Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Dumb and Dumber To Has Too Few Laughs

Plus, Beyond the Lights is melodrama done right, and The Newsroom and The Comeback are Certified Fresh

by | November 13, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got foolhardy travelers (Dumb and Dumber To, starring Jim Carrey and Jeff Daniels) and a lovelorn pop star (Beyond the Lights, starring Gugu Mbatha-Raw and Nate Parker). What do the critics have to say?

Dumb and Dumber To

30%

Twenty years ago, Dumb and Dumber solidified Jim Carrey’s reign as the king of lowbrow comedy, and established directors Bobby and Peter Farrelly as the maestros of heartfelt gross-out humor. Unfortunately, critics say that while Harry and Lloyd can still generate an occasional dumb laugh, Dumb and Dumber To is more crass than funny, and too content to recycle laughs from its superior predecessor. This time out, Harry (Jeff Daniels) needs a kidney transplant, so he recruits Lloyd (Carrey) for a road trip to find a young woman that might be his daughter in the hope that she’s cool with donating a kidney). The pundits say Dumb and Dumber To gets a lot of mileage out of the charisma of its stars, but it simply lacks the heart and freshness of the original. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Daniels’ best-reviewed films.)

Beyond the Lights

83%

“Melodramatic” has become something of a dirty word these days, but there’s nothing wrong with a little melodrama if it’s done well. Take Beyond the Lights, for example: critics say there’s nothing original about this romantic drama, but thanks to sharp direction from Gugu Mbatha-Raw and Gina Prince-Bythewood and an attractive, likeable cast, it’s a top-notch crowd-pleaser. Gugu Mbatha-Raw stars as a rising pop star who’s rapidly becoming disenchanted with fame. She falls hard for Kaz (Nate Parker), an off-duty police officer, after he helps her out of a jam. Will true love conquer all? The pundits say Beyond the Lights is so well-executed that it mostly transcends its cliches, and it ends up having a thing or two to say about the toll that fame takes on women. (Watch our interviews with Mbatha-Raw and Parker here.)

Certified Fresh on TV:

With an energetic new arc and deeper character development, The Newsroom (Certified Fresh at 82 percent) finds itself rejuvenated in its third season — even if it still occasionally serves as a soapbox for creator Aaron Sorkin.

Substantially similar to its predecessor in all the best ways, critics say this new season of The Comeback (Certified Fresh at 83 percent) thrives on Lisa Kudrow’s starring performance as Valerie Cherish.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Foxcatcher, starring Channing Tatum and Steve Carell in a drama about an Olympic wrestling hopeful who falls under the influence of a questionable patron, is Certified Fresh at 93 percent.

  • Thou Wast Mild and Lovely, a drama about wild passions on a Kentucky farm, is at 83 percent.

  • Bad Turn Worse, a drama about a trio of Texas teens whose going-away celebration is financed by stolen cash, is at 82 percent.

  • The Homesman, starring Tommy Lee Jones and Hilary Swank in a Western about a former schoolteacher who recruits a man with a past to help her establish a sanctuary for troubled women, is at 78 percent.

  • Starry Eyes, a sci-fi horror film about an actress who is unwittingly enlisted by a sinister organization, is at 78 percent.

  • Jon Stewart‘s Rosewater, starring Gael García Bernal in a based-on-true-events drama about a Newsweek reporter accused of espionage while on assignment in Iran, is at 73 percent.

  • Miss Meadows, starring Katie Holmes in a drama about an elementary school teacher who moonlights as a vigilante, is at 50 percent.

  • Wolves, an action/horror hybrid about a teen werewolf who discovers an unsettled community of wolf-people, is at 33 percent.

Tag Cloud

spider-verse DirecTV comic book movie GIFs Family harry potter Polls and Games indiana jones robots Fox Searchlight documentaries Character Guide Election biography 007 Turner mutant quibi Spring TV President crime drama target scene in color supernatural scary movies women action-comedy Mary Poppins Returns rt labs critics edition telelvision HFPA TruTV cancelled The Walt Disney Company Apple TV+ Hallmark romance Box Office Disney Plus debate dexter Brie Larson Ovation comiccon foreign Winners Hallmark Christmas movies chucky toy story 94th Oscars 73rd Emmy Awards scary Pop Emmys 45 DGA Exclusive Video rt archives RT History cults WGN scene in color series Country hollywood zombie true crime Hollywood Foreign Press Association leaderboard Amazon Prime Video streamig MTV BET Awards Certified Fresh james bond Nickelodeon nbcuniversal popular festival Pirates blaxploitation spinoff die hard Masterpiece ABC Signature Dark Horse Comics nfl live event revenge pirates of the caribbean Best Actor Pride Month First Reviews HBO Disney+ Disney Plus cancelled TV series halloween screenings technology Year in Review boxing laika doctor who stop motion ESPN Legendary Trailer new york summer TV 71st Emmy Awards Musicals Best and Worst tv talk Instagram Live FX on Hulu casting Biopics travel slashers interviews Esquire Red Carpet vs. Adult Swim golden globes Peacock classics cartoon Lifetime best italian latino independent sag awards Paramount Network zero dark thirty emmy awards christmas movies Ghostbusters Christmas Infographic SXSW 2022 Mudbound black Superheroes Song of Ice and Fire marvel comics comic book movies A24 Sundance franchise south america Drama king arthur Summer Fargo Trivia Rom-Com miniseries First Look TV movies GoT Britbox CMT mission: impossible broadcast hispanic heritage month jurassic park IFC Films spider-man cancelled TV shows cinemax TV Shondaland Funimation nature Syfy 90s Cosplay A&E Holidays vampires Oscars Holiday movie Disney Channel Schedule IFC BBC Rock Crunchyroll Winter TV werewolf Amazon Studios Star Wars Lucasfilm Podcast Reality Competition Teen name the review Epix Toys Shudder 99% thriller dogs 79th Golden Globes Awards serial killer Focus Features slasher art house obi wan Cannes PlayStation rt labs based on movie aapi space concert comics Sci-Fi Sundance Now San Diego Comic-Con Warner Bros. Netflix binge Lionsgate screen actors guild hispanic children's TV Tags: Comedy book adaptation TV One National Geographic Vudu Anna Paquin black comedy Film Paramount Plus Universal free movies teaser ID lord of the rings superhero YouTube Premium crime FX superman Marvel 21st Century Fox video on demand new star wars movies feel good TCA Awards Thanksgiving twilight all-time what to watch blockbuster reboot docuseries Tarantino game of thrones 2017 DC Comics Broadway mcc Pacific Islander Action NYCC Discovery Channel ViacomCBS genre Interview spanish language dramedy ratings sopranos 20th Century Fox 4/20 transformers Quiz psycho BBC America justice league festivals suspense NBA Pixar Turner Classic Movies japan crime thriller dragons The Arrangement medical drama 93rd Oscars MCU saw Best Picture The Purge royal family Bravo 2016 rom-coms halloween tv television ABC History theme song Premiere Dates VICE rotten movies we love stand-up comedy know your critic dreamworks richard e. Grant unscripted elevated horror YouTube Red Valentine's Day deadpool historical drama boxoffice Star Wars Celebration CW Seed Television Critics Association witnail archives fast and furious movies Pet Sematary critics toronto TIFF Marvel Studios Fantasy international Freeform remakes adenture AMC Mystery game show BET 2021 hidden camera biopic comic OneApp Avengers critic resources dc Star Trek MSNBC Musical live action Academy Awards South by Southwest Film Festival See It Skip It posters high school ABC Family OWN Netflix Christmas movies Photos Captain marvel VH1 Creative Arts Emmys docudrama The Academy french king kong hist Binge Guide Columbia Pictures El Rey Music Watching Series reviews USA Network Spike animated joker spy thriller Stephen King Comedy CBS All Access canceled TV shows science fiction Comedy Central stoner natural history Best Actress PBS E3 green book cooking Best Director prank Sneak Peek FXX Emmy Nominations Paramount a nightmare on elm street Prime Video TCA Winter 2020 versus Rocketman Tokyo Olympics Sundance TV PaleyFest comedies DC Universe Marvel Television Crackle razzies Black History Month Comic-Con@Home 2021 VOD canceled USA Set visit marvel cinematic universe Ellie Kemper Comics on TV Tomatazos WarnerMedia 24 frames japanese ITV MGM Mary Tyler Moore Walt Disney Pictures facebook Super Bowl BAFTA streaming GLAAD Acorn TV 72 Emmy Awards RT21 sequels The Witch Martial Arts finale cops crossover The CW romantic comedy Opinion 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards dark kaiju TBS TLC Disney streaming service scene in color film series LGBT Countdown criterion Fox News Apple TV Plus Video Games police drama Endgame Wes Anderson Extras TNT singing competition Arrowverse Television Academy Food Network Western discovery Black Mirror Marathons ghosts Nominations Logo Pop TV TCA obituary scorecard Oscar Horror talk show Women's History Month Paramount Pictures monster movies satire young adult sitcom 2015 LGBTQ 1990s Fall TV Comic Book basketball worst movies YA documentary cars batman renewed TV shows period drama political drama Indigenous jamie lee curtis Nat Geo Amazon breaking bad Image Comics directors streaming movies video Showtime FOX Amazon Prime DC streaming service E! golden globe awards scene in color dceu BBC One HBO Go news CBS Mary poppins legend trailers Classic Film Reality American Society of Cinematographers politics TCM universal monsters films 2018 Film Festival trophy Universal Pictures Awards Tour sequel summer TV preview Disney New York Comic Con Kids & Family anthology Writers Guild of America Chilling Adventures of Sabrina spanish godzilla blockbusters 2019 football adventure war Calendar Grammys rotten adaptation kong NBC wonder woman Elton John Geeked Week AMC Plus SundanceTV australia Sony Pictures summer preview Mindy Kaling Travel Channel Rocky YouTube Alien award winner Cartoon Network psychological thriller Hulu Tumblr child's play olympics Sony cats Heroines 2020 composers HBO Max The Walking Dead Chernobyl kids Superheroe TCA 2017 worst Apple TV Land Baby Yoda X-Men disaster series heist movie new zealand anime IMDb TV CNN diversity Neflix Spectrum Originals SDCC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt comic books aliens Awards SXSW Lifetime Christmas movies Tubi strong female leads asian-american Hear Us Out Native parents book sports social media cancelled television mockumentary Animation target APB spain fresh mob venice gangster zombies Trophy Talk Starz indie TV renewals