Hear Us Out

5 Reasons Why Peter Jackson's King Kong Is a Brilliant Example of a Remake Done Right

15 years after its release, Jackson's film still feels deeply personal, and it features another incredible motion-capture performance from Andy Serkis.

by | December 14, 2020 | Comments

King Kong (2005)

(Photo by (c)Universal courtesy Everett Collection)

Remakes are double-edged swords. The best ones manage to recapture the sense of discovery we felt with the original films while offering fresh new experiences; most remakes fail to accomplish one of those two goals, and the very worst ones miss the mark on both. Before it became trendy to refashion every beloved film as a tentpole blockbuster, Peter Jackson followed on the huge success of his Lord of the Rings trilogy with his own take on a childhood favorite, King Kong.

Jackson’s version is a gargantuan journey to a lost world using cutting-edge visual and special effects, with a story that imparts more weight to classic characters. This tale of hubris is not only a fantastic movie in its own right, but it also set a standard for blockbuster remakes that play with audiences’ familiarity with the source material and provide new perspectives on classic tales. To celebrate its 15th anniversary, we head to Skull Island explore how Peter Jackson successfully reintroduced a cinematic legend to a new generation by putting his own stamp on it.


It Feels Like a Throwback

King Kong (2005)

(Photo by Universal Pictures)

After the 1976 King Kong brought its central character to a contemporary setting, Jackson took the story back to its roots as a period piece set in the 1930s. While director Merian Cooper’s original 1933 film mostly avoided portraying the Great Depression because audiences didn’t need a reminder of what was happening around them, Jackson dove into how that environment helped birth the Kong myth. The opening scene of his film introduces the grandeur of New York’s wealth and the birth of its skyline, while giving equal gravitas to the city’s squalor; people are being served eviction notices, and soup lines extend as far as the eye can see. Not only are people desperate for money — like protagonist Ann Darrow (Naomi Watts), who accepts a job to shoot a film overseas with only the promise of maybe getting paid — but they are desperate to have some magic come back to the world.

Jackson grants added importance to the setting, not just in the cultural background, but also in the filmmaking landscape of the time. There are plenty of references to the original film, including a mention of original actress Fay Wray, and Jack Black’s character Carl Denham is also clearly meant to represent a more frustrated and unsuccessful version of Orson Welles. Jackson also takes a more old-fashioned approach to the pacing of his film, playing with audiences’ expectations and making them wait nearly an hour before finally, slowly and patiently, revealing the titular Kong.


Skull Island Feels Like a Distinct World

Even if Peter Jackson honored the original and stuck to some old-school techniques, there’s no doubt King Kong takes full advantage of every advancement in filmmaking, especially visual effects. The moment the film arrives at Skull Island, Jackson shifts gears and fully brings King Kong into horror movie territory. Sure, some of the computer-generated dinosaurs haven’t aged particularly well, but the scene when the ship’s crew falls into an insect pit — a concept Merian Cooper abandoned because it scared test audiences back in the ’30s — is utterly terrifying, especially when Lumpy (played by a human Andy Serkis, who also provided the motion capture performance for Kong himself) is devoured by an army of leeches.

The wildlife of the island not only looks great and is utilized effectively to convey a sense of wonder and horror, but the actual location looks like nothing audiences had seen to that point (except maybe in the Lord of the Rings trilogy). Skull Island feels like a place that belongs in our world, but was lost to time. The giant walls that surround the island, the temple-like architecture, and the towering mountains that loom above miles-long pits filled with giant insects lend the location a real sense of geography, capturing the mystery and adventure Carl Denham is constantly boasting about.


It Plays with Your Expectations

How do you capture the shock and awe of seeing Kong climb up the Empire State Building when everyone on Earth has either witnessed the moment themselves or seen countless parodies and homages to it for over 70 years after the original film was released? You do it by showing it from a different point of view. Just as he extends the wait before we finally meet Kong, Jackson reframes the film’s most famous set piece as a melancholy tragedy. Rather than watch the action from the perspective of the heroic airplane pilots who attempt to rescue Ann, we watch the incident unfold from Kong and Ann’s perspective, as Jackson slowly builds up the human threat to Kong before revealing the planes as if they were the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse. 

King Kong doesn’t invite the audience to be awed by the prowess of the pilots or the spectacle of a 25-foot gorilla. Instead, this scene continues long enough to make you feel the sense of dread and imminent doom descending upon the titular king. The death of Kong was sad even in the original film, but it was Peter Jackson’s King Kong that finally recognized the huge tragedy of the scene and its emotional weight, and it works because it knows you are already familiar with it.


It’s Secretly About Filmmaking

Jack Black and John Sumner in King Kong

(Photo by (c)Universal courtesy Everett Collection)

Though King Kong is full of imagery and references to Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness and plays on the ideas of savagery and civilization, the film can easily be read as an exploration of the magic of filmmaking.

Indeed, if the original film was all about mankind’s obsession with trying to tame and control nature, Jackson’s remake is about how a filmmaker shares that same false sense of control. Carl Denham spends the first act trying to sell the idea for his movie as a public service because he’s capturing the last piece of mystery left in the world. His journey to getting the film made is arduous and long — not unlike Jackson’s own journey with the film, which he had to partially finance after it became far longer and more expensive than anticipated. But Denham’s misplaced sense of duty results in the death of most of his crew, which he tries to downplay as a noble sacrifice he’ll honor by dedicating the finished production to them. This version of Denham is a far more complex antagonist than in previous versions of the film, one that mistakes his obsession with control with artistic integrity and a sense of duty towards an audience that needs escapism.


It Features an Incredible Performance from Andy Serkis

When Andy Serkis’ Gollum first showed up in The Lord of the Rings trilogy, it was a groundbreaking moment for motion-capture performance. If Gollum was Serkis’ opening statement, however, King Kong is his mic drop moment. This Kong is neither the savage brute of the original film nor the nearly no-show from the 1976 film, but a giant who looks to the horizon with big dreams in his mind and melancholy in his heart. Serkis’ Kong sold audiences on the idea that they could watch an animal behave and act with as many expressions and as much heart as its human co-stars.

A big reason why Kong’s death at the end of the film hits so hard is because of Serkis’ characterization of him not as a monster, but as someone with a soul who connects to Ann on a deeper level than just as a plaything. Even if by the end of the film we’re supposed to connect to Ann and Adrien Brody’s Jack, the real romance is between Ann and Kong; the two quickly connect as marginalized creatures who bond over the emptiness in their lives.

Serkis would, of course, go on to play Caesar, the chimpanzee leader of the newly evolved apes in the rebooted Planet of the Apes franchise, in another remarkable motion-capture performance that cemented Serkis as the king of the form. But he is one of the biggest reasons Peter Jackson’s King Kong works as well as it does, and after 15 years, his work here may still be the most compelling reason among many to revisit the film.


King Kong was released in theaters on December 14, 2005.


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Fox Searchlight cartoon south america PlayStation documentary Awards crime batman Stephen King rotten Year in Review worst war golden globes fresh The Arrangement Crackle Hallmark unscripted Disney streaming service Mudbound Kids & Family DC streaming service latino Holidays The CW New York Comic Con psychological thriller comic Black Mirror twilight universal monsters Trophy Talk Ellie Kemper news HBO Go crime thriller OWN Interview Star Wars quibi dc Disney know your critic Certified Fresh comiccon Cannes reviews 45 italian die hard indie Set visit what to watch stop motion YouTube Red Horror discovery composers 24 frames Tarantino romantic comedy Warner Bros. saw 20th Century Fox FXX TV One 93rd Oscars vampires Red Carpet Baby Yoda social media binge Tumblr Adult Swim versus movies See It Skip It Captain marvel Disney+ Disney Plus CW Seed miniseries The Walking Dead natural history Video Games canceled TV shows Shudder The Walt Disney Company richard e. Grant CBS First Look WarnerMedia Elton John American Society of Cinematographers 71st Emmy Awards dragons X-Men Musicals Fall TV Film Rocky VICE kaiju Apple TV+ The Academy BAFTA Music Peacock Avengers Crunchyroll Marvel Television YA Anna Paquin all-time Hulu live action LGBT RT21 based on movie historical drama Arrowverse mutant TIFF DC Universe GLAAD casting boxoffice Columbia Pictures Alien Family cancelled television video on demand scorecard mockumentary Election doctor who Starz french book Sony Pictures name the review ghosts Musical 2017 FX Awards Tour disaster teaser Country football Black History Month SDCC Valentine's Day Apple Vudu APB superman The Purge lord of the rings Academy Awards heist movie Schedule TCA Awards Toys Hallmark Christmas movies spanish streaming Spring TV dogs PaleyFest james bond fast and furious Character Guide anime Creative Arts Emmys Comic Book kong travel renewed TV shows Shondaland Sneak Peek Paramount Plus Countdown Extras President monster movies Trailer Acorn TV witnail transformers Star Trek Nominations Emmys Reality Turner Classic Movies 2020 Lifetime Mary poppins ABC Family festivals werewolf Superheroes Mystery Pet Sematary black animated TCM medical drama 2016 jurassic park Funimation IFC Films Paramount Network asian-american Superheroe kids docuseries DC Comics dceu new york Super Bowl documentaries Lionsgate spider-man PBS green book Action Teen christmas movies Walt Disney Pictures psycho TV renewals japanese superhero Drama GoT Oscars Endgame USA BBC San Diego Comic-Con Sundance TV Universal cancelled TV series robots spain TruTV Animation revenge cinemax MTV Marvel dramedy NYCC Exclusive Video Ovation high school Paramount australia Comics on TV cops YouTube ID boxing crime drama rotten movies we love prank period drama nature First Reviews cooking slashers Grammys Best and Worst Turner justice league Apple TV Plus Disney Plus nbcuniversal Britbox Emmy Nominations WGN Christmas zombies criterion Rock razzies hispanic E3 DirecTV sequel TCA 2017 Fantasy Binge Guide Showtime adaptation ABC true crime serial killer zombie MSNBC rt archives rom-coms Comedy singing competition El Rey jamie lee curtis TNT Disney Channel Travel Channel women pirates of the caribbean Martial Arts remakes obituary FOX BET Awards trailers Mary Tyler Moore E! independent crossover adventure Photos Hear Us Out Reality Competition TCA Winter 2020 Netflix Christmas movies scene in color telelvision 4/20 dark films laika Amazon Prime Video Nickelodeon festival series SundanceTV National Geographic Tomatazos hidden camera Winter TV VH1 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Trivia 99% halloween A&E concert HBO Pixar spinoff Pacific Islander diversity Pirates free movies TLC talk show Writers Guild of America LGBTQ theme song Infographic TV movies cancelled TV shows Thanksgiving Box Office Marvel Studios chucky zero dark thirty Summer Amazon Studios satire IFC stand-up comedy The Witch comedies Pride Month Rocketman Ghostbusters child's play Syfy golden globe awards TBS movie DGA archives 007 blockbusters CNN sequels spanish language popular OneApp BET toy story indiana jones international 2021 BBC America USA Network Sci-Fi screenings Television Critics Association 72 Emmy Awards cults halloween tv scary movies stoner romance Pop BBC One nfl Mary Poppins Returns hollywood 2019 Winners AMC blockbuster Television Academy deadpool sitcom HBO Max 2015 Premiere Dates Logo ESPN Spectrum Originals comic books Esquire game show police drama sag awards Women's History Month ViacomCBS Food Network Quiz cancelled facebook book adaptation ratings streaming movies sports television venice strong female leads harry potter thriller Cosplay History canceled science fiction Pop TV Comedy Central Spike Sundance Now 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards screen actors guild Lifetime Christmas movies Fox News target anthology Polls and Games Lucasfilm biography aliens Image Comics blaxploitation Opinion Amazon video comics critics Mindy Kaling 2018 political drama reboot FX on Hulu YouTube Premium foreign Amazon Prime RT History supernatural Bravo cats Legendary new star wars movies hist Classic Film technology directors ABC Signature TCA joker Freeform mission: impossible Watching Series politics Film Festival Podcast Holiday children's TV Heroines Western Chernobyl Rom-Com Discovery Channel classics Cartoon Network cars Epix Broadway Marathons elevated horror franchise worst movies Dark Horse Comics Tubi Masterpiece A24 Song of Ice and Fire new zealand VOD parents Nat Geo ITV marvel cinematic universe Netflix toronto SXSW emmy awards docudrama Brie Larson king kong spy thriller best MCU space Calendar CMT GIFs Chilling Adventures of Sabrina game of thrones tv talk breaking bad aapi godzilla Sundance CBS All Access 21st Century Fox finale Biopics TV Land NBC TV award winner a nightmare on elm street