Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Dark Shadows Doesn't Scare Up Enough Laughs

Plus, I Wish is graceful and touching, and God Bless America is a wild black comedy.

by | May 10, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, Tim Burton and Johnny Depp reteam to spoof the 1970s horror soap opera Dark Shadows, with help from Helena Bonham Carter, Eva Green, and Chloë Grace Moretz. What do the critics have to say?

Dark Shadows


Tim Burton and Johnny Depp have made plenty of witty, macabre pictures together. Unfortunately, critics say their latest, Dark Shadows, lacks their particular brand of black magic — despite moments of oddball inventiveness, the film suffers from jarring tonal shifts that prevent the story from resonating. Based on the 1970s soap opera, Dark Shadows stars Depp as Barnabas, a wealthy 18th century playboy who becomes a vampire after breaking a witch’s heart. After a long slumber, Barnabas awakes to find himself in the 1970s — and in the center of the squabbling family that now occupies his old mansion. The pundits say Dark Shadows looks fantastic, and Depp is enjoyable as always, but the movie never finds a consistent rhythm, mixing campy jokes and gothic spookiness with considerably less success than earlier Burton/Depp collaborations. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Depp’s best-reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Portrait of Wally, a documentary about the legal battle over a painting by the great Egon Schiele, is at 100 percent.
  • Sleepless Night, a French thriller about a dirty cop involved in a botched heist, is at 100 percent.
  • Under African Skies, a doc about a reunion between Paul Simon and Ladysmith Black Mambazo for the 25th anniversary of their Graceland collaboration, is at 100 percent.
  • You Are Here, a sci-fi drama about a woman who collects documents and recordings of a secret parallel world, is at 100 percent.
  • The Chilean import Bonsái, a dramedy about a struggling writer looking for inspiration for his autobiographical novel, is at 93 percent.
  • Patience (After Sebald), a cinematic essay on the work of writer W.G. Sebald, is at 93 percent.
  • Nobody Else But You, an offbeat mystery about the investigation into the death of a Marilyn Monroe lookalike, is at 88 percent.
  • Hirokazu Koreeda‘s I Wish, aa drama about a boy who hopes for a miracle to reunite his divorced parents, is at 87 percent.
  • A Bag of Hammers, starring Jason Ritter and Rebecca Hall in a dramedy about a pair of con men who reconsider their ways when they mentor a 12-year-old boy, is at 67 percent.
  • The Road, a horror movie about the discovery of terrifying secrets in the search for missing teens, is at 67 percent.
  • God Bless America, a black comedy about a terminally ill man who reacts violently to what he sees as the stupidity of contemporary culture, is at 62 percent (check out director Bobcat Goldthwait’s Five Favorite Films here).
  • Small, Beautifully Moving Parts, a dramedy about a pregnant woman who makes an impulsive road trip to visit her estranged mother, is at 50 percent.
  • Where Do We Go Now?, a comedy about a Lebanese town divided along religious and gender lines, is at 47 percent.
  • Transit, starring Jim Caviezel in a thriller about a family on the run from ruthless killers after stumbling upon a stash of money, is at 43 percent.
  • Girl In Progress, starring Eva Mendes and Matthew Modine in a dramedy about a teenager who attempts to stake out a life independent from her preoccupied mother, is at 35 percent.
  • Tonight You’re Mine, a romantic comedy about two young rockers who are accidentally handcuffed to each other, is at 33 percent.
  • The Cup, starring Brendan Gleeson in a drama about a jockey overcoming adversity with the help of a veteran horse trainer, is at 29 percent.
  • Hick, starring Chloë Grace Moretz and Blake Lively in a drama about a pair of young hitchhikers who run into trouble on the open road, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

DC streaming service Lifetime Britbox psycho hispanic heritage month films cats legend toronto independent Brie Larson Crunchyroll TruTV venice Mystery 21st Century Fox classics Cannes FXX kids nature worst new zealand E! documentaries richard e. Grant franchise Lifetime Christmas movies President cooking 73rd Emmy Awards NBC screenings Comedy See It Skip It SDCC romantic comedy Logo Comedy Central theme song Holiday Apple TV Plus 2018 First Reviews MTV Mindy Kaling Pop green book discovery Pop TV Fox News Endgame Awards unscripted batman crossover black comedy finale BAFTA war criterion Grammys police drama spy thriller suspense ID twilight Awards Tour boxoffice james bond sopranos revenge comics olympics Pirates historical drama indiana jones period drama australia BBC America OneApp south america Fall TV sequels mutant 2015 Tubi MCU feel good 99% Epix directors free movies PBS Broadway FX on Hulu ABC comedies parents prank CBS All Access Winter TV foreign stoner Arrowverse The CW TLC Film Discovery Channel TV Land First Look cinemax Cosplay Instagram Live Turner Bravo mob canceled GLAAD 72 Emmy Awards Paramount Plus RT History TV movies dc strong female leads king arthur concert laika 007 Freeform Lionsgate Teen Action black Chernobyl 93rd Oscars action-comedy debate hist scary sitcom docudrama Opinion FOX Christmas Toys Trailer 2019 4/20 new star wars movies cancelled TV series book hollywood Esquire Black Mirror Western obituary Binge Guide Tarantino Creative Arts Emmys 2017 Amazon Prime Video Polls and Games Country anthology CW Seed psychological thriller stop motion thriller Funimation diversity 20th Century Fox reboot 1990s television best series Video Games Marvel Studios sag awards christmas movies A24 Music young adult Sony Pictures 79th Golden Globes Awards toy story YouTube Premium Star Trek ESPN Superheroe reviews Ovation Netflix elevated horror italian Quiz WGN Tomatazos canceled TV shows Columbia Pictures dceu Warner Bros. Film Festival Acorn TV Cartoon Network zombies Shondaland X-Men dogs TCA 2017 Starz golden globes composers razzies HFPA Thanksgiving 24 frames CBS zero dark thirty teaser name the review IFC Films serial killer telelvision Disney streaming service The Purge mcc vs. Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt ITV Song of Ice and Fire book adaptation MSNBC festivals comic book movie jamie lee curtis fresh aapi jurassic park Heroines YA crime thriller spanish language comiccon TV renewals blockbuster VOD TIFF Mudbound cancelled TV shows Valentine's Day AMC Plus Vudu Prime Video Peacock Marvel Television NBA blaxploitation New York Comic Con Schedule TCA Awards medical drama facebook art house game of thrones hidden camera GIFs TV One spanish justice league APB transformers blockbusters Rocketman Photos Marvel Watching Series vampires documentary Spike dark leaderboard The Arrangement HBO Max NYCC 2020 The Walt Disney Company Best and Worst space ratings E3 science fiction zombie ViacomCBS remakes BBC Countdown asian-american Interview The Academy El Rey godzilla know your critic Sneak Peek true crime Tumblr BBC One versus IFC target nfl nbcuniversal Black History Month halloween tv spider-verse Star Wars Apple mission: impossible Television Critics Association comic books Premiere Dates trophy french Women's History Month travel latino marvel comics worst movies PlayStation Amazon Prime LGBTQ romance Mary Tyler Moore monster movies Nickelodeon singing competition 2016 halloween Syfy scene in color live action Adult Swim talk show Paramount Network Kids & Family a nightmare on elm street Reality chucky popular Turner Classic Movies ABC Family scary movies BET Awards superman scorecard Travel Channel biography ABC Signature universal monsters high school casting Martial Arts San Diego Comic-Con indie witnail Red Carpet satire video boxing BET Marathons sequel screen actors guild 45 slasher Fox Searchlight 2021 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina pirates of the caribbean streaming AMC slashers Spring TV Character Guide VH1 Musicals Pride Month Television Academy Animation doctor who cars Baby Yoda spider-man FX VICE Extras miniseries cops Mary poppins Hear Us Out cancelled Fargo PaleyFest American Society of Cinematographers LGBT TV Anna Paquin critics Disney Hallmark Christmas movies all-time Stephen King hispanic die hard dreamworks saw renewed TV shows Amazon Studios Rocky Pacific Islander kaiju Set visit Year in Review The Witch Infographic HBO gangster Summer Food Network Shudder 71st Emmy Awards rt archives supernatural Classic Film TNT Captain marvel Sundance Now cults stand-up comedy crime Trivia rt labs critics edition USA SundanceTV japanese critic resources Alien Sundance Amazon Dark Horse Comics game show video on demand lord of the rings movies Image Comics streaming movies Netflix Christmas movies TCM Disney+ Disney Plus Musical golden globe awards TCA Box Office Reality Competition 90s Avengers tv talk aliens dragons Mary Poppins Returns Comic-Con@Home 2021 Universal Pictures Disney Plus RT21 technology women Comic Book Writers Guild of America cartoon Ghostbusters werewolf marvel cinematic universe children's TV Family WarnerMedia Spectrum Originals Hulu Sundance TV A&E disaster Pixar dexter Rock robots king kong live event Horror OWN Tags: Comedy Paramount based on movie Election new york DC Universe adenture TBS YouTube spain Holidays History mockumentary crime drama archives SXSW biopic Legendary Hallmark Calendar Rom-Com social media natural history adventure Sci-Fi Super Bowl wonder woman politics ghosts Disney Channel movie Pet Sematary posters CMT Drama what to watch spinoff football CNN anime Nominations DGA Academy Awards japan deadpool harry potter Biopics USA Network National Geographic Fantasy emmy awards Walt Disney Pictures Masterpiece Ellie Kemper Trophy Talk Crackle Superheroes Elton John binge rt labs Emmys Universal kong news TCA Winter 2020 cancelled television animated Exclusive Video DirecTV 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Hollywood Foreign Press Association Podcast superhero YouTube Red heist movie Certified Fresh Nat Geo breaking bad fast and furious Oscars royal family festival Winners quibi comic book movies basketball joker HBO Go DC Comics IMDb TV Neflix Wes Anderson award winner trailers international rotten sports comic adaptation Emmy Nominations dramedy Showtime docuseries rotten movies we love child's play political drama rom-coms The Walking Dead Apple TV+ GoT genre Lucasfilm Comics on TV Tokyo Olympics