Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Dreamgirls" Hits The High Notes; "Black Christmas" Gets A Lump Of Coal

by | December 28, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got the rise and fall of a girl group ("Dreamgirls," starring Jamie Foxx, Beyonce Knowles, and Eddie Murphy) and some yuletide splatter ("Black Christmas," starring Michelle Trachtenberg). What do the critics have to say?

At the height of its powers, Motown was described by label head Berry Gordy as "the sound of young America." "Dreamgirls" is a musical about a fictional (but loosely based upon the Supremes) girl group’s rise and fall during the heady days when black pop first became the soundtrack for kids across the racial divide. An early Oscar favorite, "Dreamgirls" largely lives up to the hype, according to the pundits, with quality songs and strong performances from Jamie Foxx, Eddie Murphy, and especially "American Idol" castoff Jennifer Hudson. At 77 percent on the Tomatometer, "Dreamgirls" is Certified Fresh.

Eddie Murphy gets on up, like a sex machine…RIP James Brown.

Ah, the holiday season: a time for reflection, goodwill toward others… and piles of dead sorority girls. Nothing makes spirits bright quite like a remake of the 1975 proto-slasher "Black Christmas," which wasn’t screened for critics before hitting theaters on (surprise!) Christmas day. Well, since it opened, a few reviews have trickled in, and they’re not very nice. The plot: a group of sisters trapped inside a sorority house are picked off one-by-one by a prank-calling madman. While some critics say the film has flashes of sick wit, others say it’s too generic and too short on tension to generate scares. At 15 percent on the Tomatometer, "Black Christmas" is on the critics’ "naughty" list.

"Black Christmas": Far more sinister than your average panty raid.

Also opening this week in limited release: the Spanish period comedy "Unconscious" is at 100 percent; Guillermo Del Toro‘s eerie magic realist fantasy "Pan’s Labyrinth" is at 98 percent; "Children of Men," Alfonso Cuaron‘s dystopian sci-fi actioner starring Clive Owen, is at 94 percent; "Notes on a Scandal," a cat-and-mouse thriller starring Cate Blanchett and Judi Dench, is at 82 percent; "Miss Potter," which explores the inner life of children’s author Beatrix Potter and stars Renee Zellweger, is at 71 percent; "Perfume: The Story of a Murderer," Tom Tykwer‘s visually sumptuous serial killer film, is at 58 percent; and "The Dead Girl," a dark, multipart drama starring Toni Collette and Brittany Murphy, is at 50 percent.

Nothing says holiday cheer like a Spanish-language Freudian period sex comedy!

Recent Film Musicals:

50% — Tenacious D: In the Pick of Destiny (2006)
48% — Rent (2005)
88% — Chicago (2002)
77% — Moulin Rouge (2001)
93% — Hedwig and the Angry Inch (2001)

Recent Horror Remakes:
14% — The Wicker Man (2006)
13% — Pulse (2006)
27% — The Omen (2006)
48% — The Hills Have Eyes (2006)
10% — When a Stranger Calls (2006)

Tag Cloud

Film Nickelodeon 2019 debate singing competition anime Valentine's Day Mary Tyler Moore WarnerMedia reboot nfl crime king kong The Walt Disney Company know your critic DirecTV Oscars President films Film Festival screen actors guild Tags: Comedy parents LGBT Wes Anderson movies remakes art house Disney+ Disney Plus talk show indiana jones Cannes Image Comics name the review scary Fox Searchlight USA Network screenings Spectrum Originals San Diego Comic-Con 1990s miniseries zero dark thirty 73rd Emmy Awards Year in Review kaiju slashers HBO Max theme song television war MCU TCM 4/20 Character Guide Winter TV hidden camera gangster toy story stoner crossover Marathons feel good boxoffice transformers trophy streaming movies dreamworks 93rd Oscars women Stephen King AMC Plus archives dexter police drama ABC Signature mutant TNT BBC One sag awards vs. TCA Winter 2020 Horror series trailers Schedule streaming Fall TV natural history APB Amazon social media hollywood USA Epix halloween tv Disney streaming service psycho 45 Universal spinoff cooking Nominations stop motion Avengers MSNBC BET Awards Pixar universal monsters australia Black Mirror casting revenge japanese obituary OneApp Chernobyl renewed TV shows Peacock Syfy Paramount Plus italian worst IFC Films Pirates basketball CBS festivals based on movie new york 21st Century Fox NBA Tubi crime thriller Shudder teaser Lionsgate Spring TV award winner Star Wars adenture critics Rocketman TV movies reviews Toys adventure biopic medical drama Mary poppins new star wars movies Pride Month strong female leads TLC period drama comic book movies die hard Sci-Fi dragons dark Extras Fantasy jamie lee curtis godzilla comic books Pacific Islander TruTV YouTube Premium action-comedy black comedy Britbox Showtime worst movies 2017 OWN discovery twilight saw fast and furious 99% doctor who dceu Instagram Live Heroines CW Seed olympics Amazon Prime Video BAFTA spanish Thanksgiving cinemax National Geographic ITV Masterpiece 2021 Drama Countdown FX on Hulu franchise Marvel Studios travel game of thrones RT21 SXSW anthology Comic Book Watching Series Academy Awards cancelled television A24 TIFF Biopics spider-verse Apple TV Plus christmas movies classics foreign spanish language Food Network Podcast The Arrangement 20th Century Fox GLAAD Crunchyroll fresh El Rey Kids & Family documentaries Mary Poppins Returns Teen ID Prime Video Box Office Musical ViacomCBS true crime adaptation Vudu TBS TV Land free movies 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Martial Arts kong suspense Amazon Studios scorecard Sneak Peek mockumentary cults RT History Amazon Prime marvel comics CNN legend popular space Musicals Arrowverse canceled breaking bad what to watch Certified Fresh lord of the rings mission: impossible See It Skip It superhero unscripted Trivia toronto black dogs Turner Classic Movies cancelled TV series Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Sundance Reality cancelled HBO Go Hallmark Christmas movies richard e. Grant IMDb TV Quiz aapi BBC cops romantic comedy CBS All Access Anna Paquin Tokyo Olympics Ghostbusters The Witch cars romance indie Television Academy Pop TV psychological thriller halloween Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Women's History Month New York Comic Con Paramount Network Lifetime Christmas movies First Reviews target Comedy Central Shondaland Baby Yoda HFPA Ovation scary movies aliens independent ratings Rock comics tv talk best zombies green book Captain marvel Reality Competition versus Legendary 2020 Dark Horse Comics Family politics crime drama DC Universe The CW latino Sundance Now 2016 high school child's play A&E Apple rt labs Star Trek Superheroes Walt Disney Pictures chucky SundanceTV mob Video Games rom-coms Animation diversity The Purge YouTube Red Starz Ellie Kemper nature zombie Mystery Cartoon Network sopranos Marvel Television dramedy Trailer SDCC Alien DGA joker deadpool Super Bowl American Society of Cinematographers The Walking Dead Acorn TV LGBTQ 90s HBO scene in color Columbia Pictures razzies YA game show spider-man jurassic park quibi finale Black History Month justice league Nat Geo political drama Tumblr Lifetime concert Calendar golden globe awards cats satire comedies DC streaming service emmy awards Awards Tour ABC Family james bond all-time Creative Arts Emmys Grammys stand-up comedy rotten book adaptation Best and Worst pirates of the caribbean Warner Bros. TV Comedy spy thriller Hear Us Out biography Adult Swim cancelled TV shows Mindy Kaling composers FX blaxploitation movie venice Premiere Dates The Academy superman comiccon slasher Disney Channel sequel Elton John batman NYCC Western asian-american X-Men Tarantino kids comic DC Comics TCA facebook Crackle directors historical drama Mudbound 2018 Holiday Television Critics Association video on demand canceled TV shows Cosplay Hallmark blockbusters Discovery Channel TV One spain Trophy Talk PBS MTV football Paramount genre blockbuster VH1 animated prank rotten movies we love BBC America live event docudrama heist movie sequels Apple TV+ Emmy Nominations Interview french Christmas Photos 2015 hispanic critic resources book binge 007 Rom-Com supernatural marvel cinematic universe Freeform documentary VOD robots comic book movie Set visit docuseries vampires Esquire hist disaster Binge Guide Action Hulu ghosts Comics on TV Pet Sematary CMT mcc criterion YouTube Lucasfilm NBC PaleyFest Turner Universal Pictures Polls and Games Spike Neflix 24 frames Pop technology rt labs critics edition Bravo laika dc WGN Infographic TCA 2017 video Emmys news sitcom posters thriller king arthur wonder woman Exclusive Video 72 Emmy Awards Classic Film japan Disney Plus VICE Summer young adult GoT sports Endgame Funimation golden globes PlayStation ESPN elevated horror TCA Awards Fox News Superheroe Writers Guild of America Election harry potter monster movies leaderboard Netflix Sony Pictures Holidays TV renewals E3 71st Emmy Awards rt archives First Look nbcuniversal telelvision Disney Sundance TV Travel Channel Marvel boxing Red Carpet Hollywood Foreign Press Association E! FOX south america Tomatazos History GIFs Rocky AMC Netflix Christmas movies serial killer Fargo Broadway Opinion a nightmare on elm street live action festival ABC international cartoon 79th Golden Globes Awards Country Brie Larson witnail FXX Song of Ice and Fire Comic-Con@Home 2021 BET werewolf Winners Music Logo new zealand science fiction hispanic heritage month royal family Awards IFC children's TV