Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: Mighty Thrills, Spartan Plot In "300"; "Gift" Doesn't Keep On Giving

by | March 8, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got 300 mighty Spartans ("300," starring Gerard Butler) and a reluctant do-gooder ("The Ultimate Gift," starring Abigail Breslin). What do the critics have to say?

Fangirls and fanboys, the wait is over. "300," Zack Snyder’s CG adaptation of Frank Miller‘s cult graphic novel sensation is here. And while critics say it’s a feast for the eyes, many note it’s slightly less a delight for the brain. "300" tells the tale of the ancient Battle of Thermopylae, in which 300 Spartans fought a star-crossed battle against the heavily fortified Persian army. Subtlety is not the order of the day here, nor is slavish attention to historical detail, but the pundits say the movie is visually sumptuous, a spectacle of ultraviolence and visceral thrills. However, others say "300" takes itself seriously to the point of self parody, and lacks compelling characters and cohesive plotting. "300" is currently at 60 percent on the Tomatometer.

Because "Anticipate Defeat!" was less rousing.

"The Ultimate Gift" is a movie about learning the true meaning of wealth, and stepping outside one’s self centered existence. These are good lessons to learn, but critics say the movie, while likeable, is too sappy to fully register. "The Ultimate Gift" tells the story of a trust fund kid who stands to inherit the fortune of his recently deceased grandfather — but only after he completes a series of tasks, which include living on the streets, doing manual labor, and being nice to people. Critics say "The Ultimate Gift" is sweet, heartfelt, and well-meaning — but also schmaltzy and dramatically inert. At 35 percent on the Tomatometer, this may not be the "Ultimate" viewing experience.

"’Silverado’ was 20 years ago. You can change clothes now."

Also opening this week in limited release: the South Korean import "The Host," a monster movie/satire/family drama, is at 94 percent; "Maxed Out," a doc that takes on the credit card industry, is at 85 percent; "Beyond the Gates," a drama about a teacher caught up in the Rwandan genocide starring John Hurt and Hugh Dancy, is at 71 percent; "The Namesake," a drama about a family caught between two cultural worlds starring Kal Penn and Jacinda Barrett, is at 70 percent; and "Exterminating Angels," a French drama about voyeurism and taboos, is at 52 pecent.

"KBBL’s going to give me something stupid!"

Recent Historical Epics:
65% — Apocalypto (2006)
39% — Kingdom of Heaven (2005)
16% — Alexander (2004)
55% — Troy (2004)
78% — Gladiator (2000)

Tag Cloud

pirates of the caribbean 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards dexter versus worst saw what to watch Black Mirror politics Television Critics Association TCA name the review composers Heroines golden globe awards Premiere Dates Fox Searchlight Comic-Con@Home 2021 TV Land animated gangster streaming crime drama Academy Awards hidden camera Mary poppins aapi mission: impossible Universal live event zombie suspense emmy awards venice 2020 VH1 BBC America universal monsters Marvel Television child's play thriller discovery spider-man comic book movies boxoffice History Cosplay Box Office Prime Video doctor who Broadway technology renewed TV shows Columbia Pictures spinoff 71st Emmy Awards Reality Competition satire PBS chucky Awards Tour Peacock Star Trek Alien popular Sneak Peek Classic Film Women's History Month romance Disney Channel cults HFPA dogs Rock Rom-Com IFC Films American Society of Cinematographers movies Trailer Election documentaries RT21 2021 Nat Geo Certified Fresh Trivia Rocky Hulu Epix marvel comics Cartoon Network Holiday best Western critics ABC Family reviews AMC BET Awards Nominations Music marvel cinematic universe blockbuster godzilla Pride Month Crunchyroll reboot Sony Pictures kids war jamie lee curtis strong female leads book adaptation Sundance Now Superheroes The Walt Disney Company CNN PaleyFest Funimation know your critic debate Legendary nfl 2016 Amazon Studios hispanic heritage month zero dark thirty Video Games vampires superhero Chernobyl National Geographic BAFTA dreamworks Crackle spider-verse Cannes Travel Channel Watching Series Action 45 USA harry potter breaking bad Thanksgiving Song of Ice and Fire Fargo prank parents natural history TV One Ghostbusters Apple TV+ historical drama nature dc TV movies 93rd Oscars kaiju BBC One Drama mockumentary Spike rotten hispanic comic book movie football Winners HBO Go game of thrones Quiz witnail Marvel Studios Nickelodeon DirecTV 2015 teaser SundanceTV women Tokyo Olympics scorecard ratings sag awards Binge Guide First Look halloween tv feel good The CW Logo mutant cancelled TV shows Tumblr biography Biopics legend Pop Emmys CBS Opinion FXX deadpool casting Paramount Network The Walking Dead genre New York Comic Con werewolf spanish mob Instagram Live E3 24 frames Comics on TV fast and furious ITV Baby Yoda USA Network transformers streaming movies Avengers foreign twilight MSNBC Film Festival films jurassic park GIFs The Witch french Fox News adventure Countdown rt labs critics edition Walt Disney Pictures boxing TBS vs. medical drama high school Food Network scene in color Marathons spanish language President Paramount theme song Lionsgate The Arrangement cancelled period drama screen actors guild Extras batman Disney streaming service facebook sports Pacific Islander Hear Us Out festival Brie Larson heist movie TLC Teen worst movies Mindy Kaling DC Universe children's TV science fiction robots The Purge Mudbound TNT BBC psychological thriller serial killer Apple TV Plus Shudder Spectrum Originals Ovation Ellie Kemper Kids & Family E! crime thriller finale Valentine's Day Chilling Adventures of Sabrina quibi Black History Month Lucasfilm Infographic Dark Horse Comics diversity Holidays laika travel spain 2019 space Sci-Fi christmas movies blaxploitation superman Amazon Prime black comedy Esquire video based on movie Pop TV Animation Vudu ViacomCBS tv talk MCU Red Carpet Britbox Tarantino Winter TV adaptation Mary Poppins Returns Schedule aliens Tubi Spring TV Interview comedies australia Photos Mary Tyler Moore A24 remakes die hard green book action-comedy cops TIFF ABC Signature nbcuniversal justice league YA king kong Comedy anthology asian-american 2017 NBC DC Comics stop motion young adult Fall TV rotten movies we love Star Wars obituary Television Academy Hallmark Grammys a nightmare on elm street lord of the rings cancelled television TruTV ghosts Amazon Prime Video Turner Classic Movies SDCC Captain marvel Musical Family FOX slasher olympics new york Warner Bros. richard e. Grant festivals kong TCA 2017 cartoon black APB independent BET Best and Worst rt labs posters 72 Emmy Awards political drama Disney Trophy Talk binge Tomatazos Oscars 73rd Emmy Awards Disney Plus dark leaderboard canceled Set visit comic elevated horror true crime Syfy Lifetime San Diego Comic-Con YouTube HBO razzies Emmy Nominations stand-up comedy AMC Plus crossover monster movies 99% Exclusive Video docuseries hist halloween joker sitcom Discovery Channel cooking Hallmark Christmas movies revenge Adult Swim comics TCA Awards 4/20 romantic comedy james bond DC streaming service Netflix Christmas movies Turner police drama YouTube Red Universal Pictures king arthur 20th Century Fox OneApp Writers Guild of America Year in Review Podcast NBA Character Guide Summer all-time First Reviews SXSW television Wes Anderson live action royal family Amazon Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TCA Winter 2020 scary movies Pirates Acorn TV A&E singing competition ESPN basketball comiccon cancelled TV series Horror Calendar IFC Rocketman TV renewals TCM MTV The Academy book wonder woman news award winner Pet Sematary talk show YouTube Premium new star wars movies 79th Golden Globes Awards trophy sopranos NYCC Masterpiece docudrama Paramount Plus PlayStation toronto blockbusters supernatural slashers dramedy new zealand TV Hollywood Foreign Press Association IMDb TV Film video on demand Creative Arts Emmys DGA critic resources CBS All Access sequels Christmas GoT dragons 2018 Superheroe Polls and Games Marvel CW Seed VOD ABC trailers Lifetime Christmas movies Mystery screenings toy story LGBTQ El Rey VICE telelvision Anna Paquin HBO Max japan Comedy Central Tags: Comedy archives 21st Century Fox Neflix franchise Stephen King free movies Showtime japanese mcc spy thriller RT History movie target disaster See It Skip It Musicals cinemax golden globes Sundance OWN Image Comics 007 series WarnerMedia GLAAD Toys directors cats social media criterion hollywood 90s X-Men sequel FX on Hulu indie crime Apple south america anime concert Reality classics LGBT Comic Book rom-coms art house Fantasy Bravo Country canceled TV shows Freeform adenture Starz latino Pixar miniseries Sundance TV biopic documentary stoner zombies Endgame Arrowverse cars FX rt archives Shondaland 1990s comic books Awards psycho indiana jones Netflix Martial Arts scary Super Bowl Elton John fresh international CMT game show WGN italian unscripted dceu Disney+ Disney Plus ID