Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Invisibles" Lacks Focus; "Stomp" Comes Up Short; "Curse" Is A Mixed Blessing; "Dog" Has Bite; "Primeval" Not Screened

by | January 11, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a kid who ventures into a magical world ("Arthur and the Invisibles," with voice work from Robert De Niro and Madonna), a frat dance-off ("Stomp the Yard," starring Meagan Good), a lavish tale set during the Tang Dynasty ("The Curse of the Golden Flower," starring Chow Yun-Fat and Gong Li) and a ripped-from-the-headlines teen crime pic ("Alpha Dog," starring Bruce Willis and Justin Timberlake). What do the critics have to say?

Written by Nick Hershey and Alex Vo

"Arthur and the Invisibles" is a partially animated children’s film from director Luc Besson. Ten-year-old Arthur must find a passage to a magical world populated by tiny little beings called Minimoys in order to save his grandfather’s home. Critics say that the story tries to do too much, and the film wastes the big-name voice talent on a predictable script (including Robert De Niro, Madonna, and Snoop Dogg). In addition, they note that while the animation is interesting, it doesn’t hold up to the current CG standard. At 28 percent on the Tomatometer, "Arthur and the Invisibles" may not be something to see.

"Look how you’ve grown! You’re as tall as my ex-boyfriend now."

Two rival fraternities compete for the allegiance of a street dancer from Los Angeles in "Stomp the Yard." "Stepping" is the latest dance, and "Yard" has plenty of pep, thanks to appealing performers like Columbus Short and Meagan Good. But critics say that while "Stomp" contains impressive musical and dance numbers, it loses its momentum during the intervening soap opera-style subplots. At 27 percent on the Tomatometer, "Stomp" doesn’t quite go the extra yard.

"Let’s stomp the desert!"

You wouldn’t expect it from a Yimou Zhang movie, but "The Curse of the Golden Flower" is something not to be over-thought, but simply watched. Critics say the film goes to great lengths to visually mesmerize the audience, with enormous sets lavished in gold and silk, jade and brocade, and exquisitely bloody swordfights. But they also say the story is melodramatic. Really melodramatic. At 63 percent on the Tomatometer, this one’s both a blessing and a curse.

Apparently they had Jell-O shots in the Tang Dynasty.

Like a Hollywood remake of a Larry Clark movie, "Alpha Dog" is a glossy yet unflinching look into a violent and hedonistic teenage community. Bruce Willis and Sharon Stone play scene-chewing figures of authority, but critics say it’s Justin Timberlake who’s noteworthy, and the relationship his and Anton Yelchin’s character develop is the emotional tether that holds "Alpha Dog" together. The scribes say that while some of the techniques director Nick Cassavetes employs are a bit over the top, he’s able to draw good performances out of the cast. At 63 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Dog" has bite.

"Step 1: Cut a hole in a box."

Looks like we’re starting the year off right: we’re just two weeks into 2007, and already we’ve got a movie that wasn’t screened for critics. It’s called "Primeval," and it’s about a serial killer that has claimed more than 300 victimsm. It’s probably mediocre. Guess that Tomatometer.

Nope, it ain’t ‘The Searchers.’

Also opening this week in limited release: the compelling Holocaust documentary "Verdict on Auschwitz" is at 100 percent; "God Grew Tired of Us," a powerful doc about the Lost Boys of Sudan, is at 93 percent; "Ever Since the World Ended," a mockumentary about post-apocalyptic San Francisco, is at 75 percent; and "Tears of the Black Tiger," a heavily stylized Thai western, is at 73 percent.

Luc Besson-Directed Films:
50% — Angel-A (2007)
30% — The Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc (1999)
68% — The Fifth Element (1997)
81% — Leon The Professional (1994)
86% — La Femme Nikita (1990)

Tag Cloud

kaiju Rom-Com Cannes Watching Series Comics on TV space Anna Paquin FX Winners spy thriller Prime Video rt labs critics edition Universal Pictures latino concert wonder woman The Purge MSNBC Mudbound Amazon Prime Video toy story Toys DC streaming service Trophy Talk BBC spider-man posters prank harry potter directors Logo Legendary Rocky 1990s Cosplay DGA festivals Television Academy Ghostbusters Avengers Fall TV crime thriller TCA Winter 2020 Disney streaming service Character Guide cancelled TV series sag awards Lifetime Drama twilight strong female leads japanese lord of the rings saw 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Biopics nature Britbox LGBT free movies Freeform zombies Netflix kids dceu PlayStation italian Peacock First Look scorecard award winner know your critic live event telelvision trailers Hear Us Out Awards Vudu women slashers dc TNT cinemax IMDb TV werewolf Star Trek Food Network Grammys medical drama Sci-Fi cancelled TV shows james bond Calendar scary movies Cartoon Network TCA GoT basketball Marathons 2015 Shondaland cancelled television Infographic BBC America Opinion Star Wars Apple TV+ mockumentary Fox Searchlight ViacomCBS nfl pirates of the caribbean Epix war new zealand foreign Tokyo Olympics Brie Larson TIFF dexter CNN sopranos french 79th Golden Globes Awards 72 Emmy Awards anime serial killer revenge Trivia crossover Hallmark Turner Photos TCA 2017 El Rey Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt History golden globes TLC Nominations Disney Tomatazos Awards Tour Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Red Carpet what to watch political drama Reality halloween tv FXX Masterpiece stoner comic book movie TruTV Country Tags: Comedy Musicals Music Sundance TV Pop TV composers Apple sitcom Showtime TV One 93rd Oscars The Walking Dead 2016 biopic thriller TV renewals worst cats Premiere Dates hollywood DC Universe Baby Yoda golden globe awards video all-time hist 2018 Comic-Con@Home 2021 Summer olympics Wes Anderson scene in color adaptation Classic Film scary Western archives movies adventure justice league deadpool WGN obituary FX on Hulu Mary Tyler Moore 90s See It Skip It USA Network Christmas BAFTA adenture Schedule Disney+ Disney Plus BET Awards international 2021 science fiction Travel Channel fresh supernatural Columbia Pictures comic book movies USA TV movies IFC Crackle Spring TV politics reviews New York Comic Con travel Sundance Now australia cars Discovery Channel Comedy Central Comedy police drama social media HBO Max reboot streaming Acorn TV stand-up comedy Kids & Family dreamworks black comedy Paramount Plus National Geographic boxing ghosts Holiday historical drama indiana jones CW Seed Paramount Adult Swim streaming movies spider-verse godzilla 2020 Chernobyl spanish SXSW cults Valentine's Day CMT kong Super Bowl WarnerMedia TV BBC One 21st Century Fox new star wars movies Year in Review MCU discovery 71st Emmy Awards popular Crunchyroll 4/20 documentary docudrama Lucasfilm natural history video on demand Interview 24 frames Pet Sematary indie spanish language Hollywood Foreign Press Association Black History Month CBS All Access TCM SundanceTV Lifetime Christmas movies GLAAD RT History superman green book Pacific Islander robots Apple TV Plus Tubi Winter TV Black Mirror YouTube Red royal family Song of Ice and Fire YouTube Premium game of thrones leaderboard feel good PaleyFest black GIFs documentaries series Sony Pictures disaster VICE Image Comics teaser Best and Worst screen actors guild Spectrum Originals HFPA Polls and Games miniseries casting A24 Oscars AMC Broadway VH1 game show suspense Elton John hispanic Mindy Kaling NYCC emmy awards Captain marvel Fargo Esquire remakes Superheroe venice finale child's play rotten movies we love action-comedy E3 Pride Month christmas movies San Diego Comic-Con zero dark thirty ESPN laika dark movie Fantasy south america crime drama romance 73rd Emmy Awards Hulu singing competition classics comedies Mary poppins asian-american Sundance Marvel APB Paramount Network blockbusters YA comics blaxploitation LGBTQ Writers Guild of America Rock joker Amazon Prime hidden camera Creative Arts Emmys king kong richard e. Grant Pixar best Amazon Studios romantic comedy Disney Channel legend book adaptation news fast and furious universal monsters Turner Classic Movies TV Land halloween MTV true crime criterion Certified Fresh Emmy Nominations 2019 TBS Fox News Tumblr ABC Signature children's TV technology mutant Universal Film witnail PBS 45 The Arrangement NBA Mary Poppins Returns razzies live action Heroines Television Critics Association franchise Animation Shudder facebook rt archives Nat Geo target canceled docuseries ABC Family ITV mission: impossible quibi genre films E! Video Games Action renewed TV shows binge breaking bad parents doctor who transformers Spike cancelled zombie talk show slasher theme song comic Tarantino American Society of Cinematographers 99% diversity dramedy The Witch Thanksgiving nbcuniversal Set visit ABC gangster Holidays Netflix Christmas movies dogs Bravo OWN worst movies Pirates Musical Reality Competition satire First Reviews Starz blockbuster japan OneApp psychological thriller BET marvel comics X-Men spain Marvel Studios aapi NBC marvel cinematic universe spinoff jurassic park Quiz Women's History Month mob new york Neflix art house critic resources Family Marvel Television IFC Films 007 Box Office screenings Warner Bros. sequels elevated horror cartoon high school Amazon A&E young adult Nickelodeon DC Comics HBO AMC Plus Film Festival canceled TV shows Comic Book hispanic heritage month batman The Academy RT21 vs. Extras Superheroes sequel Teen Election FOX Instagram Live Martial Arts biography sports crime mcc boxoffice TCA Awards debate Walt Disney Pictures Dark Horse Comics monster movies The Walt Disney Company versus Mystery ID period drama anthology Stephen King YouTube die hard Syfy 2017 Countdown Ellie Kemper comiccon Trailer stop motion a nightmare on elm street toronto dragons rotten Binge Guide Rocketman tv talk ratings chucky football Disney Plus television psycho HBO Go 20th Century Fox SDCC VOD cops rom-coms based on movie Pop Alien Academy Awards rt labs Funimation Hallmark Christmas movies Endgame DirecTV festival Sneak Peek name the review The CW Emmys Podcast unscripted vampires book jamie lee curtis cooking President king arthur superhero Horror independent Ovation aliens critics Arrowverse Lionsgate Exclusive Video comic books animated trophy heist movie CBS