Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Hoax" Shines; Force Is With "ATHF"; "Disturbia" Mixed; "Pathfinder," "Stranger" Not Perfect; "Redline," Slow Burn" Not Screened

by | April 12, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got snoops ("Disturbia," starring Shia LaBeouf), temps ("Perfect Stranger," starring Halle Berry and Bruce Willis), Mooninites ("Aqua Teen Hunger Force Colon Movie Film for Theaters"), and frauds ("The Hoax," starring Richard Gere). What do the critics have to say?

With a plot involving a bored house-arrested teenager, binoculars, and a neighbor who may be a murderer, it’s hard not to imagine "Disturbia" as "Rear Window" for the YouTube generation. Shia LaBeouf plays the James Stewart role as a kid trying to figure out whether he’s witnessing the work of a serial killer — or if it’s just his imagination. Though critics say "Disturbia" rips off Hitchcock, some still praise the film’s tense atmospherics; others call it too predictable, with the exception of one problematic twist late in the game. However, most agree that star Shia LaBeouf is evolving into an engaging screen presence. At 56 percent on the Tomatometer, keep your expectations in check and "Disturbia" may be worth a peep.

"Hey, look, it’s like YouTubing with The Rockettes."

Frankly, we’re getting a little worried about Halle Berry. Ever since she took home the Oscar for "Monster’s Ball," she hasn’t been able to steer clear of mediocre movies. The latest example: "Perfect Stranger," a twisty whodunit that is unlikely to redeem her in the eyes of the scribes. Berry stars as an investigative reporter looking into the murder of a friend; signs seem to point to a powerful, sketchy ad exec (played by Bruce Willis), so she goes undercover as a temp in his firm. There’s nothing wrong with sexy potboilers, but the critics say "Perfect Stranger" is way too convoluted and filled with lame red herrings to work. At 16 percent on the Tomatometer, you may want to avoid this "Stranger."

"Now why wouldn’t they book my flight to Mypos?"

Another month, another swords-and-decapitations-filled epic. "Pathfinder" stars Karl Urban as Ghost, an orphaned Viking boy raised by Native Americans, destined to fight off his ancestors when they come back to pillage pre-Columbus America. Despite a few rousing action sequences, critics are finding lots to take issue with in "Pathfinder" including a non-existent plot, silly dialogue, a sophomoric obsession with gory violence, and even the cinematography, which bathes everything in a washed-out blue. This "Pathfinder" is lost in the woods with a 33 percent Tomatometer.

Forget the Vikings, pneumonia’s going to kill this guy.

If you’re a fan of Adult Swim’s "Aqua Teen Hunger Force," critics say you’ll probably dig its big screen adaptation, "Aqua Teen Hunger Force Colon Movie Film for Theaters." If you’re not initiated into the world of those wacky anthropomorphic fast food items Meatwad, Frylock, and Master Shake, however, you’re likely to be left cold. Absurdist antics are the order of the day as our heroes seek out a piece of antiquated gym equipment called the Insanoflex. Long story short, critics say if you’re up for wacky non-sequiturs and are untroubled by such pesky cinematic conventions as narrative, "ATHFCMFFT" is as tasty as a Happy Meal. If not, politely ignore the film’s 68 percent Tomatometer.

This movie would’ve been better if it starred Mel Gibson. And Master Blaster.

When it comes to literary scandal, James Frey and Stephen Glass ain’t got nothing on Clifford Irving, whose phony "autobiography" of reclusive billionaire Howard Hughes was a sensation — until Hughes emerged to dispute it. Irving appeared as himself in Orson Welles’ endlessly inventive final film "F for Fake," and now Lasse Hallström has made "The Hoax," a fictional account of the affair that critics say features Richard Gere’s best performance in years. The pundits say Hallström’s direction is deft enough to make the film work as a comedy, a thriller, and an empathetic character study to boot. At 85 percent, this "Hoax" is no joke. In fact, it’s Certified Fresh.

After sunrise, but before blanket turndown service.

Add two more flicks to ever-growing list of movies hidden from critics. "Redline," starring Angus MacFadyen and Eddie Griffin, is set in the world of illegal drag racing, while "Slow Burn" stars Ray Liotta and LL Cool J in a complex murder mystery. Guess those Tomatometers, kids.

"I dare you to make fun of the pompadour."

Also opening this week in limited release: "Red Road," a tense, Hitchcockian meditation on grief, is at 88 percent; the documentary "Jack Smith and the Destruction of Atlantis," about the underground artist, is at 88 percent; "Year of the Dog," a Sundance-approved comedy about the love of man’s best friend starring Molly Shannon, is at 86 percent; the Slamdance-accepted "Rock the Bells," a doc about efforts to stage a Wu-Tang reunion, is at 86 percent; "Private Fears in Public Places," a melodrama about relationships by legendary French director Alain Resnais, is at 82 percent; "Everything’s Gone Green," the tale of a slacker written by Gen-X writer Douglas Coupland, is at 67 percent; and "Lonely Hearts," a noir starring John Travolta, Salma Hayek, and Jared Leto, is at 43 percent.

This one’s strictly for the dogs.

Recent Halle Berry Movies:
57% — X-Men: The Last Stand (2006)
62% — Robots (2005)
9% — Catwoman (2004)
87% — X2: X-Men United (2003)
15% — Gothika (2003)

Recent Richard Gere Movies:
41% — Bee Season (2005)
48% — Shall We Dance? (2004)
86% — Chicago (2002)
47% — Unfaithful (2002)
52% — The Mothman Prophecies (2002)

Tag Cloud

blaxploitation Bravo a nightmare on elm street The Arrangement Netflix cars Summer TV renewals independent ABC Family Instagram Live child's play IMDb TV 45 technology spider-verse Quiz movies science fiction japan richard e. Grant Marvel Television Comic Book animated TV movies live event Drama CMT debate A24 Premiere Dates high school critics Writers Guild of America slasher Sundance TV Disney Winter TV elevated horror reboot Paramount ID all-time kong suspense dreamworks based on movie psycho First Look Fox News new zealand satire festivals Comedy Central space Columbia Pictures Rom-Com Podcast TV Land comic books golden globe awards disaster NYCC Western Apple TV Plus 93rd Oscars VICE WGN Ellie Kemper 20th Century Fox streaming 2021 Hollywood Foreign Press Association latino hollywood composers Disney Plus chucky spider-man discovery game of thrones comiccon ABC Signature indie crime rom-coms FXX ratings Avengers Pet Sematary Music new star wars movies E! diversity Ghostbusters Holidays police drama scorecard Amazon Prime Video TLC politics cancelled television OWN black Marvel Studios 2020 feel good Marvel canceled political drama Ovation RT History book adaptation History Creative Arts Emmys Teen war ESPN marvel comics The Witch Sundance Freeform VOD Rock sag awards robots Chernobyl witnail Britbox documentaries singing competition Amazon PlayStation ABC Apple LGBTQ dramedy Emmys Women's History Month Lifetime Paramount Plus period drama serial killer archives TCA Peacock Cannes cartoon blockbusters slashers Shondaland Tarantino aliens children's TV genre heist movie mockumentary criterion historical drama Trailer Film Festival Crackle kaiju sports die hard 2015 olympics Crunchyroll streaming movies DC Comics Black History Month Martial Arts Disney Channel australia anthology game show The Academy nbcuniversal 73rd Emmy Awards HBO Max binge Superheroes Turner Classic Movies GIFs indiana jones AMC Country video on demand football screen actors guild Vudu target RT21 action-comedy telelvision dexter TV One Animation spy thriller cancelled comic book movie Sci-Fi Image Comics YA superhero Chilling Adventures of Sabrina boxing DGA kids crime drama Wes Anderson young adult Apple TV+ mob unscripted Mindy Kaling BBC America transformers jamie lee curtis natural history BAFTA HBO Comedy romantic comedy Discovery Channel razzies Fox Searchlight Infographic Black Mirror Legendary Best and Worst 21st Century Fox nature cancelled TV shows psychological thriller revenge Box Office Musical Marathons Pirates finale remakes Year in Review mcc godzilla Tokyo Olympics SDCC TruTV Grammys boxoffice rotten CNN 71st Emmy Awards book social media sequels Captain marvel National Geographic prank dogs Spectrum Originals Awards Tour video TBS documentary Travel Channel Thanksgiving Opinion NBC 72 Emmy Awards GLAAD TCM joker universal monsters renewed TV shows YouTube TNT Awards LGBT 007 Film Logo Reality 2019 GoT Classic Film Action asian-american adaptation Nominations legend MSNBC 24 frames halloween tv FX Cartoon Network Star Trek aapi Biopics toy story superman Alien halloween Anna Paquin king kong classics Showtime Tags: Comedy james bond breaking bad fresh First Reviews cops YouTube Premium Rocketman Star Wars adventure PaleyFest art house AMC Plus TCA 2017 docuseries romance Adult Swim gangster CBS All Access stand-up comedy Esquire Baby Yoda saw know your critic Heroines crossover batman monster movies Broadway green book name the review talk show Fall TV news Epix Extras Trivia rt labs critics edition Valentine's Day Tomatazos werewolf Acorn TV Funimation MCU tv talk golden globes thriller WarnerMedia nfl CBS harry potter mission: impossible SundanceTV Winners See It Skip It DC Universe free movies Fantasy biopic New York Comic Con french stoner Photos toronto TIFF cancelled TV series anime spinoff Fargo leaderboard laika Nickelodeon APB DirecTV Comics on TV A&E ViacomCBS medical drama zero dark thirty Sneak Peek Calendar scene in color south america ITV Spring TV Hulu Prime Video TCA Awards cults Countdown Oscars critic resources Brie Larson travel king arthur Pride Month international trailers 4/20 E3 Rocky sopranos Nat Geo trophy 2016 cooking Endgame Musicals foreign Family Cosplay hist 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Walt Disney Pictures Mary poppins movie scary movies Turner new york directors The CW Mary Tyler Moore Warner Bros. italian canceled TV shows worst Food Network comics American Society of Cinematographers Binge Guide rotten movies we love X-Men Red Carpet dc Mary Poppins Returns Disney streaming service zombies Song of Ice and Fire The Walt Disney Company USA Character Guide hidden camera HFPA YouTube Red Watching Series Mudbound TV reviews Exclusive Video Universal Pictures dark cats spain Netflix Christmas movies hispanic heritage month TCA Winter 2020 Lifetime Christmas movies OneApp biography Pacific Islander Trophy Talk worst movies comic VH1 popular The Purge franchise Lionsgate Disney+ Disney Plus Hallmark Christmas movies crime thriller cinemax justice league comedies Polls and Games sequel blockbuster live action Pop Tumblr true crime versus rt archives USA Network Dark Horse Comics Spike christmas movies DC streaming service rt labs spanish Paramount Network BET Awards Hallmark black comedy ghosts pirates of the caribbean 79th Golden Globes Awards spanish language emmy awards 2017 miniseries lord of the rings Stephen King Television Critics Association doctor who Universal Neflix women MTV concert Sundance Now SXSW San Diego Comic-Con wonder woman El Rey supernatural Sony Pictures Election zombie Video Games IFC Academy Awards Arrowverse quibi Emmy Nominations President hispanic scary Amazon Prime posters casting NBA Holiday Interview best Schedule Horror twilight obituary Pixar 90s 1990s jurassic park Kids & Family FOX Lucasfilm venice FX on Hulu strong female leads teaser japanese royal family films Reality Competition sitcom HBO Go Christmas what to watch PBS Set visit mutant fast and furious Toys festival theme song BBC deadpool Tubi Masterpiece docudrama 2018 The Walking Dead stop motion comic book movies Amazon Studios Starz series screenings Hear Us Out Elton John parents Mystery adenture award winner Television Academy dceu 99% BBC One facebook vs. Superheroe dragons IFC Films Syfy Pop TV CW Seed BET basketball television Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Super Bowl marvel cinematic universe Comic-Con@Home 2021 Shudder vampires Certified Fresh