Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: The Golden Compass Loses Its Way

Plus, Juno and Atonement are Certified Fresh.

by | December 6, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got the first installment of the His Dark
The Golden Compass
, starring
Nicole Kidman,
Blue Richards
, and
Daniel Craig. What do the critics have to say?

The highly-anticipated
The Golden Compass
is the first of Philip
Pullman’s novels to hit the screen. It has a veritable Murderer’s Row of acting
talent (Nicole Kidman,
Sam Elliott,
Eva Green,
Daniel Craig,
Ian McKellen,
, Derek Jacobi,
Ian McShane,
Christopher Lee, and
Blue Richards
). And critics say it’s got visual flash to spare. Unfortunately, they
also largely feel Compass is a little too cold to work any kind of spell.
The film tells the story of a 12-year-old girl attempting to save her friend
from the strange, malevolent Gobblers, and finds herself in a realm of mystery
and fantastical beings. Pundits say the wondrous production design and
way-too-brisk plot overwhelms the characters, and delivers little of the
intended sense of wonder. At 45 percent on the Tomatometer, The Golden
doesn’t quite shine.

But does it know the way to San Jose?

Also opening this week in limited release: Mexican import The Violin,
about three generations of musicians/guerillas, is at 100 percent on the
Tomatometer; Juno, starring
Ellen Page and
Michael Cera
in the comic tale of a sharp teen coping with an unplanned pregnancy, is
Certified Fresh at 92 percent (read our Page interview here);
, a period drama about star-crossed
lovers starring
Keira Knightley and
James McAvoy,
is Certified Fresh at 88 percent (read our McAvoy and director Joe Wright interviews here and here, respectively);
Billy the Kid
, a doc about a teen dealing with
behavior issues in rural Maine, is at 82 percent;

‘Tis Autumn — the Search
for Jackie Paris
, a doc about an elusive, velvet-voiced jazz singer, is at
71 percent; Grace is Gone, starring
John Cusack as a man who picks up the
pieces after his wife is killed in Iraq, is at 69 percent;
Man in the Chair
about the bond between an elderly film crew member and a young cinephile
starring Christopher Plummer, is at 57 percent;
Paul Schrader‘s
The Walker,
starring Woody Harrelson as a D.C. socialite in the midst of some criminal
intrigue, is at 56 percent;
The Amateurs
, starring
Jeff Bridges in the
story of a group of suburbanites who make an adult film, is at 22 percent;
Tony N’ Tina’s Wedding
, based on the semi-improvisational off-Broadway comedy,
is at 20 percent; and
Guy Ritchie‘s
Revolver, starring Jason Statham as
an expert gambler who goes up against a crime boss, is at 15 percent.

"When I put headphones on my tummy, should I play Pavement or Archers of Loaf?”

Finally, we’d like to give props to
Rocdahut for staying awake long enough to
come closest to guessing Awake‘s 16 percent Tomatometer. I guess this
gives you a good reason to, um, rock the hut, Rocdahut.

Recent Keira Knightly Movies:
8% — Silk (2007)
46% — Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End (2007)
54% —
Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest
85% — Pride and Prejudice (2005)
73% — Pure (2005)

Tag Cloud

olympics medical drama Pet Sematary concert 2017 Musicals adaptation foreign adenture See It Skip It spanish NYCC supernatural Black Mirror ABC Signature Amazon Prime Video streaming Turner space 20th Century Fox social media TLC cancelled Crunchyroll dreamworks Disney spain twilight suspense Fox News PaleyFest leaderboard SundanceTV Trophy Talk 79th Golden Globes Awards directors ratings animated name the review streaming movies young adult CMT slasher CNN hist french Pixar know your critic TCA Awards comic book movies American Society of Cinematographers The Walking Dead Tarantino black monster movies Song of Ice and Fire Exclusive Video 007 Red Carpet ITV spy thriller justice league scene in color The Walt Disney Company sports Nominations TV Land free movies APB Ellie Kemper Animation chucky 2019 Action ESPN 2015 ID X-Men Logo SDCC miniseries Pacific Islander TIFF Paramount Plus south america king kong Cartoon Network spider-man National Geographic casting LGBTQ documentaries AMC Plus elevated horror 90s Interview Apple TV+ anime Starz Teen australia Instagram Live BBC book adaptation biography Apple TV Plus prank royal family Calendar 1990s Walt Disney Pictures OWN Shudder italian franchise Photos GIFs politics parents sag awards versus disaster Drama renewed TV shows A24 werewolf Disney+ Disney Plus pirates of the caribbean hispanic criterion period drama spinoff stand-up comedy 99% Holiday movies teaser unscripted SXSW HBO Go hispanic heritage month cancelled TV series legend mutant Watching Series cancelled television First Look Cosplay Superheroes political drama cats universal monsters BET Awards doctor who comic books cars Binge Guide comic science fiction live action Oscars Marvel Studios kaiju basketball Tumblr Quiz Christmas Ghostbusters Amazon Prime mockumentary Box Office WarnerMedia Podcast dexter First Reviews WGN Hulu comics fresh TNT joker trophy RT21 thriller ABC Sundance Winter TV stoner TBS superhero Epix Marvel Television lord of the rings Disney streaming service Showtime Premiere Dates news Family new star wars movies strong female leads marvel cinematic universe AMC revenge Hallmark zombies trailers E! The Academy Endgame Mary Tyler Moore Super Bowl Trivia Nickelodeon VOD worst screen actors guild Shondaland 2016 USA Spike dc vs. heist movie gangster 2018 zero dark thirty Horror Peacock CBS deadpool FX on Hulu hollywood psycho OneApp adventure japan women Tags: Comedy Bravo breaking bad Creative Arts Emmys Election TCM what to watch vampires BAFTA Martial Arts Awards Tour posters video on demand richard e. Grant Britbox 71st Emmy Awards game show Film Tomatazos movie YA Tubi blockbusters christmas movies aapi RT History golden globes Best and Worst Year in Review child's play BBC One The Witch sopranos talk show YouTube Avengers stop motion theme song ghosts CBS All Access Video Games President historical drama Superheroe asian-american Fall TV Grammys blaxploitation 21st Century Fox Sundance TV Pride Month television archives Legendary new zealand Countdown Schedule Writers Guild of America Apple History Country Character Guide NBA rotten Comedy Central Mary poppins screenings natural history Kids & Family Paramount Network Masterpiece TV renewals 4/20 Fargo black comedy MCU razzies action-comedy football slashers CW Seed binge Biopics Summer tv talk anthology high school Lifetime Infographic best dragons Arrowverse indie saw Certified Fresh scary rt archives festival YouTube Premium Spectrum Originals Broadway Rock game of thrones Crackle Stephen King Sundance Now Spring TV Rocky children's TV king arthur Baby Yoda robots Travel Channel Dark Horse Comics mcc zombie FXX technology Comic Book award winner biopic Reality MSNBC sequels cancelled TV shows VICE Television Critics Association TCA VH1 Black History Month Fantasy police drama Fox Searchlight The Purge 2021 obituary Alien HFPA PBS Star Wars Universal El Rey japanese Hear Us Out Heroines Hallmark Christmas movies films godzilla laika San Diego Comic-Con nature 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards marvel comics video Sci-Fi boxing crime thriller YouTube Red Wes Anderson Tokyo Olympics cops IMDb TV Rocketman Thanksgiving Set visit Turner Classic Movies Universal Pictures Netflix Christmas movies Cannes Lifetime Christmas movies die hard Toys witnail E3 indiana jones Lionsgate Film Festival transformers Captain marvel halloween tv Syfy all-time DirecTV mission: impossible wonder woman critics FX aliens The CW Mary Poppins Returns FOX Marathons BBC America Nat Geo latino Disney Channel cartoon Music 93rd Oscars Mindy Kaling sitcom dceu romance Extras live event serial killer reviews Comics on TV Pirates diversity boxoffice DGA canceled New York Comic Con fast and furious docudrama Winners GoT Elton John harry potter critic resources Women's History Month comic book movie Pop TV ABC Family Chilling Adventures of Sabrina IFC Mystery kids blockbuster Reality Competition nbcuniversal spider-verse A&E Hollywood Foreign Press Association cults crime drama scary movies Disney Plus hidden camera cooking Adult Swim spanish language LGBT jamie lee curtis rotten movies we love popular Sony Pictures romantic comedy toy story documentary finale satire Anna Paquin jurassic park PlayStation BET Trailer Mudbound james bond 2020 Esquire a nightmare on elm street HBO comiccon Comic-Con@Home 2021 reboot MTV independent new york Brie Larson Amazon Studios green book canceled TV shows genre crossover Musical 24 frames Ovation nfl TV psychological thriller Holidays Academy Awards international Amazon cinemax war Vudu worst movies USA Network Valentine's Day Chernobyl composers dogs Polls and Games Star Trek Television Academy comedies TCA 2017 book Opinion 45 docuseries Rom-Com discovery halloween Awards scorecard TruTV Image Comics Emmy Nominations TV movies emmy awards 73rd Emmy Awards toronto facebook Western target Paramount art house Netflix superman 72 Emmy Awards based on movie TV One rt labs critics edition Funimation ViacomCBS GLAAD rom-coms kong venice quibi Neflix golden globe awards crime The Arrangement IFC Films travel batman remakes Acorn TV Emmys dark feel good Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt rt labs Comedy DC Comics DC Universe Marvel debate festivals NBC sequel series DC streaming service Food Network Prime Video singing competition dramedy Warner Bros. Sneak Peek mob Lucasfilm TCA Winter 2020 Classic Film Columbia Pictures Discovery Channel true crime Pop classics Freeform telelvision HBO Max