Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Carrie Won't Replace the Original

Plus, Escape Plan and The Fifth Estate are both uneven.

by | October 17, 2013 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a telekinetic teen (Carrie, starring Chloe Grace Moretz and Julianne Moore); a pair of jail-breakers (Escape Plan, starring Sylvester Stallone and Arnold Schwarzenegger); and a document leaker (The Fifth Estate, starring Benedict Cumberbatch and Daniel Brühl). What do the critics have to say?

Carrie

50%

The original Carrie holds a special place in the hearts of horror buffs, so a remake is inherently fraught with peril. And critics say that while director Kimberly Peirce turns in a respectable effort, there’s little in this new Carrie that feels necessary. Chloe Grace Moretz stars as the title character, a teenage outcast with a demanding mom and telekinetic powers. Will the snobby kids at Carrie’s school learn not to mess with her? The pundits say Carrie is competently made, but does little to distinguish itself from Brian De Palma’s beloved original film. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some memorable horror movie remakes.)

Escape Plan

50%

God bless Sly and Arnie; it’s pretty inspiring to see the 1980s’ two biggest action stars still slugging it out well into their sixties. That said, critics feel Escape Plan isn’t the best vehicle for their talents; despite a few decent thrills, it’s a middling action flick with a flimsy plot and an overall lack of panache. Stallone stars as a security expert who’s been wrongly imprisoned, so he teams up with a fellow inmate (Schwarzenegger) and devises a plan to bust out. The pundits say the stars keep Escape Plan watchable, but they’re ultimately defeated by inert pacing and a by-the-numbers script.

The Fifth Estate

35%

Like The Social Network, The Fifth Estate is a ripped-from-the-headlines drama about how new technology is impacting our lives. Unfortunately, critics say that despite an impressive performance from Benedict Cumberbatch, this dramatic retelling of the WikiLeaks story is ill-prepared to tackle the issues it raises. Julian Assange (Cumberbatch) and hacker Daniel Domscheit-Berg (Daniel Brühl) create a site to publish clandestine information. However, when WikiLeaks scores a series of big scoops that infuriate the powerful, the site’s founders become divided on their mission and motives. The pundits say The Fifth Estate is a mostly skin-deep examination of the ethical questions that Assange raised, one that fails to bring its characters to life, despite the best efforts of a strong cast.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

spinoff mob hist science fiction ABC Signature scene in color film series crime Netflix Christmas movies werewolf archives king kong what to watch Walt Disney Pictures Premiere Dates Apple miniseries Opinion TV renewals Apple TV Plus social media GoT romantic comedy talk show kong razzies New York Comic Con romance serial killer wonder woman summer preview Interview french Video Games book supernatural revenge 4/20 jamie lee curtis Starz SundanceTV OneApp Extras blaxploitation Black History Month cops Lucasfilm Comic-Con@Home 2021 Sony spanish San Diego Comic-Con Classic Film hollywood Britbox Spring TV Rom-Com Elton John Turner Classic Movies remakes PlayStation trailers kids 73rd Emmy Awards TCA Winter 2020 Fox Searchlight obi wan WarnerMedia adventure children's TV sag awards Native SXSW Infographic dramedy movie Acorn TV game of thrones spider-verse Sundance TV FX tv talk trophy toronto blockbusters Holidays zero dark thirty art house pirates of the caribbean deadpool crossover Fox News The Walking Dead nbcuniversal war Best Director cats Chilling Adventures of Sabrina docuseries Watching Series doctor who TV movies Spike Trophy Talk name the review Hollywood Foreign Press Association IFC Films The Arrangement toy story composers ABC Family Character Guide cults broadcast Election Nat Geo criterion new york vampires 2020 game show Neflix adaptation Mystery Logo dreamworks Wes Anderson facebook Drama YA Paramount Pictures black comedy Country scorecard AMC Plus spanish language YouTube Premium Universal YouTube Red series Binge Guide dark vs. BAFTA Marathons TCA Awards target olympics Mary poppins Discovery Channel TV 20th Century Fox Esquire Endgame IMDb TV Emmy Nominations Adult Swim The Academy canceled Disney streaming service Stephen King LGBTQ rt archives popular 1990s 93rd Oscars OWN President psychological thriller ABC golden globe awards CW Seed cancelled TV shows Superheroes cartoon classics Musical 21st Century Fox festivals Paramount Plus The CW Tags: Comedy gangster basketball halloween discovery HBO Indigenous NBA MSNBC 2015 Lionsgate festival Tubi Animation mission: impossible biography new star wars movies spy thriller GLAAD USA TNT Nominations MTV SXSW 2022 Exclusive Video true crime A24 Prime Video dc TruTV TLC target scene in color Tokyo Olympics streaming movies Hulu dceu comic book movie Disney Plus Food Network RT21 slashers The Walt Disney Company Best Actor FX on Hulu natural history zombie ESPN live action rotten Marvel Quiz Horror Set visit leaderboard Comedy Central Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Pacific Islander book adaptation Paramount superman CBS Toys batman medical drama Ovation Netflix Academy Awards Oscar mockumentary nature A&E comic book movies joker political drama godzilla Marvel Studios rom-coms high school Musicals Disney+ Disney Plus Pop TV jurassic park video on demand TBS Pet Sematary blockbuster critics Cartoon Network Kids & Family Amazon Prime halloween tv harry potter BBC America Trivia MCU 2019 Rocketman E3 The Purge Star Trek new zealand Grammys DC Universe aliens Star Wars disaster dragons Broadway richard e. Grant Film Festival docudrama BET die hard politics king arthur Shondaland 2016 movies SDCC worst movies 99% 007 Women's History Month laika reboot unscripted 90s legend Epix WGN genre ITV Fantasy zombies television Bravo Showtime directors Rock E! Crackle singing competition boxing stand-up comedy Emmys Podcast comedies Mary Tyler Moore comic books scene in color royal family summer TV preview Tomatazos cooking See It Skip It streaming Television Academy TV One DirecTV 79th Golden Globes Awards cinemax comics asian-american Sundance Now Photos Pop The Witch Spectrum Originals hidden camera animated Star Wars Celebration Valentine's Day italian finale award winner CBS All Access Shudder 94th Oscars Pixar Ellie Kemper DC streaming service dexter elevated horror VOD cancelled television Television Critics Association versus TV Land lord of the rings feel good Tumblr Thanksgiving Hallmark Christmas movies child's play BET Awards Warner Bros. anthology Captain marvel fast and furious Instagram Live black AMC obituary Brie Larson Amazon Prime Video south america green book Biopics Pirates Best Actress rt labs strong female leads Marvel Television sequels USA Network concert South by Southwest Film Festival El Rey free movies Disney Channel heist movie ViacomCBS Comedy Image Comics Christmas thriller Awards hispanic debate Sony Pictures NYCC 2018 ratings all-time TCA 2017 travel sports Comic Book independent Martial Arts comiccon VICE Vudu sitcom Cosplay crime thriller justice league robots parents Writers Guild of America chucky Awards Tour satire renewed TV shows spain Film Calendar stop motion HFPA Lifetime streamig mcc 2017 telelvision australia Black Mirror Baby Yoda transformers MGM cars Best and Worst international 2021 witnail Disney Action LGBT First Reviews Oscars Western DGA summer TV Fall TV 71st Emmy Awards venice Amazon Studios Travel Channel historical drama stoner Funimation FOX Winter TV period drama slasher Geeked Week First Look action-comedy 45 james bond Hear Us Out Dark Horse Comics news emmy awards Red Carpet canceled TV shows Superheroe Chernobyl japan Fargo Best Picture Cannes a nightmare on elm street quibi National Geographic screenings Legendary worst Reality ID Super Bowl Avengers Peacock CMT cancelled TV series ghosts rt labs critics edition women Schedule American Society of Cinematographers BBC Focus Features binge Syfy football Sneak Peek crime drama YouTube Lifetime Christmas movies based on movie Apple TV+ Tarantino Heroines theme song 72 Emmy Awards TIFF films Arrowverse Winners documentaries critic resources sopranos Holiday marvel cinematic universe Masterpiece latino christmas movies FXX sequel best superhero saw PBS space Teen indiana jones kaiju APB Pride Month biopic Family comic rotten movies we love Amazon hispanic heritage month franchise Comics on TV TCA documentary RT History casting Mudbound nfl adenture dogs fresh Song of Ice and Fire Crunchyroll suspense Hallmark prank Rocky twilight screen actors guild Summer anime Sci-Fi VH1 Turner 24 frames HBO Go DC Comics japanese police drama Reality Competition foreign know your critic PaleyFest Alien universal monsters aapi Ghostbusters Music Nickelodeon CNN live event Trailer marvel comics cancelled Year in Review Certified Fresh posters NBC Mindy Kaling HBO Max BBC One psycho Columbia Pictures Creative Arts Emmys diversity GIFs young adult Paramount Network spider-man teaser History indie X-Men scene in color series Sundance Polls and Games 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards TCM interviews reviews Box Office golden globes breaking bad boxoffice technology mutant scary Countdown video scary movies Mary Poppins Returns monster movies Anna Paquin Freeform Universal Pictures IFC