Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Dumb and Dumber To Has Too Few Laughs

Plus, Beyond the Lights is melodrama done right, and The Newsroom and The Comeback are Certified Fresh

by | November 13, 2014 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got foolhardy travelers (Dumb and Dumber To, starring Jim Carrey and Jeff Daniels) and a lovelorn pop star (Beyond the Lights, starring Gugu Mbatha-Raw and Nate Parker). What do the critics have to say?


Dumb and Dumber To

30%

Twenty years ago, Dumb and Dumber solidified Jim Carrey’s reign as the king of lowbrow comedy, and established directors Bobby and Peter Farrelly as the maestros of heartfelt gross-out humor. Unfortunately, critics say that while Harry and Lloyd can still generate an occasional dumb laugh, Dumb and Dumber To is more crass than funny, and too content to recycle laughs from its superior predecessor. This time out, Harry (Jeff Daniels) needs a kidney transplant, so he recruits Lloyd (Carrey) for a road trip to find a young woman that might be his daughter in the hope that she’s cool with donating a kidney). The pundits say Dumb and Dumber To gets a lot of mileage out of the charisma of its stars, but it simply lacks the heart and freshness of the original. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Daniels’ best-reviewed films.)



Beyond the Lights

83%

“Melodramatic” has become something of a dirty word these days, but there’s nothing wrong with a little melodrama if it’s done well. Take Beyond the Lights, for example: critics say there’s nothing original about this romantic drama, but thanks to sharp direction from Gugu Mbatha-Raw and Gina Prince-Bythewood and an attractive, likeable cast, it’s a top-notch crowd-pleaser. Gugu Mbatha-Raw stars as a rising pop star who’s rapidly becoming disenchanted with fame. She falls hard for Kaz (Nate Parker), an off-duty police officer, after he helps her out of a jam. Will true love conquer all? The pundits say Beyond the Lights is so well-executed that it mostly transcends its cliches, and it ends up having a thing or two to say about the toll that fame takes on women. (Watch our interviews with Mbatha-Raw and Parker here.)

Certified Fresh on TV:


With an energetic new arc and deeper character development, The Newsroom (Certified Fresh at 82 percent) finds itself rejuvenated in its third season — even if it still occasionally serves as a soapbox for creator Aaron Sorkin.


Substantially similar to its predecessor in all the best ways, critics say this new season of The Comeback (Certified Fresh at 83 percent) thrives on Lisa Kudrow’s starring performance as Valerie Cherish.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Foxcatcher, starring Channing Tatum and Steve Carell in a drama about an Olympic wrestling hopeful who falls under the influence of a questionable patron, is Certified Fresh at 93 percent.
  • Thou Wast Mild and Lovely, a drama about wild passions on a Kentucky farm, is at 83 percent.
  • Bad Turn Worse, a drama about a trio of Texas teens whose going-away celebration is financed by stolen cash, is at 82 percent.
  • The Homesman, starring Tommy Lee Jones and Hilary Swank in a Western about a former schoolteacher who recruits a man with a past to help her establish a sanctuary for troubled women, is at 78 percent.
  • Starry Eyes, a sci-fi horror film about an actress who is unwittingly enlisted by a sinister organization, is at 78 percent.
  • Jon Stewart‘s Rosewater, starring Gael García Bernal in a based-on-true-events drama about a Newsweek reporter accused of espionage while on assignment in Iran, is at 73 percent.
  • Miss Meadows, starring Katie Holmes in a drama about an elementary school teacher who moonlights as a vigilante, is at 50 percent.
  • Wolves, an action/horror hybrid about a teen werewolf who discovers an unsettled community of wolf-people, is at 33 percent.

Tag Cloud

Mindy Kaling BET action-comedy fresh black comedy Rom-Com trailers documentaries Endgame Trailer Pirates 2018 Disney Plus Winter TV Baby Yoda dragons versus comiccon USA Network TLC Spring TV ABC Family CBS All Access leaderboard Best and Worst name the review spider-man TV One adventure Marvel Television HBO Max criterion 90s PlayStation spy thriller indie cults cancelled Fox News cancelled television Family DC streaming service halloween tv doctor who know your critic Food Network Ovation NBC Television Critics Association award winner Columbia Pictures anime FXX Emmys SXSW 24 frames Universal AMC biopic GIFs Chernobyl Paramount 20th Century Fox gangster National Geographic based on movie First Look facebook richard e. Grant Action telelvision justice league 2016 DC Universe Dark Horse Comics 2017 4/20 Year in Review blockbuster natural history spinoff wonder woman Cannes tv talk BET Awards christmas movies Infographic mcc medical drama legend Grammys Paramount Network ESPN ITV Musicals AMC Plus cancelled TV series discovery technology El Rey Acorn TV slashers Emmy Nominations nature Tarantino Reality Competition Amazon PBS dc Superheroe A&E young adult concert mockumentary classics kaiju Reality Sundance Now films comic book movie aliens Classic Film scary Brie Larson Drama GLAAD Countdown IFC Films Funimation The Walking Dead video screen actors guild Universal Pictures zombies genre festivals Hallmark saw mutant aapi First Reviews Prime Video binge new zealand cartoon Hallmark Christmas movies Vudu Shondaland animated Apple TV Plus archives scene in color cops renewed TV shows toronto Ghostbusters TIFF sopranos HFPA Rocketman MTV 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards art house Marvel live event 1990s prank IFC mission: impossible rt labs critics edition Exclusive Video comic American Society of Cinematographers cats reboot screenings twilight sag awards Sci-Fi Netflix sequels true crime target Showtime space game show Podcast basketball miniseries universal monsters spain transformers Crackle new star wars movies batman Starz godzilla FOX Ellie Kemper Marvel Studios CNN TCM elevated horror History historical drama VICE Black Mirror Shudder Country 71st Emmy Awards talk show HBO Go Disney Channel Amazon Studios Pride Month Summer 99% 21st Century Fox Chilling Adventures of Sabrina hispanic hollywood scary movies olympics docudrama Paramount Plus NBA movies james bond Star Wars Film hispanic heritage month worst movies crime thriller dark dceu Oscars Alien ratings E! Opinion Election spanish RT History Apple TV+ Legendary Disney+ Disney Plus Tags: Comedy remakes comic books TCA Winter 2020 best festival PaleyFest sports razzies witnail Trivia The Purge thriller Binge Guide Awards dramedy Spike popular ID Lifetime Christmas movies independent The CW FX book 2019 breaking bad debate stop motion high school boxing YouTube romance Certified Fresh a nightmare on elm street YA Fall TV 2015 japan 72 Emmy Awards WarnerMedia fast and furious Schedule hist canceled harry potter Image Comics Cartoon Network Premiere Dates blockbusters DirecTV nbcuniversal period drama TCA scorecard Animation kong stoner Elton John theme song Star Trek free movies Heroines anthology Music jamie lee curtis diversity Logo satire halloween dexter Mary Poppins Returns golden globes Holiday what to watch Esquire Turner Classic Movies Hear Us Out Lifetime Captain marvel IMDb TV Pet Sematary Comedy Central hidden camera MSNBC robots mob cinemax Neflix TV Land Polls and Games TruTV Christmas Musical pirates of the caribbean Watching Series psycho women children's TV Disney streaming service HBO Nominations critic resources Arrowverse franchise BBC America Black History Month TV renewals Red Carpet zombie TV movies adenture blaxploitation supernatural BBC One Wes Anderson obituary Lucasfilm Nickelodeon singing competition Rocky book adaptation unscripted cancelled TV shows TNT TBS rotten political drama Pop Interview rom-coms 2021 disaster posters king kong Warner Bros. President crime worst Awards Tour sequel dreamworks all-time Creative Arts Emmys 2020 Mystery Set visit Holidays child's play finale Sundance TV australia streaming movies boxoffice Kids & Family 007 Travel Channel Crunchyroll Rock Tokyo Olympics laika spider-verse Academy Awards superman MCU The Witch Photos strong female leads Biopics asian-american Cosplay Adult Swim suspense crossover rotten movies we love series Discovery Channel Stephen King X-Men Fargo new york south america Netflix Christmas movies casting Tumblr teaser Epix Toys critics 73rd Emmy Awards Thanksgiving Spectrum Originals 93rd Oscars comic book movies Film Festival Pop TV 79th Golden Globes Awards marvel comics Hollywood Foreign Press Association Hulu Lionsgate The Walt Disney Company french Comics on TV television Mudbound Quiz RT21 Tomatazos lord of the rings documentary BAFTA comedies dogs international Mary poppins Character Guide LGBTQ Disney Apple Fox Searchlight The Arrangement Sneak Peek GoT Freeform USA comics vs. italian ABC Signature revenge joker toy story SDCC football biography San Diego Comic-Con werewolf news video on demand Television Academy Instagram Live Masterpiece indiana jones serial killer OneApp YouTube Premium Pixar Bravo venice latino SundanceTV OWN ghosts 45 Martial Arts Super Bowl Amazon Prime Video LGBT TCA 2017 golden globe awards politics nfl E3 Comic-Con@Home 2021 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt CBS WGN deadpool heist movie police drama japanese Song of Ice and Fire psychological thriller DC Comics emmy awards black die hard CW Seed movie rt archives TV monster movies Comedy NYCC ViacomCBS CMT Western Peacock Video Games Winners Avengers Anna Paquin Horror game of thrones spanish language The Academy cars Walt Disney Pictures docuseries Mary Tyler Moore ABC Syfy adaptation Superheroes war romantic comedy zero dark thirty Amazon Prime See It Skip It foreign science fiction live action Extras Teen stand-up comedy New York Comic Con directors Tubi Writers Guild of America rt labs sitcom jurassic park Marathons VH1 vampires Pacific Islander Women's History Month slasher travel reviews feel good Sundance kids Calendar quibi cooking marvel cinematic universe BBC Nat Geo A24 streaming Trophy Talk chucky king arthur Box Office TCA Awards Fantasy Britbox Sony Pictures APB crime drama Valentine's Day composers royal family Comic Book green book VOD trophy parents Turner DGA FX on Hulu YouTube Red Broadway social media canceled TV shows superhero