Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Hostel" Worth A Stay, "Casanova" Getting No Love

by | January 5, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a bunch of madmen ("Hostel"), a notorious lover ("Casanova"), a dhampir ("BloodRayne"), and a dude who lives with his grandma ("Grandma’s Boy"). Which of these movies will score with critics?

It’s a story that’s been told a thousand times: a group of young people stray off the beaten path, only to fall into the clutches of bloodthirsty crazies who inflicts torture upon them with sadistic glee. Heck, it was told a couple weeks ago ("Wolf Creek"). So what? Sometimes it’s how you tell it, and the critics say "Hostel" is told very well. Yes, scribes say, Eli Roth‘s film is grisly, but it’s also terrifyingly exciting and makes for some incisive social commentary. At 88 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Hostel" may be worth a stay, if you like this sort of thing.

Giacomo Casanova was the world’s greatest lover, a man of endless appetites who led an impossibly colorful life (which was probably embellished in his autobiography, but is a classic nonetheless). So you couldn’t go wrong with a movie about the notable rake, right? Right? Well, the critics say this period comedy romp, starring Heath Ledger and Sienna Miller, isn’t quite as romping as it should be, and despite noteworthy visuals, the film is frothy without being particularly ribald. Worse, the man whose name is synonymous with cad-dom chooses monogamy! At 41 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Casanova" is getting no love.

The people behind both "BloodRayne" and "Grandma’s Boy" must have made a new year’s resolution to not screen their films for critics. Here at Rotten Tomatoes, we feel it’s admirable to stick to your guns, when so many of us end up breaking our resolutions almost immediately. Unfortunately, the strategy sends a message to the world that perhaps these movies aren’t very good.

Recent Heath Ledger Movies
88% — Brokeback Mountain (2005)
67% — Two Hands (2005)
39% — The Brothers Grimm (2005)
53% — Lords of Dogtown (2005)
54% — Ned Kelly (2004)

Tag Cloud

deadpool Schedule LGBTQ composers Hallmark Christmas movies comic books A24 Dark Horse Comics dogs blockbusters hist kong sequel USA ratings Alien war 71st Emmy Awards 2021 Extras Fox News golden globes HBO lord of the rings miniseries First Reviews Superheroe scene in color series king arthur Star Wars Celebration MSNBC docudrama Animation Best Director San Diego Comic-Con Avengers Mudbound Tokyo Olympics 94th Oscars VOD 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Starz Paramount Network Shondaland RT History breaking bad 2020 Women's History Month Lucasfilm Syfy unscripted Mary Poppins Returns Best Actress Podcast Crackle 4/20 twilight aapi television natural history Mystery ViacomCBS Black History Month Logo Marvel Tags: Comedy Summer Lifetime Christmas movies BBC One crime drama Election award winner Cannes Chernobyl IFC Films thriller slashers VH1 video on demand Adult Swim Nat Geo HBO Go RT21 christmas movies aliens MTV fresh ABC Signature Columbia Pictures italian hidden camera The CW Star Wars batman Comedy Central Reality Hollywood Foreign Press Association Rock ID TNT Mindy Kaling BBC America Fargo HBO Max Black Mirror football universal monsters Marvel Television Toys psychological thriller fast and furious Martial Arts transformers 99% Stephen King slasher young adult historical drama cancelled nature Travel Channel 24 frames dramedy The Purge king kong cartoon book adaptation Polls and Games TCA 2017 tv talk BET suspense target psycho Warner Bros. Broadway OneApp TruTV Pride Month social media cancelled television E3 dexter concert Netflix Christmas movies Pet Sematary reboot true crime justice league scorecard Focus Features Musical Family game show Best Actor GIFs critic resources Premiere Dates Baby Yoda Grammys new star wars movies ghosts FX Best Picture Countdown Box Office women canceled TV shows spanish NBC Infographic President razzies cancelled TV shows Rocketman jamie lee curtis rt labs elevated horror mob halloween new york Amazon Prime Video mockumentary Spring TV MGM BBC Mary poppins Teen X-Men Fox Searchlight action-comedy strong female leads Holidays Amazon Prime Universal Pictures romance Comedy 20th Century Fox stoner video Paramount Plus TLC joker obituary spider-verse jurassic park richard e. Grant robots cinemax wonder woman TCA Awards godzilla dragons Marathons finale australia Set visit Crunchyroll Brie Larson doctor who Pop political drama criterion worst movies FX on Hulu PBS Ellie Kemper black spanish language Freeform Creative Arts Emmys Mary Tyler Moore Awards Tour comedies Sci-Fi docuseries NYCC golden globe awards Superheroes Cartoon Network kaiju space halloween tv cooking rt archives 93rd Oscars live action Calendar ABC child's play disaster Comic-Con@Home 2021 dreamworks VICE hispanic heritage month Hear Us Out franchise boxing broadcast USA Network japanese Discovery Channel GLAAD TV Land sports superhero zombies Legendary toy story A&E news Captain marvel quibi Rom-Com zombie ESPN werewolf telelvision ITV asian-american french Sony Pictures stop motion LGBT Turner Classic Movies cults DGA marvel comics Academy Awards Disney streaming service Sundance TV know your critic pirates of the caribbean worst Lifetime 79th Golden Globes Awards Emmy Nominations dceu period drama book heist movie crime mission: impossible black comedy Disney Spike olympics monster movies SDCC toronto screenings Kids & Family Disney Plus diversity children's TV Oscars OWN target scene in color casting popular WarnerMedia TV renewals Oscar YouTube TV movies 1990s The Academy Winners 72 Emmy Awards hollywood Action superman comics IFC parents Western The Walking Dead a nightmare on elm street Prime Video Shudder revenge biopic Paramount Pictures remakes indie TV One festivals Comics on TV spain Lionsgate Tubi TCA foreign travel AMC Plus Watching Series Video Games Ghostbusters supernatural Indigenous kids rotten movies we love BET Awards Valentine's Day Exclusive Video The Witch The Walt Disney Company National Geographic Trivia anime Apple TV Plus Super Bowl GoT Netflix Vudu canceled interviews NBA Native The Arrangement streaming movies Esquire legend binge Opinion teaser spy thriller Awards comic book movie films Biopics Television Critics Association stand-up comedy Photos 21st Century Fox scene in color film series Neflix streamig Wes Anderson Winter TV Epix 2015 boxoffice MCU medical drama renewed TV shows Music game of thrones vampires dark basketball FXX witnail versus trophy feel good Heroines screen actors guild Showtime TCA Winter 2020 archives indiana jones PaleyFest CBS international posters talk show genre trailers comic romantic comedy Fall TV TV 73rd Emmy Awards live event DirecTV critics APB nfl Holiday crime thriller prank rotten cops CNN ABC Family Paramount high school 007 Television Academy Britbox BAFTA CBS All Access singing competition Apple 45 Marvel Studios Star Trek all-time WGN rom-coms CW Seed sitcom reviews New York Comic Con Certified Fresh movies summer preview Classic Film scary FOX dc Thanksgiving festival science fiction hispanic Arrowverse rt labs critics edition 2016 comiccon what to watch DC Comics Nickelodeon Anna Paquin Fantasy Pop TV Pixar Elton John Sundance Geeked Week Endgame TCM Sneak Peek police drama emmy awards IMDb TV Disney+ Disney Plus Walt Disney Pictures leaderboard 90s Masterpiece green book harry potter die hard based on movie crossover History Funimation sopranos 2017 Horror Best and Worst Bravo art house marvel cinematic universe Year in Review Character Guide politics zero dark thirty summer TV preview animated movie chucky classics james bond Pacific Islander spinoff YouTube Red PlayStation 2019 scary movies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Ovation Tomatazos cats nbcuniversal SXSW south america new zealand biography vs. Acorn TV sag awards Spectrum Originals Pirates YouTube Premium Film Image Comics Quiz Country Writers Guild of America Amazon Nominations Tumblr adventure Reality Competition Peacock Universal comic book movies South by Southwest Film Festival mutant E! Drama adaptation laika documentary Hallmark best obi wan DC Universe documentaries gangster Disney Channel Binge Guide japan Emmys American Society of Cinematographers Rocky adenture anthology cancelled TV series Film Festival technology 2018 series name the review Sony discovery royal family TBS Trailer debate latino CMT Tarantino Song of Ice and Fire Interview summer TV independent Sundance Now TIFF DC streaming service HFPA YA Red Carpet Cosplay venice mcc Apple TV+ Christmas saw theme song SundanceTV serial killer cars scene in color Trophy Talk sequels free movies Food Network Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Instagram Live blockbuster Musicals directors spider-man See It Skip It First Look El Rey AMC Comic Book facebook Hulu satire SXSW 2022 Turner blaxploitation streaming Amazon Studios