Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Borat" Best Reviewed Film Of Year: High-Five!; "Flushed Away" Worth A Spin; "Santa Clause 3" Gets Coal

by | November 2, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies brings us the profound discoveries of a great Kazak journalist ("Borat," starring Sacha Baron Cohen), a battle between Santa and Jack Frost ("The Santa Clause 3: The Escape Clause," starring Tim Allen), and a tale of rats in the sewer ("Flushed Away," featuring the voice work of Kate Winslet and Hugh Jackman). What do the critics have to say?

Jagshemash! Here in U.S and A., what do critic say about "Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan?" They like! In fact, the scribes are almost universally pleased with the film, and some are going as far as calling it one of the funniest comedies ever. Part satire, part shockumentary, "Borat" follows the gleefully sexist, homophobic, and anti-Semitic title character (Cohen) on a cross-country trek to learn more about our strange nation; along the way he dredges up the seamy underbelly of American prejudice and ignorance. At 95 percent on the Tomatometer, "Borat" is not only Certified Fresh, it’s the best reviewed wide release of the year, topping such acclaimed movies as "Dave Chappelle’s Block Party," "The Departed," and "United 93." That’s a good thing, since Borat himself has said if the movie doesn’t do well, he will be execute.

Borat loves the U.S. and A.

It doesn’t sound like the most auspicious subject for a film: mice and rats are flushed down a toilet, where they find a bustling municipality in the sewer. However, in the hands of Aardman Productions, the endlessly imaginative company responsible for "Chicken Run" and "Wallace and Gromit," anything is possible. And so it is with "Flushed Away," which tells the upstairs-downstairs tale of a coddled mouse who finds action and adventure after a trip through the plumbing. Critics say that while "Flushed Away" may not achieve the dizzying heights of "Wallace & Gromit: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit" (which scored 95 percent on the Tomatometer), it’s an eccentric, inventive family film with plenty of laughs. At 76 percent on the Tomatometer, "Flushed Away" is critically sanitized for your viewing pleasure.

Dive in! It’s fresh!

"The Santa Clause 3: The Escape Clause," was barely screened for critics, much like star Tim Allen‘s last flick, "Zoom." The big difference is that "Clause" at least has a couple good reviews, whereas "Zoom" had none. The story of Santa’s duel with Jack Frost for control over Christmas, "Clause" hasn’t exactly enchanted the critics who have seen it; they say the movie is labored and mostly mirthless. It’s currently at 29 percent on the Tomatometer.

Yes, Virginia, there is a "Santa Clause 3."

Also opening this week in limited release: "Commune," a documentary about the Black Bear Ranch in California, is at 100 percent; "Romantico," a heartbreaking documentary about a musician working illegally in the U.S., is at 100 percent; Pedro Almodovar‘s "Volver," starring Penelope Cruz in a complex tale of womanhood, is Certified Fresh at 90 percent; "Wondrous Oblivion," the story of a boy and his neighbor who bond over the game of cricket, is at 60 percent; "Death & Texas," a death penalty satire, is at 60 percent; the twisty thriller "Unknown," starring Greg Kinnear, is at 29 percent; "Shottas," a based-on-true-events Jamaican crime flick, is at 20 percent; and "Zerophilia," a gender-bending rom-com, is at 18 percent.

Pedro Almodovar and Penelope Cruz take a spectral walk down memory lane with "Volver." Check out our retrospective of the Spanish director’s work here.

Finally, we’d like to bestow props upon the whimsically monikered killthemall4444, who correctly predicted that the equally whimsical "Saw III" would wind up with a Tomatometer of 28 percent. Congrats, ktm4444.

Best Reviewed Wide Releases of 2006:
95% — Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan
93% — Dave Chappelle’s Block Party
93% — The Departed
90% — United 93
88% — Inside Man
84%– Akeelah and the Bee
83% — Slither
83% — The Descent
80% — A Prairie Home Companion
79% — Catch a Fire

Recent Tim Allen Movies:
0% — Zoom (2006)
28% — The Shaggy Dog (2006)
4% — Christmas with the Kranks (2004)
55% — The Santa Clause 2 (2002)
22% — Who Is Cletis Tout? (2002)

Recent Sacha Baron Cohen Movies:
72% — Talladega Nights: The Ballad of Ricky Bobby (2006)
55% — Madagascar (2005)
55% — Ali G Indahouse: The Movie (2002)

Tag Cloud

Musicals Showtime Academy Awards Rom-Com sequel comedies anthology godzilla critic resources Comic Book E3 Prime Video Interview kong live action 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards football OWN archives genre king arthur Indigenous E! SundanceTV Peacock revenge CNN art house Paramount Pictures comiccon First Reviews know your critic Dark Horse Comics Writers Guild of America Biopics obituary olympics emmy awards Kids & Family Reality Competition DC Comics Geeked Week renewed TV shows Musical Thanksgiving richard e. Grant documentaries A24 Pet Sematary BAFTA BET reboot Countdown USA Network Black Mirror Black History Month The Walking Dead Mindy Kaling Mary Poppins Returns interviews teaser razzies Lifetime Christmas movies theme song Fox Searchlight scene in color series serial killer Red Carpet streaming sitcom Classic Film golden globe awards X-Men golden globes spider-man social media trophy TCA 2017 trailers Trophy Talk technology Super Bowl game of thrones Columbia Pictures Turner Classic Movies strong female leads CBS streamig The Purge Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Animation vs. batman Music black comedy Television Academy composers worst festival NBA king kong lord of the rings Pop heist movie Spike concert best Fargo Baby Yoda Amazon Prime Video Infographic festivals action-comedy Election Action Amazon Studios Set visit HBO Max Quiz 99% Sundance TV National Geographic Superheroes Song of Ice and Fire medical drama Legendary BBC America Paramount movies Acorn TV GoT critics docudrama SXSW Universal Pictures spider-verse Fall TV Cartoon Network romance marvel cinematic universe IMDb TV crime drama satire Sony Pictures Apple series El Rey Paramount Plus cars Video Games 2018 The Arrangement cinemax summer preview scene in color film series Trivia The Academy ghosts Captain marvel Bravo Best Actress The Walt Disney Company what to watch PlayStation 20th Century Fox adaptation romantic comedy video Hulu 2021 historical drama south america obi wan Instagram Live comic book movies Lionsgate Trailer Netflix Star Trek New York Comic Con Ovation DC Universe scary movies Hallmark Anna Paquin TCM AMC Plus Fantasy Epix zero dark thirty BET Awards fast and furious Emmy Nominations Marvel Studios RT21 90s mockumentary YA crime thriller debate transformers rom-coms Travel Channel mutant aliens name the review Universal Amazon TV Land Mudbound tv talk Disney+ Disney Plus police drama mcc french adventure popular TCA Awards Horror 2017 Netflix Christmas movies saw target scene in color Hear Us Out war 2015 international rotten Heroines Apple TV+ LGBT Photos scorecard cancelled TV series political drama Best Picture Lifetime Logo Box Office wonder woman dc Comedy Central Film Festival prank Pixar basketball Elton John nfl high school stand-up comedy 2020 disaster Polls and Games Rocketman TV 1990s Oscars Spring TV Disney streaming service spanish language MCU leaderboard Brie Larson hist sag awards ESPN spy thriller new york Focus Features BBC CMT Nominations NBC feel good foreign Exclusive Video Pacific Islander nature Binge Guide science fiction PaleyFest Crunchyroll Premiere Dates HFPA telelvision dexter Arrowverse doctor who See It Skip It VICE Mary poppins criterion 45 blockbuster book adaptation Tags: Comedy Stephen King mission: impossible rt labs critics edition BBC One TruTV Mystery MTV stop motion harry potter comic books ABC Signature 21st Century Fox screen actors guild Star Wars WarnerMedia TCA Winter 2020 Marvel Television YouTube Red cancelled TV shows toronto Toys jurassic park Martial Arts indiana jones Broadway jamie lee curtis ID crossover Native 2019 Christmas unscripted docuseries Oscar natural history travel Schedule versus children's TV summer TV dragons Mary Tyler Moore zombies independent Syfy Teen broadcast NYCC Character Guide Winners parents book worst movies spinoff Esquire SDCC zombie cancelled television cancelled kaiju superhero ITV DGA History TV movies GIFs aapi rotten movies we love MGM screenings cops Nickelodeon Sony The CW politics GLAAD robots Nat Geo Wes Anderson scene in color Pirates AMC comic Comics on TV spain Awards based on movie child's play First Look Hollywood Foreign Press Association ABC discovery YouTube japanese quibi game show kids free movies mob DC streaming service TNT MSNBC die hard OneApp chucky directors ABC Family dreamworks australia universal monsters gangster Pop TV Superheroe dark Turner a nightmare on elm street Disney Plus Discovery Channel young adult Holiday dceu 4/20 psycho Lucasfilm blockbusters elevated horror 79th Golden Globes Awards target asian-american witnail crime Calendar breaking bad biography thriller TBS Cannes CW Seed TCA singing competition Summer sopranos slashers Warner Bros. joker canceled IFC Films Tokyo Olympics TV renewals cooking slasher christmas movies halloween tv nbcuniversal 93rd Oscars TV One japan Apple TV Plus Grammys talk show movie new zealand space Amazon Prime rt archives canceled TV shows Country DirecTV award winner diversity cats Valentine's Day true crime USA A&E posters green book ViacomCBS Western Adult Swim 72 Emmy Awards Comic-Con@Home 2021 franchise Shudder supernatural Sci-Fi animated Masterpiece toy story ratings Walt Disney Pictures VH1 Opinion Holidays miniseries Comedy Crackle psychological thriller IFC RT History scary 71st Emmy Awards rt labs Food Network Alien summer TV preview TLC blaxploitation indie stoner Women's History Month Avengers venice Freeform sports SXSW 2022 new star wars movies Drama anime Watching Series Best Actor Vudu cults justice league Creative Arts Emmys Pride Month Tumblr dramedy comic book movie Sundance sequels superman Star Wars Celebration adenture Best and Worst Tomatazos live event hispanic Image Comics legend FX on Hulu HBO women Ghostbusters video on demand 007 classics Spectrum Originals Tubi facebook cartoon Disney VOD news Neflix suspense spanish italian FOX San Diego Comic-Con WGN Chernobyl hidden camera period drama 2016 black halloween binge Hallmark Christmas movies 94th Oscars Britbox Starz royal family hollywood reviews Rocky FX Disney Channel twilight FXX Sneak Peek PBS Emmys comics laika Cosplay Television Critics Association 24 frames biopic Marvel boxoffice TIFF vampires Awards Tour films deadpool Ellie Kemper remakes pirates of the caribbean streaming movies Marathons APB documentary Certified Fresh Year in Review South by Southwest Film Festival all-time Family casting boxing monster movies The Witch YouTube Premium President Sundance Now Shondaland Best Director Podcast LGBTQ HBO Go werewolf fresh 73rd Emmy Awards CBS All Access dogs latino marvel comics hispanic heritage month finale Rock Winter TV Endgame Extras Tarantino Funimation television Film Fox News Chilling Adventures of Sabrina American Society of Cinematographers Reality Paramount Network james bond