Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: A Christmas Carol Dazzles But Disappoints

Plus, The Box is a mixed bag, The Fourth Kind is lost in space, and Goats is worth a look.

by | November 5, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got some modern-day Dickens (Disney’s A Christmas Carol, starring Jim Carrey and Gary Oldman); a button-pushing thriller (The Box, starring Cameron Diaz and James Marsden); vanishing Alaskans (The Fourth Kind, starring Milla Jovovich and Elias Koteas); and some psychic soldiers (The Men Who Stare at Goats, starring George Clooney and Jeff Bridges). What do the critics have to say?


Disney’s A Christmas Carol

Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol is one of literature’s most haunting morality tales — and one of the most adapted. Critics are largely split on two key aspects of Robert Zemeckis’ motion-capture version starring Jim Carrey: whether it honors the, ahem, spirit of Dickens’ classic, and whether the motion-capture technology is aesthetically appealing. No need to rehash the plot; if you’ve never heard the tale of mean ol’ Ebenezer Scrooge (Carrey) and his long-suffering employee Bob Cratchit (Gary Oldman), get thee to a library immediately. While some find Zemeckis’ live action/animation hybrid an echanting way of updating a seasonal classic, others feel the visuals bog down the classic tale with an overabundance of empty action.


The Box

Richard Kelly has only made three films, but he’s had a roller-coaster of a career. His debut was the cult-fave Donnie Darko, which was followed by the ambitious but roundly-panned Southland Tales. Now comes his latest mind twister The Box, which is splitting critics; some say it’s an intriguing head trip, while others say it’s preposterous and inconsistent. Cameron Diaz and James Marsden play a married couple presented with a mysterious proposition from a stranger: there’s a button in a box, and if they push it, they will receive a million dollars, but someone will die. Some pundits say The Box is tense, edgy, and original, while others deride its plot holes and lack of overall cohesion. (Check out Kelly’s Five Favorite Films here.)


The Fourth Kind

With its combination of a government conspiracy, extraterrestrial visitors, and the foreboding climes of Alaska, The Fourth Kind seemingly has all the elements in place for a gripping horror flick. Too bad the execution’s so clumsy, critics say. Milla Jovovich stars as a shrink whose patients all tell her similar tales of nighttime frights; could aliens be to blame? The pundits say The Fourth Kind has some decent shocks, but its gimmicky presentation — a split screen technique in which patients describe their experiences alongside pseudo-documentary footage of the events — doesn’t quite come off, and the performances are uneven.


The Men Who Stare at Goats

For the most part, the recent wave of Iraq war films has brought downbeat dramas, so the satirical aim of The Men Who Stare at Goats is certainly welcome. And critics say that the film, though scattershot, has moments of brilliant absurdist humor. Hinting that its story is not terribly far from the truth, Goats is the tale of a secret military program that involves the use of psychics who attempt to use their mind power to defeat the enemy. The pundits say the film is elevated by the deadpan comic presence of George Clooney, and if the film never fully comes together, many of its scenes are sharp and funny. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down Clooney’s best-reviewed films.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

television Fox News Star Wars Celebration space Reality Crackle new york jurassic park nbcuniversal 2017 independent critic resources Emmy Nominations BBC One book Hear Us Out indiana jones Super Bowl Apple TV Plus spider-verse Peacock Awards Best Actress Netflix Christmas movies HBO Max Sundance vs. GoT Instagram Live 20th Century Fox APB pirates of the caribbean unscripted X-Men Cannes Tomatazos Wes Anderson broadcast Disney streaming service comiccon Lionsgate quibi black casting free movies binge razzies Year in Review travel Rom-Com USA Music disaster crime drama fresh Pop crime thriller DC streaming service Freeform AMC target scene in color DC Comics Oscar children's TV scorecard Paramount Plus know your critic posters superman MSNBC leaderboard Mudbound Star Wars San Diego Comic-Con 90s italian critics AMC Plus art house BBC Anna Paquin Image Comics NBA harry potter TruTV IFC summer TV preview Photos Musical Dark Horse Comics Comedy ratings Election Universal Pictures TV Premiere Dates dogs Pacific Islander Reality Competition Broadway franchise target Baby Yoda CBS ABC Signature biopic Black History Month Marathons comic books El Rey TIFF diversity genre classics BAFTA justice league Spring TV Best Actor kids TNT National Geographic action-comedy romance Lucasfilm cats obi wan king arthur Family renewed TV shows Holidays Video Games concert IMDb TV child's play chucky docuseries VICE mockumentary Winter TV debate boxing black comedy richard e. Grant serial killer LGBT Stephen King scene in color series Arrowverse Marvel Television Nominations romantic comedy aliens Song of Ice and Fire thriller CNN rt labs A&E composers satire cancelled TV shows kong series Neflix Crunchyroll Trailer 79th Golden Globes Awards PlayStation live event mob award winner sopranos New York Comic Con WGN 1990s movie dark MGM saw Rock trophy Rocky FX on Hulu sequel Warner Bros. Fall TV universal monsters Pop TV witnail versus PBS The Arrangement TCM VOD rom-coms The CW NBC Holiday marvel comics 24 frames YouTube Red Discovery Channel true crime adaptation 4/20 news rt archives mission: impossible PaleyFest adenture hollywood screenings Opinion Amazon Studios heist movie Television Critics Association Mystery GIFs ABC book adaptation TCA marvel cinematic universe The Walking Dead anime football cancelled TV series mutant Britbox DGA The Witch natural history dc dexter TBS Brie Larson Heroines 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards tv talk Hollywood Foreign Press Association Creative Arts Emmys psychological thriller Avengers Columbia Pictures Comic-Con@Home 2021 name the review lord of the rings docudrama sag awards Mindy Kaling historical drama A24 Disney Hallmark Christmas movies slashers zero dark thirty comics Endgame CMT legend Apple TV+ Grammys police drama remakes VH1 TCA Awards live action Native Film 007 reboot transformers BET Awards Martial Arts Animation OWN Countdown discovery Sony Pictures Red Carpet Pet Sematary Turner dragons supernatural Chernobyl video ghosts Focus Features spider-man WarnerMedia dreamworks game of thrones based on movie Exclusive Video Film Festival Geeked Week Tokyo Olympics Set visit BBC America strong female leads festivals scene in color film series 99% canceled TV shows Fargo cancelled television Marvel Oscars HBO Go YouTube Premium Country emmy awards golden globe awards interviews olympics venice Writers Guild of America new star wars movies animated indie Best Director Mary Poppins Returns Sneak Peek rotten christmas movies Binge Guide stand-up comedy jamie lee curtis documentary Vudu all-time war Podcast Universal miniseries The Academy batman feel good blaxploitation Box Office social media Best Picture deadpool scary halloween tv archives 2021 japanese Emmys Pirates Tags: Comedy vampires criterion Women's History Month rt labs critics edition cults comic LGBTQ cartoon Mary Tyler Moore 2015 Interview 2016 Mary poppins worst movies 2020 reviews popular MCU Summer australia political drama facebook President spinoff wonder woman Drama The Walt Disney Company king kong Shudder Nickelodeon Trivia MTV biography Starz talk show First Look cooking Turner Classic Movies Esquire CW Seed Disney Plus directors green book Kids & Family Thanksgiving Captain marvel toronto revenge psycho Quiz 94th Oscars aapi 45 Awards Tour RT History a nightmare on elm street Rocketman worst Calendar anthology nature high school Showtime E3 Teen History GLAAD superhero technology Comics on TV cops spy thriller Horror best Legendary die hard foreign stoner werewolf period drama Schedule Acorn TV Ghostbusters hispanic cars suspense spain Superheroe comic book movies comedies sequels Infographic twilight movies 2019 Prime Video Pixar Trophy Talk summer TV prank politics Television Academy Paramount TCA Winter 2020 Valentine's Day Extras royal family japan Chilling Adventures of Sabrina screen actors guild adventure teaser HBO Syfy Bravo SXSW 2022 Tarantino what to watch OneApp Hallmark Christmas Tubi streamig Western trailers stop motion parents BET Lifetime Christmas movies HFPA Spectrum Originals Shondaland Elton John breaking bad Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Spike Nat Geo Masterpiece young adult USA Network SDCC mcc ITV SXSW Hulu hispanic heritage month Ellie Kemper Sundance TV Watching Series canceled TV One FOX spanish language Certified Fresh RT21 summer preview NYCC Comic Book South by Southwest Film Festival American Society of Cinematographers DirecTV TV Land blockbuster festival rotten movies we love toy story hist zombies Walt Disney Pictures CBS All Access sports Logo women 2018 theme song Apple Superheroes YA Action crime Classic Film Netflix science fiction Epix Cosplay Marvel Studios First Reviews Ovation Musicals kaiju Sci-Fi halloween 72 Emmy Awards SundanceTV nfl godzilla Paramount Network Cartoon Network Best and Worst documentaries Amazon TLC dramedy singing competition scary movies video on demand Funimation TV movies james bond boxoffice french See It Skip It sitcom ViacomCBS Fantasy cancelled 73rd Emmy Awards Amazon Prime ID films golden globes streaming Sony FX scene in color latino 71st Emmy Awards new zealand Black Mirror comic book movie Winners robots south america Pride Month doctor who telelvision Adult Swim dceu finale crossover cinemax Star Trek Character Guide Fox Searchlight Disney+ Disney Plus Tumblr Lifetime hidden camera streaming movies 93rd Oscars ESPN E! The Purge YouTube joker Amazon Prime Video ABC Family FXX Food Network Disney Channel basketball TV renewals TCA 2017 fast and furious monster movies Travel Channel IFC Films Paramount Pictures Sundance Now blockbusters Comedy Central 21st Century Fox game show Polls and Games obituary medical drama DC Universe laika international Indigenous gangster Academy Awards Toys slasher asian-american spanish Alien zombie elevated horror Biopics