Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: A Sad "Happily"; A Messy "Cleaner"; Inspiring "Writers"; and Powerful "Men"

by | January 4, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a postmodern fairy tale ("Happily N’Ever After," with voicework from Sigourney Weaver and Sarah Michelle Gellar), a wacky conspiracy caper ("Code Name: The Cleaner," starring Cedric the Entertainer and Lucy Liu), a committed teacher ("Freedom Writers," starring Hilary Swank), and a chilling dystopia ("Children of Men," starring Clive Owen and Michael Caine). What do the critics have to say?

Once upon a time, in the land of make-believe (better known as Hollywood), there was a brand new formula for making dazzling kiddie movies. It was called CG, and children all over the world rejoiced when such fare as "Toy Story" and "Shrek" hit the theaters. But then an evil curse plagued the land, as a string of mediocre stories threatened to make CG stale. The latest: "Happily N’Ever After," a postmodern "Cinderella" spoof. Critics say this is a pretty charm-free affair, with less-than-dazzling images and a bland storyline. At six percent on the Tomatometer, this is a pretty grim fairy tale. And among CG features, only "Doogal," at five percent, is lower-rated.

"Sure, magic will do the dishes, but can it make my movie funny?"

Cedric the Entertainer is a funny guy, and as a supporting player he’s stolen scenes in everything from "Lemony Snicket" to "Be Cool." Sadly, he’s yet to have a starring vehicle that has utilized his comedic talents to the fullest, and it appears "Code Name: The Cleaner" is no exception. In this action/comedy, Cedric plays a janitor who stumbles into the middle of a government conspiracy, from which he tries to extricate himself with the help of Lucy Liu. The critics say the weak script does none of the actors any favors, playing up absurd thriller elements to leaden effect. At a big fat zero percent on the Tomatometer, this one’s in dire need of a "Clean-" up.

"Yes, I’ve always enjoyed the sophisticated yet robust taste of Xtreme Fruit Skittles."

Liberal and conservative education experts both have it wrong. What our inner city schools need is neither greater funding nor vouchers. In order to save the impoverished students of America, we need an unconventional, no-nonsense teacher to instruct students in ballroom dance, football, or poetry, preferably in the guise of Antonio Banderas, The Rock, or Michelle Pfeiffer. In "Freedom Writers," Hilary Swank plays a fresh-faced teacher who gets her students in touch with their creative writing side, and — wonder of wonders — it’s getting reasonably good reviews. The critics say the film may be clichéd, but it’s earnest and features strong performances. At 64 percent on the Tomatometer, this may be one to "Write" home about.

"Remember, Bagels for Complacency Day is next week."

Director Alfonso Cuaron may have made his best movie yet with "Children of Men," continuing a hot streak that began with "Y Tu Mama Tambien" and "Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban." This time, Cuaron has envisioned a world where women have become infertile and every country has become a dystopia or slipped into a fascist state. At 92 percent on the Tomatometer, critics are praising not only the film’s technical aspects (including seamless CG work, fluid camerawork, and complex battle scenes), but also the emotional story and performances.

"Any fool knows a dog needs a home and shelter from pigs on the wing."

Also opening this week in limited release is "Thr3e," a psychological serial killer flick with a spiritual twist, which is currently at 17 percent.

Alex Vo contributed to this article.

Recent CG Animated Films:
77% — Happy Feet (2006)
76% — Flushed Away (2006)
41% — Everyone’s Hero (2006)
76% — Cars (2006)
64% — The Ant Bully (2006)

Recent Hilary Swank Movies:
36% — The Black Dahlia (2006)
92% — Million Dollar Baby (2004)
100% — 11:14 (2003)
42% — The Core (2003)
92% — Insomnia (2002)

Recent Cedric the Entertainer Movies:
81% — Charlotte’s Web (2006)
14% — Honeymooners (2005)
55% — Madagascar (2005)
29% — Be Cool (2005)
9% — Man of the House (2005)

Recent Clive Owen Movies:
88% — Inside Man (2006)
21% — Derailed (2005)
77% — Sin City (2005)
68% — Closer (2004)
29% — King Arthur (2004)

Tag Cloud

PBS HBO Max king kong Shondaland PlayStation space mob USA scene in color Oscars VH1 golden globe awards YouTube Premium Sneak Peek Spectrum Originals Paramount Plus Emmys adenture Podcast quibi movies remakes cats screen actors guild AMC Black Mirror Peacock Pride Month obituary leaderboard strong female leads Animation Walt Disney Pictures spider-verse dceu Music versus Rocky Travel Channel WarnerMedia Horror genre Awards Tour action-comedy critics The CW The Witch Anna Paquin feel good IMDb TV Christmas Tags: Comedy DirecTV diversity Tubi romantic comedy Binge Guide emmy awards TNT docuseries high school fast and furious Musical Watching Series Starz Best and Worst japanese foreign sports Disney natural history Adult Swim blockbuster Hear Us Out canceled TV shows First Reviews Tokyo Olympics rt archives Cosplay kaiju 45 cancelled El Rey cinemax kids heist movie MTV Paramount Network cooking Rom-Com prank Ovation know your critic Crunchyroll lord of the rings harry potter Drama Holiday YA dark Martial Arts robots comic books new york rt labs TLC Disney Plus Fargo children's TV Mindy Kaling Reality Competition franchise TV movies 20th Century Fox Instagram Live Disney+ Disney Plus Academy Awards Star Trek First Look Sony Pictures kong toronto golden globes international Syfy Fox Searchlight Marathons hist Certified Fresh parents CBS Disney Channel all-time The Arrangement DC streaming service Cartoon Network boxing comics TCM See It Skip It Awards renewed TV shows Amazon Prime Video ID telelvision suspense Writers Guild of America Grammys art house critic resources Ellie Kemper HFPA book Disney streaming service spinoff VICE Rock Teen Kids & Family Apple Extras BBC America justice league zombies indiana jones women President independent royal family satire what to watch teaser saw Super Bowl Superheroe fresh psychological thriller movie classics 2017 4/20 Acorn TV olympics chucky LGBT YouTube History crime thriller 73rd Emmy Awards worst movies asian-american Set visit toy story ABC Tarantino reboot The Walt Disney Company Nickelodeon Captain marvel E! criterion ratings historical drama casting Sci-Fi Thanksgiving disaster Warner Bros. Masterpiece Classic Film Spike Pirates Pop OneApp 79th Golden Globes Awards anime X-Men binge comic book movies award winner Stephen King 71st Emmy Awards 2015 posters DGA Fantasy TCA Awards werewolf trailers 93rd Oscars Women's History Month richard e. Grant worst based on movie video miniseries Universal Pictures Song of Ice and Fire VOD CMT biography RT21 Marvel scary movies Chernobyl Election Television Critics Association Action Turner DC Comics spider-man Epix streaming movies Musicals 2020 Fox News wonder woman ghosts FOX cars Pixar IFC Films 1990s venice Broadway documentary 72 Emmy Awards superman black canceled Film witnail TCA Reality comic slashers festival adventure travel Polls and Games aliens dexter monster movies stop motion laika 99% nature pirates of the caribbean TV Land Valentine's Day deadpool target Infographic ITV Endgame psycho cops National Geographic football screenings transformers 2016 name the review breaking bad Baby Yoda Mary Poppins Returns Avengers NBC Sundance TV Star Wars RT History king arthur The Walking Dead SXSW Hallmark Christmas movies Hulu Food Network blockbusters italian cartoon romance dragons BET Awards Esquire E3 Winter TV batman Superheroes mutant Red Carpet Spring TV crime drama technology AMC Plus Prime Video halloween Brie Larson Pop TV A&E BET DC Universe sopranos Mystery FX ESPN video on demand Calendar boxoffice USA Network Western trophy game of thrones dramedy nbcuniversal Showtime The Academy IFC black comedy serial killer directors GIFs documentaries Marvel Studios Netflix Christmas movies archives green book indie Rocketman Trivia Trailer Comics on TV spanish language cults police drama Winners GLAAD french sag awards talk show Apple TV Plus debate vampires Countdown Legendary Box Office young adult Film Festival streaming twilight TBS 90s festivals reviews Photos Amazon Prime CW Seed scorecard doctor who unscripted Crackle Pacific Islander a nightmare on elm street Nominations japan popular Video Games south america Freeform Dark Horse Comics films Exclusive Video NYCC Hallmark adaptation halloween tv social media live event Tomatazos comedies Toys theme song Lifetime hispanic San Diego Comic-Con facebook Lifetime Christmas movies Television Academy comic book movie dogs BAFTA MSNBC rotten YouTube Red GoT stoner Image Comics new zealand PaleyFest joker razzies SundanceTV animated australia television 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards marvel cinematic universe supernatural ABC Family Arrowverse legend Logo cancelled TV shows Discovery Channel mockumentary cancelled television Interview rom-coms Country Biopics Heroines best Tumblr nfl CBS All Access Hollywood Foreign Press Association ViacomCBS sequels A24 Mary poppins Sundance APB sitcom 2018 thriller Creative Arts Emmys Wes Anderson superhero Mary Tyler Moore Columbia Pictures rt labs critics edition TCA Winter 2020 latino CNN SDCC composers New York Comic Con The Purge Comic Book jurassic park series medical drama Apple TV+ Elton John Paramount TCA 2017 WGN Marvel Television political drama LGBTQ hispanic heritage month marvel comics Lionsgate Summer Comedy Year in Review Amazon Studios HBO Lucasfilm singing competition spy thriller spanish Britbox comiccon anthology TV TruTV BBC Amazon Cannes Sundance Now Nat Geo 007 BBC One Premiere Dates biopic jamie lee curtis book adaptation Vudu war crime mission: impossible Funimation godzilla concert 21st Century Fox TV One news Comedy Central rotten movies we love Netflix die hard ABC Signature universal monsters Fall TV crossover zero dark thirty Pet Sematary 2021 slasher true crime politics cancelled TV series FX on Hulu Universal new star wars movies Mudbound elevated horror zombie Schedule Holidays Alien vs. MCU Opinion period drama Ghostbusters Quiz dreamworks OWN discovery Character Guide hollywood game show james bond Shudder 24 frames free movies stand-up comedy dc spain mcc child's play TIFF aapi gangster 2019 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina christmas movies finale tv talk basketball Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt science fiction Family sequel docudrama HBO Go NBA Bravo TV renewals Trophy Talk American Society of Cinematographers Comic-Con@Home 2021 hidden camera Turner Classic Movies Emmy Nominations blaxploitation Black History Month revenge scary FXX Neflix live action