice and Fire VICE CNN video revenge HBO Max mockumentary dragons richard e. Grant Ellie Kemper adenture Disney Plus true crime Infographic Winter TV social media Star Wars Celebration ratings archives documentary french Sundance TV golden globe awards animated APB Rocketman Fox Searchlight new york Academy Awards franchise TLC DC streaming service Shudder Best Picture Logo foreign canceled trophy Mystery Year in Review heist movie Mudbound Music Western news binge basketball Reality Mary Tyler Moore book films zero dark thirty scorecard OWN tv talk serial killer what to watch BAFTA Cartoon Network twilight witnail james bond Nat Geo Black History Month The Witch comic book movies Trophy Talk Action scene in color hispanic heritage month Animation Endgame HBO Go blaxploitation 90s spanish Tags: Comedy directors DC Universe kong indie YouTube Red Paramount Plus X-Men rotten sopranos Brie Larson Amazon Studios Adult Swim scene in color series dexter Spike 21st Century Fox game show finale based on movie USA Network ESPN saw series romance History cults Musical The Walt Disney Company Broadway Bravo zombie spanish language natural history spinoff award winner kids indiana jones TV Red Carpet best festival new zealand SXSW Interview popular scary movies Apple Podcast comic christmas movies japan royal family ITV GLAAD TV Land Indigenous AMC Star Trek hollywood Comics on TV war summer TV black comedy science fiction ID obi wan Disney streaming service dark Syfy cats Rom-Com 2020 spy thriller