Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Pirates" is Adrift, "Bug" Creepy and Crawly

by | May 24, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, it’s the pirates ("Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End," starring Johnny Depp and Keira Knightley) versus the bugs ("Bug," starring Ashley Judd). We know who’ll take the box office, but who emerges victorious with the critics?

Another week, another money-printing franchise closes its first trilogy. Johnny Depp returns as Jack Sparrow in "Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End," along with his army-sized supporting cast, boundless CGI, and about a dozen unresolved plot threads left over from "Dead Man’s Chest." Sound awesomely excessive? The critics think so too. Except for the awesome part. They contend that when it’s not exhausting the viewer with over-the-top action sequences, "At World’s End" is boring the viewer with talky scenes of exposition and strained dialogue. At 53 percent, "At World’s End" is on par with "Dead Man’s Chest," but a far cry from the original’s Certified Fresh 79 percent.

"Here’s a trick I learned from the Vulcans."

Ignoring 1990’s obscure "The Guardian," "Bug" represents director William Friedkin’s first major foray into horror since "The Exorcist." Ashley Judd stars as Agnes, a depressed waitress who holes up in a seedy motel (is there any other kind?) with an unstable war veteran who sees creepy crawlies everywhere. The critics are calling this a return to form for Friedkin. Though "Bug" descends into incomprehensibility at the end, they’re nevertheless impressed by "Bug"’s cinéma vérité camerawork and palpable dread. At 63 percent, horror and thriller fanatics should consider going buggin’ this weekend.

Judd adminsters the elbow lick challenge.

Also opening in limited release: "Paprika," an animated head trip from director Satoshi Kon, is at 92 percent; "The Boss of It All," the new black comedy from the notorious Lars von Trier, is at 92 percent; "Ten Canoes," a unique tragicomedy set among an Aboriginal tribe, is at 91 percent; "Golden Door," a romantic fable about an Italian clan coming to America, is at 60 percent; "Angel-A," likely Luc Besson’s last live action film, is at 43 percent; and "Hollywood Dreams," a comedy about a struggling actress in Tinseltown, is at 25 percent.

"Got any Nuprin? I’ve a splitting headache."

Recent Johnny Depp Movies
54% — Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest
84% — Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
83% — Tim Burton’s Corpse Bride
32% — The Libertine
46% — Secret Window

Tag Cloud

Binge Guide hispanic heritage month young adult king kong toronto Hallmark Christmas movies twilight Song of Ice and Fire Star Wars Celebration Fox News Black History Month Sundance Now true crime independent Mudbound joker latino Starz Tubi french Film book adaptation HBO Go Toys based on movie dceu Amazon Prime Video Avengers South by Southwest Film Festival vs. 2020 universal monsters docudrama rotten RT21 sports Super Bowl directors christmas movies AMC suspense Arrowverse 007 Hulu TCM Mary Poppins Returns nature aliens toy story New York Comic Con obi wan Comic-Con@Home 2021 Creative Arts Emmys Martial Arts unscripted Winners Ellie Kemper X-Men romance Musicals Mary poppins dreamworks 73rd Emmy Awards Alien DC streaming service PaleyFest politics Women's History Month genre remakes Hollywood Foreign Press Association Paramount boxoffice TCA Awards Marvel renewed TV shows summer TV First Look medical drama screenings kaiju Rock cults indiana jones 2021 94th Oscars Star Wars Shudder 90s women aapi elevated horror science fiction disaster Baby Yoda Paramount Network Warner Bros. Esquire Best Picture Red Carpet Black Mirror YouTube Red Best Director Best Actress Sony Pictures Nominations football Walt Disney Pictures Pet Sematary monster movies Schedule Pacific Islander Trophy Talk Heroines Marathons legend TV crossover MCU WarnerMedia Disney+ Disney Plus crime thriller Podcast CW Seed Bravo trophy HBO Max Dark Horse Comics E3 TBS binge spanish richard e. Grant know your critic die hard Marvel Studios WGN mockumentary Pop TV hist Pop TV renewals Writers Guild of America Western werewolf Logo Fall TV criterion Instagram Live finale batman olympics what to watch Spike Amazon Prime festival Amazon Studios rt labs critics edition Prime Video comedies Biopics cinemax BET Awards reviews international spider-man ViacomCBS Marvel Television worst golden globes The CW black comedy social media Neflix classics comic book movie AMC Plus DGA stop motion anthology IFC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt trailers facebook Fantasy BET YouTube halloween slasher gangster Rom-Com spinoff TV movies Apple Musical 79th Golden Globes Awards Country ghosts Crunchyroll Sneak Peek CMT Reality free movies Showtime Polls and Games obituary Britbox crime drama worst movies deadpool Acorn TV Certified Fresh franchise Pirates Television Academy mob Holiday spider-verse golden globe awards 4/20 sag awards justice league scorecard canceled President jurassic park DC Universe thriller Rocky archives BBC America Columbia Pictures Comic Book dragons game of thrones MSNBC TV Land Fox Searchlight kong canceled TV shows Video Games fast and furious TCA Winter 2020 a nightmare on elm street broadcast rotten movies we love heist movie MTV National Geographic El Rey Peacock Awards Tour rt archives Legendary Travel Channel Horror Freeform Native cartoon OneApp natural history Opinion vampires critic resources cars LGBTQ The Arrangement APB History documentaries Classic Film Ghostbusters Food Network BBC Box Office ABC Valentine's Day teaser quibi best blaxploitation superman Hallmark Teen boxing MGM action-comedy ratings news ABC Signature VOD Awards First Reviews versus book BAFTA adenture 24 frames Indigenous Universal Pictures scene in color film series pirates of the caribbean Character Guide 72 Emmy Awards comic book movies The Walking Dead Television Critics Association australia Tomatazos Adult Swim casting spy thriller lord of the rings FXX art house video on demand HFPA Sony CBS Premiere Dates Mindy Kaling Anna Paquin CBS All Access romantic comedy blockbusters new york live event Geeked Week Ovation Election posters Masterpiece Oscar NBA 2019 festivals docuseries harry potter FX Trailer Lifetime 2017 zombies Set visit hidden camera Netflix cops Captain marvel anime streaming movies prank The Witch Turner emmy awards Sundance comic concert dogs FX on Hulu comic books comiccon sopranos VICE San Diego Comic-Con black foreign Comedy reboot Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Elton John Reality Competition animated laika Comedy Central TIFF 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards nfl Cosplay robots south america Fargo Syfy jamie lee curtis james bond The Walt Disney Company parents venice IFC Films Animation live action Rocketman sequels Photos crime Lucasfilm marvel cinematic universe spanish language wonder woman 99% godzilla zombie movies Lifetime Christmas movies TruTV chucky Wes Anderson dramedy RT History streamig Universal ITV 21st Century Fox Disney Grammys scary cancelled TV series Epix FOX Star Trek YA GLAAD Crackle psycho Discovery Channel slashers talk show marvel comics rom-coms Disney streaming service American Society of Cinematographers critics fresh cancelled TV shows cats Cartoon Network Christmas Focus Features See It Skip It video serial killer diversity TLC transformers scene in color series Emmys discovery period drama rt labs superhero scary movies political drama BBC One mcc Film Festival Best Actor award winner tv talk Oscars comics 1990s Infographic witnail Academy Awards 71st Emmy Awards Lionsgate Tokyo Olympics Image Comics Emmy Nominations Shondaland Apple TV Plus GIFs police drama DC Comics streaming halloween tv Calendar Spring TV television italian Extras Tags: Comedy Best and Worst japan Winter TV series king arthur adaptation Chernobyl hollywood The Academy A&E biography children's TV Thanksgiving Exclusive Video 93rd Oscars name the review Holidays hispanic documentary telelvision 2015 YouTube Premium Superheroes satire Nat Geo travel Watching Series Tumblr war mission: impossible feel good kids VH1 USA Network supernatural Vudu summer preview GoT zero dark thirty nbcuniversal screen actors guild TCA 2017 Music asian-american 2018 green book dark Paramount Plus Tarantino 45 high school Spectrum Originals japanese royal family Pride Month Pixar Hear Us Out Netflix Christmas movies Mystery Kids & Family Action E! technology movie Paramount Pictures doctor who stand-up comedy summer TV preview miniseries SXSW 2022 dexter Disney Channel breaking bad DirecTV Apple TV+ 2016 ID SundanceTV Sci-Fi Nickelodeon Family saw 20th Century Fox stoner psychological thriller Quiz PlayStation NBC indie leaderboard theme song Drama TNT Countdown new star wars movies IMDb TV interviews new zealand ESPN A24 Mary Tyler Moore target scene in color SDCC TV One USA Superheroe game show blockbuster singing competition Amazon popular ABC Family SXSW Funimation OWN Summer HBO composers spain cancelled television Year in Review Trivia strong female leads sitcom Sundance TV Interview Brie Larson Cannes all-time cooking sequel child's play LGBT Broadway Turner Classic Movies Stephen King CNN The Purge space scene in color target dc historical drama razzies mutant Disney Plus debate Endgame TCA films adventure PBS NYCC basketball Comics on TV cancelled revenge biopic