Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Ocean's Thirteen" Is Slick And Fun; "Hostel" Is Worth A Visit: "Surf's Up" Is Tubular

by | June 7, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got smooth criminals ("Ocean’s Thirteen," starring George Clooney, Brad Pitt, and Matt Damon); ill-fated vacationers ("Hostel: Part II," starring Bijou Phillips and Heather Matarazzo); and surfing penguins ("Surf’s Up," with voice work from Jon Heder and Shia LaBeouf). What do the critics have to say?

For those who dig stargazing, "Ocean’s Eleven" must have seemed like a gift from heaven. Featuring George Clooney, Brad Pitt, Matt Damon, Julia Roberts, and Don Cheadle, and directed by the always interesting Steven Soderbergh, it was a heist movie with some good laughs and a sleek design. "Ocean’s Twelve" may have been of a trifle, but it got by on the sheer fun of watching a bunch of big name stars having a good time. Now the gang is back with "Ocean’s Thirteen," and critics say it’s loaded with the same stylish, unpretentious charm as the first two. This time, the crew plots to undermine a big-time casino mogul, played by Al Pacino, who swindled one of the gang. "Ocean’s Thirteen" may not be the height of cinematic profundity, but pundits say it’s a slick, entertaining piece of mainstream entertainment. At 70 percent, this one is a lucky "Thirteen." However, it’s still a notch below the original (original remake?), which stands at 81 percent.

Alternate scene take from "Garden State."

With the release of "Saw" and "Hostel," critics devised a label for the sub-genre of particularly grisly slasher flicks: torture porn. Within this sub-set, Eli Roth is emerging as an auteur; in addition to his howlingly funny (and completely depraved) fake trailer for "Thanksgiving" in "Grindhouse," Roth brings us "Hostel: Part II." Yet again, American college students fall into the clutches of sicko Europeans obsessed with torture. Critics say that while many will be repulsed by what they see (if they see "Hostel: Part II" at all), Roth’s filmmaking craftsmanship has markedly improved, with better developed characters and some sly political commentary — in addition to oodles of gore. But other critics say Roth’s work is still in service to brutally disgusting material. "Hostel: Part II" is at 64 percent on the Tomatometer.

"I’m trying a new method today. I call it ‘Uwe Boll Marathon.’"

Can’t get enough of cinematic penguins? How about animated penguins? Well, if "March of the Penguins" and "Happy Feet" didn’t sate your appetite for the antics of those well-dressed, flightless residents of Antarctica, now comes "Surf’s Up." Sort of a "Waiting for Guffman" for the kiddie set, the movie goes behind the scenes — mockumentary style — at the Penguin World Surfing Championships, where young upstart Cody Maverick (voiced by Shia LaBeouf) hopes to make a splash. The critics say many of the gags will soar like eagles over the heads of the little ones, but "Surf’s Up" is a laid-back, witty frolic. At 72 percent on the Tomatomter, "Surf’s Up" is pretty tubular, dude.

"And I got this from a Magic: The Gathering tourney."

Also opening this week in limited release: "12:08 East of Bucharest," a wry comedy about the fall of communism in Romania, is at 100 percent on the Tomatometer; "Your Mommy Kills Animals," a doc about the animal rights movement, is at 100 percent; "La Vie En Rose," a biopic about the French chanteuse Edith Piaf, is at 83 percent (check out Jen Yamato’s mini review here); "You’re Gonna Miss Me," a doc about the eccentric 13th Floor Elevators singer Roky Erickson, is at 71 percent; and "Belle Toujours," the latest from Portuguese master (and nonagenarian) Manoel de Oliveira, is at 71 percent.

Roky knows how we roll.

Recent Steven Soderbergh Movies:
33% — The Good German (2006)
69% — Bubble (2006)
55% — Ocean’s Twelve (2004)
64% — Solaris (2002)
36% — Full Frontal (2002)

Tag Cloud

Disney+ Disney Plus live event El Rey 45 Best Director HFPA Mary Poppins Returns BET The Purge vampires TCM Neflix cats strong female leads mission: impossible CBS All Access crossover summer preview President Musical Focus Features directors FX on Hulu Emmys 24 frames Mary Tyler Moore Rock American Society of Cinematographers 93rd Oscars Awards 2017 Rocky E! children's TV science fiction Lucasfilm natural history quibi sag awards crime thriller nfl Comedy interviews basketball free movies deadpool adaptation Country mcc Polls and Games The Academy critic resources 1990s hispanic Election 79th Golden Globes Awards The Walking Dead fresh Best Picture Showtime australia Television Academy 20th Century Fox zombie TNT historical drama Britbox game of thrones Kids & Family Sci-Fi Pop trophy king kong dexter IFC Films south america twilight Paramount Pictures Holidays SXSW Countdown toy story Hear Us Out romantic comedy CBS Photos PaleyFest Martial Arts adenture sequel cooking Women's History Month venice YouTube game show cancelled TV shows hidden camera halloween tv Instagram Live target scene in color golden globe awards SDCC Western Elton John cults NYCC DirecTV Watching Series Comic-Con@Home 2021 comiccon target Box Office Valentine's Day book adaptation NBA asian-american Trivia Cartoon Network classics Baby Yoda Writers Guild of America Set visit AMC Plus broadcast Universal TV movies adventure green book nature satire Creative Arts Emmys Sundance Now godzilla Freeform GLAAD biopic 71st Emmy Awards OWN crime serial killer Fall TV nbcuniversal Opinion singing competition cancelled TV series 99% HBO Max Hulu IMDb TV WarnerMedia sports dark revenge legend Video Games police drama spanish batman 2016 Comic Book boxoffice spider-man Anna Paquin new zealand Disney Channel spain Universal Pictures FX Film dragons black comedy Spectrum Originals slashers worst movies summer TV preview elevated horror Netflix E3 kaiju zero dark thirty Amazon OneApp 2018 Native stop motion TruTV Teen TV Crunchyroll Hallmark psychological thriller Classic Film See It Skip It cops emmy awards heist movie A&E stoner justice league unscripted pirates of the caribbean black APB sitcom Apple TV+ Fantasy MSNBC indie DC Universe Trophy Talk Disney streaming service political drama supernatural trailers dc japanese Columbia Pictures documentary PBS travel TCA Walt Disney Pictures Arrowverse Oscars CNN scorecard posters BBC America 4/20 Best Actress psycho Pixar spinoff The Walt Disney Company TV One New York Comic Con best docuseries Mary poppins hollywood blockbusters Sundance TV Star Trek genre Legendary kong Binge Guide ABC Family Warner Bros. video on demand robots Pop TV streamig Nat Geo Funimation Ovation cancelled TCA 2017 Wes Anderson Tokyo Olympics Tarantino social media Adult Swim hispanic heritage month Pride Month Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Star Wars Celebration blockbuster Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt films Musicals scary reviews all-time richard e. Grant Turner Classic Movies BBC comics saw Shudder space art house live action Comics on TV hist cancelled television MTV 2019 Stephen King gangster A24 Superheroes italian stand-up comedy mob Marvel anime chucky TV renewals finale Tubi boxing dogs what to watch mockumentary Tags: Comedy Prime Video jurassic park Mudbound Hallmark Christmas movies james bond YouTube Premium DC Comics theme song period drama remakes festival USA versus comedies BET Awards SXSW 2022 Amazon Prime Video doctor who indiana jones toronto Toys RT History Turner Mystery Heroines History HBO Go die hard Rom-Com Best Actor comic streaming Star Wars PlayStation technology scene in color series Calendar cars summer TV VICE young adult Starz tv talk Fox News 73rd Emmy Awards Paramount politics Infographic Nickelodeon scary movies video medical drama Shondaland Sony Pictures comic book movies Spring TV composers ghosts vs. First Look ITV monster movies casting independent archives LGBTQ marvel cinematic universe facebook diversity telelvision GIFs Christmas Amazon Prime Lionsgate DGA YouTube Red Horror mutant IFC Discovery Channel Brie Larson USA Network sequels Comedy Central Acorn TV Apple TV Plus true crime reboot GoT aliens name the review concert TBS Certified Fresh jamie lee curtis YA RT21 documentaries Pacific Islander Netflix Christmas movies CW Seed crime drama women 2020 Travel Channel renewed TV shows Broadway WGN Action Marathons Avengers movies franchise Crackle Lifetime Christmas movies BAFTA action-comedy BBC One Music Summer halloween Extras critics zombies fast and furious know your critic talk show Vudu The Witch TCA Awards Dark Horse Comics comic books ViacomCBS Tomatazos international docudrama book Black History Month news rt labs critics edition series Masterpiece based on movie streaming movies canceled TV shows Song of Ice and Fire Exclusive Video spider-verse Animation Winners Academy Awards Hollywood Foreign Press Association a nightmare on elm street Syfy ID Esquire The Arrangement Family scene in color film series VOD suspense Black Mirror dreamworks television First Reviews Thanksgiving Disney Plus Drama Biopics Apple LGBT movie ratings werewolf award winner royal family FXX rotten movies we love Nominations discovery Emmy Nominations disaster breaking bad 94th Oscars new star wars movies Disney football popular Super Bowl rotten Trailer prank screenings marvel comics christmas movies festivals Awards Tour Spike golden globes Podcast Year in Review leaderboard VH1 ABC Signature Mindy Kaling Reality Competition AMC 007 lord of the rings sopranos worst rt labs 2021 Peacock Captain marvel ABC Pet Sematary Marvel Television kids anthology latino biography Bravo Superheroe razzies Ghostbusters Premiere Dates Schedule laika romance animated San Diego Comic-Con debate superman new york olympics witnail high school miniseries Red Carpet NBC Indigenous dramedy cinemax Rocketman universal monsters Sony HBO ESPN slasher thriller Sneak Peek Television Critics Association TCA Winter 2020 Amazon Studios superhero 21st Century Fox parents 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards feel good Marvel Studios Film Festival 72 Emmy Awards Oscar Interview rom-coms Winter TV japan french Food Network Lifetime spanish language scene in color war dceu MCU Chernobyl Image Comics Paramount Network Cannes harry potter TIFF Character Guide canceled Grammys TLC wonder woman spy thriller 2015 CMT Cosplay Reality Alien binge Fargo comic book movie Logo cartoon South by Southwest Film Festival criterion blaxploitation National Geographic Best and Worst child's play X-Men Holiday Quiz TV Land SundanceTV FOX Geeked Week Endgame MGM foreign joker obituary DC streaming service Tumblr screen actors guild Ellie Kemper transformers teaser 90s rt archives aapi Pirates obi wan Sundance king arthur Fox Searchlight Epix The CW Paramount Plus