Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Hostel" Worth A Stay, "Casanova" Getting No Love

by | January 5, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a bunch of madmen ("Hostel"), a notorious lover ("Casanova"), a dhampir ("BloodRayne"), and a dude who lives with his grandma ("Grandma’s Boy"). Which of these movies will score with critics?

It’s a story that’s been told a thousand times: a group of young people stray off the beaten path, only to fall into the clutches of bloodthirsty crazies who inflicts torture upon them with sadistic glee. Heck, it was told a couple weeks ago ("Wolf Creek"). So what? Sometimes it’s how you tell it, and the critics say "Hostel" is told very well. Yes, scribes say, Eli Roth‘s film is grisly, but it’s also terrifyingly exciting and makes for some incisive social commentary. At 88 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Hostel" may be worth a stay, if you like this sort of thing.

Giacomo Casanova was the world’s greatest lover, a man of endless appetites who led an impossibly colorful life (which was probably embellished in his autobiography, but is a classic nonetheless). So you couldn’t go wrong with a movie about the notable rake, right? Right? Well, the critics say this period comedy romp, starring Heath Ledger and Sienna Miller, isn’t quite as romping as it should be, and despite noteworthy visuals, the film is frothy without being particularly ribald. Worse, the man whose name is synonymous with cad-dom chooses monogamy! At 41 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Casanova" is getting no love.

The people behind both "BloodRayne" and "Grandma’s Boy" must have made a new year’s resolution to not screen their films for critics. Here at Rotten Tomatoes, we feel it’s admirable to stick to your guns, when so many of us end up breaking our resolutions almost immediately. Unfortunately, the strategy sends a message to the world that perhaps these movies aren’t very good.

Recent Heath Ledger Movies
88% — Brokeback Mountain (2005)
67% — Two Hands (2005)
39% — The Brothers Grimm (2005)
53% — Lords of Dogtown (2005)
54% — Ned Kelly (2004)

Tag Cloud

streaming Red Carpet Fargo Bravo indiana jones miniseries cartoon hist docudrama CW Seed Epix mcc legend APB Music spain Tumblr AMC young adult Box Office Disney streaming service zombie Nat Geo Hallmark Christmas movies OWN RT21 political drama king arthur free movies Spring TV Vudu Ghostbusters classics Certified Fresh Comics on TV golden globes Universal name the review dark movies sequel hidden camera Netflix Christmas movies vs. GLAAD Sony Pictures Baby Yoda know your critic genre CMT universal monsters Crunchyroll posters 45 Superheroes Musical Universal Pictures TV Land dreamworks Fantasy Tomatazos australia renewed TV shows romance true crime Elton John films obituary Paramount Plus Podcast olympics fresh Extras Apple 2017 Western Neflix diversity historical drama Broadway 2020 what to watch talk show japanese 1990s telelvision HBO Go DC Universe PlayStation MSNBC debate kong stop motion facebook Song of Ice and Fire Peacock Avengers dramedy cancelled AMC Plus Nickelodeon movie new star wars movies Awards Tour leaderboard Comic Book Columbia Pictures Mary Tyler Moore nfl Sneak Peek anthology TCA lord of the rings DC Comics Showtime TCA Winter 2020 football spinoff news Amazon Prime Video Film twilight south america 007 vampires cancelled television Food Network razzies versus Travel Channel Comedy Central Lifetime Christmas movies First Look Chilling Adventures of Sabrina National Geographic heist movie Opinion 2021 99% marvel comics boxoffice Premiere Dates anime TCA 2017 dc Countdown spanish HFPA VH1 comiccon Disney Plus Marvel Netflix Heroines new zealand unscripted documentaries critics gangster adaptation cancelled TV series ABC Signature based on movie saw Infographic rotten reboot halloween Academy Awards SDCC CBS All Access Martial Arts godzilla nature superhero finale hispanic heritage month quibi spider-verse supernatural TV movies Rocky CNN live action animated halloween tv History GoT Marvel Studios Teen Paramount Cannes aapi binge El Rey Summer emmy awards Endgame Tarantino Disney+ Disney Plus toy story Hollywood Foreign Press Association Fox News The Walking Dead biopic dragons spanish language BET Awards Reality HBO festivals cars WGN See It Skip It casting royal family book cooking die hard Quiz Freeform Apple TV+ rt archives harry potter President Pop TV Holiday ID comic book movies italian adventure Spike Warner Bros. franchise Black History Month comic book movie TNT Star Trek art house critic resources Mudbound hispanic comic books Animation San Diego Comic-Con slashers Oscars Amazon Studios french documentary joker black comedy medical drama Winners Emmys USA Network Dark Horse Comics Apple TV Plus award winner rom-coms The Academy kids a nightmare on elm street Kids & Family Drama Tubi thriller TV One dceu TruTV Tags: Comedy Hulu Christmas popular Cosplay green book Comic-Con@Home 2021 book adaptation women Hallmark Rock ITV dogs Sundance Now sports screen actors guild blockbuster doctor who MCU aliens Sundance TV christmas movies mob cinemax Exclusive Video BET Prime Video YouTube Red Set visit TLC adenture black Shondaland Ellie Kemper game show Nominations Arrowverse television docuseries biography dexter suspense zombies high school cats zero dark thirty canceled asian-american American Society of Cinematographers Tokyo Olympics sag awards chucky rt labs critics edition all-time comedies Alien science fiction Fall TV USA fast and furious tv talk disaster sopranos 20th Century Fox breaking bad Pride Month Brie Larson Spectrum Originals FOX singing competition E! New York Comic Con Video Games 2016 93rd Oscars Toys romantic comedy Legendary space Television Academy serial killer Lifetime Starz latino streaming movies Writers Guild of America trailers Masterpiece Acorn TV hollywood jurassic park IFC ABC venice crime thriller 2019 Mystery japan slasher VOD Horror 24 frames festival Marvel Television DC streaming service crime Ovation Turner canceled TV shows ABC Family Captain marvel Women's History Month ViacomCBS Amazon Prime crime drama Interview NYCC X-Men TCM Stephen King Mary Poppins Returns psychological thriller Star Wars Television Critics Association target foreign 90s Image Comics E3 YouTube Sundance Character Guide Cartoon Network Biopics OneApp justice league Disney comics Fox Searchlight worst The Walt Disney Company NBC Grammys BBC One satire Discovery Channel The Arrangement pirates of the caribbean 4/20 james bond kaiju SXSW spider-man deadpool Amazon politics spy thriller Family ESPN A24 Calendar ratings sequels Funimation Trailer FX on Hulu monster movies robots LGBT Polls and Games Pacific Islander video war marvel cinematic universe Trophy Talk mission: impossible BAFTA witnail scary king kong Anna Paquin Photos ghosts TCA Awards Best and Worst Pet Sematary Mary poppins stoner Logo strong female leads natural history live event Crackle Shudder cancelled TV shows mockumentary blaxploitation action-comedy prank Pop social media First Reviews rotten movies we love Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 72 Emmy Awards The Witch cults PaleyFest Winter TV jamie lee curtis technology Classic Film nbcuniversal 21st Century Fox international Disney Channel MTV directors DirecTV scary movies period drama Adult Swim teaser Super Bowl concert Lucasfilm TIFF children's TV rt labs Lionsgate Hear Us Out scene in color HBO Max wonder woman 71st Emmy Awards Turner Classic Movies police drama A&E comic theme song Pixar Paramount Network transformers SundanceTV Film Festival 2015 Schedule indie Holidays trophy Esquire TBS BBC America reviews CBS Black Mirror game of thrones The CW 2018 travel 79th Golden Globes Awards elevated horror independent The Purge series Musicals Wes Anderson YA PBS FX richard e. Grant BBC Chernobyl cops FXX criterion Marathons video on demand mutant Comedy new york Pirates Rom-Com revenge Instagram Live child's play 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Sci-Fi toronto WarnerMedia Trivia stand-up comedy VICE Thanksgiving TV YouTube Premium Election Creative Arts Emmys crossover Superheroe Emmy Nominations GIFs laika screenings Action scorecard Watching Series golden globe awards DGA basketball blockbusters NBA Binge Guide werewolf LGBTQ Walt Disney Pictures sitcom worst movies 73rd Emmy Awards remakes IMDb TV Awards boxing discovery Mindy Kaling Britbox Valentine's Day archives Year in Review superman composers Rocketman Reality Competition batman Syfy Country TV renewals parents feel good psycho IFC Films best RT History