Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Norbit" Is Flabby; "Hannibal Rising" Isn't That Tasty

by | February 8, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a nerd with an overbearing fiancée ("Norbit," starring Eddie Murphy) and the early days of Hannibal Lecter ("Hannibal Rising," starring Gaspard Ulliel and Gong Li). What do the critics have to say?

Eddie Murphy’s searing, Oscar-nominated performance as a James Brown-esque soul singer in "Dreamgirls" may be the venerable star’s best work to date. So, what does he do for an encore? "Norbit," a film that critics say is as lowbrow as the day is long. Murphy plays three roles (a nerdy guy, his incredibly brash and obese significant other, and his Asian-American adoptive father), a strategy that paid off in the "Nutty Professor" movies. Does it work this time? Not really, say critics; though Murphy gives it his all, the material is crass and largely unfunny. At 21 percent on the Tomatometer, "Norbit" is not phat.

Eddie Murphy gets in touch with nature.

As Hannibal Lecter, Anthony Hopkins created one of the most iconic villains in the movies, a character so morally repugnant and yet so brilliant that audiences could only imagine what was going on inside his head. "Hannibal Rising" is an attempt at explanation. As it turns out, young Dr. Lecter (Gaspard Ulliel) went through a lot: he was orphaned, his sister suffered a horrible fate, and he became hell-bent on revenge. The problem with "Hannibal Rising," say critics, is not the direction, as Peter Webber creates an eerie, sinister mood throughout. The scribes say that explaining Hannibal’s motivations reduces the character to a collection of dime-store psychological traits. At 16 percent on the Tomatometer, "Hannibal Rising" isn’t much of a cinematic feast.

Underage drinking will lead to other problems in life.

Also opening this week in limited release: "The Lives of Others," a thriller set during the paranoid days of the East German regime (and a Best Foreign Film Oscar Nominee), is at 93 percent; "The Decomposition of the Soul," a documentary about the tactics of the East German secret police, is at 67 percent; "Burning Annie," an indie comedy about a college kid obsessed with "Annie Hall," is at 29 percent; and "The Last Sin Eater," the tale of a young girl’s search for absolution, is at 17 percent.

Praying for a better Tomatometer.

And finally, mad props to bribios for correctly guessing "The Messengers"’ Tomatometer of 14 percent. Excellent work, bribios.

Recent Eddie Murphy Movies:
79% — Dreamgirls (2006)
88% — Shrek 2 (2004)
14% — The Haunted Mansion (2003)
29% — Daddy Day Care (2003)
17% — I Spy (2002)

Hannibal Lecter Movies:
68% — Red Dragon (2002)
37% — Hannibal (2001)
95% — The Silence of the Lambs (1991)
94% — Manhunter (1986)

Tag Cloud

VH1 basketball VICE TV One know your critic WGN debate Avengers prank 99% all-time cancelled TV shows Wes Anderson deadpool japan joker sag awards 73rd Emmy Awards Character Guide films dexter FX name the review PBS Musicals slashers Pixar Spectrum Originals Trivia boxing Opinion TruTV GLAAD medical drama psycho Cannes comedies sports pirates of the caribbean TIFF YouTube Premium asian-american TCA 2017 BET Awards crossover Instagram Live twilight TNT godzilla Disney Marvel Television 21st Century Fox AMC Plus DGA halloween 2015 live action king kong ABC Signature cancelled TV series Mary Poppins Returns supernatural Horror NBA Academy Awards Tokyo Olympics Fantasy fresh Superheroe 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards kids toy story Video Games 72 Emmy Awards Marvel Studios LGBTQ documentaries dragons stand-up comedy Black Mirror Rocketman FOX blockbuster award winner docudrama blockbusters worst movies hispanic festival hidden camera Acorn TV superhero Hallmark video YouTube zombies Winners international Paramount Network rotten ESPN Prime Video movies Mindy Kaling book adaptation streaming cooking sequel superman scary movies romantic comedy Fall TV Amazon Prime Video james bond batman The Academy YouTube Red green book adenture IFC dc biography 2020 Vudu GoT Comics on TV Superheroes dceu transformers 1990s Quiz Turner Christmas elevated horror critic resources series Tarantino ITV Television Academy australia ghosts Super Bowl screen actors guild Writers Guild of America Lifetime Christmas movies Star Trek SDCC die hard Star Wars 79th Golden Globes Awards zombie BBC America Cartoon Network gangster chucky E! rom-coms Holiday women E3 game of thrones Lifetime A24 festivals composers marvel cinematic universe MTV free movies rotten movies we love Baby Yoda slasher Apple TV Plus Trailer japanese Fox Searchlight Pride Month Extras movie Rom-Com Apple TV+ unscripted NYCC italian Musical Legendary DirecTV period drama spy thriller SXSW IMDb TV spider-man nature video on demand Sundance Now San Diego Comic-Con social media obituary Trophy Talk cancelled new star wars movies Fargo thriller Classic Film TCA Winter 2020 CBS finale stoner razzies remakes Travel Channel Creative Arts Emmys New York Comic Con science fiction cops The Arrangement comic book movies Certified Fresh game show spanish Photos Brie Larson classics 2021 justice league sopranos anthology live event black Sundance TV Pirates spider-verse GIFs Biopics Crackle Dark Horse Comics Epix political drama anime disaster adaptation Disney Channel Pet Sematary french Shudder History 007 Rock action-comedy children's TV jurassic park 2016 reviews ABC Family versus wonder woman Awards Tour Showtime TCA Awards worst venice Cosplay 4/20 binge Amazon Prime mockumentary feel good universal monsters concert BET Syfy TLC Arrowverse Pop TV YA streaming movies Crunchyroll Amazon comic books Tags: Comedy BAFTA Grammys scene in color Best and Worst Britbox MSNBC independent emmy awards Election mutant Disney streaming service TV renewals Country 93rd Oscars Schedule 24 frames cars miniseries high school Turner Classic Movies Spike Interview christmas movies Adult Swim Starz Comedy Central teaser Watching Series Elton John Sneak Peek monster movies target Comic Book spinoff Winter TV trailers screenings Family TCM Logo politics BBC One HBO Go fast and furious American Society of Cinematographers First Look crime thriller dreamworks best 2018 The Purge foreign Columbia Pictures adventure telelvision National Geographic Walt Disney Pictures legend dogs Heroines Endgame Ghostbusters hist Marvel Lionsgate Captain marvel nfl jamie lee curtis PaleyFest Sci-Fi Chernobyl RT History Fox News football Sundance Box Office reboot CW Seed 45 Reality Competition Reality IFC Films President hollywood The Walking Dead WarnerMedia Music dramedy sitcom travel Tomatazos strong female leads new york El Rey ABC natural history 20th Century Fox FX on Hulu FXX historical drama vampires BBC theme song Ovation PlayStation Freeform golden globe awards Comic-Con@Home 2021 Disney Plus Mary poppins Drama RT21 Television Critics Association satire black comedy kaiju cinemax Funimation Nat Geo comiccon VOD trophy rt labs critics edition archives Netflix Christmas movies serial killer war latino Kids & Family Mudbound cartoon cults psychological thriller 90s book Infographic USA 2019 APB indiana jones royal family Western CBS All Access Alien CNN animated heist movie nbcuniversal art house news Summer mission: impossible ID critics new zealand genre Apple technology Emmy Nominations HBO lord of the rings Food Network space Black History Month harry potter AMC Calendar Image Comics First Reviews Peacock witnail stop motion rt labs aliens scary Spring TV Holidays mcc See It Skip It a nightmare on elm street discovery parents Paramount Disney+ Disney Plus Film Festival spanish language richard e. Grant comic talk show werewolf crime drama HBO Max Thanksgiving 2017 franchise docuseries Podcast quibi MCU olympics tv talk DC Comics Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Year in Review NBC Hear Us Out Hollywood Foreign Press Association Paramount Plus Film zero dark thirty Animation vs. TV Land Nickelodeon mob romance Song of Ice and Fire DC Universe revenge Bravo hispanic heritage month LGBT Mystery The Witch OWN true crime saw comic book movie Pop USA Network Pacific Islander Hulu TV movies television cats HFPA rt archives based on movie leaderboard Netflix Awards CMT Marathons robots toronto crime Premiere Dates Chilling Adventures of Sabrina singing competition diversity marvel comics aapi doctor who sequels Hallmark Christmas movies Exclusive Video blaxploitation Warner Bros. facebook Tumblr indie Valentine's Day golden globes SundanceTV scorecard Red Carpet what to watch Lucasfilm Anna Paquin kong Nominations suspense A&E casting canceled south america Discovery Channel Comedy directors Martial Arts police drama 71st Emmy Awards Polls and Games TCA Amazon Studios breaking bad documentary Shondaland The Walt Disney Company posters Esquire boxoffice criterion Set visit Universal ViacomCBS DC streaming service Countdown Broadway child's play Women's History Month Rocky canceled TV shows comics OneApp TBS Sony Pictures popular cancelled television spain Teen Toys Neflix ratings halloween tv The CW Universal Pictures Tubi Oscars Emmys Stephen King Binge Guide young adult Masterpiece king arthur biopic Mary Tyler Moore TV X-Men laika Ellie Kemper renewed TV shows Action dark