Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: 17 Again Is Sweet And Poignant

Plus, State of Play Is Certified Fresh, and guess Crank High Voltage's Tomatometer!

by | April 16, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a high school do-over (17 Again, starring Zac Efron and Leslie Mann), some journalistic thrills (State of Play, starring Russell Crowe and Rachel McAdams), and cardiovascular action (Crank High Voltage, starring Jason Statham and Bai Ling). What do the critics have to say?


17 Again

If you’ve seen Big, Back to the Future, and Peggy Sue Got Married, you’ll have a pretty good idea what’s in store with 17 Again. The good news? The critics say the film may be derivative, but it’s also clever, entertaining, and poignant, largely thanks to an impressive post-High School Musical turn from Zac Efron. He stars as Mike O’Donnell, a big man on campus circa 1989 who, 20 years later, finds his life and his marriage to high school sweetie Scarlett (Leslie Mann) on the rocks. He gets a second chance to correct his mistakes when he’s magically transformed into his 17-year-old self — albeit with his late-30s personality intact — and discovers a thing or two about life. While some critics find the film’s premise a bit unseemly (a 30-year-old bro-ing down with minors?), most say 17 Again is mostly sweet, funny, and perceptive, and that Efron has a bright future as a leading man.


State of Play

The newspaper industry is in bad shape these days, so it almost seems quaint to release a thriller about a principled investigative journalist in the midst of a vast conspiracy. But here’s a news flash: critics say State of Play is engrossing, smart, unnerving, and surprisingly timely, a tribute to the hardworking reporters that shed light on our political system. Russell Crowe stars as old-school Washington beat reporter Cal McAffrey, who’s had a solid professional rapport with up-and-coming congressman Stephen Collins (Ben Affleck) — that is, until some of Collins’ associates turn up dead. McAffrey uneasily joins forces with Della (Rachel McAdams), a blogger at the paper, to untangle a sinister web of secrets and lies. The pundits say State of Play may offer a few too many twists and turns, but its ensemble, which also includes Helen Mirren as McAffrey’s exacting editor, is unimpeachable, as is the immediacy and authenticity of the newsroom setting. State of Play is Certified Fresh.


Crank High Voltage

It appears the folks behind Crank High Voltage were concerned it would make critics, ahem, cranky, because it wasn’t screened prior to release (strange, since its predecessor notched a perfectly respectable 60 percent on the Tomatometer). Jason Statham once again stars as Chev Chelios (apparently no relation to the Red Wings defenseman) whose heart is removed; he must do everything in his power to keep his battery-powered ticker going while finding his missing organ. Kids, guess that Tomatometer! (And don’t forget to check out Crank star Bai Ling’s Five Favorite Films.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Oblivion, a doc about the turbulent recent history of Peru as seen through the eyes of assorted Lima residents, is at 90 percent on the Tomatometer.
  • Lemmon Tree, about a conflict over a lemon grove on the Israeli/Palestinian border in the West Bank, is at 85 percent.
  • Every Little Step, a documentary about the early days, and revival, of A Chorus Line, is at 83 percent.
  • American Violet, a drama about a single mother who must battle accusations of drug dealing, is at 78 percent.
  • Is Anybody There?, which stars Michael Caine in the tale of a boy who meets a free-spirited occupant of his parents’ old folks home, is at 50 percent..
  • The Golden Boys, starring David Carradine and Mariel Hemingway in a comedy about three retired sea captains who could use a woman’s touch in their drab Cape Cod house, is at 40 percent.
  • The Sleep Dealer, an indie sci-fi drama about exploited third-world workers in a futuristic dystopia, is at 38 percent.

Tag Cloud

Shudder thriller golden globe awards Baby Yoda NYCC know your critic Fox News Tumblr Neflix game show streaming movies BBC One Sony Pictures twilight king arthur TruTV San Diego Comic-Con Black Mirror Christmas Biopics 2017 Action international RT History Rock spanish 71st Emmy Awards New York Comic Con comic El Rey LGBTQ science fiction 99% Indigenous Tomatazos 94th Oscars ABC Family Superheroe Crackle Toys japanese cancelled TV shows Teen TV One satire saw Black History Month ITV streamig Amazon Studios video The CW summer TV south america DC streaming service boxoffice FOX Heroines scary movies VICE mcc Crunchyroll comics crime drama mockumentary medical drama christmas movies blockbusters slashers 79th Golden Globes Awards theme song Cannes OWN Summer Alien spain Binge Guide spanish language BET Awards laika A&E blaxploitation dc Ghostbusters independent Fargo Marvel Studios TV movies Nat Geo canceled zombie National Geographic critic resources 2019 politics obi wan Marvel Television E! Paramount Network Sneak Peek Animation screenings Trailer marvel comics Red Carpet Nominations quibi Classic Film YA talk show aliens aapi australia cancelled Star Wars Holiday 1990s hispanic lord of the rings space 2018 Musicals VOD Countdown Paramount Plus rt archives YouTube Video Games worst Turner sequel zero dark thirty best batman Emmys cancelled television movies legend festival football vs. The Academy Sundance Now Apple TV+ child's play Comics on TV PBS sitcom green book SXSW 2022 unscripted Best and Worst feel good ABC Pop indie dogs trophy TIFF witnail Opinion Television Academy travel Amazon kaiju psycho live event police drama serial killer worst movies halloween king kong Winter TV Watching Series royal family cats dramedy PaleyFest Esquire BET critics revenge rt labs book The Arrangement obituary Academy Awards E3 Broadway Writers Guild of America Country jamie lee curtis HBO Max mission: impossible high school crossover jurassic park TCA Winter 2020 A24 new york BBC anthology Arrowverse biography Fantasy cops LGBT VH1 dexter comic book movies docudrama kids superman 73rd Emmy Awards Native comic books casting razzies scene in color film series 24 frames Apple disaster fast and furious Film Trophy Talk cooking Premiere Dates suspense Comic Book First Reviews stand-up comedy Comedy Central facebook documentary rotten movies we love American Society of Cinematographers spider-man Horror Apple TV Plus crime thriller italian halloween tv MCU MSNBC foreign 4/20 OneApp elevated horror Disney Plus Mindy Kaling supernatural directors technology marvel cinematic universe Super Bowl comic book movie YouTube Premium Best Actor X-Men Reality Competition heist movie Kids & Family broadcast Lifetime YouTube Red target Television Critics Association Sundance cartoon IFC Films trailers harry potter SDCC miniseries Acorn TV MTV hist slasher Song of Ice and Fire psychological thriller ghosts Sony Pop TV Geeked Week interviews Logo hidden camera sag awards scorecard Year in Review fresh Exclusive Video natural history debate doctor who strong female leads cancelled TV series Holidays ViacomCBS SXSW Polls and Games composers Captain marvel scary renewed TV shows canceled TV shows scene in color series basketball Bravo BBC America nfl Britbox Brie Larson Prime Video Showtime golden globes Funimation Calendar Tubi Vudu GIFs telelvision criterion classics joker President 2016 Awards indiana jones Warner Bros. crime true crime rotten series nbcuniversal adaptation gangster remakes Pixar adenture Drama Freeform Grammys Best Actress Travel Channel sports TCA Awards Oscar Schedule Fall TV Legendary 45 See It Skip It Universal animated free movies Lionsgate First Look children's TV Image Comics Paramount Pictures wonder woman GoT vampires Thanksgiving movie black comedy Dark Horse Comics boxing Epix game of thrones genre finale Creative Arts Emmys Infographic parents kong scene in color nature Hallmark Christmas movies TBS Set visit 2015 72 Emmy Awards Disney Channel PlayStation Marathons docuseries toy story latino Mary Tyler Moore godzilla IFC olympics justice league DirecTV name the review news Box Office Mudbound APB adventure Peacock social media Music 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards festivals television TV summer preview universal monsters japan reboot cinemax cults CMT franchise what to watch Awards Tour FX on Hulu Spring TV spider-verse archives Oscars The Walking Dead CNN Chernobyl AMC Extras biopic dceu summer TV preview Film Festival video on demand SundanceTV Netflix Christmas movies singing competition Comedy NBA Fox Searchlight venice reviews leaderboard films Women's History Month DGA Wes Anderson WGN binge chucky DC Universe Best Picture Lucasfilm james bond Star Wars Celebration art house Instagram Live Pet Sematary Starz young adult The Witch action-comedy mutant Sundance TV versus HFPA 90s dragons Reality Universal Pictures Pride Month Superheroes concert TV Land monster movies TNT Columbia Pictures anime Hulu period drama Rom-Com Amazon Prime 2020 new star wars movies MGM Paramount USA RT21 dreamworks Discovery Channel Ovation Adult Swim Podcast romance robots streaming Martial Arts based on movie zombies Syfy 93rd Oscars asian-american romantic comedy CBS comiccon teaser Netflix Hear Us Out 007 Rocky mob emmy awards sequels a nightmare on elm street Disney streaming service all-time transformers women Chilling Adventures of Sabrina AMC Plus black superhero Certified Fresh Emmy Nominations Star Trek Shondaland popular WarnerMedia Trivia new zealand The Walt Disney Company documentaries Photos werewolf ID stoner french live action Turner Classic Movies Pacific Islander 2021 discovery stop motion CW Seed TCM spinoff Interview Lifetime Christmas movies hollywood 20th Century Fox tv talk Anna Paquin rt labs critics edition FXX ratings The Purge TV renewals HBO Go South by Southwest Film Festival Sci-Fi Disney Hallmark Marvel Tags: Comedy Mystery Rocketman Elton John Family spy thriller Cosplay Cartoon Network rom-coms prank screen actors guild BAFTA comedies ABC Signature TCA 2017 Musical Character Guide TLC Best Director blockbuster Mary Poppins Returns sopranos hispanic heritage month posters Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 21st Century Fox Comic-Con@Home 2021 Focus Features Amazon Prime Video Valentine's Day breaking bad pirates of the caribbean CBS All Access Stephen King DC Comics Spike Walt Disney Pictures History Tokyo Olympics award winner IMDb TV historical drama target scene in color Ellie Kemper cars political drama die hard GLAAD Quiz USA Network richard e. Grant FX book adaptation dark diversity Food Network toronto Avengers Winners Masterpiece deadpool Western Spectrum Originals Disney+ Disney Plus TCA HBO Hollywood Foreign Press Association NBC Endgame war Mary poppins ESPN Election Pirates Tarantino Nickelodeon