Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Despite Laughs, Extract Isn't Quite Potent Enough

Plus, All About Steve is floundering, while Gamer has yet to receive a review.

by | September 3, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a wacky workplace (Extract, starring Jason Bateman and Ben Affleck), crazy love (All About Steve, starring Sandra Bullock and Bradley Cooper), and video game violence (Gamer, starring Gerard Butler and Ludacris). What do the critics have to say?



Mike Judge is one of contemporary cinema’s finest chroniclers of the working life — and what a madhouse it can be. His first feature, Office Space, was a riotous exercise in workplace absurdity, but critics say his latest, Extract, isn’t quite as funny — or as insightful. Jason Bateman stars as the owner of a flavoring factory with plenty on his mind: his wife’s affections are waning, one of his employees has suffered a cringe-worthy injury, and his best pay gives him questionable advice, usually while under the influence. The pundits say Extract has some very funny moments and several fine performances, but overall, the film feels slighter and more uneven than Judge’s previous work.


All About Steve

Sandra Bullock’s pure likability has elevated plenty of so-so romantic comedies, but she can’t always overcome the deficiencies of a terrible script. Case in point: All About Steve, which critics describe as one of the worst in the actress’ solid career. Bullock stars as a woman who falls head-over-heals for a TV cameraman (Bradley Cooper) after a single blind date and proceeds to follow him around the country. The pundits say All About Steve is an oddly creepy, sour film, featuring a heroine so desperate and peculiar that audiences may be more likely to pity than root for her. (Also, be sure to check out our rundown of the Best Stalker Movies in this week’s Total Recall.)



It appears the folks behind Gamer are afraid that it’s the cinematic equivalent to the N-Gage, since it wasn’t screened for critics prior to release. Gerard Butler stars as the main character in a futuristic MMORPG, but with a twist: he’s a living, breathing human being, and he’s being controlled by a teen gamer. Kids, turn off that Atari Jaguar and guess that Tomatometer!

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Liverpool, a minimalist drama about a lonely Argentine man, is at 100 percent.
  • Unmade Beds, about two hipster immigrants in London looking for love, is at 86 percent.

  • Amreeka, a dramedy about a Palestinian woman making a new life in a small American town, is at 80 percent.

  • American Casino, a documentary that explores the causes and effects of the current economic crisis, is at 54 percent.

  • Tickling Leo, about a family’s dark secret from World War II, is at 33 percent.

Tag Cloud

2015 Bravo boxing football stop motion ABC Signature king kong spy thriller Tokyo Olympics Western films screen actors guild obituary suspense strong female leads kids Martial Arts Comic Book OWN Marvel Studios historical drama social media Rocky king arthur USA Network Best Picture marvel comics BBC cats leaderboard dramedy Grammys 1990s supernatural trophy TV renewals ITV scorecard Teen Fargo Binge Guide Star Wars Celebration disaster spanish Ovation streaming movies Trailer 007 archives video TV Land new york Paramount Pictures Legendary jurassic park Elton John Disney Mary poppins wonder woman First Reviews halloween Logo GIFs Certified Fresh Exclusive Video broadcast NYCC festivals El Rey VH1 Television Academy theme song independent screenings Drama cancelled TV shows summer TV BBC One sitcom award winner 94th Oscars Image Comics zombies Prime Video Peacock Mudbound canceled docuseries AMC Plus laika art house 2016 debate HBO Go video on demand Instagram Live Thanksgiving sopranos Mary Tyler Moore free movies Character Guide Sony Pictures Netflix Red Carpet game of thrones Sci-Fi comic books Universal science fiction binge rt archives 2020 monster movies Spring TV concert mob basketball Pixar Epix TCA Winter 2020 Academy Awards dark italian Calendar 93rd Oscars Comedy satire talk show Fox News CMT police drama Mystery Paramount Network Dark Horse Comics jamie lee curtis Set visit SXSW 2022 romantic comedy Reality Competition 72 Emmy Awards zero dark thirty Baby Yoda Disney Channel thriller cars crime The CW Comedy Central french Pride Month japan WGN universal monsters romance franchise MSNBC a nightmare on elm street FXX women toy story Tumblr streamig witnail Podcast rotten movies we love 79th Golden Globes Awards Indigenous The Walt Disney Company HFPA Interview hispanic superman 2019 Syfy spanish language SXSW GoT Comics on TV new star wars movies natural history Fantasy breaking bad rt labs critics edition TNT know your critic Chilling Adventures of Sabrina marvel cinematic universe APB YouTube Sneak Peek prank Nominations Rock batman FX on Hulu canceled TV shows DirecTV Columbia Pictures Christmas DC Universe scene in color series Marvel Television justice league Holidays black comedy USA mutant best directors mcc streaming VOD Emmys spain remakes Photos Nat Geo Television Critics Association emmy awards TCA 2017 Film Anna Paquin worst stoner Video Games royal family YouTube Premium criterion Lifetime Christmas movies movies Superheroes scary LGBTQ TruTV 99% sports San Diego Comic-Con Lucasfilm Masterpiece cinemax feel good Best Actor all-time National Geographic ABC American Society of Cinematographers comic Winter TV PBS boxoffice werewolf Best Director Emmy Nominations cooking TLC Trophy Talk Amazon Prime Video dc Turner spider-man nature kong adventure sequel RT History 4/20 IFC Films scene in color film series IFC Turner Classic Movies teaser Valentine's Day DC streaming service Year in Review adenture festival dexter RT21 Cosplay Travel Channel reboot hist Netflix Christmas movies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt golden globes Summer Apple Rom-Com critic resources child's play Spike Action die hard DC Comics Avengers olympics south america name the review gangster Paramount Britbox Awards posters See It Skip It singing competition casting rom-coms TBS Captain marvel Musicals Amazon Studios legend new zealand IMDb TV SundanceTV Cannes hispanic heritage month documentaries toronto Oscar AMC MCU rotten Lifetime comics Acorn TV YouTube Red Hallmark Christmas movies cults 2021 diversity BET Awards CBS FOX CW Seed Freeform Countdown E3 biopic target scene in color scene in color foreign quibi blockbusters The Walking Dead interviews discovery Amazon The Arrangement golden globe awards 73rd Emmy Awards PlayStation hollywood NBA Best Actress anthology Lionsgate superhero Awards Tour james bond BET blockbuster 24 frames blaxploitation finale series Adult Swim sag awards kaiju psychological thriller Schedule crime drama robots Pet Sematary Sony harry potter Fox Searchlight indie game show crime thriller asian-american mockumentary movie Kids & Family venice CNN slasher Hollywood Foreign Press Association E! Disney Plus X-Men Infographic GLAAD slashers 45 nfl live event Amazon Prime politics Native Song of Ice and Fire TV One Pop Brie Larson Disney+ Disney Plus Animation Quiz twilight Film Festival Horror ESPN Tubi Watching Series Hulu Ellie Kemper revenge Hallmark dogs technology chucky Pop TV Warner Bros. book adaptation nbcuniversal Pacific Islander Discovery Channel Wes Anderson spider-verse Black Mirror Star Trek period drama TIFF target Starz cancelled TV series halloween tv godzilla HBO political drama Shondaland dceu high school green book Vudu anime Musical Reality ratings Ghostbusters summer TV preview true crime latino worst movies tv talk children's TV stand-up comedy Universal Pictures joker 21st Century Fox parents vs. CBS All Access 20th Century Fox Best and Worst NBC cancelled live action Stephen King YA Marvel New York Comic Con classics Superheroe Holiday japanese Endgame deadpool genre fresh First Look ID vampires PaleyFest Writers Guild of America Broadway Black History Month South by Southwest Film Festival Rocketman DGA TV movies animated book Country The Academy facebook heist movie action-comedy Trivia ghosts versus Crunchyroll Family Extras Classic Film lord of the rings Oscars The Purge summer preview Walt Disney Pictures dreamworks television cartoon Election Nickelodeon reviews cancelled television comic book movie Comic-Con@Home 2021 BAFTA Heroines Esquire Sundance OneApp documentary zombie adaptation transformers Marathons A24 Paramount Plus hidden camera black sequels Star Wars international WarnerMedia FX Box Office young adult mission: impossible composers Disney streaming service LGBT Tags: Comedy A&E Winners Neflix Tomatazos Arrowverse crossover TCM Chernobyl Crackle Apple TV+ TV Apple TV Plus 2018 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards 90s indiana jones BBC America SDCC pirates of the caribbean Toys comedies trailers TCA what to watch aapi spinoff Alien Sundance TV obi wan doctor who aliens razzies biography Sundance Now MTV critics MGM President comic book movies Spectrum Originals Mary Poppins Returns australia psycho christmas movies cops rt labs Funimation HBO Max space travel dragons based on movie History Fall TV Music 71st Emmy Awards VICE Tarantino unscripted popular Opinion telelvision miniseries Polls and Games medical drama saw Food Network Hear Us Out Creative Arts Emmys ABC Family Geeked Week The Witch serial killer Focus Features Premiere Dates news ViacomCBS comiccon Mindy Kaling fast and furious Pirates 2017 Shudder war docudrama Showtime richard e. Grant TCA Awards elevated horror Super Bowl scary movies Biopics Women's History Month Cartoon Network renewed TV shows