Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Dinner for Schmucks Serves Up An OK Time

Plus, Charlie St. Cloud and Cats and Dogs fail to wow the critics.

by | July 30, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a dinner party disaster (Dinner for Schmucks, starring Steve Carell and Paul Rudd), some after-death bonding (Charlie St. Cloud, starring Zac Efron and Kim Basinger), and a joint canine-feline mission (Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore, starring Chris O’Donnell and Jack McBrayer). What do the critics have to say?


Dinner for Schmucks

It’s not unusual for a remake to lose something in transition, and that’s the case with Dinner for Schmucks, an American take on the acid French farce The Dinner Game. Still, critics say even if this isn’t the most biting comedy, the inventiveness of Steve Carell and Paul Rudd make it consistently watchable and occasionally hilarious. Rudd stars as a guy struggling to get ahead at his company, until his boss invites him to a dinner party. One problem: the dinner is a competition, and he has to bring the biggest idiot he can find. So he brings Barry (Carell), a world class fool who also has a core of decency and some interesting talents. The pundits say Schmucks lacks the bite of the original, and often devolves into empte slapstick. However, it’s also got goofiness and absurdity to spare, and its performers are on top of their games. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down Rudd’s best-reviewed movies.)


Charlie St. Cloud

Slowly but surely, Zac Efron is moving away from the teenybop material that made him a star. However, if his turn in last year’s Me and Orson Welles signaled a new maturity, the critics say the generic weepy Charlie St. Cloud is a big step backward. Efron stars as a young man overcome with grief at the death of his younger brother; soon however, he’s communicating with his sibling from the beyond. Will he stay true to the little guy even after meeting the girl of his dreams? The pundits say Charlie St. Cloud is a melodramatic mess, uneasily mixing romantic and supernatural elements with a bit too much schmaltz to resonate.


Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore

Nine years ago, Cats and Dogs was a surprise box office hit that generated some tepid but decent reviews. Not this time: critics say the sequel, subtitled The Revenge of Kitty Galore, is a dull satire of James Bond movies that’s unlikely to generate much enthusiasm among the kiddies in the audience. This time out, the cats and dogs join forces to defeat an evil plan by Kitty Galore, a rogue housecat bent on world domination. The pundits say this one’s a dog, with mediocre CGI effects, little storytelling to speak of, and an utter lack of originality.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Awards genre Awards Tour cancelled TV shows scene in color Tags: Comedy laika Sci-Fi venice book adaptation Hallmark Christmas movies Star Wars social media Paramount jurassic park YouTube Premium 24 frames Nat Geo See It Skip It docudrama 2019 GoT twilight 20th Century Fox Shondaland BET Awards Ovation diversity GIFs series TV TV movies mob cancelled TV series History Amazon Prime Disney documentary chucky National Geographic Box Office natural history art house Superheroes name the review posters mutant GLAAD HFPA nbcuniversal Apple all-time spanish live action spider-man comic book movie adaptation MSNBC Fall TV leaderboard psychological thriller hollywood FX on Hulu remakes TCA Winter 2020 marvel comics criterion canceled aapi witnail The Purge Exclusive Video Sundance ID Fargo Film TV Land HBO war CBS All Access Lifetime Grammys marvel cinematic universe stoner french heist movie monster movies fast and furious finale psycho sequels harry potter romance christmas movies target SXSW black Sundance TV suspense italian classics IMDb TV San Diego Comic-Con based on movie historical drama Martial Arts ghosts reviews Reality Holidays El Rey Mary poppins ITV Star Trek wonder woman Infographic TV One IFC blockbusters Spring TV Comic Book police drama new york Syfy scorecard award winner Classic Film Heroines asian-american Epix WarnerMedia prank Starz space Superheroe scary Freeform lord of the rings Adult Swim Opinion VICE comedies Comic-Con@Home 2021 sports Polls and Games dogs foreign sitcom Academy Awards Mystery Holiday Tarantino 79th Golden Globes Awards TCA Awards revenge 1990s USA Binge Guide Hallmark Tokyo Olympics Horror Legendary comic books Nickelodeon Emmys adventure Character Guide President The Arrangement critics king kong animated films game of thrones superman quibi YouTube Red science fiction free movies 007 TruTV AMC Plus HBO Max Disney streaming service NBA Turner spain Marvel Television rt labs critics edition MTV anime unscripted 2016 worst movies Winners Fox Searchlight Spectrum Originals justice league Ellie Kemper south america trailers kaiju Drama Baby Yoda Elton John razzies 73rd Emmy Awards international ESPN Country Super Bowl HBO Go debate Travel Channel crossover E! Quiz Brie Larson Amazon Prime Video Music Emmy Nominations RT21 SundanceTV Countdown Pop TV james bond Stephen King Valentine's Day nfl cinemax ViacomCBS green book LGBTQ Song of Ice and Fire festival Teen CMT Thanksgiving Anna Paquin cops dramedy mcc singing competition ABC Family VOD Trivia serial killer popular Pirates spider-verse biography obituary werewolf video cats The Witch movies women Schedule Musicals elevated horror Cartoon Network romantic comedy crime ABC Signature disaster Logo australia mockumentary 45 CNN canceled TV shows IFC Films Lifetime Christmas movies Broadway CBS composers Marathons japan Paramount Network Watching Series Podcast toy story rotten DC streaming service APB cartoon Peacock best movie telelvision feel good WGN FX hispanic CW Seed American Society of Cinematographers Kids & Family OWN 21st Century Fox Comics on TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina travel Captain marvel Oscars dexter Mary Poppins Returns Netflix Christmas movies universal monsters documentaries DC Comics SDCC PBS spy thriller crime drama Creative Arts Emmys action-comedy Women's History Month supernatural Cannes Amazon TIFF Election Interview kids Year in Review Lionsgate cancelled E3 Esquire Television Critics Association Trophy Talk versus Vudu slashers Fantasy young adult trophy basketball a nightmare on elm street screenings archives doctor who hist teaser 99% BBC cults slasher Biopics video on demand emmy awards king arthur joker PlayStation Funimation theme song 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards high school Calendar legend Cosplay The Academy Certified Fresh rom-coms indiana jones kong parents Nominations Apple TV Plus Dark Horse Comics Neflix Rocky Best and Worst Hear Us Out directors know your critic streaming 72 Emmy Awards FOX comic Marvel Rom-Com toronto Video Games LGBT Shudder spinoff critic resources First Reviews biopic DirecTV vampires 2018 concert Pop ratings Trailer screen actors guild YouTube franchise news Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Winter TV Family thriller saw Comedy Central RT History what to watch indie Reality Competition Hulu independent Marvel Studios Animation zombies Showtime Warner Bros. 90s Red Carpet 4/20 mission: impossible casting Photos AMC Tomatazos 2017 Netflix dreamworks Sundance Now hidden camera medical drama Pride Month YA BBC One dceu sag awards Set visit richard e. Grant Masterpiece Crunchyroll A&E batman rt labs PaleyFest 2021 Film Festival golden globes Sneak Peek Writers Guild of America blockbuster Musical Rocketman renewed TV shows Sony Pictures fresh Chernobyl boxing Acorn TV Hollywood Foreign Press Association Spike football Apple TV+ dc Disney+ Disney Plus strong female leads Universal Pictures Wes Anderson Amazon Studios Arrowverse Pacific Islander Rock TCA 71st Emmy Awards boxoffice hispanic heritage month X-Men VH1 BBC America Turner Classic Movies period drama Paramount Plus sequel Food Network zero dark thirty Tubi japanese 2015 New York Comic Con TCA 2017 stop motion technology streaming movies binge Crackle child's play Britbox scary movies political drama cars Walt Disney Pictures discovery adenture 93rd Oscars Discovery Channel DGA anthology First Look ABC comic book movies DC Universe miniseries breaking bad Image Comics golden globe awards new zealand Television Academy spanish language Universal Disney Plus Toys Christmas children's TV deadpool talk show transformers The Walt Disney Company Pixar docuseries godzilla Avengers book rotten movies we love Lucasfilm TLC Alien gangster festivals TBS pirates of the caribbean jamie lee curtis MCU aliens stand-up comedy blaxploitation FXX comics Black History Month Extras BET BAFTA rt archives Mudbound live event robots Ghostbusters NBC tv talk latino halloween tv sopranos worst 2020 comiccon halloween Columbia Pictures Mary Tyler Moore Bravo Premiere Dates olympics TNT OneApp true crime black comedy NYCC TV renewals reboot The CW Instagram Live Summer Comedy vs. cancelled television superhero die hard royal family Western facebook new star wars movies Black Mirror satire dragons Disney Channel Mindy Kaling crime thriller game show zombie television Tumblr Fox News cooking Action A24 nature USA Network politics TCM dark Prime Video The Walking Dead Pet Sematary Endgame