Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Conan the Barbarian is a Bloody Mess

Plus, Fright Night scares up some laughs and chills, but Spy Kids and One Day strike out.

by | August 19, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a heroic strongman (Conan the Barbarian, starring Jason Momoa and Rachel Nichols), pint-sized agents (Spy Kids: All the Time in the World in 4D, starring Jessica Alba and Joel McHale), scary neighbors (Fright Night, starring Anton Yelchin and Colin Farrell), and part-time lovers (One Day, starring Anne Hathaway and Jim Sturgess). What do the critics have to say?

Conan the Barbarian


The 1982 Conan the Barbarian became a seminal entry in the sword-and-sorcery subgenre, maiking Arnold Schwarzenegger a star in the process. And although critics say Jason Momoa does his best with the title role, this new Conan the Barbarian eschews pulpy swashbuckling for non-stop action, and the result is a numbing barrage of blood, guts, and noise. The titular warrior is out for vengeance against the warlord who killed his family. On the trail of his foe, he encounters the beautiful Tamara (Rachel Nichols), and together, they leave a mountain of dead bodies strewn about the countryside. The pundits say Conan the Barbarian has a decent look and some thrills, but it’s mostly just a brutal, hyperactively-edited gore-fest that barely pauses to develop the characters or the plot. (Check out co-star Rose McGowan’s Five Favorite Films here.)

Spy Kids: All the Time in the World in 4D


Throughout his career, director Robert Rodriguez has led a seemingly incongruous double life: when he’s not making stylistically bold neo-grindhouse films, he’s helming impish adventure tales for the kiddies. Unfortunately, critics say the fourth installment of his venerable Spy Kids franchise, All the Time in the World in 4D, is tired, juvenile stuff that isn’t improved by gimmicky 3D and scratch ‘n’ sniff cards. Jessica Alba stars as retired spy who’s lured back into action when a maniacal super villain threatens the free world. She’s joined in her mission by some newly recruited spy kids. The pundits say Spy Kids 4 is almost entirely bereft of the charm and excitement of the series’ first two entries, with mediocre special effects and an overabundance of sophomoric humor. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Rodriguez’s best-reviewed movies.)

Fright Night


On paper, a remake of Fright Night sounds like an opportunistic attempt to cash in on the current vampire craze — especially since the original, a minor genre classic that deftly (and self-referentially) mixed laughs and scares, still holds up pretty well. However, critics say this new Fright Night is surprisingly effective, thanks to some terrific performances and a solid script that captures — and occasionally expands upon — what worked the first time around. Anton Yelchin stars as Charley, a too-cool-for-school teen who notices that something’s not quite right about Jerry (Colin Farrell), the guy who moved in next door. As it turns out, Jerry’s a vampire who’s preying on the neighborhood, and it’s up to Charley to stop him. The pundits say that while Fright Night doesn’t always match the mischievous appeal of its source material, the script is sharp and clever, and the cast — particularly Farrell, who oozes sly menace — is uniformly excellent.

One Day


The premise of One Day is undeniably intriguing: it’s a romantic dramedy featuring two mismatched would-be lovers whose tentative relationship stretches for decades. Unfortunately, critics say the execution is a bit off; we’re never quite convinced our heroes are meant to be together, and the annual check-in conceit alluded to in the title seems contrived after a while. Anne Hathaway and Jim Sturgess are the couple, who meet at the end of college and are attracted to one another despite class and personality differences. Every subsequent June 15, we get glimpses of their lives, loves, and careers, as the pair maintains a friendship that might someday become something more. The pundits say One Day deserves credit for attempting to upend the traditional structure of the movie romance, and the stars’ repartee is fitfully amusing, but the characters are too ill-defined to make much of an impression.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Summer Pasture, a documentary about the harsh lives of Tibetan nomads, is at 100 percent.
  • The Last Circus, a dramedy about a clown whose life is upended by the rise of Fascism in Spain, is at 92 percent.
  • The Hedgehog, a drama about a morose 12-year-old who befriends the grumpy concierge in her apartment building, is at 83 percent.
  • Mozart’s Sister, a historical drama about the great composer’s talented older sibling, is at 80 percent.
  • Griff the Invisible, a comedy/romance about a shy working stiff who moonlights as a superhero, is at 78 percent.
  • Atrocious, a lo-fi horror film about a family that films its investigation into a terrifying urban legend, is at 67 percent.
  • The Journals Of Musan, a drama about a North Korean defector awkwardly adjusting to his new life in South Korea, is at 60 percent.
  • John Sayles‘s Amigo, a drama about a village torn apart by the Philippine-American War, is at 59 percent.
  • 5 Days Of War, starring Rupert Friend and Emmanuelle Chriqui in a drama about an American reporter caught in the crossfire of the 2008 Georgian conflict with Russia, is at 55 percent.
  • A Horrible Way to Die, an indie thriller about an escaped serial killer who’s looking for his ex-girlfriend, is at 40 percent.
  • Flypaper, starring Patrick Dempsey and Ashley Judd in a crime comedy about a would-be bank robber who develops a bond with a teller, is at 22 percent.
  • Programming The Nation?, a documentary about subliminal messages in politics and advertising, is at 14 percent.

Tag Cloud

Logo live event Esquire Fantasy CMT black Pixar Broadway Masterpiece LGBTQ best Nominations Travel Channel Reality Competition Chernobyl cancelled TV shows Photos strong female leads aliens Sony Pictures The Academy reboot IFC 90s feel good 79th Golden Globes Awards E3 Action concert series Tubi gangster trophy Video Games Countdown DC Universe TIFF zero dark thirty kids cars reviews RT21 WGN Columbia Pictures franchise elevated horror period drama parents Awards political drama Disney children's TV CBS Premiere Dates sports worst medical drama Marvel Television Women's History Month Comic-Con@Home 2021 art house Super Bowl Spectrum Originals Lionsgate hispanic heritage month Certified Fresh politics Disney+ Disney Plus hist Black History Month FX on Hulu Interview Stephen King Star Wars psycho twilight Cannes Tomatazos Comics on TV psychological thriller binge Polls and Games diversity Infographic Heroines Teen BET Trivia MCU The CW remakes stop motion know your critic breaking bad festivals TV renewals facebook Binge Guide Tarantino stand-up comedy 2019 Creative Arts Emmys sequel Rom-Com San Diego Comic-Con romantic comedy Mary poppins cancelled Ghostbusters BAFTA AMC Plus comics TLC TBS ABC blockbuster Character Guide rom-coms Kids & Family Opinion 71st Emmy Awards rotten movies we love Alien doctor who blaxploitation HBO monster movies nfl HBO Go Freeform Baby Yoda Neflix Pirates Paramount Network Shondaland FX basketball 2016 Christmas book police drama 007 Exclusive Video dc vs. ViacomCBS hollywood Election mockumentary Pet Sematary Ovation posters CNN joker social media mob TV movies cooking crime drama Epix ghosts Turner YouTube Red TCA Marvel Studios Endgame young adult Western women SDCC National Geographic Superheroe Pop all-time Thanksgiving SXSW Pop TV comiccon APB MSNBC GoT kaiju Wes Anderson adaptation debate Instagram Live scary australia james bond name the review Pacific Islander mission: impossible Nat Geo dceu marvel cinematic universe game show Emmy Nominations Ellie Kemper Mary Poppins Returns fresh Comedy latino BET Awards new york pirates of the caribbean Podcast The Walking Dead ESPN zombie Nickelodeon nbcuniversal travel sequels comic book movie richard e. Grant renewed TV shows classics Film anime Star Trek green book Writers Guild of America TCA Winter 2020 critics Crunchyroll A&E Set visit canceled TV shows Oscars Horror 45 Hollywood Foreign Press Association Comic Book prank godzilla revenge new zealand GLAAD Rocky Adult Swim WarnerMedia The Walt Disney Company Comedy Central obituary transformers 4/20 docuseries Apple teaser leaderboard slasher Turner Classic Movies Starz genre Emmys deadpool chucky emmy awards spider-man Family Hallmark toy story TCA Awards cinemax Toys Apple TV+ sag awards spanish Spike TV One french rotten serial killer Showtime cats anthology GIFs Amazon indie VOD streaming Anna Paquin Sundance Now based on movie Watching Series PlayStation 72 Emmy Awards FOX worst movies AMC Warner Bros. Disney Plus lord of the rings Netflix Christmas movies Elton John spinoff Martial Arts japanese child's play TNT popular justice league Acorn TV rt labs critics edition versus Television Critics Association cults Cartoon Network TCA 2017 YouTube die hard mcc Pride Month halloween tv VH1 cancelled television NYCC batman BBC satire criterion 1990s Chilling Adventures of Sabrina golden globes Reality HBO Max comic book movies El Rey LGBT Classic Film CBS All Access marvel comics quibi Sci-Fi mutant NBA crossover dark video on demand BBC America PBS king kong dreamworks award winner razzies President Mindy Kaling Arrowverse See It Skip It ITV OWN USA Network adventure History target OneApp Sundance discovery Lifetime The Purge superman dramedy crime thriller MTV Spring TV 2018 singing competition First Look Fargo nature Extras 2020 New York Comic Con ratings TruTV Tokyo Olympics Disney Channel rt archives Trailer Prime Video IMDb TV Song of Ice and Fire Sneak Peek spider-verse American Society of Cinematographers golden globe awards video talk show Musical movie Summer Trophy Talk Winners Sundance TV USA what to watch DGA 21st Century Fox witnail suspense toronto scene in color Awards Tour dogs Best and Worst Musicals Amazon Prime Video BBC One harry potter disaster boxing cops 2017 Vudu The Witch natural history war spy thriller cartoon foreign romance kong 99% news Schedule Grammys true crime comic halloween historical drama adenture independent thriller streaming movies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Shudder zombies Mystery Disney streaming service international YouTube Premium action-comedy television Academy Awards saw comedies Winter TV YA Bravo Netflix italian Marvel Hulu Cosplay south america supernatural spanish language werewolf documentary Amazon Studios Quiz boxoffice Biopics science fiction Universal SundanceTV TV Land composers robots venice Funimation Music archives fast and furious comic books casting Dark Horse Comics 93rd Oscars screenings Lifetime Christmas movies FXX movies indiana jones Britbox slashers a nightmare on elm street telelvision Drama black comedy DC streaming service blockbusters X-Men Tags: Comedy Walt Disney Pictures Calendar DirecTV technology First Reviews Mudbound Hallmark Christmas movies Country Holiday PaleyFest Lucasfilm Avengers Hear Us Out Rocketman DC Comics films festival theme song tv talk space RT History Paramount Plus sitcom critic resources Black Mirror dragons HFPA directors 73rd Emmy Awards free movies 20th Century Fox stoner E! Discovery Channel documentaries Mary Tyler Moore scary movies animated jurassic park Peacock laika Paramount Syfy spain Image Comics Brie Larson new star wars movies Animation Fox Searchlight Legendary canceled aapi NBC screen actors guild Food Network A24 unscripted royal family 2021 japan sopranos Marathons Year in Review Fall TV christmas movies jamie lee curtis Apple TV Plus hispanic Crackle finale 2015 Film Festival TCM 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Red Carpet cancelled TV series ABC Family TV football Rock ABC Signature heist movie docudrama Holidays rt labs The Arrangement crime miniseries biopic trailers olympics CW Seed hidden camera asian-american legend Universal Pictures biography scorecard IFC Films dexter Valentine's Day high school superhero Fox News vampires Captain marvel Superheroes Box Office VICE wonder woman live action Television Academy ID universal monsters game of thrones 24 frames Amazon Prime Tumblr book adaptation king arthur