Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Darkness Balances on the Edge of Freshness

Plus, When in Rome gets tossed to the lions.

by | January 28, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an angry detective (Edge of Darkness, starring Mel Gibson and Ray Winstone) and a Roman holiday (When in Rome, starring Kristen Bell and Josh Duhamel). What do the critics have to say?


Edge of Darkness

It’s been nearly a decade since Mel Gibson has played a leading role onscreen. And critics say the reason Edge of Darkness works as well as it does is Gibson’s presence, which elevates the film above a run-of-the-mill revenge thriller. Based upon the 1980s British TV series of the same name (also directed by Martin Campbell, who helms here), Edge stars Gibson as a Boston detective filled with grief after the murder of his daughter. However, as he investigates, he learns her death is part of a larger conspiracy. The pundits say Gibson is in fine form, delivering a world-weary, compelling performance that mostly makes up for the film’s contrivances. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Gibsons’s best-reviewed films.)


When in Rome

When in Rome attempts to meld romantic comedy and fairy tale tropes into a picturesque travelogue. However, critics say this long-delayed would-be confection is hardly worth the trip — it’s a forced and unconvincing attempt at whimsy that falls flat. Kristen Bell stars as Beth, a single gal who finds herself in a sticky situation: after removing coins from a “fountain of love” in the Eternal City, she’s followed back to New York by a string of obsessed suitors. The pundits say When in Rome is leaden, generic, and occasionally creepy, wasting an excellent cast (including Will Arnett, Anjelica Huston, and Danny DeVito) on a largely laugh-free script.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • North Face, a historical drama about a pair of climbers attempting to conquer a perilous peak in the Swiss Alps, is at 89 percent.

  • Off and Running, documentary about a college track prospect grappling with her unconventional family life, is at 80 percent.

  • The Israeli import For My Father, a drama about a suicide bomber who finds himself living among his purported targets, is at 50 percent.
  • Saint John of Las Vegas, starring Steve Buscemi in a dramedy about a recovering compulsive gambler drawn back to Vegas, is at seven percent.

Finally, we’d like to send a big “EEYEAHH” to King Crunk (WHAT?!) for successfully guessing Legion‘s 17 percent Tomatometer. (OKAY!)

Tag Cloud

prank 94th Oscars Logo book Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 24 frames crossover Marathons football HBO Max HFPA twilight Fox Searchlight mcc Tomatazos reboot nbcuniversal children's TV Lifetime aapi CW Seed Tubi universal monsters new star wars movies strong female leads marvel comics know your critic Esquire venice women The CW MCU Thanksgiving sequels APB Syfy The Walt Disney Company Election dragons movies criterion Spectrum Originals cinemax Mudbound Box Office Pop blaxploitation theme song YouTube Red Shudder Video Games Grammys Hallmark Christmas movies festival Tumblr toy story Polls and Games Marvel Television independent Oscar child's play Certified Fresh halloween Martial Arts young adult Turner Pacific Islander scene in color series Horror anime Wes Anderson Comedy new york transformers golden globes rom-coms Reality Competition Sneak Peek YouTube Premium BBC One comics emmy awards true crime 79th Golden Globes Awards Animation rt labs boxing Disney concert Food Network Prime Video Spike Film debate Infographic toronto japan Disney streaming service NBA zombie DC Comics ABC Family Universal TCM Vudu gangster Sundance Now Discovery Channel free movies Britbox kong BET Awards target scene in color dceu Native ratings christmas movies Disney+ Disney Plus Turner Classic Movies live event Captain marvel vs. Disney Plus Mary poppins IFC leaderboard Trivia Photos marvel cinematic universe canceled Superheroe E3 Pride Month Comics on TV finale cancelled TV shows scary Emmy Nominations Nickelodeon Sony FXX SDCC hidden camera 2021 breaking bad Tags: Comedy dexter TNT TCA Awards cancelled TV series new zealand TIFF ViacomCBS rt archives Endgame japanese technology cars mockumentary canceled TV shows disaster renewed TV shows nature TV renewals Apple TV Plus Set visit saw batman Baby Yoda book adaptation DirecTV E! summer TV preview worst Classic Film Showtime Marvel Studios HBO Go revenge DC Universe black comedy Awards Tour festivals teaser Focus Features Writers Guild of America TCA 2017 interviews Adult Swim all-time Hallmark Hulu Premiere Dates Universal Pictures ghosts Warner Bros. based on movie documentaries Song of Ice and Fire screenings hispanic Apple scary movies Star Trek fresh legend target GoT historical drama Binge Guide 71st Emmy Awards Comic Book quibi Holidays CNN thriller 2019 jurassic park cooking directors BET SundanceTV GLAAD justice league best serial killer Disney Channel Best Director Geeked Week Shondaland unscripted Fargo action-comedy joker stand-up comedy The Purge comiccon satire adventure Reality YouTube heist movie Cosplay Tokyo Olympics Spring TV Heroines ITV james bond Legendary comic books Pop TV TCA Winter 2020 spain MGM rotten hollywood sitcom Western Family summer preview RT History Indigenous TLC Netflix Cartoon Network Ovation X-Men razzies sopranos Podcast SXSW art house Women's History Month Paramount Network DGA supernatural Masterpiece Oscars what to watch Musical Dark Horse Comics sag awards WGN screen actors guild crime thriller indiana jones Sci-Fi Fox News politics Quiz Marvel 93rd Oscars witnail comic book movies Biopics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina sports Columbia Pictures pirates of the caribbean Chernobyl Calendar Sundance Summer Awards binge 45 scorecard Emmys USA South by Southwest Film Festival Schedule President crime drama Paramount Pictures video on demand Avengers royal family superman Arrowverse comic book movie A24 olympics reviews live action DC streaming service Musicals science fiction green book Super Bowl police drama Brie Larson Crunchyroll french LGBT archives 2017 FX 007 Exclusive Video ABC Signature 2018 boxoffice American Society of Cinematographers spanish slasher BBC Tarantino facebook casting Travel Channel Pet Sematary doctor who stoner remakes classics Christmas discovery docudrama PlayStation PBS Holiday Star Wars Celebration composers Best Actress Mary Poppins Returns posters Paramount TV Land 90s mutant spinoff Peacock Year in Review political drama AMC harry potter adaptation CMT RT21 CBS Black History Month Starz zero dark thirty Comedy Central war a nightmare on elm street Anna Paquin richard e. Grant indie period drama FOX south america video Countdown 99% Amazon Sony Pictures miniseries Fall TV foreign VICE singing competition deadpool series AMC Plus Instagram Live Broadway First Look Rock TV movies Lionsgate zombies Trailer Fantasy dark Pixar Freeform Netflix Christmas movies romance Character Guide animated feel good Toys PaleyFest basketball MTV El Rey YA superhero 1990s Nat Geo Mary Tyler Moore Bravo Image Comics blockbusters VH1 spider-man Trophy Talk Stephen King comedies MSNBC fast and furious rotten movies we love movie critics cancelled television HBO hispanic heritage month aliens high school trophy The Witch Winter TV summer TV Epix tv talk dreamworks asian-american king arthur Nominations news The Academy Superheroes obituary adenture rt labs critics edition Hear Us Out spider-verse genre latino 4/20 Film Festival elevated horror Acorn TV slashers spanish language halloween tv parents The Arrangement kaiju National Geographic psychological thriller Amazon Prime Country name the review LGBTQ Winners obi wan Interview 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards NBC anthology stop motion king kong CBS All Access blockbuster Best Actor Lifetime Christmas movies werewolf BAFTA popular lord of the rings OneApp Mystery streamig TCA 20th Century Fox films game of thrones cops Rom-Com hist mob scene in color film series Star Wars Cannes Valentine's Day worst movies FX on Hulu suspense laika Sundance TV Red Carpet game show ESPN streaming movies Academy Awards First Reviews award winner Teen telelvision docuseries Black Mirror Lucasfilm 72 Emmy Awards nfl ID diversity cats Pirates BBC America See It Skip It TV Amazon Prime Video USA Network Ghostbusters Walt Disney Pictures medical drama IFC Films Best and Worst San Diego Comic-Con golden globe awards New York Comic Con Creative Arts Emmys robots cancelled NYCC ABC Ellie Kemper biography A&E 21st Century Fox trailers godzilla The Walking Dead Extras documentary travel natural history broadcast 2020 die hard Rocketman Alien romantic comedy TBS crime Funimation space dogs TV One psycho Watching Series Action OWN History Music international australia italian vampires chucky VOD social media Apple TV+ Amazon Studios comic IMDb TV biopic black SXSW 2022 2015 Neflix dc spy thriller Drama 73rd Emmy Awards versus Comic-Con@Home 2021 Mindy Kaling Elton John dramedy WarnerMedia Opinion Kids & Family television kids Best Picture streaming critic resources franchise mission: impossible Paramount Plus sequel 2016 jamie lee curtis TruTV cartoon Crackle Rocky Hollywood Foreign Press Association GIFs monster movies wonder woman cults Television Critics Association Television Academy talk show scene in color