Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Alice Looks Great, Lacks Wonder

Plus, Brooklyn's Finest isn't quite arresting.

by | March 5, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a trip down the rabbit hole (Alice in Wonderland, starring Johnny Depp and Mia Wasilkowska) and a ride-along with the boys in blue (Brooklyn’s Finest, starring Richard Gere and Don Cheadle). What do the critics have to say?


Alice in Wonderland

At first glace, a Tim Burton adaptation of Alice in Wonderland seems perfectly serendipitous: Hollywood’s most playfully macabre filmmaker would be the obvious choice to reinterpret Lewis Carroll’s darkly whimsical tale. However, critics say the result is curiouser – a film of remarkable visual invention that lacks strong plotting or a sense of wonder. Mia Wasilkowska stars as the titular heroine who heads down the rabbit hole, where she encounters such eccentrics as the goofy-but-somewhat-sinister Mad Hatter (Johnny Depp) and the tyrannical Red Queen (Helena Bonham Carter). The pundits say Burton’s taste for phantasmagoric images is intact, but he loses track of the narrative, and the film misses the book’s good humor and sense of wide-eyed awe. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Burton’s best-reviewed films, as well as our feature on composer Danny Elfman’s Five Favorite Films.)


Brooklyn’s Finest

With Training Day, Antoine Fuqua brought fresh, gritty energy to the cop drama. Now he’s back on the mean streets with Brooklyn’s Finest and critics say this one is far less — ahem — arresting. Finest follows three cops (Richard Gere, Don Cheadle, and Ethan Hawke) who, over the course of a particularly hectic week, find their personal and professional lives at wit’s end; will they sacrifice their ethics in the line of duty? The pundits say the movie features fine performances in the service of a shopworn script that borrows liberally from dozens of law enforcement flicks without bringing much new to the table.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

2020 MCU italian Pet Sematary black breaking bad documentaries Freeform nature Masterpiece ABC Family BBC One ID trailers ESPN hollywood RT History Stephen King parents Opinion 007 venice TNT El Rey 45 art house Nominations Paramount Plus TIFF WarnerMedia DirecTV Pride Month rotten movies we love ITV hist scene in color stoner The Academy Captain marvel Wes Anderson DGA stop motion BET live action Amazon comic book movies robots BET Awards Avengers worst movies asian-american Brie Larson Exclusive Video Creative Arts Emmys Turner Classic Movies Hallmark Food Network NYCC international miniseries dogs docuseries YA zero dark thirty Television Academy royal family NBA Peacock dramedy cats halloween blockbusters Election 79th Golden Globes Awards best LGBTQ Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Red Carpet Sony Pictures MSNBC Video Games Amazon Studios Winners high school USA Network Tarantino mcc crime franchise new zealand golden globes OWN Alien indie Elton John Superheroe comic books thriller Mary Tyler Moore YouTube Red Netflix Christmas movies travel TCA zombie medical drama ViacomCBS romance suspense Dark Horse Comics japanese ABC 24 frames Amazon Prime child's play NBC Disney Plus TV One animated lord of the rings target kong Rocketman Action critics Tomatazos Horror leaderboard diversity dceu Vudu Paramount Network Trivia sag awards 2018 Star Wars Marvel Studios Thanksgiving know your critic Best and Worst The Purge witnail 2017 Image Comics razzies Travel Channel elevated horror Emmy Nominations based on movie Reality Competition 2019 PBS heist movie Country game of thrones die hard Rocky superhero Infographic HBO Martial Arts halloween tv TV screenings scary movies french Chilling Adventures of Sabrina YouTube Premium finale TCA Winter 2020 Endgame MTV all-time WGN indiana jones TLC ghosts Sci-Fi toy story toronto USA Turner social media Teen Spring TV war kids First Reviews directors DC Comics The Walking Dead crossover natural history Netflix Paramount Family green book foreign 73rd Emmy Awards American Society of Cinematographers Writers Guild of America 72 Emmy Awards movies zombies Prime Video YouTube Polls and Games series discovery cooking young adult spider-man Mary Poppins Returns comic book movie The Witch Lucasfilm japan movie Awards boxing science fiction chucky christmas movies Countdown posters Classic Film New York Comic Con south america Hear Us Out FX on Hulu richard e. Grant criterion VH1 See It Skip It APB Character Guide dragons X-Men The Walt Disney Company 2016 SDCC popular sopranos festivals nbcuniversal Summer Sundance TV godzilla Crackle 4/20 Apple TV Plus screen actors guild cinemax comic blockbuster cancelled TV series Shudder VOD superman Nat Geo BAFTA Marathons Pirates Awards Tour Lifetime Christmas movies comics FOX TV movies cults Esquire live event mission: impossible hispanic Song of Ice and Fire political drama SundanceTV 93rd Oscars aliens spanish language remakes Toys Fantasy theme song Christmas talk show politics Fox Searchlight anthology television Adult Swim HBO Go universal monsters revenge facebook 71st Emmy Awards Baby Yoda Academy Awards werewolf Super Bowl sports Rock cars Certified Fresh singing competition Spectrum Originals dexter Starz ratings A24 SXSW Anna Paquin E3 Pixar vs. blaxploitation binge Bravo renewed TV shows Walt Disney Pictures Sneak Peek Rom-Com Comedy Set visit nfl disaster video on demand Biopics supernatural GoT sequel FX rt labs Mudbound Interview Lionsgate name the review children's TV GIFs streaming crime drama concert romantic comedy reboot Pop Musical olympics DC Universe Comic Book Funimation festival telelvision Western police drama Marvel Television a nightmare on elm street E! Sundance Now Crunchyroll cancelled television Television Critics Association dark book rt labs critics edition video Ghostbusters films spanish space Kids & Family spy thriller women comedies reviews Winter TV mockumentary VICE critic resources Binge Guide 2015 boxoffice trophy IMDb TV Arrowverse AMC Superheroes Pop TV Cartoon Network Sundance Mary poppins action-comedy Photos free movies what to watch emmy awards slashers TruTV BBC debate slasher scary aapi Shondaland Heroines Lifetime james bond adenture Drama twilight ABC Signature A&E Apple book adaptation Warner Bros. Music Britbox 99% mob independent Mindy Kaling Animation GLAAD 2021 news composers Amazon Prime Video FXX new york crime thriller The CW legend Universal Pictures cancelled TV shows Schedule jurassic park cartoon OneApp biopic Fargo Marvel feel good dreamworks Universal TCM adaptation CNN anime Pacific Islander 21st Century Fox Acorn TV BBC America Hulu TBS deadpool Mystery Disney Trailer cancelled Holidays prank Instagram Live mutant Fall TV President award winner Musicals Tags: Comedy Discovery Channel fast and furious Oscars Disney+ Disney Plus gangster Hallmark Christmas movies Box Office basketball quibi genre Year in Review Extras satire joker PlayStation Black Mirror docudrama strong female leads Spike cops transformers Calendar latino kaiju hispanic heritage month Nickelodeon PaleyFest TV renewals monster movies Hollywood Foreign Press Association Cannes CBS First Look RT21 rom-coms saw DC streaming service rotten jamie lee curtis Valentine's Day The Arrangement football golden globe awards adventure Neflix worst comiccon Holiday biography laika Broadway 1990s Women's History Month Black History Month canceled TV shows archives Ellie Kemper LGBT marvel cinematic universe Trophy Talk Tubi sequels Star Trek Syfy Cosplay serial killer casting sitcom IFC Films Chernobyl CMT tv talk Watching Series vampires batman period drama CW Seed teaser 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Quiz king arthur National Geographic IFC scorecard Apple TV+ Reality Premiere Dates obituary Disney Channel Grammys technology australia versus marvel comics 20th Century Fox Emmys spider-verse spain Comic-Con@Home 2021 pirates of the caribbean TCA 2017 Comics on TV Podcast AMC Plus Fox News king kong Legendary harry potter canceled hidden camera HBO Max new star wars movies Film Film Festival psychological thriller TV Land Tokyo Olympics unscripted 90s wonder woman justice league psycho San Diego Comic-Con classics Logo Ovation true crime game show TCA Awards Columbia Pictures streaming movies doctor who fresh historical drama History dc rt archives CBS All Access Showtime stand-up comedy Epix HFPA Disney streaming service Tumblr documentary Comedy Central black comedy spinoff