Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Silver Surfer" Trips Fantastically, "Nancy Drew" Without a Clue, "DOA" Dead on Arrival

by | June 14, 2007 | Comments

Pop quiz, hotshot: which of the lesser Roberts do you prefer? Because this Friday, it’s a match between Eric Roberts (playing the bad guy in "DOA: Dead or Alive") and Emma Roberts (title star of "Nancy Drew"). Also, there’s some arty movie about people in spandex ("Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer," starring Ioan Gruffudd and Jessica Alba). What do the critics have to say about them?

"Spider-Man" fought the symbiote, the X-Men went through the Phoenix saga, and Batman will soon fight The Joker for the first time (again). Now it’s The Fantastic Four’s turn to go through their most famous story: the Galactus crisis. In "Rise of the Silver Surfer," the molecularly enhanced quartet returns to ward off the planet-gobbling Galactus and his sporty assistant, the Silver Surfer. Critics argue that the exciting bits come only during the beginning and the climatic finale, with everything in-between featuring the same wooden acting and juvenile hijinks that pervaded the first. At 31 percent Tomatometer, "Silver Surfer" does not rise to the occasion.


"’The Shield’ kicks ‘Nip/Tuck”s ass in every way!"

After a long hiatus from the public consciousness, "Nancy Drew" is resurrected in the form of a chipper, sanguine gumshoe in Talbots. Emma Roberts stars as said Nancy, who, with some help from her friends and none from her bewildered classmates, is determined to solve a mystery that’s pickled professional dicks for decades. Though some critics are tickled by "Nancy Drew"’s jokey, laidback attitude, others take offense that the film bears little resemblance to the books, in addition to the thin characters and even-thinner central mystery. At 50 percent Tomatometer, critics are closing the case on "Nancy Drew."


Nancy Drew, borrowing the Duke Lacrosse prosecutor’s trusted handbook.

Video games and summer blockbusters have a lot in common, and the "Dead or Alive" series represents these qualities in spades: it’s repetitive, violent, and features men and women of rather fantastic proportions. I still don’t know what the games are about (I recall fighting a big ugly bird at the end of the second one), but the plot of the "Dead or Alive" movie adaptation involves hardened fighters attending a mysterious tournament run by Julia Roberts‘s brother. While some pundits were more than ready to turn off their brains for the feature, everybody else wasn’t game for the wacky plot, bad acting, or Eric Roberts’s constantly exposed paunch. "DOA" is more dead than alive at 47 percent Tomatometer.


Hot chicks + swords = boxoffice gold!

"The Trials of Darryl Hunt," a harrowing doc chronicling a rape in the American South, is at 100 percent; "Czech Dream," a doc about a grand prank in the Czech Republic, is at 88 percent; "Beyond Hatred," a reflection in documentary form from parents of a murdered 29-year old, is at 83 percent; "Gypsy Caravan," a visually appealing doc about gypsy music, is at 80 percent; "Lights in the Dusk," the latest deadpan-o-rama from Aki Kaurismäki, is at 74 percent; "Fido," a zombie spoof set in the Atomic Age, is at 70 percent (catch our interview with the "Fido" director here); "Golden Door," a lyrical drama recalling the classic Italian directors, is at 64 percent; and "Eagle vs Shark," a darkly twee romantic comedy from New Zealand, is at 47 percent.


"Lights in the Dusk," accurately recreating my last romantic date.

Tag Cloud

emmy awards japan Writers Guild of America Amazon animated spy thriller WarnerMedia Binge Guide Emmy Nominations diversity Pirates directors Apple dramedy deadpool boxoffice stand-up comedy hidden camera saw Prime Video popular streaming Captain marvel Alien breaking bad monster movies cops OWN Chernobyl South by Southwest Film Festival medical drama Action Esquire Drama Chilling Adventures of Sabrina independent 99% transformers news renewed TV shows rotten movies we love DirecTV movies Podcast dc psycho TV Lifetime facebook Grammys Premiere Dates 2016 genre TBS Shondaland Ghostbusters Nickelodeon laika Super Bowl mob Television Critics Association cinemax trophy NBC marvel comics golden globes obi wan Paramount Pictures Television Academy dragons binge Marathons Pride Month Hulu Classic Film worst Western WGN french comic books American Society of Cinematographers National Geographic doctor who Legendary SXSW Winter TV comiccon halloween tv suspense Best and Worst fast and furious spider-verse movie zero dark thirty Fox Searchlight parents politics a nightmare on elm street casting canceled TV shows VICE Winners Women's History Month Showtime stop motion miniseries new york Star Wars RT History streamig adventure obituary broadcast dceu crime thriller Schedule sag awards 1990s zombies Baby Yoda 45 Fox News ITV golden globe awards 21st Century Fox Reality Competition Crunchyroll The CW toronto nfl 73rd Emmy Awards TIFF jamie lee curtis vampires IFC Films Columbia Pictures Extras TV movies classics Opinion zombie comics Summer cults Interview Nominations superman harry potter thriller festivals Amazon Prime Video ABC name the review crime Comedy spain cats biopic based on movie cartoon dark Avengers interviews festival Britbox mutant TNT 2020 Turner Classic Movies dreamworks adenture Hollywood Foreign Press Association Film MGM feel good Emmys Biopics crossover rt labs critics edition rom-coms Kids & Family Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt book scene in color series posters indie Tumblr Pet Sematary FX wonder woman VH1 Watching Series lord of the rings superhero Horror technology spanish language spanish black GIFs 20th Century Fox 71st Emmy Awards Quiz FOX Elton John jurassic park CBS All Access cancelled MSNBC TV One best halloween The Purge high school TV Land comic book movies critics Crackle richard e. Grant Comics on TV ABC Family A24 psychological thriller foreign summer TV canceled USA Network asian-american President know your critic sports Star Wars Celebration batman First Look CMT Indigenous Fantasy Thanksgiving E3 Best Actor Anna Paquin Travel Channel aliens Paramount travel Best Actress Netflix Christmas movies Netflix kaiju international TCM Academy Awards hist Turner Acorn TV Amazon Studios Wes Anderson comedies Disney streaming service Pacific Islander Rom-Com disaster anime YouTube Red art house game show Freeform target scene in color pirates of the caribbean 2021 90s Epix japanese archives Amazon Prime Character Guide Tubi space Tags: Comedy BET Awards australia Hallmark The Academy scene in color film series trailers Sundance TV Apple TV Plus sopranos TCA 2017 Comedy Central 79th Golden Globes Awards theme song Geeked Week olympics kong television gangster Video Games Rocky Endgame true crime YA supernatural boxing Holiday TCA Awards Focus Features Logo unscripted Polls and Games San Diego Comic-Con Best Picture action-comedy Ellie Kemper Year in Review talk show History king kong women Musical historical drama book adaptation The Arrangement razzies worst movies concert summer TV preview spinoff black comedy romance blaxploitation venice Masterpiece Funimation Exclusive Video cancelled TV series Broadway Vudu Comic-Con@Home 2021 scorecard Creative Arts Emmys slashers joker Disney target VOD CNN Oscars spider-man strong female leads Nat Geo scary movies elevated horror Superheroes Disney Plus Instagram Live leaderboard comic Fall TV teaser singing competition Set visit El Rey TruTV MCU CW Seed blockbusters HBO Go documentary anthology all-time criterion Native mcc DC Universe composers Pop TV Spike Trivia YouTube Teen Reality summer preview Sci-Fi south america OneApp mission: impossible dogs Mary Tyler Moore RT21 children's TV Pixar chucky award winner SXSW 2022 debate Animation LGBTQ screenings kids 2015 Paramount Network Image Comics toy story Tarantino TCA period drama cancelled television Lifetime Christmas movies aapi 2017 Hear Us Out See It Skip It twilight The Walking Dead Sneak Peek FX on Hulu Rock Heroines Fargo Red Carpet 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Black History Month Valentine's Day BBC 72 Emmy Awards ABC Signature YouTube Premium sequel franchise 2019 vs. new zealand Sundance Now FXX Walt Disney Pictures scene in color screen actors guild SundanceTV social media video streaming movies docudrama Pop MTV hispanic heritage month IFC game of thrones cancelled TV shows HBO Max HBO rt labs DGA satire romantic comedy Syfy TLC telelvision heist movie DC Comics Mudbound Music tv talk ESPN hollywood The Witch political drama universal monsters Election GoT APB video on demand Certified Fresh ID Oscar Shudder new star wars movies justice league Disney Channel young adult robots legend Song of Ice and Fire ViacomCBS Awards Tour Lionsgate Adult Swim christmas movies Cartoon Network basketball Toys cooking 4/20 Tokyo Olympics stoner Photos Starz indiana jones Marvel science fiction films reviews Musicals Disney+ Disney Plus Discovery Channel Christmas blockbuster Bravo Lucasfilm rotten Dark Horse Comics child's play Universal BET Box Office slasher TV renewals free movies LGBT Peacock Universal Pictures dexter Sony Pictures PlayStation Black Mirror 24 frames X-Men 93rd Oscars prank biography Star Trek 007 serial killer Stephen King series war NBA SDCC DC streaming service Neflix die hard Mary poppins remakes finale nature james bond Mindy Kaling IMDb TV Paramount Plus 94th Oscars Mystery Family CBS witnail Trophy Talk Brie Larson werewolf A&E Marvel Television cars GLAAD football godzilla mockumentary ratings what to watch New York Comic Con Martial Arts Food Network 2018 Hallmark Christmas movies Cosplay latino Holidays AMC HFPA Warner Bros. Mary Poppins Returns comic book movie documentaries sitcom police drama Tomatazos critic resources docuseries First Reviews reboot italian Countdown Sundance Ovation quibi ghosts live event Spectrum Originals BBC America Awards BAFTA Cannes TCA Winter 2020 Comic Book hispanic Apple TV+ Country BBC One revenge Arrowverse The Walt Disney Company versus royal family marvel cinematic universe Trailer PBS Rocketman green book adaptation Infographic Superheroe E! rt archives crime drama natural history Marvel Studios sequels discovery Best Director scary Sony PaleyFest USA live action king arthur nbcuniversal NYCC Spring TV Film Festival fresh AMC Plus Calendar