Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Ratatouille" is Tasty, "Die Hard" is Solid, "Sicko" is Socko, "Evening" Falls

by | June 28, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies we have hungry, hungry rats ("Ratatouille," starring Patton Oswalt and Brad Garrett), a world-weary hero (Bruce Willis in "Live Free or Die Hard"), a provocateur extraordinaire ("Sicko," the new doc from Michael Moore), and a rare midsummer tearjerker ("Evening," starring Meryl Streep and Claire Danes). What do the critics have to say?

After a slight stumble with "Cars," "Ratatouille" marks a semi-return to form for Pixar. This animated flick stars Remy (voiced by Patton Oswalt), a rat whose aspirations to become a chef land him in a struggling restaurant’s kitchen, where he befriends a hapless garbage boy (Lou Romano). While critics are floored by the stunning leap in animation quality that Pixar seems to make with each movie, they’re equally impressed by "Ratatouille"’s fast pacing, memorable characters, and overall good humor. And like director Brad Bird‘s previous film, "The Incredibles," "Ratatouille" juggles themes of identity and individualism without being heavy-handed. "At 90 percent Tomatometer, the Certified Fresh "Ratatouille" is a movie to savor. (Check out RT’s interview with Patton Oswalt.)

"You like me…you really like me!"

Despite the title, the setting for the latest "Die Hard" isn’t New Hampshire; it’s Washington, D.C., where a group of super-hackers (led by Timothy Olyphant) are plotting to attack America’s computer infrastructure and bring the nation to its knees. McClane teams with a cyber geek to stop them; rousing pyrotechnics ensue. Critics say that while the plot is beyond preposterous, it’s of little matter with stunts and action this exhilarating and intense. And they also note that Bruno settles nicely into his iconic role. At 77 percent on the Tomatometer, "Live Free" is not only Certified Fresh, it’s the second-best-reviewed "Die Hard" after the original. (Check out RT’s interview with Bruce Willis here.)

Just another day at the office for McClane.

Wherever Michael Moore goes, cameras, and controversy, follow. That’s certainly the case for "Sicko"; Moore’s latest doc, which compares and contrasts our privatized health care with other health care systems abroad, has gotten him in hot water with the Bush administration over a potentially embargo-violating Cuban medical trip. But Moore is finding much love among critics, who call it a mature, humanistic film. They praise Moore’s decision to spend much of the time off-screen, allowing the events to convince and anger on their own merits. At 89 percent Tomatometer, "Sicko" is Certified Fresh and just what the doctor ordered. (Check out RT’s interview with Michael Moore.)

"Anyone know where I can get some freedom fries?"

Like so many other ambitious, richly layered novels adapted into films, "Evening" is what some critics call impossible to translate faithfully to the big screen. Assembling a dazzling cast, "Evening" stars Vanessa Redgrave as terminally ill mother who recounts to her children an affair she had as a young woman (played by Claire Danes). Critics call it a melodramatic artsy film, one that tries to go for emotional uplift, but with plot devices and character arcs that are too obvious to be genuinely affecting. At 32 percent Tomatometer, "Evening" falls and tumbles.

A few actors trying to make a quick getaway.

Also opening this week in limited release: "Ghosts of Cité Soleil," a harrowing portrait of the titular Haitian slum, is at 81 percent; "Over the GW," an autobiographical look into rehab, is at 80 percent; "In Between Days," a coming of age story with a Korean twist, is at 77 percent; and "Vitus," a drama about a young musical prodigy, is at 69 percent.

Recent Pixar Movies
76% — "Cars"
97% — "The Incredibles"
98% — "Finding Nemo"
95% — "Monster’s Inc."
100% — "Toy Story 2"

Tag Cloud

sag awards Epix Bravo movies E! Peacock Holidays Tomatazos DC Comics toronto popular Tags: Comedy VH1 slasher sequel Apple Heroines green book discovery Amazon Prime Video children's TV ABC talk show ABC Family mcc razzies comics VOD rotten movies we love Turner WGN Action black Star Trek facebook Best and Worst See It Skip It french sports NBA anthology cancelled unscripted zombies streaming diversity nbcuniversal kong spanish target art house Universal 20th Century Fox AMC MTV lord of the rings action-comedy Hollywood Foreign Press Association crime thriller Pop Extras dreamworks directors Trivia MSNBC Tumblr documentary streaming movies cinemax young adult CBS Cannes psycho Year in Review zombie batman Election Trophy Talk Universal Pictures Black History Month New York Comic Con Vudu screenings Pride Month HBO Writers Guild of America anime hispanic heritage month nfl dc festivals Video Games italian zero dark thirty new york Crunchyroll teaser renewed TV shows Polls and Games new star wars movies Film Tokyo Olympics Character Guide period drama pirates of the caribbean die hard Paramount Plus 2019 robots Grammys Marvel Television critic resources romantic comedy franchise Baby Yoda stand-up comedy rt labs critics edition legend Superheroe History SDCC GLAAD Britbox Spring TV Rom-Com Summer game of thrones romance boxing trailers vs. scene in color Mary poppins politics james bond IMDb TV Winners Family Freeform 2020 Television Critics Association blaxploitation reviews films live event USA Network spider-verse psychological thriller Lifetime asian-american Alien medical drama BBC Quiz Teen MCU E3 Paramount spinoff TCA Awards AMC Plus Acorn TV ratings DC streaming service Horror obituary Photos heist movie TV movies NBC Comedy Central new zealand godzilla boxoffice Lucasfilm Super Bowl chucky LGBT El Rey toy story TV renewals worst movies Fall TV 93rd Oscars Awards Tour Black Mirror Song of Ice and Fire hollywood 2016 adventure Film Festival 99% spain halloween The Witch witnail international Nat Geo Hallmark TV cops miniseries crime drama award winner First Reviews A&E 21st Century Fox ID Hear Us Out police drama Binge Guide laika President Logo Comics on TV comedies Biopics Thanksgiving Amazon TV One Pirates Marvel movie Elton John ghosts deadpool National Geographic supernatural Arrowverse Endgame satire ViacomCBS jurassic park GIFs Fox Searchlight 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards DirecTV First Look BBC America japan fresh Watching Series video space adaptation scorecard Countdown political drama 90s science fiction The Arrangement Nickelodeon sitcom FOX stoner Classic Film Interview Neflix Pixar blockbuster south america Comic-Con@Home 2021 Mary Tyler Moore sopranos werewolf cancelled television hispanic superman Legendary crossover rt labs concert BET Awards biography Emmy Nominations high school Image Comics WarnerMedia game show Masterpiece series christmas movies cats YA golden globe awards The Walt Disney Company HBO Max true crime Sundance Now Lionsgate Disney Plus CW Seed Amazon Prime black comedy IFC Films TruTV Fargo Tubi Apple TV+ RT21 TCA harry potter Hallmark Christmas movies dceu Sneak Peek king arthur critics football Cosplay 2018 a nightmare on elm street royal family comic book movie canceled TV shows mob Valentine's Day marvel comics Warner Bros. Shondaland Stephen King HFPA Premiere Dates king kong American Society of Cinematographers Spectrum Originals rom-coms cancelled TV series APB cooking slashers cults A24 Sci-Fi book adaptation Travel Channel The Walking Dead FX Opinion BBC One OneApp Emmys TV Land ESPN blockbusters Ovation Awards cars FXX finale monster movies parents quibi richard e. Grant Red Carpet Sony Pictures Mudbound gangster TBS Showtime comic news hist know your critic tv talk emmy awards fast and furious Oscars feel good TCA Winter 2020 Hulu animated singing competition TNT Tarantino Rocky spy thriller Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 79th Golden Globes Awards theme song classics wonder woman travel Set visit spanish language what to watch CMT universal monsters halloween tv canceled Mary Poppins Returns Walt Disney Pictures doctor who nature debate PBS Crackle Rocketman kids HBO Go archives binge book Wes Anderson Ghostbusters FX on Hulu Schedule Musicals independent indie dexter IFC australia dark docudrama YouTube basketball golden globes 2021 aliens The Purge Disney streaming service telelvision Captain marvel Pop TV breaking bad spider-man Box Office Western best Infographic Netflix Reality Competition strong female leads Avengers thriller stop motion Netflix Christmas movies docuseries comic books prank X-Men screen actors guild scary Pet Sematary Brie Larson TLC comic book movies criterion child's play Starz japanese rotten transformers Disney DGA disaster trophy VICE Podcast venice Mindy Kaling 71st Emmy Awards serial killer GoT suspense Funimation Prime Video mockumentary LGBTQ dogs 007 San Diego Comic-Con 73rd Emmy Awards superhero Disney+ Disney Plus latino PaleyFest Kids & Family twilight worst aapi documentaries Broadway RT History 4/20 Amazon Studios based on movie dragons crime TIFF SXSW USA Music ABC Signature Comedy rt archives Holiday Columbia Pictures Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt BET Star Wars Marvel Studios Certified Fresh YouTube Premium marvel cinematic universe Sundance TV remakes Discovery Channel 24 frames Ellie Kemper Nominations Rock kaiju vampires comiccon TCM Drama BAFTA Trailer Reality free movies Esquire posters casting Toys adenture CBS All Access Dark Horse Comics Television Academy Martial Arts jamie lee curtis elevated horror Exclusive Video DC Universe 2017 justice league TCA 2017 all-time mutant 2015 indiana jones Spike reboot Musical live action Fox News name the review Winter TV ITV Paramount Network technology Comic Book sequels Adult Swim social media Country genre 72 Emmy Awards Women's History Month mission: impossible The CW CNN hidden camera joker Chernobyl Calendar Animation Food Network Syfy biopic Academy Awards Cartoon Network Shudder 45 historical drama Creative Arts Emmys saw versus OWN SundanceTV Christmas composers Pacific Islander Disney Channel scary movies Turner Classic Movies Fantasy Sundance YouTube Red revenge video on demand Instagram Live Apple TV Plus NYCC foreign Superheroes Mystery festival The Academy women dramedy olympics war cancelled TV shows Lifetime Christmas movies PlayStation television 1990s natural history Anna Paquin cartoon Marathons leaderboard