Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Alice Looks Great, Lacks Wonder

Plus, Brooklyn's Finest isn't quite arresting.

by | March 5, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a trip down the rabbit hole (Alice in Wonderland, starring Johnny Depp and Mia Wasilkowska) and a ride-along with the boys in blue (Brooklyn’s Finest, starring Richard Gere and Don Cheadle). What do the critics have to say?


Alice in Wonderland

At first glace, a Tim Burton adaptation of Alice in Wonderland seems perfectly serendipitous: Hollywood’s most playfully macabre filmmaker would be the obvious choice to reinterpret Lewis Carroll’s darkly whimsical tale. However, critics say the result is curiouser – a film of remarkable visual invention that lacks strong plotting or a sense of wonder. Mia Wasilkowska stars as the titular heroine who heads down the rabbit hole, where she encounters such eccentrics as the goofy-but-somewhat-sinister Mad Hatter (Johnny Depp) and the tyrannical Red Queen (Helena Bonham Carter). The pundits say Burton’s taste for phantasmagoric images is intact, but he loses track of the narrative, and the film misses the book’s good humor and sense of wide-eyed awe. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Burton’s best-reviewed films, as well as our feature on composer Danny Elfman’s Five Favorite Films.)


Brooklyn’s Finest

With Training Day, Antoine Fuqua brought fresh, gritty energy to the cop drama. Now he’s back on the mean streets with Brooklyn’s Finest and critics say this one is far less — ahem — arresting. Finest follows three cops (Richard Gere, Don Cheadle, and Ethan Hawke) who, over the course of a particularly hectic week, find their personal and professional lives at wit’s end; will they sacrifice their ethics in the line of duty? The pundits say the movie features fine performances in the service of a shopworn script that borrows liberally from dozens of law enforcement flicks without bringing much new to the table.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

E3 international LGBTQ E! harry potter Arrowverse Super Bowl Trailer TCA Winter 2020 binge Bravo Photos Fantasy spider-man Tarantino Discovery Channel technology aliens movies war Polls and Games dragons scary TCA Awards festivals scene in color discovery fresh royal family trailers NYCC RT21 Cosplay The Walking Dead Watching Series justice league Funimation french cancelled TV shows composers YouTube Red cars FX laika Sony miniseries gangster Film Festival king arthur PBS Britbox video Song of Ice and Fire summer preview genre Legendary marvel comics summer TV franchise deadpool Oscar nbcuniversal Paramount Network Tomatazos joker streaming movies Toys DC Comics target Comedy Central Elton John Sci-Fi singing competition Pixar blaxploitation Classic Film MSNBC YouTube The Academy critics Crackle mutant green book indiana jones Wes Anderson comic book movie New York Comic Con critic resources remakes Writers Guild of America foreign YA TruTV screen actors guild Mindy Kaling Netflix Christmas movies 93rd Oscars Western docudrama diversity renewed TV shows streamig Superheroe reviews Vudu comic books elevated horror Prime Video Syfy toy story saw Ghostbusters disaster DC streaming service ghosts science fiction Mudbound Cartoon Network rt labs critics edition feel good italian First Reviews sag awards streaming sequels emmy awards best south america PaleyFest archives Martial Arts what to watch book adaptation video on demand zero dark thirty vampires Comedy Adult Swim Star Wars Celebration BBC jamie lee curtis book HBO hollywood crime high school Sony Pictures ABC Signature Marathons Summer TV movies cops hispanic heritage month Drama scene in color film series basketball Holiday movie obituary anthology football Captain marvel El Rey VICE Anna Paquin biopic Hollywood Foreign Press Association finale CBS All Access slasher Tokyo Olympics james bond 2016 Heroines A24 Disney Channel dark 94th Oscars romantic comedy AMC SXSW OWN Star Wars independent CW Seed Logo GLAAD 2018 comic book movies Apple TV+ christmas movies DirecTV documentaries comiccon Reality 45 TLC Tubi docuseries 99% Starz CMT japanese Focus Features Reality Competition Chernobyl Emmy Nominations Black History Month interviews crime drama game of thrones politics crossover stoner Sundance TV FOX Turner parents screenings ABC Family series Alien mission: impossible mcc Tags: Comedy First Look Spring TV Trivia Election ID Comics on TV Geeked Week Nat Geo witnail blockbusters Walt Disney Pictures Musical comic transformers Music IFC Films robots Creative Arts Emmys Lifetime pirates of the caribbean spanish language golden globes OneApp Marvel Studios Extras Marvel RT History hispanic Masterpiece teaser dreamworks breaking bad new york TCM Christmas quibi Neflix political drama Shondaland YouTube Premium BBC America canceled TV shows National Geographic biography Quiz true crime BBC One Family Musicals facebook television die hard festival APB 79th Golden Globes Awards Columbia Pictures legend dogs Countdown Travel Channel women Universal adventure A&E stand-up comedy Rom-Com Oscars award winner Mystery all-time BET Awards nature twilight Podcast Kids & Family Peacock Best Picture sopranos USA Network classics rotten movies we love obi wan ratings Calendar 2017 talk show Pop Emmys Fall TV Freeform Pacific Islander mockumentary Best Director children's TV History IFC President kaiju Spike 20th Century Fox documentary Ovation target scene in color strong female leads superhero animated The Witch know your critic Best Actress South by Southwest Film Festival Amazon Studios Netflix leaderboard Paramount Plus a nightmare on elm street Dark Horse Comics kong young adult boxoffice Exclusive Video universal monsters Biopics slashers Sundance TV debate olympics HBO Go Disney TV One Stephen King black Fox News serial killer VH1 Horror 73rd Emmy Awards Apple TV Plus sports popular Brie Larson scorecard worst movies boxing unscripted SXSW 2022 jurassic park Pop TV australia Grammys reboot DGA sequel CBS Rocketman The Walt Disney Company period drama The Arrangement Hear Us Out broadcast posters TIFF criterion NBC wonder woman Box Office Infographic Best Actor name the review casting Tumblr Character Guide king kong Hallmark Christmas movies HBO Max rotten Winners Disney Plus 21st Century Fox TNT halloween tv psycho BET Year in Review Lionsgate Women's History Month Animation Winter TV DC Universe Rock Set visit 4/20 24 frames 2020 Crunchyroll TV Land asian-american cartoon Best and Worst SDCC rt archives worst Mary Tyler Moore See It Skip It spain space cancelled TV series MCU cancelled television Image Comics Spectrum Originals comics satire telelvision Opinion trophy marvel cinematic universe 72 Emmy Awards Mary Poppins Returns Valentine's Day BAFTA medical drama Pride Month Turner Classic Movies Teen doctor who FX on Hulu action-comedy live action WarnerMedia 2019 hidden camera Amazon rt labs Paramount Pictures Television Critics Association Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Apple FXX Film Showtime adenture cinemax Avengers scene in color series theme song PlayStation cancelled Lucasfilm Mary poppins chucky monster movies spy thriller live event Awards WGN Black Mirror Binge Guide superman Television Academy spanish Superheroes Esquire TBS Pet Sematary Awards Tour Academy Awards indie new star wars movies zombies TCA 2017 black comedy heist movie HFPA AMC Plus Thanksgiving Hulu travel social media American Society of Cinematographers razzies TV renewals Interview spider-verse game show Trophy Talk tv talk cults Instagram Live comedies toronto Endgame IMDb TV Lifetime Christmas movies Rocky romance dexter suspense ViacomCBS Fargo USA Chilling Adventures of Sabrina kids summer TV preview MTV art house japan Ellie Kemper based on movie Sneak Peek Nominations Shudder anime cooking San Diego Comic-Con Disney+ Disney Plus fast and furious dc SundanceTV Baby Yoda blockbuster concert Acorn TV Cannes natural history 007 Video Games Country latino Premiere Dates Amazon Prime adaptation The Purge crime thriller Comic Book sitcom lord of the rings batman halloween supernatural police drama child's play 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards CNN GIFs Certified Fresh films VOD Star Trek Disney streaming service stop motion Pirates ABC LGBT Warner Bros. free movies new zealand ITV Universal Pictures MGM 90s historical drama rom-coms ESPN godzilla 71st Emmy Awards Amazon Prime Video Sundance Now scary movies Broadway werewolf prank Hallmark dceu The CW nfl psychological thriller Marvel Television revenge hist cats Schedule canceled aapi vs. Food Network TCA Nickelodeon Epix thriller golden globe awards NBA GoT Paramount venice Comic-Con@Home 2021 X-Men Red Carpet Fox Searchlight news zombie 2015 1990s directors dramedy mob Action Native 2021 richard e. Grant Holidays spinoff versus Indigenous