Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Hoax" Shines; Force Is With "ATHF"; "Disturbia" Mixed; "Pathfinder," "Stranger" Not Perfect; "Redline," Slow Burn" Not Screened

by | April 12, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got snoops ("Disturbia," starring Shia LaBeouf), temps ("Perfect Stranger," starring Halle Berry and Bruce Willis), Mooninites ("Aqua Teen Hunger Force Colon Movie Film for Theaters"), and frauds ("The Hoax," starring Richard Gere). What do the critics have to say?

With a plot involving a bored house-arrested teenager, binoculars, and a neighbor who may be a murderer, it’s hard not to imagine "Disturbia" as "Rear Window" for the YouTube generation. Shia LaBeouf plays the James Stewart role as a kid trying to figure out whether he’s witnessing the work of a serial killer — or if it’s just his imagination. Though critics say "Disturbia" rips off Hitchcock, some still praise the film’s tense atmospherics; others call it too predictable, with the exception of one problematic twist late in the game. However, most agree that star Shia LaBeouf is evolving into an engaging screen presence. At 56 percent on the Tomatometer, keep your expectations in check and "Disturbia" may be worth a peep.

"Hey, look, it’s like YouTubing with The Rockettes."

Frankly, we’re getting a little worried about Halle Berry. Ever since she took home the Oscar for "Monster’s Ball," she hasn’t been able to steer clear of mediocre movies. The latest example: "Perfect Stranger," a twisty whodunit that is unlikely to redeem her in the eyes of the scribes. Berry stars as an investigative reporter looking into the murder of a friend; signs seem to point to a powerful, sketchy ad exec (played by Bruce Willis), so she goes undercover as a temp in his firm. There’s nothing wrong with sexy potboilers, but the critics say "Perfect Stranger" is way too convoluted and filled with lame red herrings to work. At 16 percent on the Tomatometer, you may want to avoid this "Stranger."

"Now why wouldn’t they book my flight to Mypos?"

Another month, another swords-and-decapitations-filled epic. "Pathfinder" stars Karl Urban as Ghost, an orphaned Viking boy raised by Native Americans, destined to fight off his ancestors when they come back to pillage pre-Columbus America. Despite a few rousing action sequences, critics are finding lots to take issue with in "Pathfinder" including a non-existent plot, silly dialogue, a sophomoric obsession with gory violence, and even the cinematography, which bathes everything in a washed-out blue. This "Pathfinder" is lost in the woods with a 33 percent Tomatometer.

Forget the Vikings, pneumonia’s going to kill this guy.

If you’re a fan of Adult Swim’s "Aqua Teen Hunger Force," critics say you’ll probably dig its big screen adaptation, "Aqua Teen Hunger Force Colon Movie Film for Theaters." If you’re not initiated into the world of those wacky anthropomorphic fast food items Meatwad, Frylock, and Master Shake, however, you’re likely to be left cold. Absurdist antics are the order of the day as our heroes seek out a piece of antiquated gym equipment called the Insanoflex. Long story short, critics say if you’re up for wacky non-sequiturs and are untroubled by such pesky cinematic conventions as narrative, "ATHFCMFFT" is as tasty as a Happy Meal. If not, politely ignore the film’s 68 percent Tomatometer.

This movie would’ve been better if it starred Mel Gibson. And Master Blaster.

When it comes to literary scandal, James Frey and Stephen Glass ain’t got nothing on Clifford Irving, whose phony "autobiography" of reclusive billionaire Howard Hughes was a sensation — until Hughes emerged to dispute it. Irving appeared as himself in Orson Welles’ endlessly inventive final film "F for Fake," and now Lasse Hallström has made "The Hoax," a fictional account of the affair that critics say features Richard Gere’s best performance in years. The pundits say Hallström’s direction is deft enough to make the film work as a comedy, a thriller, and an empathetic character study to boot. At 85 percent, this "Hoax" is no joke. In fact, it’s Certified Fresh.

After sunrise, but before blanket turndown service.

Add two more flicks to ever-growing list of movies hidden from critics. "Redline," starring Angus MacFadyen and Eddie Griffin, is set in the world of illegal drag racing, while "Slow Burn" stars Ray Liotta and LL Cool J in a complex murder mystery. Guess those Tomatometers, kids.

"I dare you to make fun of the pompadour."

Also opening this week in limited release: "Red Road," a tense, Hitchcockian meditation on grief, is at 88 percent; the documentary "Jack Smith and the Destruction of Atlantis," about the underground artist, is at 88 percent; "Year of the Dog," a Sundance-approved comedy about the love of man’s best friend starring Molly Shannon, is at 86 percent; the Slamdance-accepted "Rock the Bells," a doc about efforts to stage a Wu-Tang reunion, is at 86 percent; "Private Fears in Public Places," a melodrama about relationships by legendary French director Alain Resnais, is at 82 percent; "Everything’s Gone Green," the tale of a slacker written by Gen-X writer Douglas Coupland, is at 67 percent; and "Lonely Hearts," a noir starring John Travolta, Salma Hayek, and Jared Leto, is at 43 percent.

This one’s strictly for the dogs.

Recent Halle Berry Movies:
57% — X-Men: The Last Stand (2006)
62% — Robots (2005)
9% — Catwoman (2004)
87% — X2: X-Men United (2003)
15% — Gothika (2003)

Recent Richard Gere Movies:
41% — Bee Season (2005)
48% — Shall We Dance? (2004)
86% — Chicago (2002)
47% — Unfaithful (2002)
52% — The Mothman Prophecies (2002)

Tag Cloud

SundanceTV Disney olympics Television Academy Hulu CBS blaxploitation Netflix Set visit Box Office Walt Disney Pictures children's TV harry potter 1990s rom-coms Awards Tour Quiz sequel Trailer Marvel strong female leads Marvel Studios spy thriller 94th Oscars Sundance FXX Character Guide Focus Features Opinion Toys documentaries natural history DC Universe marvel cinematic universe Tumblr Pop Cartoon Network target streaming breaking bad Shondaland psycho Turner Classic Movies Disney+ Disney Plus action-comedy hist Cannes summer preview Sony Pictures popular Oscar posters adenture psychological thriller AMC Captain marvel Syfy serial killer suspense TV Land singing competition stand-up comedy batman TNT saw australia SXSW 2022 Geeked Week Best Actor tv talk dreamworks finale FX ABC Disney streaming service child's play Pixar Christmas heist movie BBC Extras Britbox Paramount Network OWN godzilla Calendar anthology documentary facebook period drama Martial Arts ABC Family witnail mockumentary VH1 romance BBC America zero dark thirty emmy awards OneApp WarnerMedia 007 Spike American Society of Cinematographers award winner Showtime aapi robots movie mutant genre Sundance Now doctor who comic spain Crunchyroll italian LGBT Schedule international die hard jurassic park Certified Fresh National Geographic streamig black comedy 2018 First Reviews Emmys 79th Golden Globes Awards TCA 2017 First Look South by Southwest Film Festival franchise rotten TCA Awards Thanksgiving 4/20 President Disney Channel versus medical drama Music halloween cults Television Critics Association true crime San Diego Comic-Con movies game show spider-man japan films cinemax Mary Tyler Moore cancelled cancelled television Paramount Pop TV Lucasfilm Cosplay Alien Hallmark transformers Best and Worst MGM Podcast The Witch concert latino monster movies Black Mirror cancelled TV series Reality Competition crossover Comic Book scene in color film series obi wan YouTube pirates of the caribbean kong Vudu TV One Superheroe critic resources Grammys YouTube Premium 21st Century Fox BBC One Tubi summer TV preview 2019 Amazon Studios miniseries political drama dceu spinoff 24 frames worst Animation Marvel Television GLAAD Amazon streaming movies cats The Academy The CW Year in Review blockbuster Exclusive Video sequels ID japanese scene in color series Crackle leaderboard 73rd Emmy Awards Fantasy 90s dramedy docudrama Emmy Nominations Warner Bros. superhero Apple werewolf Writers Guild of America screenings twilight Sci-Fi prank cops zombies video Super Bowl mob biography Women's History Month Chernobyl king arthur hispanic heritage month Holidays Film Festival Heroines 2020 royal family marvel comics Premiere Dates The Walt Disney Company Black History Month social media IMDb TV BAFTA discovery cooking Mudbound rt labs critics edition Amazon Prime History Dark Horse Comics HBO Go rotten movies we love Funimation diversity Superheroes video on demand archives Mystery NYCC 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Rocketman Trophy Talk target scene in color Binge Guide BET Trivia christmas movies thriller Shudder scary Pride Month women new zealand travel Western best Tarantino 93rd Oscars Instagram Live fresh A&E Amazon Prime Video Native Anna Paquin Kids & Family talk show telelvision supernatural cancelled TV shows Esquire legend See It Skip It adaptation crime drama USA Network theme song TCM kaiju book adaptation Photos what to watch joker Comics on TV Discovery Channel scary movies mcc TLC TBS Election Disney Plus science fiction Tags: Comedy police drama worst movies news richard e. Grant Columbia Pictures gangster BET Awards broadcast comic book movies sports quibi dragons FOX Ellie Kemper E3 comic books Hallmark Christmas movies vampires satire Netflix Christmas movies remakes Broadway live action Winners IFC AMC Plus Sneak Peek politics interviews renewed TV shows dark HBO Max ghosts based on movie Holiday series universal monsters YA deadpool chucky GIFs RT History ratings TCA Winter 2020 rt archives Rock technology green book MCU Classic Film SXSW revenge 2021 Nominations El Rey rt labs ABC Signature E! foreign docuseries Best Actress Bravo canceled TV shows Universal Pictures cartoon 45 PlayStation Legendary black zombie TV Stephen King Countdown scene in color VOD comics stop motion venice television animated reboot binge feel good basketball Family adventure USA New York Comic Con WGN RT21 PaleyFest IFC Films CMT Pet Sematary boxing Ovation screen actors guild sitcom golden globes debate Tomatazos 2015 Logo Comic-Con@Home 2021 The Walking Dead Masterpiece Rocky Creative Arts Emmys king kong blockbusters Watching Series Winter TV new york Mary poppins south america french Action Hear Us Out festival CW Seed 71st Emmy Awards composers VICE Comedy reviews war A24 name the review Hollywood Foreign Press Association Oscars DirecTV justice league new star wars movies anime NBA crime Baby Yoda casting stoner 72 Emmy Awards Turner CNN Drama LGBTQ Country Summer HFPA a nightmare on elm street canceled criterion SDCC wonder woman Lifetime Christmas movies Neflix halloween tv Horror dexter Wes Anderson book Food Network Brie Larson golden globe awards boxoffice independent 2017 obituary 20th Century Fox sopranos Tokyo Olympics biopic Ghostbusters DGA Star Wars Celebration unscripted summer TV Paramount Pictures lord of the rings crime thriller Comedy Central superman dc Universal trailers hidden camera Fox News HBO TIFF all-time Mary Poppins Returns vs. Mindy Kaling toronto Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Lionsgate PBS DC streaming service Nickelodeon Epix elevated horror trophy Spectrum Originals Indigenous Nat Geo comic book movie Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt live event directors Travel Channel nfl CBS All Access football classics X-Men ViacomCBS comiccon Prime Video space Peacock Musicals TruTV nature teaser Adult Swim NBC DC Comics FX on Hulu YouTube Red Freeform dogs spanish Best Picture Musical cars hispanic Reality know your critic MTV Fox Searchlight mission: impossible Spring TV ESPN Film comedies Apple TV Plus APB slashers festivals parents Arrowverse Rom-Com Red Carpet GoT jamie lee curtis ITV spider-verse sag awards Polls and Games Song of Ice and Fire toy story Academy Awards Acorn TV Sundance TV The Arrangement Infographic Lifetime fast and furious Fargo MSNBC free movies Teen Valentine's Day Apple TV+ Sony Video Games TV movies Star Wars TV renewals asian-american disaster scorecard razzies Pacific Islander Awards Star Trek young adult Paramount Plus critics Best Director james bond 99% kids spanish language Image Comics 2016 art house Starz Avengers laika game of thrones TCA Pirates high school slasher indiana jones hollywood historical drama The Purge indie aliens Elton John Interview Biopics romantic comedy Fall TV Endgame Marathons nbcuniversal