Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: 10,000 B.C. is Primitive; Bank Gets the Job Done

Also: College Trip is on a Road to nowhere.

by | March 6, 2008 | Comments

This week
at the movies, we’ve got prehistoric passion (10,000 B.C., starring
Steven Strait and
Camilla Belle), travel travails (College Road Trip,
starring Martin Lawrence and
Raven-Symone), and
hard-boiled heists (The Bank Job, starring
Jason Statham). What do the
critics have to say?

If you’re
looking for subtlety,
Roland Emmerich is not your man. That’s not to say he’s a
bad filmmaker; he’s made some quality big-budget, high-concept yarns (Independence
Day
springs to mind) that deliver thrills aplenty. Unfortunately, critics say
his latest,

10,000 B.C.
, is mired in the stone age. B.C. stars

Steven Strait and
Camilla Belle
as a pair of hunting-and-gathering honeys; when
Belle gets kidnapped, Strait and members of their tribe journey into the unknown
to save her — and run across saber-toothed tigers, wooly mammoths, and other
civilizations. The pundits say 10,000 B.C. doesn’t lack for compelling
visuals, but it’s weak on plot and characterization and filled with
unintentional comedy. At 12 percent on the Tomatometer, 10,000 B.C. is a
Mesolithic mess. It’s also the worst-reviewed film of Emmerich’s career.




“Jiminy Jilickers! Just missed the Red Bull Flugtag!”

With
College Road Trip,
Martin Lawrence joins
Ice Cube and
Robin Williams in the pantheon
of once-edgy performers toplining poorly-reviewed family road trip comedies.
Lawrence stars as the overbearing father of
Melanie (
Raven-Symone), whose plan for a just-the-girls trip to look at schools
is undermined by her dad’s insistence on going along for the ride; subsequently,
laffs are had and lessons are learned, at least in theory. The pundits say Road
Trip
features over-the-top gags and a remarkable shortage of comic
imagination. At zero percent on the Tomatometer, this is the worst-reviewed film
of Lawrence’s career, edging out the five percent
Big Momma’s House 2
.




Maiden voyage of the Battleship Pigtemkin.

After
touring the martial arts circuit in movies like
The Transporter
and
War
,
Jason Statham returns to his grimy thriller roots with

The Bank Job
.
Based on the real-life 1971 robbery of security deposit boxes, he stars as a
petty thug in over his head as the job spirals out of control. It’s a throwback
to the heist movies of yore, and according to the critics (to quote
The French
Connection
‘s tagline) the time is right for an out-and-out thriller like this.
Director Roger Donaldson never lets the pace flag, forging a movie that’s
dramatic, funny, and plain entertaining. At 73 percent on the Tomatometer, The Bank Job is looking like a solid investment. (And
check out our Total Recall feature on heist movies

here
.)




“Who knew Louise Brooks could bend like that?”

Also
opening this week in limited release:




Testing out the rumor that Stratocasters taste like fried banana.

Recent
Roland Emmerich Films:
—————————————–
46% — The Day After Tomorrow (2004)
62% — The Patriot (2000)
25% — Godzilla (1998)
62% —

Independence
Day
(1996)
43% — Stargate (1994)

Tag Cloud

Sneak Peek Western SundanceTV FX Captain marvel Pixar 21st Century Fox Legendary DC Comics Grammys marvel comics remakes TBS book adaptation spain emmy awards Quiz Shudder venice rt labs olympics Ghostbusters VICE sequels Crackle Amazon Studios mockumentary target ABC Family halloween TNT nature Television Academy rotten Nickelodeon AMC Nominations Box Office Masterpiece TCM mob Fantasy Action Red Carpet Creative Arts Emmys live event jurassic park zero dark thirty james bond kids historical drama franchise medical drama dexter Showtime cats superman lord of the rings Trophy Talk telelvision dreamworks ITV theme song Bravo Vudu History festivals Character Guide Rocky Countdown First Look technology Rom-Com TIFF Starz chucky TV One Chilling Adventures of Sabrina criterion New York Comic Con Shondaland TV movies sag awards game show finale Netflix Christmas movies composers cancelled TV shows police drama sports comic book movies Trailer comedies streaming Broadway Anna Paquin Superheroes USA Network Elton John high school Discovery Channel Awards Tour Netflix Kids & Family YouTube Red Calendar Nat Geo boxing Pride Month 71st Emmy Awards 90s Teen anthology Classic Film adventure black based on movie Reality Competition nbcuniversal dark Animation Amazon Prime Video Chernobyl scary movies Star Wars Apple TV Plus Logo romantic comedy south america CBS disaster BBC One series foreign comic book movie Year in Review Star Trek Ovation Disney+ Disney Plus Hallmark concert NBA DC Universe HBO Sci-Fi feel good GIFs book 73rd Emmy Awards award winner mission: impossible Amazon Prime screen actors guild Ellie Kemper RT History American Society of Cinematographers scene in color boxoffice Election San Diego Comic-Con werewolf serial killer 72 Emmy Awards best Marvel ABC casting TV Land OneApp Disney streaming service IFC new zealand Comedy Central Pacific Islander Valentine's Day Comic Book mutant Disney Funimation Exclusive Video fast and furious Biopics Sundance sitcom zombie Opinion Infographic rotten movies we love television new star wars movies Paramount Song of Ice and Fire ID Rock dc dceu documentaries young adult blaxploitation godzilla die hard SXSW 2017 razzies singing competition anime heist movie all-time 2021 AMC Plus GoT The Purge hidden camera 1990s Marvel Studios TCA news elevated horror The Walking Dead what to watch Set visit 2015 Esquire Universal cars Horror Disney Channel true crime 24 frames See It Skip It Freeform Winter TV Premiere Dates Mudbound women 2018 twilight YouTube Premium Syfy Toys TCA 2017 Turner Classic Movies Super Bowl versus hispanic heritage month Television Critics Association doctor who sequel scary Rocketman BBC America crossover Cartoon Network USA adenture GLAAD Drama Arrowverse Musicals cartoon Spectrum Originals Comedy Thanksgiving video on demand Tomatazos Certified Fresh asian-american documentary talk show golden globes President IMDb TV binge Stephen King Academy Awards Binge Guide action-comedy Film Travel Channel Apple TV+ discovery MCU trophy football Pop TV king kong wonder woman Sundance TV Comic-Con@Home 2021 HBO Go Lifetime Christmas movies genre 007 FOX Fox Searchlight Mary Poppins Returns Photos RT21 Pirates rt archives docudrama golden globe awards X-Men BBC biography movies Tokyo Olympics Lifetime toy story natural history cooking canceled TV shows toronto Watching Series stand-up comedy universal monsters animated teaser YA tv talk directors australia E! DC streaming service Fall TV BAFTA new york APB space 4/20 blockbuster HBO Max rt labs critics edition scorecard supernatural a nightmare on elm street Sony Pictures National Geographic italian Tags: Comedy diversity PBS Mindy Kaling Awards Mary Tyler Moore Marvel Television cinemax LGBTQ slasher Interview laika Emmy Nominations dragons Tarantino marvel cinematic universe Christmas Lionsgate Extras war jamie lee curtis CBS All Access Black History Month The Arrangement worst vs. Amazon worst movies PaleyFest The Witch Emmys Schedule OWN Oscars Cosplay Prime Video 2019 trailers Musical Peacock Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt El Rey cancelled TV series stoner spanish language quibi screenings ViacomCBS Fargo travel 93rd Oscars blockbusters game of thrones adaptation DirecTV 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards witnail Music miniseries SDCC satire justice league docuseries indiana jones Apple TCA Winter 2020 LGBT 79th Golden Globes Awards VH1 The Academy TV Holiday ESPN CMT A&E Tubi joker halloween tv 20th Century Fox aliens Family video cops romance TruTV canceled slashers live action comiccon Food Network Adult Swim Instagram Live superhero facebook child's play sopranos comics Alien hist Pet Sematary Hear Us Out stop motion batman Black Mirror critic resources Acorn TV Mary poppins Avengers posters royal family mcc unscripted french prank Fox News Walt Disney Pictures vampires spanish legend The CW CNN politics obituary suspense leaderboard Hulu science fiction hispanic TLC WarnerMedia PlayStation Turner dramedy revenge strong female leads christmas movies 45 E3 Universal Pictures robots comic books 2020 Paramount Network IFC Films fresh dogs 2016 Disney Plus The Walt Disney Company Writers Guild of America crime thriller Mystery Heroines Martial Arts japan political drama hollywood FX on Hulu black comedy Cannes debate saw Britbox Summer movie 99% ghosts nfl comic psycho YouTube deadpool know your critic Video Games Baby Yoda king arthur ratings Neflix classics BET Awards Winners name the review free movies archives monster movies social media japanese ABC Signature Brie Larson MTV Lucasfilm cancelled WGN children's TV Comics on TV Country Pop BET renewed TV shows transformers NYCC Wes Anderson kong harry potter VOD HFPA cancelled television Polls and Games critics Trivia psychological thriller Sundance Now breaking bad aapi Superheroe green book Crunchyroll Hallmark Christmas movies First Reviews reviews Marathons zombies Dark Horse Comics biopic spider-man crime streaming movies art house spy thriller TCA Awards Spring TV cults MSNBC independent Epix Columbia Pictures Reality latino Podcast reboot A24 period drama Paramount Plus Tumblr international popular Warner Bros. spinoff Endgame festival indie TV renewals thriller NBC rom-coms Hollywood Foreign Press Association crime drama Women's History Month Film Festival films CW Seed Holidays Spike FXX pirates of the caribbean Image Comics gangster spider-verse DGA kaiju Best and Worst parents basketball richard e. Grant