Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Despite Laughs, Extract Isn't Quite Potent Enough

Plus, All About Steve is floundering, while Gamer has yet to receive a review.

by | September 3, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a wacky workplace (Extract, starring Jason Bateman and Ben Affleck), crazy love (All About Steve, starring Sandra Bullock and Bradley Cooper), and video game violence (Gamer, starring Gerard Butler and Ludacris). What do the critics have to say?



Mike Judge is one of contemporary cinema’s finest chroniclers of the working life — and what a madhouse it can be. His first feature, Office Space, was a riotous exercise in workplace absurdity, but critics say his latest, Extract, isn’t quite as funny — or as insightful. Jason Bateman stars as the owner of a flavoring factory with plenty on his mind: his wife’s affections are waning, one of his employees has suffered a cringe-worthy injury, and his best pay gives him questionable advice, usually while under the influence. The pundits say Extract has some very funny moments and several fine performances, but overall, the film feels slighter and more uneven than Judge’s previous work.


All About Steve

Sandra Bullock’s pure likability has elevated plenty of so-so romantic comedies, but she can’t always overcome the deficiencies of a terrible script. Case in point: All About Steve, which critics describe as one of the worst in the actress’ solid career. Bullock stars as a woman who falls head-over-heals for a TV cameraman (Bradley Cooper) after a single blind date and proceeds to follow him around the country. The pundits say All About Steve is an oddly creepy, sour film, featuring a heroine so desperate and peculiar that audiences may be more likely to pity than root for her. (Also, be sure to check out our rundown of the Best Stalker Movies in this week’s Total Recall.)



It appears the folks behind Gamer are afraid that it’s the cinematic equivalent to the N-Gage, since it wasn’t screened for critics prior to release. Gerard Butler stars as the main character in a futuristic MMORPG, but with a twist: he’s a living, breathing human being, and he’s being controlled by a teen gamer. Kids, turn off that Atari Jaguar and guess that Tomatometer!

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Liverpool, a minimalist drama about a lonely Argentine man, is at 100 percent.
  • Unmade Beds, about two hipster immigrants in London looking for love, is at 86 percent.

  • Amreeka, a dramedy about a Palestinian woman making a new life in a small American town, is at 80 percent.

  • American Casino, a documentary that explores the causes and effects of the current economic crisis, is at 54 percent.

  • Tickling Leo, about a family’s dark secret from World War II, is at 33 percent.

Tag Cloud

prank 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards satire remakes aapi Apple TV+ biopic legend movie Comedy TV Black Mirror boxoffice halloween tv E3 Emmy Nominations Hulu Universal Pictures natural history a nightmare on elm street Creative Arts Emmys Logo award winner dc Apple TV Plus Trophy Talk razzies Star Wars disaster Comedy Central DirecTV docudrama Drama Cosplay Summer Tokyo Olympics Disney+ Disney Plus zombie YouTube gangster RT History king kong know your critic Biopics reboot romance HFPA Fargo best miniseries sopranos Trivia Rock TNT Shudder Quiz 2016 The CW Podcast football 45 revenge slashers franchise jurassic park RT21 Brie Larson Alien crime thriller batman live event AMC Plus sitcom IFC Films TIFF cancelled television deadpool Year in Review The Academy Marvel SXSW comiccon Awards Star Trek BBC black comedy Cannes game show Stephen King X-Men FX on Hulu Paramount CMT Country 20th Century Fox 72 Emmy Awards Disney El Rey rom-coms GIFs Turner Reality Competition Song of Ice and Fire toy story discovery The Walking Dead HBO Go TV One Cartoon Network name the review Legendary television Arrowverse IMDb TV streaming movies asian-american new star wars movies stand-up comedy DGA Crackle Reality Opinion worst movies Walt Disney Pictures Calendar BBC America travel Amazon Winners The Witch Apple Teen 2021 james bond Fox News series adventure Mystery spider-verse diversity Christmas Pet Sematary First Reviews romantic comedy Fox Searchlight Countdown green book basketball Character Guide ghosts SundanceTV Rocketman Netflix YouTube Red cancelled based on movie Pixar venice reviews talk show American Society of Cinematographers ViacomCBS marvel comics Sundance TV Election directors screen actors guild blaxploitation theme song new york TLC toronto casting comic 71st Emmy Awards Musical Mindy Kaling technology crime wonder woman foreign Prime Video LGBTQ Fall TV festivals Black History Month Tags: Comedy new zealand superman women First Look TCA anthology See It Skip It LGBT telelvision sports Toys GoT Watching Series marvel cinematic universe Hear Us Out australia History historical drama WarnerMedia Avengers Mudbound adenture Showtime biography OneApp Britbox APB kaiju young adult Binge Guide anime streaming dogs TCA Awards classics 79th Golden Globes Awards Lionsgate AMC dceu Video Games royal family Freeform 2018 hidden camera Disney Plus WGN slasher PaleyFest Warner Bros. Captain marvel mcc book adaptation medical drama Discovery Channel 4/20 supernatural 73rd Emmy Awards Marathons Pacific Islander ABC Signature Esquire all-time comic book movies NBA period drama Music true crime Lucasfilm screenings BET Awards cartoon Crunchyroll Trailer Best and Worst Anna Paquin festival rt labs critics edition archives Winter TV San Diego Comic-Con psychological thriller king arthur TruTV dexter emmy awards animated cancelled TV shows Spectrum Originals USA indie harry potter obituary renewed TV shows Sci-Fi Amazon Prime Video Photos 21st Century Fox kong godzilla Disney streaming service target quibi ABC Writers Guild of America cancelled TV series documentary trailers high school action-comedy psycho video on demand stoner live action joker Endgame Amazon Prime Paramount Network scorecard political drama docuseries adaptation Mary Poppins Returns rotten movies we love Ovation TCA 2017 kids international A24 teaser concert Chernobyl zero dark thirty Syfy Vudu films fast and furious die hard hispanic heritage month posters TBS 2017 Schedule Paramount Plus Netflix Christmas movies sag awards strong female leads VICE sequels finale Amazon Studios aliens nature worst Baby Yoda boxing tv talk Epix south america Mary poppins hist Polls and Games video YA comic book movie Starz MCU Image Comics A&E Hollywood Foreign Press Association popular police drama saw mob Holidays Instagram Live Rom-Com 2015 space Tomatazos black spanish YouTube Premium cooking Classic Film vampires Spike social media crime drama transformers Box Office ratings suspense blockbusters fresh BBC One Ghostbusters USA Network HBO Max elevated horror Action NBC Valentine's Day Superheroes singing competition science fiction FOX Oscars parents mockumentary ID DC Universe Sundance free movies heist movie golden globes justice league NYCC japanese documentaries The Walt Disney Company VOD 2019 critic resources nbcuniversal spain Horror cats genre Heroines stop motion game of thrones Sneak Peek Television Critics Association scary movies criterion TCM zombies binge IFC trophy Musicals OWN Food Network Extras E! BAFTA rt archives Rocky laika cults Tarantino dragons PlayStation japan Lifetime Christmas movies Neflix werewolf Wes Anderson Western Hallmark Christmas movies Pop canceled The Arrangement mutant Emmys Turner Classic Movies 90s facebook Women's History Month DC streaming service PBS sequel Sundance Now Awards Tour superhero richard e. Grant indiana jones Sony Pictures Interview jamie lee curtis debate children's TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina cars Marvel Studios Adult Swim Acorn TV art house VH1 leaderboard doctor who crossover Lifetime 24 frames christmas movies TV renewals rotten TCA Winter 2020 FX composers book President Premiere Dates universal monsters breaking bad thriller chucky Spring TV Tumblr versus Nickelodeon Funimation rt labs 99% dark french olympics CBS All Access BET Ellie Kemper news Red Carpet Film comics Hallmark dreamworks Disney Channel nfl TV Land unscripted Television Academy Exclusive Video Comic Book latino CBS witnail FXX CW Seed Pop TV Film Festival Pride Month comedies politics independent Certified Fresh vs. Fantasy Universal Masterpiece Martial Arts The Purge DC Comics Comics on TV Broadway halloween cinemax spinoff Shondaland ITV GLAAD serial killer mission: impossible Nat Geo war Bravo spider-man Peacock Kids & Family comic books what to watch Infographic Elton John Grammys National Geographic MSNBC canceled TV shows CNN spanish language critics blockbuster hispanic Mary Tyler Moore Dark Horse Comics Family HBO 1990s cops child's play 007 lord of the rings Pirates Travel Channel italian robots Holiday 93rd Oscars Thanksgiving Superheroe scary Columbia Pictures Animation scene in color Academy Awards New York Comic Con feel good pirates of the caribbean hollywood golden globe awards Set visit ESPN twilight Nominations 2020 SDCC Comic-Con@Home 2021 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Tubi spy thriller Super Bowl MTV Marvel Television movies dramedy TV movies ABC Family monster movies