Hear Us Out

20 Years Later, Scooby-Doo Is Still a Clever, Subversive Take on the Mystery Inc. Gang

Film critic Rendy Jones waxes nostalgic about the well-executed balance between satire and faithful homage and the all-around campy fun of the long-running cartoon's first live-action adaptation.

by | June 17, 2022 | Comments

Out of the many long-running franchises in animation history, no show received as many iterations as Scooby-Doo. Since 1969, the iconic Hanna-Barbera series has been reincarnated more times than Doctor Who has regenerated. There was a Scooby-Doo that was prolific for each generation: Gen-Xers grew up with the first run of the series, Scooby-Doo, Where Are You!, and Millennials had A Pup Named Scooby-Doo and Scooby-Doo On Zombie Island. Lucky for me, Gen-Z got one of the most iconic iterations to date: Scooby-Doo, the 2002 live-action film adaptation. But Scooby-Doo wasn’t just a cultural reset smash hit that Gen-Z puts on a pedestal to this very day; it changed the trajectory of the franchise forever.

With the movie celebrating its 20th anniversary this week (feel old yet?), it’s a perfect time to unmask that 31% Tomatometer score and make the case as to why the Raja Gosnell-directed and James Gunn-written classic is a clever and subversive take on the franchise’s history.

It Deconstructs the Archetypes and Has Fun Doing It

Poster image for Scooby-Doo (2002)

(Photo by ©Warner Bros.)

Anyone could have done a procedural copy-and-paste job to adapt Scooby-Doo for the big screen, but James Gunn attempted to deconstruct the series’ formula while staying true to it. His approach was meant to be in the same vein as Shrek, who was the hotshot cool kid in the classroom at the time. While it doesn’t hit the same mark Shrek did from a satirical standpoint, Gunn’s script was a valiant attempt at commenting on the archetypes of the characters and the mysteries they’ve experienced. It was Gunn’s first venture into the realm he’s known best for today: a found family ensemble with good chemistry who also can’t stand each other.

It’s an enticing if not refreshing concept to disband the gang for most of the movie. The overall exhaustion of the gang’s status quo — Velma is always undervalued for her work, Fred is a showboat, Daphne is constantly kidnapped — warrants the break-up in the opening. The story establishes that they’ve been working together for many years, and the bubbling internal dysfunction between the mystery gang reaches its breaking point. It’s quickly paced, but you feel the weight of it all.

Linda Cardellini and Freddie Prinze Jr. as Velma and Fred in Scooby-Doo (2002)

(Photo by ©Warner Bros.)

Working individually on Spooky Island two years later, the new mystery allows them to slowly rekindle their relationships, and the gang learns what it’s like to be a team again. Gunn’s script explores different avenues and shifts the functionality of the team’s dynamic. While he didn’t get clearance to make Velma or Fred outrightly gay as he intended, he did get to make their relationship a strong one. One of the best examples is when Velma comments on how Daphne and Fred always split up together when they try investigating for clues and she’s left on her own. In a surprising twist, Fred lets Velma tag along with him and they work together throughout. It’s not commentary for the sake of being meta but for bettering the relationship of a group that has been on the rocks.

Arguably, the best played-for-laughs aspect is Daphne’s arc, which back then was meant to be hilarious but today is empowering. During the team’s breakup, she spent her time training in martial arts so she can defend herself from being kidnapped, which often happened in the series. The climactic fight between her and Zarkos is well executed, and the script is never in your face about her gender like so many modern superhero films are; it lets her actions speak for themselves.

Its Sense of Humor Is Goofy, but It’s Timeless

Mathew Lillard as Shaggy and Neil Fanning as the voice of Scooby-Doo in Scooby-Doo (2002)

(Photo by ©Warner Bros.)

Scooby-Doo remains true to formula without throwing in modern references. Gunn’s script largely avoids pop culture shout-outs to give the movie a timeless factor, unlike movies like Alvin and the Chipmunks, Sonic the Hedgehog, or even 2020’s Scoob!, all of which frontload their humor with pop culture references. Granted, Scooby-Doo did overdo it in the fart joke department, but outdated references expire fast, and fart jokes are forever.

It Was a Potent Shot of Early 2000s Nostalgia

Having stated the above, though, Scooby-Doo is also a compelling time capsule of its era. The tropical resort setting is straight out of MTV, complete with a cameo from Sugar Ray, and the Mystery Inc. gang’s modernized looks fit in seamlessly, despite calling back to their classic outfits.

The cameo appearances aren’t unreasonably gratuitous, either; they provide a glimpse into the show’s identity, or they serve as legitimate plot details. Daphne, for example, realizes people are being possessed when she notices Mark McGrath’s eyes glow a demonic green as he sings to her. It’s subtle but effective, a combination that a lot of movies today have difficulty achieving.

It Boasts a Perfectly Cast Killer Ensemble

Sarah Michelle Gellar, Linda Cardellini, Matthew Lillard, and Freddie Prinze Jr. as the Mystery, Inc. gang in Scooby-Doo (2002)

(Photo by ©Warner Bros.)

Casting director Mary Vernieu deserves a Nobel Prize for assembling an ensemble of great actors who fit into their respective roles so perfectly. This was the first live-action adaptation of the series, and she knocked it out of the park with Avengers-level precision. Soon-to-be-married duo Freddy Prinze Jr. and Sarah Michelle Gellar (their wedding was just a few months after Scooby-Doo opened) were top-notch as Fred and Daphne; Gellar’s independent spunkiness and Prinze’s confident, self-centered attitude brought more life than the characters had in previous iterations. Linda Cardellini’s absolutely nailed Velma with her nasally, deadpan delivery. And then there was Matthew Lillard.

What can one say about Matthew Lillard’s performance as Shaggy? Despite the film’s negative reviews, Lillard’s performance was universally praised, and he’s now the primary actor who portrays the character in all Scooby-Doo-related media to this very day. It was the role he was born to play, and he is now one with Shaggy.

Matthew Lillard as Shaggy in Scooby-Doo (2002)

(Photo by ©Warner Bros.)

All joking aside, though the narrative places all the characters at odds with one another, you can see the genuine chemistry between the cast, the shared camaraderie within the Mystery Inc. gang that matched the spirit of the source material. Sure, Scooby-Doo himself might suffer from CGI that looks dated even by 2002 standards (seriously, compare this to the other big family blockbuster of the time, Stuart Little 2), but the energy Lillard shares with that dog is more realistic than a lot of the schlock we see even today.

We’re not saying Scooby-Doo is some gold standard of family entertainment, but it understands its source material and knows how to play off of it, which is more than a lot of other live-action adaptations can say. The casting is pitch-perfect, the balance between being faithful and satirical is fresh, and it’s just classic campy fun. It was a modernized Scooby-Doo without emphasizing how modernized it was, which, in today’s cinema landscape, is more welcome than ever.

Scooby-Doo was released in theaters on June 14, 2002.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Spring TV nature cancelled TV series name the review Box Office casting Reality Competition scene in color Sony Pictures Family fast and furious mission: impossible game show Ovation australia book Comic Book 1990s IFC know your critic Interview game of thrones SDCC ABC Family Vudu vs. Netflix Christmas movies a nightmare on elm street Fall TV cops science fiction Ellie Kemper action-comedy mockumentary Hallmark Christmas movies Writers Guild of America dreamworks Disney Plus italian werewolf quibi VICE japanese Trivia Shudder Sundance Now El Rey christmas movies 2015 godzilla classics french Disney streaming service leaderboard Universal Pictures hollywood See It Skip It HBO Max Tags: Comedy Anna Paquin elevated horror Rock cartoon indie deadpool Superheroe mutant war USA 2019 Avengers ABC Signature Walt Disney Pictures mob Britbox Women's History Month OneApp streamig live action Paramount Network Best Picture CMT Tokyo Olympics 20th Century Fox debate Star Wars Celebration Paramount Plus prank Sony Music Binge Guide GLAAD Trailer dramedy Toys posters Best Actor Pet Sematary Endgame Nat Geo Alien Holiday Disney Channel mcc Native trailers Cartoon Network dexter revenge Biopics YouTube technology critics DC Universe AMC Plus Star Trek Horror spinoff child's play Teen teaser Marvel Studios women james bond CBS Spike award winner Valentine's Day VOD Sneak Peek Rom-Com Heroines rotten basketball Focus Features Mary Tyler Moore heist movie GoT miniseries police drama Travel Channel king kong Netflix series new york MCU indiana jones anthology Fantasy ESPN Awards cancelled TV shows spy thriller strong female leads comiccon dc crossover docuseries Photos Kids & Family NYCC halloween Adult Swim Character Guide Neflix archives Amazon Prime Video Super Bowl Amazon Studios IFC Films halloween tv 99% Emmy Nominations young adult Mindy Kaling tv talk Hulu festivals CBS All Access Geeked Week Animation Cannes toronto rt labs USA Network TIFF period drama Best and Worst vampires San Diego Comic-Con sopranos The Walt Disney Company TCA football Pop TV genre 79th Golden Globes Awards animated Action sequels TV The Walking Dead target broadcast crime YouTube Red aliens Reality summer preview New York Comic Con fresh CNN olympics cats SundanceTV AMC new zealand 007 kids Dark Horse Comics streaming Nominations movie ID Trophy Talk Quiz Hear Us Out Film Chernobyl Tubi Creative Arts Emmys Podcast E3 films nfl Universal scene in color film series Election kaiju SXSW 2022 Exclusive Video E! zombies slasher Legendary latino Western A24 foreign boxoffice TCA Winter 2020 news ghosts transformers Musicals romantic comedy travel IMDb TV dark stand-up comedy BAFTA dceu Sundance TV comic book movies Food Network Watching Series Black History Month Best Director batman nbcuniversal The Purge Amazon rotten movies we love 24 frames dragons spider-man pirates of the caribbean legend obituary biopic hist Showtime Broadway PBS video on demand movies green book aapi stop motion Drama BBC America History Ghostbusters HFPA Tarantino Mary poppins Song of Ice and Fire biography joker Wes Anderson NBA 72 Emmy Awards Opinion based on movie Freeform wonder woman PaleyFest YouTube Premium 71st Emmy Awards TLC south america reboot Marvel spanish 2021 Sci-Fi target scene in color renewed TV shows Television Academy FX on Hulu APB independent PlayStation 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Musical royal family TNT Baby Yoda Lucasfilm The Arrangement Crunchyroll rt archives ITV franchise best Pixar Cosplay talk show Amazon Prime Lifetime Christmas movies YA universal monsters supernatural screen actors guild telelvision WGN screenings jurassic park Peacock trophy cults comedies 2017 saw Fox Searchlight Best Actress Spectrum Originals Pacific Islander psychological thriller scary movies crime drama hispanic heritage month video Masterpiece 4/20 breaking bad documentary directors harry potter blockbusters adaptation international Extras black comedy Tumblr Esquire hispanic MTV 93rd Oscars President kong The Witch First Look facebook true crime TBS asian-american documentaries Disney+ Disney Plus Christmas superman worst worst movies Red Carpet Black Mirror DC Comics Film Festival boxing TCM scorecard zero dark thirty political drama Calendar Star Wars The CW VH1 composers summer TV preview richard e. Grant marvel comics robots concert Premiere Dates scary Mystery critic resources unscripted sitcom Classic Film rt labs critics edition natural history TV movies zombie stoner Tomatazos Apple TV+ FXX golden globes ViacomCBS A&E LGBT singing competition cancelled crime thriller comics Academy Awards Sundance 2020 Oscars cancelled television emmy awards 45 Fargo Turner Classic Movies adventure HBO Go sequel Instagram Live spain BBC One spider-verse Pop scene in color series lord of the rings Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Comedy psycho blockbuster Fox News Columbia Pictures doctor who TCA 2017 die hard art house Comics on TV satire superhero cinemax RT21 DC streaming service Rocky Pride Month ratings medical drama National Geographic The Academy FX Captain marvel toy story TCA Awards GIFs discovery comic Indigenous serial killer what to watch WarnerMedia Acorn TV social media politics disaster binge popular Disney 2016 ABC Rocketman adenture rom-coms BET Awards 2018 razzies thriller 21st Century Fox Holidays DGA hidden camera Marathons monster movies Paramount Winter TV space all-time Stephen King Bravo Apple Warner Bros. 90s Mary Poppins Returns 94th Oscars high school cooking Syfy remakes diversity finale parents live event Apple TV Plus Comic-Con@Home 2021 jamie lee curtis NBC obi wan Year in Review Superheroes streaming movies FOX American Society of Cinematographers theme song japan First Reviews Comedy Central Image Comics Turner Television Critics Association Country Paramount Pictures South by Southwest Film Festival historical drama interviews DirecTV Pirates king arthur festival Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt criterion new star wars movies X-Men Elton John Arrowverse sag awards versus Starz OWN Discovery Channel venice comic book movie BBC Hollywood Foreign Press Association Oscar TV One suspense witnail Epix Video Games slashers summer TV SXSW anime Thanksgiving TV Land children's TV Lifetime HBO Funimation canceled TV shows Infographic gangster sports Logo romance free movies Schedule Brie Larson reviews 73rd Emmy Awards Mudbound comic books television TruTV Awards Tour RT History justice league book adaptation CW Seed Winners MGM Set visit canceled Marvel Television marvel cinematic universe dogs Prime Video docudrama golden globe awards Shondaland Polls and Games Emmys Grammys Lionsgate Hallmark Summer Nickelodeon Certified Fresh feel good LGBTQ black Martial Arts spanish language BET blaxploitation TV renewals laika Crackle MSNBC Countdown chucky twilight cars