Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Dreamgirls" Hits The High Notes; "Black Christmas" Gets A Lump Of Coal

by | December 28, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got the rise and fall of a girl group ("Dreamgirls," starring Jamie Foxx, Beyonce Knowles, and Eddie Murphy) and some yuletide splatter ("Black Christmas," starring Michelle Trachtenberg). What do the critics have to say?

At the height of its powers, Motown was described by label head Berry Gordy as "the sound of young America." "Dreamgirls" is a musical about a fictional (but loosely based upon the Supremes) girl group’s rise and fall during the heady days when black pop first became the soundtrack for kids across the racial divide. An early Oscar favorite, "Dreamgirls" largely lives up to the hype, according to the pundits, with quality songs and strong performances from Jamie Foxx, Eddie Murphy, and especially "American Idol" castoff Jennifer Hudson. At 77 percent on the Tomatometer, "Dreamgirls" is Certified Fresh.

Eddie Murphy gets on up, like a sex machine…RIP James Brown.

Ah, the holiday season: a time for reflection, goodwill toward others… and piles of dead sorority girls. Nothing makes spirits bright quite like a remake of the 1975 proto-slasher "Black Christmas," which wasn’t screened for critics before hitting theaters on (surprise!) Christmas day. Well, since it opened, a few reviews have trickled in, and they’re not very nice. The plot: a group of sisters trapped inside a sorority house are picked off one-by-one by a prank-calling madman. While some critics say the film has flashes of sick wit, others say it’s too generic and too short on tension to generate scares. At 15 percent on the Tomatometer, "Black Christmas" is on the critics’ "naughty" list.

"Black Christmas": Far more sinister than your average panty raid.

Also opening this week in limited release: the Spanish period comedy "Unconscious" is at 100 percent; Guillermo Del Toro‘s eerie magic realist fantasy "Pan’s Labyrinth" is at 98 percent; "Children of Men," Alfonso Cuaron‘s dystopian sci-fi actioner starring Clive Owen, is at 94 percent; "Notes on a Scandal," a cat-and-mouse thriller starring Cate Blanchett and Judi Dench, is at 82 percent; "Miss Potter," which explores the inner life of children’s author Beatrix Potter and stars Renee Zellweger, is at 71 percent; "Perfume: The Story of a Murderer," Tom Tykwer‘s visually sumptuous serial killer film, is at 58 percent; and "The Dead Girl," a dark, multipart drama starring Toni Collette and Brittany Murphy, is at 50 percent.

Nothing says holiday cheer like a Spanish-language Freudian period sex comedy!

Recent Film Musicals:

50% — Tenacious D: In the Pick of Destiny (2006)
48% — Rent (2005)
88% — Chicago (2002)
77% — Moulin Rouge (2001)
93% — Hedwig and the Angry Inch (2001)

Recent Horror Remakes:
14% — The Wicker Man (2006)
13% — Pulse (2006)
27% — The Omen (2006)
48% — The Hills Have Eyes (2006)
10% — When a Stranger Calls (2006)

Tag Cloud

marvel cinematic universe halloween Arrowverse Lucasfilm monster movies Legendary art house reviews 2018 Watching Series video 94th Oscars TNT legend Teen australia WGN posters travel films sequel Television Academy Sundance Now Mary Tyler Moore critic resources Disney streaming service deadpool South by Southwest Film Festival Warner Bros. Holidays 99% obituary VOD Polls and Games spy thriller Reality Competition Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 2020 AMC Awards archives Nickelodeon ratings facebook Drama Ghostbusters concert adaptation Academy Awards Rocketman live action feel good Lionsgate target scene in color Comedy Sneak Peek scary summer preview Chernobyl king arthur what to watch revenge composers Disney Channel 2021 canceled dexter name the review Rock Rocky National Geographic Mary poppins comic book movie FXX Year in Review Turner Mindy Kaling debate news social media Spring TV A&E summer TV Lifetime Amazon Prime Christmas wonder woman President jurassic park olympics Extras 71st Emmy Awards hollywood romantic comedy Ellie Kemper child's play black comedy Sony Pictures Toys Apple TV+ Peacock nature Super Bowl Black Mirror TCA 2017 christmas movies Marvel aliens directors Musical Valentine's Day Paramount Plus sequels women telelvision The Arrangement Winners 4/20 Star Wars genre Baby Yoda spanish language Horror all-time comics mission: impossible Emmys Superheroe french 2015 ABC Signature 2019 Musicals Trophy Talk BBC One El Rey Western cancelled TV series Ovation Awards Tour MGM summer TV preview basketball Set visit festival action-comedy satire comedies APB Quiz Star Wars Celebration 2017 criterion BET Awards prank Mystery Infographic USA Network rotten movies we love Stephen King Podcast Family Reality blockbusters anime psycho TV One universal monsters marvel comics Rom-Com spanish fast and furious Hear Us Out SundanceTV new star wars movies The Purge police drama OWN Best Picture Elton John cancelled television Tokyo Olympics free movies best royal family mockumentary adventure Comic Book BET black Image Comics biopic Emmy Nominations First Look Certified Fresh PaleyFest science fiction Broadway Tomatazos 20th Century Fox game of thrones true crime Fargo worst rt labs critics edition Binge Guide The Walt Disney Company football italian streamig popular Countdown Showtime spider-man comic book movies NBC scene in color TCA Awards Grammys indie The CW cancelled PBS Walt Disney Pictures YouTube Red MTV Sci-Fi Paramount Pictures toy story leaderboard WarnerMedia japanese period drama strong female leads DirecTV reboot romance Captain marvel cartoon Calendar Comedy Central new zealand GIFs The Walking Dead werewolf series mutant interviews Netflix Christmas movies BBC Instagram Live vampires richard e. Grant Pop TV game show chucky Disney+ Disney Plus Spectrum Originals CBS Shondaland joker diversity 2016 Sony foreign saw SXSW 2022 dramedy Amazon Prime Video DC Universe festivals movies stand-up comedy Brie Larson Alien Pop scene in color film series Interview robots Cosplay sag awards Pacific Islander Paramount Network Esquire TV Geeked Week casting Amazon animated miniseries 73rd Emmy Awards binge Box Office television Funimation finale green book Election dogs Spike 24 frames kids hidden camera History Travel Channel rotten HFPA GLAAD Tubi 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards The Witch medical drama Best and Worst Hollywood Foreign Press Association dragons BBC America doctor who Logo anthology Action Kids & Family Star Trek boxoffice remakes new york biography SXSW obi wan spider-verse trailers comic books Pet Sematary American Society of Cinematographers Pirates Trailer Syfy 90s YA ID kong movie streaming movies DC streaming service GoT zombie political drama book PlayStation Oscars Cannes rt archives Acorn TV laika docuseries TV renewals batman NYCC dc japan classics aapi zombies TCA Winter 2020 superman Discovery Channel IFC Creative Arts Emmys independent fresh video on demand DGA cops documentaries Nat Geo Dark Horse Comics kaiju harry potter Red Carpet 1990s gangster superhero elevated horror venice docudrama war lord of the rings scene in color series screen actors guild MSNBC HBO hist Endgame disaster stoner Wes Anderson cars south america zero dark thirty mcc crime thriller Country Tumblr golden globe awards The Academy Food Network Amazon Studios Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Classic Film latino documentary dceu Best Actress scary movies space TruTV Video Games Film Festival Netflix Marvel Studios emmy awards TCA ESPN Tarantino Exclusive Video Fox Searchlight international singing competition breaking bad 79th Golden Globes Awards Martial Arts psychological thriller franchise Superheroes suspense quibi blaxploitation Lifetime Christmas movies screenings crime drama San Diego Comic-Con die hard TLC CNN Tags: Comedy Freeform rt labs crossover Nominations sitcom hispanic YouTube Neflix parents target blockbuster ViacomCBS Sundance TV HBO Go Fantasy based on movie spinoff Crunchyroll book adaptation streaming Summer thriller crime Universal Pictures Fall TV dark serial killer sopranos talk show tv talk ABC Family AMC Plus Schedule MCU 93rd Oscars cooking FOX theme song live event Holiday USA Disney Columbia Pictures asian-american Adult Swim RT History SDCC YouTube Premium Trivia Crackle Hulu Masterpiece vs. Opinion Native toronto trophy Epix comic technology indiana jones Disney Plus Bravo Best Actor VH1 versus witnail IFC Films godzilla award winner X-Men Comic-Con@Home 2021 BAFTA DC Comics TBS Fox News historical drama Universal canceled TV shows twilight Britbox NBA Vudu E3 scorecard mob teaser nbcuniversal cancelled TV shows critics cats high school Hallmark Christmas movies natural history Premiere Dates FX TV Land Marvel Television Paramount Music 007 james bond Focus Features broadcast slashers golden globes Anna Paquin jamie lee curtis Hallmark Apple TV Plus E! dreamworks comiccon pirates of the caribbean Mary Poppins Returns heist movie Women's History Month LGBTQ Pixar LGBT young adult TIFF Photos Thanksgiving Sundance First Reviews Black History Month sports FX on Hulu Shudder cinemax hispanic heritage month spain Heroines OneApp Biopics 72 Emmy Awards a nightmare on elm street Marathons politics justice league children's TV slasher ABC VICE IMDb TV CMT CBS All Access rom-coms Pride Month cults TCM Starz CW Seed TV movies See It Skip It Character Guide New York Comic Con Comics on TV Television Critics Association stop motion Avengers 45 Oscar Turner Classic Movies supernatural worst movies Best Director Mudbound Cartoon Network unscripted king kong ghosts nfl Indigenous boxing Song of Ice and Fire razzies halloween tv Film Apple know your critic RT21 discovery Prime Video Winter TV A24 Writers Guild of America Animation renewed TV shows ITV adenture HBO Max transformers 21st Century Fox