Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Pirates" is Adrift, "Bug" Creepy and Crawly

by | May 24, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, it’s the pirates ("Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End," starring Johnny Depp and Keira Knightley) versus the bugs ("Bug," starring Ashley Judd). We know who’ll take the box office, but who emerges victorious with the critics?

Another week, another money-printing franchise closes its first trilogy. Johnny Depp returns as Jack Sparrow in "Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End," along with his army-sized supporting cast, boundless CGI, and about a dozen unresolved plot threads left over from "Dead Man’s Chest." Sound awesomely excessive? The critics think so too. Except for the awesome part. They contend that when it’s not exhausting the viewer with over-the-top action sequences, "At World’s End" is boring the viewer with talky scenes of exposition and strained dialogue. At 53 percent, "At World’s End" is on par with "Dead Man’s Chest," but a far cry from the original’s Certified Fresh 79 percent.

"Here’s a trick I learned from the Vulcans."

Ignoring 1990’s obscure "The Guardian," "Bug" represents director William Friedkin’s first major foray into horror since "The Exorcist." Ashley Judd stars as Agnes, a depressed waitress who holes up in a seedy motel (is there any other kind?) with an unstable war veteran who sees creepy crawlies everywhere. The critics are calling this a return to form for Friedkin. Though "Bug" descends into incomprehensibility at the end, they’re nevertheless impressed by "Bug"’s cinéma vérité camerawork and palpable dread. At 63 percent, horror and thriller fanatics should consider going buggin’ this weekend.

Judd adminsters the elbow lick challenge.

Also opening in limited release: "Paprika," an animated head trip from director Satoshi Kon, is at 92 percent; "The Boss of It All," the new black comedy from the notorious Lars von Trier, is at 92 percent; "Ten Canoes," a unique tragicomedy set among an Aboriginal tribe, is at 91 percent; "Golden Door," a romantic fable about an Italian clan coming to America, is at 60 percent; "Angel-A," likely Luc Besson’s last live action film, is at 43 percent; and "Hollywood Dreams," a comedy about a struggling actress in Tinseltown, is at 25 percent.

"Got any Nuprin? I’ve a splitting headache."

Recent Johnny Depp Movies
54% — Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest
84% — Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
83% — Tim Burton’s Corpse Bride
32% — The Libertine
46% — Secret Window

Tag Cloud

best ABC Family TV One know your critic streaming fast and furious Baby Yoda Universal Pictures Starz E3 true crime Acorn TV robots Lifetime Christmas movies Rock 45 critic resources thriller Captain marvel ITV new star wars movies comic book movies San Diego Comic-Con sitcom Martial Arts lord of the rings 99% comic books aapi renewed TV shows rom-coms jurassic park directors Podcast disaster comiccon Brie Larson Rocketman crime thriller New York Comic Con jamie lee curtis Year in Review The Purge anthology Amazon Prime crime drama movie indiana jones foreign Disney 93rd Oscars legend Lifetime franchise werewolf trophy pirates of the caribbean Drama halloween tv Heroines series Hallmark Syfy Exclusive Video Ovation Horror Toys Awards Prime Video talk show Pacific Islander boxing TV Land Cartoon Network YouTube Mary poppins Arrowverse cars USA Network Biopics 2021 71st Emmy Awards spider-verse king kong game show slashers Alien travel GoT Rom-Com Reality canceled TV shows Anna Paquin AMC ABC Signature Women's History Month Emmys 79th Golden Globes Awards Nickelodeon ABC casting aliens SDCC Interview cancelled television Esquire CW Seed Superheroes documentary Star Wars El Rey genre justice league Shudder MTV rt labs Hallmark Christmas movies target medical drama popular supernatural Neflix screen actors guild independent Discovery Channel PlayStation Comedy BET obituary saw Crunchyroll Action international Pop dexter Mystery Cosplay Reality Competition crossover Paramount theme song Spectrum Originals comedies high school deadpool NYCC HFPA young adult Peacock batman football 72 Emmy Awards spanish language cops nfl Lionsgate Funimation spanish remakes Academy Awards AMC Plus Lucasfilm 2015 olympics TV movies Western CBS Tags: Comedy docuseries unscripted Character Guide Universal Image Comics cats Superheroe Holidays YouTube Premium hispanic heist movie leaderboard worst TCM TruTV rotten marvel comics HBO Go social media action-comedy golden globes discovery Paramount Network spain 21st Century Fox vampires name the review anime Amazon Prime Video twilight versus Tokyo Olympics Opinion TV GIFs 007 television stop motion witnail 73rd Emmy Awards YouTube Red festival what to watch Sundance TV Emmy Nominations 1990s mutant hist The Academy posters HBO Britbox festivals adaptation documentaries live action Pixar kong zombies DC Comics Musical Stephen King Premiere Dates BBC One Countdown 90s Kids & Family ESPN kaiju X-Men Television Critics Association quibi 4/20 NBA worst movies Trophy Talk RT21 Sneak Peek Black Mirror game of thrones Christmas The CW latino universal monsters rt archives Family WarnerMedia toy story Masterpiece animated Comics on TV TCA Winter 2020 IFC Films razzies 2016 Rocky Red Carpet classics stoner VICE Crackle black christmas movies binge book adaptation TCA spy thriller Polls and Games BAFTA DGA dceu spider-man Teen TIFF Disney streaming service nbcuniversal SXSW serial killer Photos golden globe awards toronto Fox Searchlight American Society of Cinematographers chucky Creative Arts Emmys Dark Horse Comics child's play Amazon rt labs critics edition trailers Super Bowl History hidden camera Apple TV Plus VOD cancelled Video Games scary cults Disney Channel CMT USA basketball A24 Broadway Marvel Studios Sony Pictures Shondaland Binge Guide Freeform Animation Box Office MSNBC Best and Worst feel good FXX based on movie news gangster art house Avengers award winner Calendar cinemax National Geographic critics Infographic blockbusters joker ghosts Summer green book slasher cancelled TV series The Walking Dead Travel Channel BBC die hard Film Festival Endgame Winter TV IFC venice japanese Comedy Central sopranos DC Universe romance A&E Paramount Plus emmy awards WGN NBC comics LGBT comic book movie satire japan Elton John Ellie Kemper composers mob Bravo new zealand E! movies IMDb TV Schedule adenture FX finale Fargo PaleyFest 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards docudrama dark Disney Plus President miniseries Nat Geo Adult Swim Music superhero monster movies kids Apple 2019 doctor who harry potter HBO Max video on demand historical drama scary movies First Reviews Winners PBS women APB Trailer The Walt Disney Company sequels TLC Valentine's Day king arthur FX on Hulu south america Star Trek marvel cinematic universe TBS french war Film dogs boxoffice concert dragons richard e. Grant Turner Mudbound Epix Pet Sematary a nightmare on elm street hollywood Nominations Showtime TCA Awards VH1 Hear Us Out rotten movies we love 20th Century Fox Netflix 24 frames scene in color 2020 See It Skip It Ghostbusters fresh adventure telelvision cancelled TV shows Pirates Thanksgiving zombie Chernobyl crime BET Awards Holiday DC streaming service psychological thriller Tomatazos cooking transformers TV renewals Tumblr streaming movies Fantasy Legendary sports Cannes Grammys zero dark thirty psycho reviews archives Set visit ratings Walt Disney Pictures facebook Marvel FOX dramedy Vudu TNT singing competition period drama Watching Series political drama Warner Bros. CBS All Access diversity SundanceTV halloween ViacomCBS Comic Book natural history TCA 2017 Extras Awards Tour OneApp space canceled politics Television Academy films Oscars DirecTV Fall TV science fiction Black History Month comic BBC America cartoon police drama Quiz Mary Poppins Returns Spike Comic-Con@Home 2021 Netflix Christmas movies mockumentary parents indie Sundance Now Food Network prank biography Amazon Studios Instagram Live YA Mary Tyler Moore Apple TV+ Pop TV Pride Month children's TV mcc Sci-Fi Turner Classic Movies Wes Anderson james bond Trivia stand-up comedy 2018 book Tarantino technology asian-american Certified Fresh RT History all-time dc suspense ID Musicals vs. Fox News Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt blaxploitation Hulu italian free movies revenge Logo MCU video hispanic heritage month First Look Classic Film Marvel Television CNN mission: impossible teaser blockbuster wonder woman australia debate Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Writers Guild of America Disney+ Disney Plus black comedy Columbia Pictures screenings sequel Country reboot breaking bad spinoff Hollywood Foreign Press Association sag awards royal family scorecard Song of Ice and Fire superman biopic Tubi 2017 Mindy Kaling Marathons OWN criterion elevated horror Election LGBTQ dreamworks The Arrangement new york romantic comedy Sundance Spring TV live event laika GLAAD godzilla tv talk strong female leads The Witch nature