Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: Third Time's Not the Charm for "Shrek"

by | May 17, 2007 | Comments

America is going green this week: "Shrek the Third" (featuring the voices of Mike Meyers, Eddie Murphy, and Antonio Banderas) is our single new wide release. Critics loved the first two, how do they feel about this one?

Shrek’s third outing finds our green antihero in an unusual predicament: the king has died, and Shrek is next in line to ascend to the throne. Typically, he wants nothing of it and must set off to find a replacement. Hijinks, fart jokes, and ironic postmodern deconstruction ensue. But critics say "Third" has gone too far with the "Shrek" formula: it relies too heavily on pop culture references and fairy tale spoofs, marginalizing the heart and charm that made the first two classics. Also, the sheer amount of new and returning characters has given the best characters – Shrek, Donkey, and Fiona – the least screen time in any "Shrek" yet. "Shrek the Third" is at 42 percent, a far cry from "Shrek"’s and "Shrek 2"’s 89 and 88 percent Tomatometers, respectively.

"I…am not right-handed."

And opening in limited release: "Once," a crowd-pleasing drama about two street musicians (check out our interview with director John Carney), is at 100 percent; "Severance," a British import of shock horror and droll comedy, is at 74 percent; "Brooklyn Rules," a drama set in the titular borough circa 1985, is at 56 percent; "Flanders," the new art pic from festival fave Bruno Dumont, is at 50 percent; "The Wendell Baker Story," a light-hearted drama featuring possibly more Wilson Brothers than we’re equipped to handle, is at 40 percent; "Fay Grim," the new action/thriller/comedy from quirky auteur Hal Hartley, is at 40 percent; "Even Money," a cautionary tale about the ills of gambling, is at 20 percent; and "The Last Sin Eater," the second release of Fox Faith’s Christian parable, is at 20 percent.

In "Flanders" field.

And medals, commendations, and accolades to unbreakable_samurai and SplendidIsolation who both came closest to guessing "Delta Farce"’s three percent Tomatometer last week. We, too, were surprised by its extraordinarily high rating.

Recent Mike Meyers Movies
88% – Shrek 2 (2004)
14% – View From the Top (2003)
12% – Dr. Seuss’ The Cat in the Hat (2003)
55% – Austin Powers in Goldmember (2002)
89% – Shrek (2001)

Tag Cloud

cults feel good name the review MTV dogs Musicals APB boxing Captain marvel Disney+ Disney Plus zombie San Diego Comic-Con suspense streaming movies revenge binge Freeform National Geographic green book Disney versus Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TBS Fantasy Shudder kids rt labs TCA Awards directors Rocky Discovery Channel olympics 73rd Emmy Awards screen actors guild rom-coms Rom-Com Rock nbcuniversal know your critic ratings Tomatazos Neflix deadpool Sundance DC Universe slashers Masterpiece ABC Family Shondaland halloween tv Country adenture Kids & Family animated hidden camera TCA A24 transformers DGA composers politics space sequel Nat Geo indiana jones ViacomCBS concert heist movie Mindy Kaling YouTube breaking bad series American Society of Cinematographers Trophy Talk Paramount Network Family FOX reboot Logo Image Comics Comic Book Dark Horse Comics critic resources mob 72 Emmy Awards Netflix Binge Guide Apple 45 Amazon Prime Video Super Bowl rt archives 2018 Pirates Countdown australia comedies Hallmark Syfy Tarantino aliens police drama docuseries 93rd Oscars TruTV comic Comedy Mary Tyler Moore Reality Competition nature women dark black comedy Infographic Chernobyl Cartoon Network zombies Grammys venice Extras Valentine's Day Star Wars FX on Hulu independent japan hist worst movies die hard Superheroes vampires Emmy Nominations comic book movies Watching Series adventure ABC Signature ESPN Disney Channel diversity live action reviews BET comiccon serial killer dreamworks movie political drama Amazon Studios Women's History Month critics Sony Pictures sopranos dragons spy thriller SundanceTV scorecard Britbox CBS doctor who Film Festival See It Skip It richard e. Grant Amazon Prime children's TV king kong PaleyFest gangster YouTube Premium Black History Month finale Writers Guild of America south america Television Critics Association Crackle stop motion telelvision Quiz kaiju TV renewals HBO Go 71st Emmy Awards Prime Video remakes Reality ID WGN MCU TV Land spider-man french boxoffice Television Academy BBC America Holidays 20th Century Fox period drama marvel cinematic universe Mary Poppins Returns high school trophy talk show Alien dc historical drama TCA Winter 2020 RT History streaming video VOD NBC biopic Showtime miniseries renewed TV shows Oscars FXX dramedy 2016 FX Best and Worst Awards new york Arrowverse Winners best Hulu international romantic comedy 79th Golden Globes Awards trailers zero dark thirty book war medical drama chucky E! Winter TV El Rey RT21 cancelled TV series VICE Paramount Plus PBS screenings Mary poppins harry potter Starz Paramount Broadway docudrama Pop cops History Brie Larson 2020 Marvel Television unscripted New York Comic Con films foreign Awards Tour 4/20 Nickelodeon Holiday Esquire popular golden globes comics Lifetime IMDb TV mutant SXSW award winner classics BBC live event archives Summer biography batman Anna Paquin DC streaming service 2015 criterion disaster A&E 24 frames worst Marvel Studios game of thrones YouTube Red crime thriller Drama Spectrum Originals Cannes japanese 2017 basketball genre Instagram Live Travel Channel child's play robots The Purge Musical ABC joker Pop TV Lionsgate Year in Review Hear Us Out DC Comics documentary rotten The CW razzies Box Office The Walt Disney Company mission: impossible Martial Arts saw Polls and Games james bond Animation Universal Pictures spanish language CMT Academy Awards Star Trek obituary 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards lord of the rings travel Podcast Superheroe The Academy crime all-time sports GoT 007 Apple TV Plus anime Food Network AMC Plus golden globe awards Comic-Con@Home 2021 legend television cats Pacific Islander Ghostbusters scene in color quibi Nominations singing competition IFC thriller monster movies First Reviews GIFs Western aapi debate italian canceled Opinion Vudu Apple TV+ Marathons Sundance Now facebook TV action-comedy Ellie Kemper Mudbound dexter superhero game show BAFTA CBS All Access Calendar HFPA Fox Searchlight theme song Music Turner hispanic Fox News video on demand Crunchyroll mockumentary jurassic park parents Trivia Tokyo Olympics Wes Anderson TV movies festivals pirates of the caribbean rotten movies we love NYCC emmy awards Thanksgiving Turner Classic Movies Disney streaming service black Funimation Red Carpet SDCC anthology Trailer fast and furious Certified Fresh news nfl Action posters CW Seed true crime toronto stand-up comedy Classic Film Warner Bros. Rocketman Premiere Dates BET Awards Elton John Lucasfilm Character Guide Exclusive Video crime drama HBO Walt Disney Pictures Ovation target sag awards social media 99% casting Disney Plus ghosts supernatural cancelled TV shows TIFF asian-american Marvel leaderboard halloween GLAAD Teen IFC Films cooking jamie lee curtis blaxploitation Black Mirror MSNBC E3 scary movies Video Games TNT documentaries teaser hollywood Epix WarnerMedia scary Tubi Hollywood Foreign Press Association spinoff Sci-Fi christmas movies mcc YA Netflix Christmas movies Election President Interview new zealand Adult Swim PlayStation festival spider-verse cars a nightmare on elm street free movies Mystery Schedule adaptation Creative Arts Emmys Fall TV The Witch prank comic book movie Baby Yoda Photos Pride Month Horror blockbusters marvel comics Columbia Pictures superman Peacock Stephen King movies LGBTQ Lifetime Christmas movies cancelled young adult slasher twilight Hallmark Christmas movies laika Sundance TV spain Avengers based on movie rt labs critics edition sitcom fresh OWN discovery Acorn TV art house canceled TV shows comic books hispanic heritage month The Arrangement football Legendary USA Pet Sematary ITV werewolf satire TCM USA Network king arthur Set visit witnail Emmys spanish kong TLC 1990s AMC what to watch justice league Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt strong female leads Song of Ice and Fire DirecTV Toys First Look royal family vs. The Walking Dead Spring TV wonder woman godzilla 2021 CNN toy story natural history Tags: Comedy stoner NBA romance Comics on TV Tumblr sequels latino Fargo Sneak Peek HBO Max VH1 indie Universal Endgame elevated horror cancelled television BBC One Film X-Men dceu Pixar Cosplay universal monsters Heroines Biopics TV One psycho Spike cartoon 90s cinemax science fiction franchise new star wars movies tv talk psychological thriller LGBT blockbuster OneApp 21st Century Fox crossover Amazon Comedy Central book adaptation Christmas technology 2019 Bravo TCA 2017