5 Kick-Ass Female Directors Warner Bros. Should Consider for Batgirl

by | February 23, 2018 | Comments

(Photo by 20th Century Fox Film Corp.)

Yesterday news broke that Avengers director Joss Whedon was leaving Batgirl, the Warner Bros. feature that he was writing and was slated to direct. Though some are lamenting the nerd icon’s departure, many insiders and comic book fans are viewing it as an opportunity. The Buffy the Vampire Slayer creator clearly can write a dynamic female character, but memories of the Black Widow storyline from Age of Ultron and his leaked Wonder Woman script had some doubting his ability to bring an entertaining Batgirl story to the big screen. Now many are asking, hey, why not have a woman direct this woman-led film?

The record-breaking success of films like Black Panther and Wonder Woman demonstrates that audiences are yearning for stories from underrepresented groups — told by those who are part of those groups. What Patty Jenkins and Ryan Coogler did with those films is largely due to their ability to tell stories from their own experiences. They felt lived-in, genuine. Batgirl is arguably DC’s most identifiable heroine outside of Wonder Woman, and a female director and writer seem the logical choice to shepherd her to screen. After Whedon’s exit was announced, comic book writer and Bad Feminist author Roxane Gay was quick to chime in on Twitter that she could pen the new Batgirl film (and it seems the execs from DC entertainment agree). Assuming that Warner Bros. and DC take Gay up on her offer, the next question is: Who should step behind the lens? With that in mind, here are five picks for awesome — but lesser known — female directors DC should consider.

1. Gina Prince-Bythewood

(Photo by 20th Century Fox courtesy Everett Collection)

If you haven’t seen the criminally underrated Beyond the Lights (83%) — and we know you haven’t, because the flick made just over $14 million at the box office — you might not have experienced the brilliance of Gina Prince-Bythewood, my top choice to take the lead on Batgirl. Already slated to direct Silver and Black — a comic adaption for Black Cat and Silver Sable planned in Sony’s Spider-Man-themed cinematic universe — Bythewood is a self-professed comic book nerd and a no-brainer to take on the project.

Average Tomatometer score (as director): 74.7%

2. Lexi Alexander

(Photo by Lionsgate courtesy Everett Collection)

The outspoken director and former fighting champion has an affinity for fight choreography, and Batgirl is often recognized for her fierce and gymnastic fighting prowess. Before Wonder Woman, Alexander was the only woman to helm a major studio comic book adaption — Punisher: War Zone (27%) — and I, for one, would love to see her gritty, violent take on Barbara Gordon/Batgirl.

Average Tomatometer score (as director): 37.5%

3. Tamara Jenkins

(Photo by 20th Century Fox courtesy Everett Collection)

Hear me out on this one: Jenkins might not be the first name that comes to mind for a comic book movie director, but if we closely examine the Batgirl canon, we discover she might actually be the best choice. Barbara Gordon’s story is often an equal mix of comedy and tragedy, and few are as well equipped to blend those flavors as the woman who gave us The Savages (89%). Jenkins also directed the cult-classic Slums of Beverly Hills (80%), and a vibrant color scheme — like we see in Slums — is desperately needed to help brighten up DC’s live action adaptations.

Average Tomatometer score (as director): 87.7%

4. Sam Taylor-Johnson

(Photo by Chuck Zlotnick/Focus Features)

While her last outing, Fifty Shades of Grey (25%), dented her reputation a touch, the Nowhere Boy (79%) director is a huge talent. Still reeling from her turbulent experience on Fifty Shades, she passed on the chance to direct Brie Larson in Captain Marvel, but she might now be ready to suit up for a comic book film. She’s known for her gorgeously cinematic shot choices — they’ll no doubt be a feature of her upcoming drama, A Million Little Pieces — and one can’t help but fantasize about what her sprawling vision for Gotham City would be.

Average Tomatometer score (as director): 52%

5. Angela Robinson

(Photo by Claire Folger/Annapurna Pictures)

Robinson’s last film, Professor Marston and the Wonder Women, was not a success at the box office, but it was embraced by critics (87%) and the few theatergoers who got a chance to see it (the film’s Rotten Tomatoes audience score is a solid 79%). The two female protagonists in Professor Marston perfectly mirror the Barbara Gordon/Batgirl dual identity, and whoever is chosen to lead the production will need to service both sides of the Batgirl persona for a truly authentic adaptation.

Average Tomatometer score (as director): 64.5%

Note: Only films for which a Tomatometer score exists were used to calculate the average score for the directors.

Tag Cloud

Esquire live action comic book movie TV Land YA football anime Holidays Fox Searchlight dark Sundance VH1 book President canceled Disney romance animated boxing Reality San Diego Comic-Con comiccon boxoffice biography Sony Pictures Sundance Now Comic Book Discovery Channel dceu scary movies politics Certified Fresh Ghostbusters Avengers Logo new star wars movies Women's History Month blockbuster Warner Bros. police drama Binge Guide Pop The Purge Amazon Prime Video Mary Poppins Returns Summer Tokyo Olympics true crime ghosts CNN gangster Apple TV Plus teaser cars a nightmare on elm street mcc space YouTube Red miniseries rotten adventure Marvel Studios criterion mutant Bravo sports kong Amazon Prime dexter Country The Walking Dead halloween tv Stephen King sitcom breaking bad werewolf American Society of Cinematographers Set visit marvel cinematic universe Superheroes Song of Ice and Fire comic psycho king arthur war Martial Arts action-comedy Countdown 1990s crime drama Black History Month Hallmark A&E MSNBC toronto 007 4/20 WarnerMedia Emmy Nominations 21st Century Fox USA Network Marvel Television anthology Sundance TV hispanic Interview Spike period drama zombie Film basketball X-Men worst movies ABC Family PaleyFest science fiction E3 know your critic game of thrones posters Captain marvel series NBC APB Hear Us Out Tubi reviews 71st Emmy Awards television Hulu Awards Tour DGA Year in Review remakes rt labs spain travel slasher book adaptation popular satire Red Carpet 2021 nbcuniversal best ID Pet Sematary IFC superman Film Festival BET Freeform Endgame toy story documentary franchise blockbusters Valentine's Day ViacomCBS Disney+ Disney Plus SDCC target Animation FX VICE Election political drama MTV joker die hard Travel Channel BAFTA Oscars hispanic heritage month Disney Channel golden globes 2019 monster movies Super Bowl casting Pirates Nominations screenings Tarantino vampires 73rd Emmy Awards History harry potter critics OWN NBA Elton John slashers PBS Legendary TCA Fantasy Paramount Plus ratings new zealand scene in color indiana jones natural history Christmas psychological thriller PlayStation CBS All Access halloween The CW comic book movies prank YouTube Premium Marvel asian-american olympics comedies Epix stop motion Turner Classic Movies BBC One Trailer deadpool Shondaland crime child's play DC Comics Best and Worst cartoon Cosplay Creative Arts Emmys Image Comics Tumblr canceled TV shows docuseries Video Games sequels El Rey Food Network hidden camera Apple TV+ AMC rotten movies we love all-time Mindy Kaling Amazon Studios quibi Musical cults Rocketman Apple CMT tv talk sequel Black Mirror black saw renewed TV shows Schedule zero dark thirty Spectrum Originals diversity Kids & Family video game show Shudder Netflix Christmas movies worst Cartoon Network BET Awards award winner spanish First Reviews Classic Film 20th Century Fox spanish language CBS Fall TV Disney Plus DirecTV 93rd Oscars 45 2016 children's TV ABC Signature social media japanese FOX superhero GoT disaster spider-man The Walt Disney Company Pride Month cops twilight kids Comics on TV theme song cancelled TV shows Adult Swim crossover emmy awards TV renewals discovery 24 frames Trivia RT21 HBO Go stand-up comedy doctor who adaptation crime thriller aliens Star Wars hollywood facebook Pacific Islander thriller TV movies festival Netflix Columbia Pictures Academy Awards Comedy Central telelvision Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Podcast New York Comic Con aapi Sneak Peek National Geographic venice supernatural italian Sci-Fi romantic comedy FXX 90s Lucasfilm streaming Writers Guild of America Lionsgate Thanksgiving japan WGN foreign rt archives streaming movies dc mission: impossible Paramount Network 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Cannes Calendar green book Alien cinemax Rocky Tomatazos transformers festivals 99% TruTV unscripted archives cooking fast and furious binge Anna Paquin Showtime TBS Pop TV TIFF Amazon Exclusive Video indie spy thriller Television Critics Association SundanceTV jurassic park batman Heroines composers Arrowverse chucky kaiju sag awards Masterpiece news Acorn TV cancelled television Spring TV dogs Mary poppins TV One Toys ESPN robots rom-coms Superheroe hist Lifetime Marathons films directors TNT cancelled TV series nfl OneApp pirates of the caribbean Wes Anderson technology Rock fresh movie medical drama based on movie RT History scorecard Hallmark Christmas movies video on demand independent ABC Crackle name the review reboot First Look 72 Emmy Awards Baby Yoda See It Skip It lord of the rings Trophy Talk The Academy Winners dragons Paramount biopic Opinion Winter TV classics 2018 stoner Brie Larson blaxploitation heist movie elevated horror james bond legend TCA 2017 Musicals Fox News Holiday godzilla 2017 marvel comics Ovation justice league Quiz royal family Music french latino Nat Geo Box Office Peacock golden globe awards versus comics IFC Films Biopics south america talk show MCU Polls and Games VOD TV NYCC Funimation The Witch adenture Grammys australia finale historical drama Emmys GIFs SXSW Comic-Con@Home 2021 trailers universal monsters wonder woman Starz Britbox jamie lee curtis serial killer Chilling Adventures of Sabrina obituary Mary Tyler Moore Family Disney streaming service what to watch richard e. Grant CW Seed DC Universe Broadway Photos Syfy cats Extras critic resources Action Nickelodeon singing competition Turner nature LGBTQ Reality Competition docudrama BBC America dramedy Comedy free movies parents screen actors guild zombies The Arrangement cancelled witnail TCM A24 christmas movies FX on Hulu strong female leads Awards HBO new york king kong ITV Lifetime Christmas movies Drama GLAAD HBO Max mockumentary debate concert Crunchyroll Watching Series Dark Horse Comics Mudbound Star Trek Pixar LGBT razzies Infographic young adult Television Academy YouTube E! USA BBC Teen 2015 comic books Rom-Com spinoff TCA Winter 2020 Mystery rt labs critics edition 2020 Character Guide Premiere Dates Ellie Kemper DC streaming service Walt Disney Pictures movies Horror laika suspense international Vudu women high school Universal revenge documentaries feel good Western Chernobyl TLC TCA Awards