Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: 17 Again Is Sweet And Poignant

Plus, State of Play Is Certified Fresh, and guess Crank High Voltage's Tomatometer!

by | April 16, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a high school do-over (17 Again, starring Zac Efron and Leslie Mann), some journalistic thrills (State of Play, starring Russell Crowe and Rachel McAdams), and cardiovascular action (Crank High Voltage, starring Jason Statham and Bai Ling). What do the critics have to say?


17 Again

If you’ve seen Big, Back to the Future, and Peggy Sue Got Married, you’ll have a pretty good idea what’s in store with 17 Again. The good news? The critics say the film may be derivative, but it’s also clever, entertaining, and poignant, largely thanks to an impressive post-High School Musical turn from Zac Efron. He stars as Mike O’Donnell, a big man on campus circa 1989 who, 20 years later, finds his life and his marriage to high school sweetie Scarlett (Leslie Mann) on the rocks. He gets a second chance to correct his mistakes when he’s magically transformed into his 17-year-old self — albeit with his late-30s personality intact — and discovers a thing or two about life. While some critics find the film’s premise a bit unseemly (a 30-year-old bro-ing down with minors?), most say 17 Again is mostly sweet, funny, and perceptive, and that Efron has a bright future as a leading man.


State of Play

The newspaper industry is in bad shape these days, so it almost seems quaint to release a thriller about a principled investigative journalist in the midst of a vast conspiracy. But here’s a news flash: critics say State of Play is engrossing, smart, unnerving, and surprisingly timely, a tribute to the hardworking reporters that shed light on our political system. Russell Crowe stars as old-school Washington beat reporter Cal McAffrey, who’s had a solid professional rapport with up-and-coming congressman Stephen Collins (Ben Affleck) — that is, until some of Collins’ associates turn up dead. McAffrey uneasily joins forces with Della (Rachel McAdams), a blogger at the paper, to untangle a sinister web of secrets and lies. The pundits say State of Play may offer a few too many twists and turns, but its ensemble, which also includes Helen Mirren as McAffrey’s exacting editor, is unimpeachable, as is the immediacy and authenticity of the newsroom setting. State of Play is Certified Fresh.


Crank High Voltage

It appears the folks behind Crank High Voltage were concerned it would make critics, ahem, cranky, because it wasn’t screened prior to release (strange, since its predecessor notched a perfectly respectable 60 percent on the Tomatometer). Jason Statham once again stars as Chev Chelios (apparently no relation to the Red Wings defenseman) whose heart is removed; he must do everything in his power to keep his battery-powered ticker going while finding his missing organ. Kids, guess that Tomatometer! (And don’t forget to check out Crank star Bai Ling’s Five Favorite Films.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Oblivion, a doc about the turbulent recent history of Peru as seen through the eyes of assorted Lima residents, is at 90 percent on the Tomatometer.
  • Lemmon Tree, about a conflict over a lemon grove on the Israeli/Palestinian border in the West Bank, is at 85 percent.
  • Every Little Step, a documentary about the early days, and revival, of A Chorus Line, is at 83 percent.
  • American Violet, a drama about a single mother who must battle accusations of drug dealing, is at 78 percent.
  • Is Anybody There?, which stars Michael Caine in the tale of a boy who meets a free-spirited occupant of his parents’ old folks home, is at 50 percent..
  • The Golden Boys, starring David Carradine and Mariel Hemingway in a comedy about three retired sea captains who could use a woman’s touch in their drab Cape Cod house, is at 40 percent.
  • The Sleep Dealer, an indie sci-fi drama about exploited third-world workers in a futuristic dystopia, is at 38 percent.

Tag Cloud

Nominations nbcuniversal pirates of the caribbean cartoon Pacific Islander GLAAD MTV Mindy Kaling Drama psycho HBO Go Apple TV Plus Freeform American Society of Cinematographers critics laika target Travel Channel Sci-Fi Extras Dark Horse Comics See It Skip It Sony Pictures Spectrum Originals screenings science fiction transformers Winter TV dreamworks japan hist E3 TCM Netflix Christmas movies high school Walt Disney Pictures Disney Plus worst nature medical drama book adaptation OWN Pop TV Television Critics Association MSNBC festivals video ghosts james bond blockbuster Amazon Studios Grammys mob dragons Comedy ITV Calendar The Purge Red Carpet japanese Marvel Studios The Academy Prime Video Shudder dramedy Hollywood Foreign Press Association New York Comic Con Lucasfilm scary royal family scary movies Paramount Network true crime TCA History Warner Bros. emmy awards Family zero dark thirty french 2016 supernatural Video Games Rocky Disney streaming service cancelled Exclusive Video stand-up comedy Stephen King superman Mystery Reality Competition Spike dceu Marvel Television sopranos 2019 Bravo Apple TV+ free movies period drama docuseries Shondaland historical drama Toys YouTube Premium Trophy Talk Animation PBS San Diego Comic-Con Discovery Channel crime drama Cannes Premiere Dates spinoff FOX canceled TV shows Tokyo Olympics popular chucky DirecTV revenge adenture 007 franchise comic books superhero comic book movies theme song green book Netflix christmas movies sitcom boxoffice quibi TV One golden globe awards Pet Sematary Elton John TIFF razzies Broadway trophy facebook LGBT Logo WarnerMedia Crackle SundanceTV Image Comics basketball streaming movies doctor who ratings disaster Pirates spanish game show Rom-Com AMC Plus canceled saw name the review Set visit BBC America Teen rotten richard e. Grant Country PaleyFest Avengers dark TV Marvel DC Comics DC streaming service ID cars Awards Tour psychological thriller renewed TV shows Columbia Pictures golden globes rt labs critics edition CBS directors composers twilight Film El Rey Superheroes Britbox australia 4/20 Martial Arts Summer Year in Review DC Universe 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards The Walking Dead Hulu Reality cancelled television Creative Arts Emmys Pixar young adult WGN Captain marvel live action witnail cops feel good documentaries Classic Film comics Tags: Comedy crime 2018 marvel cinematic universe YouTube Winners 45 TruTV what to watch 73rd Emmy Awards kaiju biopic Crunchyroll Marathons APB HBO Disney+ Disney Plus Holiday Tarantino SXSW 90s TLC political drama Comic Book Amazon concert BBC Amazon Prime know your critic halloween tv BET OneApp Universal Pictures 2020 casting archives ABC Signature best die hard war worst movies E! fast and furious Chilling Adventures of Sabrina spy thriller Horror dogs politics heist movie police drama Election hispanic heritage month sequels Ellie Kemper Apple rom-coms new zealand leaderboard trailers rotten movies we love Legendary Nickelodeon king arthur women RT History Christmas lord of the rings Spring TV natural history comedies Arrowverse Neflix romantic comedy biography Lionsgate reboot HFPA singing competition AMC RT21 TCA 2017 book Sundance breaking bad sag awards Sundance TV technology diversity series CBS All Access Countdown latino YouTube Red binge Amazon Prime Video Pride Month LGBTQ tv talk Mudbound anthology aapi Valentine's Day dexter Opinion foreign unscripted movies based on movie Fargo dc Comedy Central spider-verse TBS blockbusters Mary poppins justice league vampires 93rd Oscars Interview Rocketman teaser posters talk show Adult Swim 20th Century Fox 1990s Certified Fresh USA Network CNN independent adventure VICE DGA rt labs debate Star Wars FX Fox Searchlight scene in color IMDb TV A&E classics Binge Guide 2015 godzilla Oscars miniseries Polls and Games legend blaxploitation Black Mirror nfl universal monsters stoner Emmy Nominations Comics on TV child's play cults festival romance asian-american Turner Classic Movies slasher comic book movie crime thriller movie hidden camera mission: impossible action-comedy Women's History Month Endgame Sundance Now Disney Channel Wes Anderson international First Look discovery Black History Month batman Chernobyl mockumentary Kids & Family cancelled TV shows monster movies NYCC documentary films comic IFC Films PlayStation Alien Television Academy animated award winner crossover fresh thriller The CW Thanksgiving screen actors guild National Geographic telelvision Starz new york Hallmark Cosplay docudrama comiccon X-Men video on demand black comedy robots serial killer Tumblr USA TV movies Nat Geo zombies President kong Brie Larson BAFTA Disney indiana jones venice zombie Infographic sequel 2017 news travel BBC One 21st Century Fox Song of Ice and Fire Box Office Film Festival indie obituary jamie lee curtis hispanic Music reviews MCU 71st Emmy Awards NBC werewolf live event Instagram Live Fall TV Tomatazos 2021 VH1 Awards Paramount Plus children's TV FX on Hulu ABC Family A24 Podcast Academy Awards TV Land Trailer Ovation Peacock parents Paramount stop motion marvel comics Vudu Hear Us Out olympics toronto a nightmare on elm street aliens HBO Max ABC Rock 24 frames Universal cancelled TV series Fantasy ViacomCBS Holidays Watching Series CMT hollywood Musical criterion The Arrangement Comic-Con@Home 2021 spider-man joker space toy story Food Network spain vs. slashers TCA Winter 2020 Action NBA Best and Worst adaptation YA Epix Masterpiece Western italian Lifetime harry potter scorecard The Witch Biopics satire elevated horror Cartoon Network cinemax Lifetime Christmas movies prank Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt boxing deadpool Acorn TV BET Awards streaming jurassic park wonder woman social media TNT Pop Funimation Showtime game of thrones First Reviews Anna Paquin Mary Tyler Moore 99% Baby Yoda kids all-time Emmys mutant 79th Golden Globes Awards football anime sports FXX spanish language ESPN Super Bowl Mary Poppins Returns Character Guide gangster Quiz GoT Turner art house new star wars movies Ghostbusters black strong female leads critic resources finale IFC television TV renewals Sneak Peek The Walt Disney Company Fox News Trivia suspense VOD cooking Musicals south america Heroines Writers Guild of America Superheroe Syfy SDCC TCA Awards Tubi king kong Hallmark Christmas movies Schedule versus mcc remakes 72 Emmy Awards halloween Esquire Star Trek GIFs Photos cats genre CW Seed rt archives