Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Breaking Dawn Part 1 Doesn't Shine

Plus, Happy Feet Two looks nice but lacks a solid script.

by | November 17, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a vampire wedding (The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part 1, starring Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson), and dancing penguins (Happy Feet Two, with voice work by Elijah Wood and Robin Williams). What do the critics have to say?

The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn Part 1


As the Twilight Saga comes into the home stretch, it looks to go out with a whimper rather than a bang, say critics, who find Breaking Dawn Part 1 to be full of limp pacing and unintentional laughs. In Breaking Dawn Part 1, Bella (Kristen Stewart) and Edward (Robert Pattinson) have gotten hitched, and soon Bella is preggers with a lil’ bloodsucker, a development that fills old flame Jacob (Taylor Lautner) with apprehension. The pundits say Breaking Dawn Part 1 is even more melodramatic than previous installments, with cringe-worthy dialogue and a weird puritanical streak that robs the movie of any sense of swoony fun.

Happy Feet Two


Those jovial aquatic birds are back with Happy Feet Two, though critics say the sequel lacks the easy charm of Happy Feet; instead, it’s nicely animated but also thinly plotted and way too busy. This time out, Mumbles (Elijah Wood) and his two-left-footed son must rescue a group of emperor penguins trapped in an ice floe. The pundits say Happy Feet Two looks terrific, but it’s hampered by a lackluster script and an overabundance of supporting characters. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down co-star Robin Williams’ best-reviewed movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

technology indiana jones Shondaland cats casting cancelled 2019 Mary Poppins Returns DC Universe Pop Turner 2020 Esquire IMDb TV Focus Features BBC children's TV Box Office Nat Geo thriller Dark Horse Comics TCA Awards marvel comics Broadway Binge Guide natural history Tumblr A24 Netflix emmy awards art house popular TCA Winter 2020 Spike Sony 007 Travel Channel Family Amazon Prime toronto Marvel crossover Trivia scary movies Funimation doctor who monster movies strong female leads 21st Century Fox superhero zombies Neflix President Pacific Islander basketball movies PaleyFest series SXSW 2022 latino MGM harry potter 2017 San Diego Comic-Con Prime Video Best Actress CBS Black History Month TCM TruTV A&E spain Ghostbusters Women's History Month comic book movies American Society of Cinematographers golden globe awards National Geographic Paramount Pictures Shudder debate nature live event Musical 90s Emmy Nominations Netflix Christmas movies PlayStation scene in color independent romantic comedy Spring TV RT21 Indigenous binge NBC die hard finale Tags: Comedy cults Wes Anderson First Look E3 Mindy Kaling Television Academy HFPA Columbia Pictures genre Winter TV green book spy thriller king kong japanese Crackle South by Southwest Film Festival Superheroes NBA universal monsters new york Comic-Con@Home 2021 2018 rt archives free movies new zealand comedies El Rey Hulu 72 Emmy Awards Walt Disney Pictures new star wars movies venice Captain marvel Polls and Games Drama superman documentary all-time slashers Best and Worst french Film south america Star Wars Celebration cartoon FOX Television Critics Association Heroines canceled TV shows classics FX Awards Acorn TV Apple TV+ scene in color film series ViacomCBS Rocketman rotten ABC legend Amazon Prime Video telelvision Red Carpet jurassic park RT History Countdown television First Reviews news Hallmark Hallmark Christmas movies reviews japan Warner Bros. cinemax Mystery sopranos Fox Searchlight Trophy Talk Sundance TV best sports Summer 2016 Music Amazon USA football gangster rt labs critics edition heist movie CMT stand-up comedy screenings Comedy Central DirecTV 93rd Oscars Spectrum Originals Extras TNT MSNBC documentaries historical drama hispanic heritage month Schedule Comic Book composers dramedy archives summer TV preview spinoff Video Games mob Nickelodeon The Arrangement what to watch VOD dc foreign 73rd Emmy Awards Election franchise james bond Country LGBTQ festival adaptation TCA Hollywood Foreign Press Association richard e. Grant wonder woman The CW satire video on demand OWN Star Trek Film Festival royal family posters Discovery Channel Showtime Academy Awards remakes crime thriller Epix Native festivals 1990s Trailer Nominations docudrama TV jamie lee curtis Western hidden camera quibi lord of the rings ghosts unscripted dragons dogs adenture obituary Infographic GoT comic books DC streaming service biography BBC America Emmys SDCC NYCC YouTube fresh ABC Signature Stephen King Fargo live action Cannes Exclusive Video Image Comics crime drama Mary poppins Thanksgiving black comedy child's play game show theme song Valentine's Day TV One godzilla cars critic resources cops Geeked Week prank discovery politics Tarantino streamig Paramount The Witch saw Turner Classic Movies Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TV Land comic book movie Calendar WarnerMedia king arthur BET Awards Marvel Television Sci-Fi Opinion kong AMC Plus Year in Review robots Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt a nightmare on elm street name the review based on movie Best Actor psychological thriller singing competition SundanceTV 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards elevated horror Amazon Studios docuseries Winners space fast and furious twilight Endgame zombie MCU travel HBO Go Freeform GIFs ITV spanish language 94th Oscars Action stop motion FXX target scene in color VICE Ellie Kemper OneApp interviews toy story Fall TV YA Chernobyl New York Comic Con revenge summer preview award winner broadcast aapi Apple Vudu Sundance Now rt labs Cosplay Universal Interview Arrowverse Biopics scary E! Pirates batman werewolf razzies Holidays Bravo streaming movies supernatural Best Director indie versus boxoffice Pride Month Kids & Family sitcom spider-verse mission: impossible Legendary 79th Golden Globes Awards Reality Competition 99% parents Mary Tyler Moore Photos GLAAD BBC One TIFF IFC Films justice league blaxploitation Britbox dreamworks Super Bowl black 24 frames CW Seed book Ovation Star Wars CNN canceled ESPN animated dceu transformers 20th Century Fox cancelled television cancelled TV series blockbuster AMC game of thrones kids Logo TV renewals marvel cinematic universe 71st Emmy Awards See It Skip It trophy anthology stoner halloween tv MTV Quiz Podcast YouTube Red Alien boxing Peacock sequels Toys LGBT renewed TV shows Comedy Horror science fiction Pet Sematary obi wan chucky Masterpiece Certified Fresh witnail joker History Rom-Com Brie Larson war know your critic psycho aliens HBO Max 4/20 serial killer Instagram Live biopic Teen Cartoon Network Comics on TV nfl teaser Lucasfilm vs. ratings Lionsgate sag awards Song of Ice and Fire women tv talk Superheroe Pixar worst Starz Disney Sony Pictures action-comedy mcc directors Reality cooking halloween scorecard Baby Yoda criterion Pop TV The Academy blockbusters australia The Walking Dead kaiju spanish italian Anna Paquin anime suspense Food Network IFC Grammys Rocky Disney Channel crime target young adult Fox News reboot Martial Arts WGN Best Picture YouTube Premium period drama disaster Character Guide CBS All Access miniseries worst movies SXSW Adult Swim Mudbound medical drama pirates of the caribbean Universal Pictures critics political drama FX on Hulu X-Men screen actors guild ABC Family The Purge Musicals Animation Syfy HBO Tomatazos BET adventure spider-man vampires TCA 2017 USA Network golden globes films breaking bad rotten movies we love social media DGA PBS Creative Arts Emmys video trailers slasher police drama Tokyo Olympics Premiere Dates olympics Oscars Tubi Awards Tour zero dark thirty hist APB laika Lifetime Crunchyroll comics true crime movie facebook Christmas Paramount Plus Watching Series scene in color series ID Black Mirror dexter Holiday christmas movies asian-american international rom-coms mockumentary diversity TBS talk show Writers Guild of America Paramount Network Hear Us Out sequel DC Comics 2021 Oscar nbcuniversal cancelled TV shows Sneak Peek VH1 Lifetime Christmas movies leaderboard Marvel Studios Avengers hispanic book adaptation TLC Set visit TV movies mutant The Walt Disney Company Disney streaming service Rock comiccon streaming Fantasy Sundance comic feel good hollywood BAFTA Apple TV Plus Marathons concert Disney Plus dark summer TV Disney+ Disney Plus high school Elton John deadpool Classic Film 2015 45 romance