Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Knocked Up" Is A Knockout; "Mr. Brooks," "Gracie" Less So

by | May 31, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies we’ve got matters of life ("Knocked Up," starring Katherine Heigl and Seth Rogen), death ("Mr. Brooks," starring Kevin Costner and Demi Moore), and soccer ("Gracie," starring Elisabeth Shue). What do the critics have to say?

When director Judd Apatow titles a movie, you always know what to expect. Like, what else could something called "The 40-Year-Old-Virgin" possibly have been about? And Apatow’s newest flick, "Knocked Up," is just as bluntly advertised: a perpetually stoned schlub (Seth Rogen) impregnates a woman way out of his league (Katherine Heigl) after a one-night stand, putting the kibosh on his arrested development. But, like "Virgin," "Knocked" has a sweetness and depth that extends well beyong most comedies; critics call it a hilarious, poignant, and refreshing look at the rigors of courtship and child-rearing, with a sometimes raunchy, always witty script that is ably acted and directed. At 88 percent on the Tomatometer, "Knocked Up" isn’t just Certified Fresh, it even tops "Virgin"’s 82 percent.


In "Mr. Brooks," Kevin Costner plays a successful businessman and loving father with a big secret: he’s a serial killer on the down low. It’s an admittedly intriguing setup, and critics say "Mr. Brooks" gives its talented cast, which includes Demi Moore, William Hurt, and Dane Cook (!) a chance to take on some meaty roles, as well as providing audiences with some amusing, smarter-than-average plot twists and thrills. Unfortunately, the pundits also note that "Mr. Brooks" is overstuffed with said twists, making for a film that becomes more preposterous as it goes along. "Mr. Brooks" currently stands at 53 percent on the Tomatometer.

"They call me Mister Brooks!"

"Gracie" is the latest in a long line of inspirational sports movies that feature a dogged protagonist overcoming prejudice and family trauma. The film, a fictional treatment of star Elisabeth Shue’s high school sports career, tells the story of a 15-year-old (Carly Schroeder) who wants to play soccer at a time when there isn’t a girls’ squad at her school. Couple the sexism Gracie faces with the tragic death of her brother, and you’ve got the stuff that sports movies are made of, right? Well, critics say that "Gracie" can be rousing and touching in spots, but it’s ultimately undone by its predictable story arc and a lack of nuance. At 42 percent on the Tomatometer, "Gracie" is something of a draw.

Apparently trying out an interesting new soccer maneuver.

Also opening this week in limited release: "The Trials of Darryl Hunt," a doc about a man falsely accused of murder, is at 100 percent; "Radiant City," a visually expressive doc about suburban sprawl, is at 91 percent; "Crazy Love," a doc about a remarkably dysfunctional relationship, is at 87 percent; "Day Watch," the second installation in Timur Bekmambetov’s vampire trilogy, is at 73 percent; "Pierrepoint – The Last Hangman," which tells the tale of a conflicted executioner, is at 73 percent; and the indie rom-com "I’m Reed Fish" is at 67 percent.

"I can’t help it if I think the last season of ‘Gilmore Girls’ sucked."

Recent Kevin Costner Movies:
38% — The Guardian (2006)
18% — Rumor Has It… (2005)
74% — The Upside of Anger (2005)
78% — Open Range (2003)
7% — Dragonfly (2002)

Tag Cloud

book adaptation Amazon Prime Video reviews TCA 2017 cops renewed TV shows sequel Heroines Sneak Peek godzilla talk show rt labs critics edition National Geographic Western ABC Family blockbuster Disney+ Disney Plus singing competition comics Kids & Family romance Mary poppins slashers CW Seed zero dark thirty A24 Women's History Month Logo children's TV dc documentaries video on demand mission: impossible TV Land The CW USA Apple TV+ video kong Shondaland young adult Quiz fast and furious Pacific Islander high school Mystery space franchise FOX mob VICE indiana jones Set visit emmy awards biopic Superheroe Bravo OneApp festival DC Comics criterion basketball SDCC Opinion Reality Competition comic books robots razzies Brie Larson Summer based on movie Exclusive Video Fox Searchlight hollywood latino new zealand Marvel Studios 2021 Pride Month Year in Review Baby Yoda Box Office archives 99% Dark Horse Comics Lifetime Christmas movies Cartoon Network RT History CNN period drama The Academy TNT Tokyo Olympics Hollywood Foreign Press Association adenture 79th Golden Globes Awards harry potter Apple 73rd Emmy Awards TCM Columbia Pictures blaxploitation rom-coms sag awards Awards Tour hispanic heritage month BAFTA Disney supernatural Interview streaming movies Fantasy Cannes WGN historical drama Warner Bros. Britbox YouTube directors movie Spectrum Originals Hallmark Christmas movies south america 21st Century Fox jurassic park disaster AMC Plus werewolf Amazon Anna Paquin 2020 90s international cars Super Bowl Ovation Family Premiere Dates cancelled television docuseries politics sequels Travel Channel richard e. Grant Action monster movies sitcom Funimation American Society of Cinematographers Peacock olympics crime thriller dexter science fiction twilight NYCC Grammys nfl Mudbound TCA Awards spanish superhero diversity binge canceled TV shows Rom-Com Mary Tyler Moore dramedy die hard Nominations Amazon Studios thriller OWN discovery vampires marvel cinematic universe Countdown Comic-Con@Home 2021 mcc Creative Arts Emmys X-Men Universal Infographic prank Nat Geo dragons italian classics cults miniseries telelvision Turner rt labs comic heist movie Comedy GIFs BBC One live event The Walt Disney Company documentary Disney Plus Pirates chucky Fox News genre halloween tv PBS jamie lee curtis satire Christmas movies IFC Films Wes Anderson Biopics comiccon zombie Tumblr Musical pirates of the caribbean zombies TV renewals golden globes YouTube Premium Star Wars rotten movies we love NBA Comic Book concert BET Awards AMC VOD kids television remakes Trivia worst movies posters stoner WarnerMedia TV crime laika Song of Ice and Fire Film Festival travel GLAAD game show HBO Go book action-comedy First Reviews Spring TV Turner Classic Movies nature The Purge natural history Winners Sony Pictures LGBT Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Trailer Classic Film king arthur psychological thriller TCA Winter 2020 rotten Crunchyroll child's play gangster Spike king kong Starz BBC America foreign Calendar cancelled TV series stop motion 2019 christmas movies Paramount Lionsgate Hulu 2016 Star Trek Apple TV Plus TCA suspense comic book movies Podcast canceled Freeform Television Academy japanese RT21 YA japan Black Mirror Tags: Comedy Academy Awards E! Fargo TruTV Country Ellie Kemper 71st Emmy Awards Thanksgiving Comedy Central worst aapi sports Showtime First Look IFC Winter TV facebook Rock 20th Century Fox target royal family fresh hist FX Video Games 007 HBO Max critic resources Rocky leaderboard Music Awards Pop TV name the review marvel comics FXX parents Hear Us Out trailers boxing wonder woman Drama deadpool sopranos james bond Broadway black comedy hispanic HFPA unscripted Fall TV Schedule Elton John news San Diego Comic-Con MCU what to watch spain DirecTV LGBTQ transformers stand-up comedy TBS vs. adaptation strong female leads Tomatazos cartoon serial killer 2017 anthology Nickelodeon Pixar obituary new star wars movies 24 frames Watching Series Adult Swim breaking bad hidden camera all-time trophy lord of the rings golden globe awards Discovery Channel Valentine's Day festivals Rocketman Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Esquire Emmys Pop HBO asian-american Captain marvel Best and Worst TLC Musicals President spider-man Sundance Lucasfilm 4/20 Instagram Live Election Universal Pictures Black History Month teaser nbcuniversal cinemax boxoffice Binge Guide revenge spy thriller know your critic saw Paramount Plus New York Comic Con USA Network anime 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards ViacomCBS DC streaming service Legendary Shudder A&E MSNBC spider-verse spanish language Marathons Stephen King Cosplay films E3 aliens The Witch Epix cats Tubi dreamworks 1990s BBC superman Character Guide VH1 Trophy Talk indie series The Walking Dead true crime rt archives Writers Guild of America venice cancelled kaiju Horror 2018 scary movies critics Polls and Games black TV movies scorecard slasher Syfy Prime Video Neflix Walt Disney Pictures art house Sundance Now PaleyFest Superheroes witnail Alien Crackle cancelled TV shows Avengers Paramount Network a nightmare on elm street screenings Lifetime Chernobyl See It Skip It Netflix Christmas movies Reality Marvel casting DGA versus NBC Pet Sematary Toys adventure batman Arrowverse independent ITV CBS 2015 best cooking CMT reboot ID Sci-Fi quibi Mary Poppins Returns SundanceTV theme song romantic comedy women legend football technology Oscars comic book movie Teen Food Network Television Critics Association green book medical drama Acorn TV El Rey dogs ghosts FX on Hulu feel good halloween Endgame tv talk Holiday Tarantino IMDb TV ESPN screen actors guild live action Red Carpet BET game of thrones History finale justice league dceu 72 Emmy Awards award winner Netflix mockumentary animated mutant Hallmark Mindy Kaling toronto war political drama DC Universe Film Certified Fresh APB ratings biography popular ABC Signature scene in color toy story Vudu comedies 93rd Oscars universal monsters Emmy Nominations ABC TV One streaming blockbusters Disney streaming service docudrama Animation Martial Arts Amazon Prime Comics on TV Masterpiece dark Disney Channel psycho 45 australia PlayStation SXSW police drama new york composers free movies Holidays crossover crime drama MTV scary YouTube Red The Arrangement Image Comics Extras elevated horror french spinoff Sundance TV joker Photos Marvel Television TIFF Ghostbusters GoT CBS All Access social media doctor who debate